[Standard] Final Fantasy VII Mafia - Mafia Wins D4

[Katiora]

 

And I am now caught up. @cory the only thing that has stood out to me is bfg's play... Everyone says that it looks good but please everyone remember she has a pretty well developed scum game and can seem very town early on. Nyn seems slightly reserved but she had already stated that she wasn't going to be as active as normal(which corrected to Norma, not sure who she is) this game before we even started.

 

We seem to have quite a few people that haven't checked in yet.

From what I've been told (including BFG herself), BFG's scum game is pretty clearly distinguished from her town game.

Are you saying that's not the case?

I'm saying she's profecient at faking this early in the game lol I don't think anything she's done is indicative of her role by itself.

[Sooh]

Darthe's faux pop-psychology is the dominant trait of his game; as he a wolf he's a droning psychiatrist; as a villager he's the patient in the chair

This made me giggle and nod a bit. I'm not sure how true it is, but it certainly would be fun to look for. 

 

Idk why so many are saying that there are several people who haven't checked in. Afaik every slot but Csarmi has been in the thread so far. I suppose it could be because they haven't had much presence in the thread so far?

 

It feels too soon to have any real feelings about people in the thread, but I think already BFG is posting enough to possibly be town. On the other hand there's Alanna who feels way too serious way too soon. I know she asked Ironeyes what he thought about someone being serious in their first post, and I wanted to let him respond before saying it's slightly wolfy and pingy to me. 

[Clovdyx]

Vote count!

 

• Alanna - 1 - Darthe
• Darthe - 1 - Lizabeth

 

Day One ends at 12:30 Eastern time on Saturday, 10/30.

 

[Clovdyx]

You all don't want to know the (not that) unfortunate typo I almost made in that post.

[BFG]

Good morning :)

[BFG]

 

My mafia game isn't quite as obvious/bad to be a simple case of 'if I'm posting...'

[BFG]

No one is yet townie or wolfy, just comfortable and uncomfortable as fits them as people, mostly.

Pretty apt

[BFG]

Alanna gets serious early as town, but I'm pretty sure she did as mafia in her PerC game, so not sure that by itself means much

 

I don't recall her having 'difficulty' with the joke phase of the game but she does relax a little later on this game

 

 

Alanna, can you expand on your 'if Cory carries on as he is and lynchee a wolf you'll lock him in as town' thought?

[BFG]

Kats pushing me both ways at the moment

 

her joke in response to Darthe read awkwardly to me and I'd also sort of expected her to address the early Darthe/Cory stuff, her opinion on me is interesting, she was in my last mafia game where I almost got lynched Day 1 and didn't for a combination of good/lucky timing on my part and (bad) reasons by others, but she's never seen me as a universal town read when mafia because that hasn't happened in about a year and a half :(

 

I have one decent reason to think Kat could be town, but I need to check it against her mafia games :p

[BFG]

What stuck out to me the most was the reactions to your OP. Kat said it seemed wolfy (which I'd actually like her to elaborate on). Laine said something about you making a big deal about it, which eh. And Darthe said it seemed pre-written... which is a bit of a head scratcher to me. But then most of the things he says are.

 

I just found it generally funny. I don't think it says much irt your alignment.

Why is Kats response the one you're most interested in? (you seem to have Alannas and Darthes response as null)

[BFG]

in unrelated news

 

Yay I beat Cloudflare :P

[Nynaeve]

 

What stuck out to me the most was the reactions to your OP. Kat said it seemed wolfy (which I'd actually like her to elaborate on). Laine said something about you making a big deal about it, which eh. And Darthe said it seemed pre-written... which is a bit of a head scratcher to me. But then most of the things he says are.

 

I just found it generally funny. I don't think it says much irt your alignment.

Why is Kats response the one you're most interested in? (you seem to have Alannas and Darthes response as null)

 

 

Cause it wasn't explained

[Nynaeve]

You seem too....... Nice?? Idk... Or maybe a bit more reserved. But I'm not sure I've read all the thread. I need to reread tomorrow when I get on a PC and can tell what pages I'm on better.

 

:-O

[BFG]

Ok :)

[alannalynn]

Alanna gets serious early as town, but I'm pretty sure she did as mafia in her PerC game, so not sure that by itself means much

 

I don't recall her having 'difficulty' with the joke phase of the game but she does relax a little later on this game

 

 

Alanna, can you expand on your 'if Cory carries on as he is and lynchee a wolf you'll lock him in as town' thought?

I really don't think my serious-ness matters.

 

Re: cory: generally his willingness to lynch wolves is an indicator of town? Wolf cory doesn't die n1 and doesn't lynch his teammates. Town cory feels townie and may not lunch wolves d1, probably dies n1, and if he doesn't, he goes on to lynch a wolf d2. I thought my comments were fairly self explanatory. Cory doesn't really matter, we're never going to lynch him d1 even if there was a hint he was a wolf so we as might as well not waste time discussing his behavior when he's so self solving.

 

I'll be out for the rest of the morning into the afternoon, btw.

[BFG]

 

Alanna gets serious early as town, but I'm pretty sure she did as mafia in her PerC game, so not sure that by itself means much

 

I don't recall her having 'difficulty' with the joke phase of the game but she does relax a little later on this game

 

 

Alanna, can you expand on your 'if Cory carries on as he is and lynchee a wolf you'll lock him in as town' thought?

I really don't think my serious-ness matters.

 

Re: cory: generally his willingness to lynch wolves is an indicator of town? Wolf cory doesn't die n1 and doesn't lynch his teammates. Town cory feels townie and may not lunch wolves d1, probably dies n1, and if he doesn't, he goes on to lynch a wolf d2. I thought my comments were fairly self explanatory. Cory doesn't really matter, we're never going to lynch him d1 even if there was a hint he was a wolf so we as might as well not waste time discussing his behavior when he's so self solving.

 

I'll be out for the rest of the morning into the afternoon, btw.

won't mention that other game

 

Ok, the lynching a wolf bit was the important part? Was wondering if you had a town read on him already from the 'carries on as now' part

[Darthe]

Bfg do you usually get serious so fast?

[BFG]

Depends?

[Clovdyx]

 

Vote count!

 

• Alanna - 1 - Darthe
• Darthe - 1 - Lizabeth

 

Day One ends at 12:30 Eastern time on Saturday, 10/30.

 

Still correct, and with the proper number of O's.

[BFG]

[Cory Caboose]

morning all

[alannalynn]

Probably a town BFG

[BFG]

morning all

Good afternoon :)

[Darthe]

Depends?

On?

[Katiora]

 

Depends?

On?

Thank goodness makes it so much easier to clean up the mess when you poop on yourself....

 

Back to seriousness...

 

Bfg I didn't address Cory/darthe because darthe will always seem wolf to me because of the way he plays (belligerent, "all-knowing", uncompromising) and Cory will always appear town because of the way he gets so invested in the game. I'm horrible at reading both so I will comment very little on either, especially early unless they do something crazy.