[Basic] Pirates of the Caribbean (Curse of the Black Pearl) Game Thread - D2

[Guest]

@Monstr @Tiink @Calder @Nolder

 

 

Hi. Who's scum and why?

[Guest]

Quick question to those who know Besie:

 

Does she do huge read posts like that as scum?

 

Because I know I do. But I want to believe she is town and not only for that post.

[Guest]

I do, Nego.

[Calder]

@Monstr @Tiink @Calder @Nolder

 

 

Hi. Who's scum and why?

Scum:

 

Zander - Not too much scum experience with him. But, one game stands out as it was a scum sweep. I didnt really suspect him until the end when his final vote explanation felt like his "early feeling" posts were backed into. Like if you submitted a paper and then had to fudge outline notes and a rough draft to hand into the professor that you never originally did. I have that same feeling now. That his feelings are arbitrary and not hunting. Just willing to back into something that will get a lynch through.

 

Calder - Unhelpful. Not particularly insightful. Inflated sense of self. Always scum.

[Calder]

Any other reads are town for me. I have a large list of people I would be shocked if were scum. Process of elim the rest for me.

[Pralaya]

 

So, Besie, want to hear from you. What did you do different in your town game as compared to your wolf games?

 

Lol, as scum I lived in the fake impression of trying to be town even when I was scum. So when I was town I just attempted the same.

The biggest difference is that I actually don't know who the scum were in that game, as this game - and that should come out in my posts. 

 

Whilst we're talking: You haven't really said much at all this game. Have you formed an opinion? Who do you think the scum are?

 

 

So, a problem of TMI. Good to know.

 

I gave my thoughts a couple of pages back. Nothing much has stood out as scum so far and i am getting my town reads away. 

 

Something that slightly pinged me during my read is manbat.. Especially this post/ It looked like he was trying to take advantage of sooh's read of Tinker, while not calling it out explicitly. It stood out as odd to me.  

[Darthe]

Hey manbat, y u say besie is on a wolf team with nol in particular?

[monstrman]

Hey manbat, y u say besie is on a wolf team with nol in particular?

It's for a specific reason that I will reveal if she's in fact scum, but tbh I don't think so, and I'm not too enthused on Nego being scum either

 

To be honest, this game seems much different from the last scum game I saw calder play so I'm inclined to think he's town. Incidentally, I also think that if zander is a wolf all he's doing is pushing townies right now, i.e. he and believer are never on a scum team. Aorn i'm torn because I don't really notice believer saying much itt aside from defending himself and i'd like to see more reads. I cannot say I have confidence in a read on his alignment one way or the other, and it's probably at least halfway a me problem.

 

I have darthe as a villager mostly because of a gut feeling based on how you're reading me, I'm just waiting on you exploding with wim again to call you a lock villager. I think if you're a villager it will come as the game progresses too

 

Besie I had as town because the way she said that she was leaning town on me but (player I think darthe or zander) had a good point about something I had said or done and it read to me like besie is a player that seems to have trouble separating her reads and the reads of other players, likely because she has a hard time not doubting herself. That said, I understand that it's possible she was just saying that to appease me and also leave herself the option of voting me later, so I don't necessarily think she's a lock villager either just someone I don't consider worth voting yet. If my personality read is wrong, she's probably a wolf.

[monstrman]

That whole post wasn't directed at you but I wanted to talk to everyone too a our some reads I had so I just used it as a springboard

 

I think as a result the structure of the post got cluttered a bit

[monstrman]

 

 

So, Besie, want to hear from you. What did you do different in your town game as compared to your wolf games?

 

 

Lol, as scum I lived in the fake impression of trying to be town even when I was scum. So when I was town I just attempted the same.

The biggest difference is that I actually don't know who the scum were in that game, as this game - and that should come out in my posts. 

 

Whilst we're talking: You haven't really said much at all this game. Have you formed an opinion? Who do you think the scum are?

 

So, a problem of TMI. Good to know.

 

I gave my thoughts a couple of pages back. Nothing much has stood out as scum so far and i am getting my town reads away. 

 

Something that slightly pinged me during my read is manbat.. Especially this post/ It looked like he was trying to take advantage of sooh's read of Tinker, while not calling it out explicitly. It stood out as odd to me.

If I was trying to take advantage of tinker I'd have voted tinker.

[monstrman]

Or take advantage of sooh's read of Tinker

 

I used sooh's read of Tinker as my read of her, and then considered her read as a possibility because I have no read of Tinker myself, and probably won't be capable of making one even today because I am bad at making reads of low posting players that barely talk to me if at all

[monstrman]

You'll notice I subsequently asked tinker a question

 

Not sure if he ever responded tbh

[Tiinker]

You'll notice I subsequently asked tinker a question

 

Not sure if he ever responded tbh

What was the question?

[Tiinker]

Tiink, what do you think about zander and darthe's alignments?

 

This one? I don't know I haven't read closely enough to give anything good. For the sake of saying something I'll say null.

[Calder]

 

Tiink, what do you think about zander and darthe's alignments?

 

 

This one? I don't know I haven't read closely enough to give anything good. For the sake of saying something I'll say null.

This is a bad look to me. Zander and Darthe are up there in terms of content. Null without able to give specifics seems unlikely.

[Tiinker]

I haven't read closely enough to give anything good.

[Tiinker]

Also why would I give specifics with null? There isn't anything that specifically stands out. Look, here's what I'll do. I'll give you some reads when I've actually read the thread properly like I said earlier.

[Guest]

My bottom 3 are Tiink, Calder and Darthe, with Calder as the least scummy of the 3 - as previously stated.

 

The last few pages and Tiink's replies - i'd really like to see more first, before placing my final vote here. 

With Calder I just generally would like to see more. 

Atm I'm going to [v]Darthe[/v] for the reasons mentioned.

 

Using my previous reasons for his being in the probably scum (p22), and I'm including the posts in the spoiler for further explanation

 

 

Thats cool manbat, we are here now. Gimme a few pages to hard clear you and we will just pretend we are a hydra

 

 

ANYWAY I hope you're obvious enough a villager for me to not have to deal with you again like last game..?

We had our spat but ultimately we crushed it

Villa is in my blood, I wont even have to work for it

 

 

 

 

Nego wim early game? How long since you last played?

a couple of days ago but it was CS mafia

 

Well, I like it so keep on

 

 

 

I kinda think zander is a villager independent of darthe alignment tbh

His post about me being hard to read seemed pure

Any chance I could cash in on that? Youre suuiper hard to read senpai

 

 

 

I mean unless darthe/zander's play is "defend each other and push the same villagers" i feel like one of them is a villager at the very least ofc if not both

Can confirm. 1+ villa here. Good math man

 

(although i believe he said this one was sarcasm) 

 

 

Sooh is probably a villager

I agree

 

 he gave all the #raisins
 

I do that toosooh =) no clue what happened two games ago, sometimes not even what team I was on

 

Btw, going through this I'm kinda feeling Darthe as villagery. Nothing that has pinged me the wrong way there yet. Of course last time we played he duped me completely as a wolf until the end, so meh, but I'm not lynching there today.

 not sure why
 

Zander, youve become a meme. Much like #fulldarthe


Welcome, friend

 

Hey earlier when I picked the wolf team did anyone notice how those players responded?
 
Cause I didn't, and that's weird.

 

 

Reread thoughts.
 
*snip*

These are my least fav sorts of posts, mainly because they're way too long, but also I find that quite frequently wolves rely on them to generate content since this requires little to no analysis.  Just effort.  
 
You did a pretty good job of adding in thoughts.  [unvote]

 

pocketattemptdenied.gif 

 

Not much has happened but I now doubt monster is a wolf so that's developed

 
No specific reasoning given here, but he answered what I asked so.

 

 

His agreeing with so many people I don't like atm. He's being very nice. In previous games where I was involved he generally made a fuss about everything when town. He's just as calm in the current game - but his alignment there isn't known yet so I'm not using that for this thought process.

 

Still busy day for me; I'll be around but not fully till later today or tomorrow.

[Sooh]

I think the Zander:Belieber argument is either v/v or v/w OR w/v but can't tell which. Believer handled himself really well in it so I'm inclined to believe he is town atm and definitely would not lynch him today based on that convo.

 

We'll see how things develop though.

Kinda exactly how I feel about that argument. Like I said before, Believer's start wasn't too great with his all too easy reads, but what Zander jumped on him for was weird, and Believer did have good responses which seemed sincere.

 

 

Sooh please make me town read you for sure. I want to redo Haunted Mansion but so far I'm not able to.

I don't know how to do that on command. You're just going to have to read my posts and hopefully that'll ease your worry.

 

 

Quick question to those who know Besie:

 

Does she do huge read posts like that as scum?

 

Because I know I do. But I want to believe she is town and not only for that post.

What I remember from her scum game were several long multiquote posts in a row that she had prepared and then posted just one by one. If she did post posts like that before I've forgotten.

[Calder]

Null on players that have little content makes sense of course. But, when players have a lot, I think you are pressed to defend a null stance on them.

[Guest]

 

Tiink, what do you think about zander and darthe's alignments?

 

This one? I don't know I haven't read closely enough to give anything good. For the sake of saying something I'll say null.

 

 

Yes, this question, which I believe I also asked you at least once. Thanks for finally replying.

 

You and Calder did the same thing - didn't reply to questions I asked but replied when someone else asked it. Are you two skimming my posts? >.>

[Sooh]

 

 

 

 

So, Besie, want to hear from you. What did you do different in your town game as compared to your wolf games?

 

Lol, as scum I lived in the fake impression of trying to be town even when I was scum. So when I was town I just attempted the same.

The biggest difference is that I actually don't know who the scum were in that game, as this game - and that should come out in my posts. 

 

Whilst we're talking: You haven't really said much at all this game. Have you formed an opinion? Who do you think the scum are?

 

 

So, a problem of TMI. Good to know.

 

I gave my thoughts a couple of pages back. Nothing much has stood out as scum so far and i am getting my town reads away. 

 

 

Something that slightly pinged me during my read is manbat.. Especially this post/ It looked like he was trying to take advantage of sooh's read of Tinker, while not calling it out explicitly. It stood out as odd to me.

 

What are you saying here? Monstr is scum because he agreed with me about Tiink? Or Monstr and Tiink are scum together? I'm not sure I'm understanding your conclusion here.

[Nynaeve]

Official Coin Count

 

Believer (2): dice, Zander

dice (1): Believer

Darthe (1): Besie

 

Not voting cause all the rum is gone (9): The rest of you wankers.

 

 

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

[Calder]

 

 

Tiink, what do you think about zander and darthe's alignments?

 

 

This one? I don't know I haven't read closely enough to give anything good. For the sake of saying something I'll say null.

 

Yes, this question, which I believe I also asked you at least once. Thanks for finally replying.

 

You and Calder did the same thing - didn't reply to questions I asked but replied when someone else asked it. Are you two skimming my posts? >.>

I skim 70% of posts.

[Calder]

[v]Zander[/v]