[Basic] Pirates of the Caribbean (Curse of the Black Pearl) Game Thread - D2

[Guest]

Morning everyone.

 

 

 

Pral/Kat- Pral has posted and Kats on vacation as far as i know

 

Hellion- Well cant mention much about other games but Im not holding my breath on Hellion showing up.

 

thats it for "non posters"

Calder 19 Tiinker 12 dicetosser1 10 Believer 10 Pralaya 9 Nolder 7

 

I heard about Kat being away as well, but is there a reason why you singled out Kat/Pral and Hellion over the other people in the low numbers?

 

 

I agree that it's nothing on Kat and Hellian due to no posts. I am, however, linking Kat to Pral due to their being the same slot.

 

Of those bottom 6 mentioned,

Nolder has basically said nothing useful

Pral shares his thoughts on the beginning pages but basically just jokes around a bit

Believer hasn't done anything noteworthy, as he said he wouldn't

Dice shares his thoughts and votes believer for something i see as slight town alignment indicative of him, but not of believer imo

Tiink votes and unvotes (p11) and asks how to improve his own gameplay (p12) but nothing else, really?

Calder asks those loads of completely unhelpful questions (imo, sorry) and does something that could be seen as gameplay on p10 for a bit by sharing thoughts

 

I didn't reread for the above - i just went over my list so i could've missed something that someone else might think is either "gameplay" or alignment indicative.

 

I'm posting this because imo, even though there's few posts, if the content actually helps further the gameplay then i don't mind so much. 

The people who HAVE posted and who are still barely doing anything is Nolder, Pral, Believer and Tiink imo, followed by Dice and Calder.

[Believer]

I could be wrong dude.

 

Your DEF playing different then last game

 

I feel youre playing somewhat differently from Disney as well.

 

So if I feel youre playing differently then both games you were Town in, my suss should be justified somewhat unless youre disputing the facts.

 

Then we can discuss.

 

Im not down playing anything irt to your PR;s.

 

I get the difference.

I'm not disputing the fact that I'm playing differently from both of those earlier games. I play my role in the way I see it most optimally.

 

That being said, Disney was highly unusual for me in the way that the IC role was set up. I was not revealed at start, rather I was granted the ability to reveal at any point during the game by simply PMing a mod. This had 2 effects on my play.

Effect #1: I was forced (by responsibility to my team) to milk my role for as much as it was worth, which was a lot. I had to play very recklessly whilst balancing that with the fact that it was a majority game. Imagine if I had let myself get lynched because I wasn't paying enough attention.

 

Effect #2: I was effectively burnt out. Disney forced me to play extremely actively and always be aware of the vote count. Can I be slightly scummier without getting another vote? Who's currently not voting for me? Is it a tipping point for them if I make another outrageous claim/case? Combine this with actually trying to make outrageous claims/cases that lead somewhere and you've got someone who works very hard for a very long time without respite.

 

 

Now with regards to my disdain of D1.

I am not used to nor do I like long phases, it tends to be too much time and too little content. People fill the void with fluff and it gets harder to get to what's good. Nowhere is this more true than on D1.

Granted, D1 is the day of the meta-read and tone-reading, but seeing as I have very little of that with any of you it's hard for me to get invested. I certainly read most of what's being said, but my contribution would likely be limited in its scope and even moreso in its accuracy.

 

 

I think I've covered all of the criticism against me, for now. Hit me up if you want something specific and I'll look into it.

 

For Zanders eyes only

 

Seriously, only Zander.

No really, only Zander.

Zander are we alone yet?

Okay good.

PM me on Skype for nipples. <3

 

 

 

 

 

[Guest]

If anyone has experience on playing with Believer, could you please comment on thoughts/meta regarding Believer?

[Zander?]

 

I could be wrong dude.

 

Your DEF playing different then last game

 

I feel youre playing somewhat differently from Disney as well.

 

So if I feel youre playing differently then both games you were Town in, my suss should be justified somewhat unless youre disputing the facts.

 

Then we can discuss.

 

Im not down playing anything irt to your PR;s.

 

I get the difference.

I'm not disputing the fact that I'm playing differently from both of those earlier games. I play my role in the way I see it most optimally.

 

That being said, Disney was highly unusual for me in the way that the IC role was set up. I was not revealed at start, rather I was granted the ability to reveal at any point during the game by simply PMing a mod. This had 2 effects on my play.

Effect #1: I was forced (by responsibility to my team) to milk my role for as much as it was worth, which was a lot. I had to play very recklessly whilst balancing that with the fact that it was a majority game. Imagine if I had let myself get lynched because I wasn't paying enough attention.

 

Effect #2: I was effectively burnt out. Disney forced me to play extremely actively and always be aware of the vote count. Can I be slightly scummier without getting another vote? Who's currently not voting for me? Is it a tipping point for them if I make another outrageous claim/case? Combine this with actually trying to make outrageous claims/cases that lead somewhere and you've got someone who works very hard for a very long time without respite.

 

 

Now with regards to my disdain of D1.

I am not used to nor do I like long phases, it tends to be too much time and too little content. People fill the void with fluff and it gets harder to get to what's good. Nowhere is this more true than on D1.

Granted, D1 is the day of the meta-read and tone-reading, but seeing as I have very little of that with any of you it's hard for me to get invested. I certainly read most of what's being said, but my contribution would likely be limited in its scope and even moreso in its accuracy.

 

 

I think I've covered all of the criticism against me, for now. Hit me up if you want something specific and I'll look into it.

 

For Zanders eyes only

 

Seriously, only Zander.

No really, only Zander.

Zander are we alone yet?

Okay good.

PM me on Skype for nipples. <3

 

 

 

 

 

 

My criticism is that youre playing differently to you Town Meta.

 

Limited as that is with you its still different.

 

Youve agreed yourself youre playing differently and that D1 is Meta stuff and fluff mostly.

 

If Im wrong youve got lots of time to prove it but you havent eased my concerns from this post.

 

And also....you cant bribe me with your nipples....youre a nipple prostitute and will show them to me regardless imo

[Believer]

 

 

 

I could be wrong dude.

 

Your DEF playing different then last game

 

I feel youre playing somewhat differently from Disney as well.

 

So if I feel youre playing differently then both games you were Town in, my suss should be justified somewhat unless youre disputing the facts.

 

Then we can discuss.

 

Im not down playing anything irt to your PR;s.

 

I get the difference.

I'm not disputing the fact that I'm playing differently from both of those earlier games. I play my role in the way I see it most optimally.

 

That being said, Disney was highly unusual for me in the way that the IC role was set up. I was not revealed at start, rather I was granted the ability to reveal at any point during the game by simply PMing a mod. This had 2 effects on my play.

Effect #1: I was forced (by responsibility to my team) to milk my role for as much as it was worth, which was a lot. I had to play very recklessly whilst balancing that with the fact that it was a majority game. Imagine if I had let myself get lynched because I wasn't paying enough attention.

 

Effect #2: I was effectively burnt out. Disney forced me to play extremely actively and always be aware of the vote count. Can I be slightly scummier without getting another vote? Who's currently not voting for me? Is it a tipping point for them if I make another outrageous claim/case? Combine this with actually trying to make outrageous claims/cases that lead somewhere and you've got someone who works very hard for a very long time without respite.

 

 

Now with regards to my disdain of D1.

I am not used to nor do I like long phases, it tends to be too much time and too little content. People fill the void with fluff and it gets harder to get to what's good. Nowhere is this more true than on D1.

Granted, D1 is the day of the meta-read and tone-reading, but seeing as I have very little of that with any of you it's hard for me to get invested. I certainly read most of what's being said, but my contribution would likely be limited in its scope and even moreso in its accuracy.

 

 

I think I've covered all of the criticism against me, for now. Hit me up if you want something specific and I'll look into it.

 

For Zanders eyes only

 

Seriously, only Zander.

No really, only Zander.

Zander are we alone yet?

Okay good.

PM me on Skype for nipples. <3

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

My criticism is that youre playing differently to you Town Meta.

 

Limited as that is with you its still different.

 

Youve agreed yourself youre playing differently and that D1 is Meta stuff and fluff mostly.

 

If Im wrong youve got lots of time to prove it but you havent eased my concerns from this post.

 

And also....you cant bribe me with your nipples....youre a nipple prostitute and will show them to me regardless imo

 

Yes, my answer to that is that I play differently in every game I play because my roles are different.

 

If I read myself not knowing my role, I'd be null. Nothing I've said is something that is alignment indicative.

[Believer]

And also....you cant bribe me with your nipples....youre a nipple prostitute and will show them to me regardless imo

You're desperate enough to see them again that any nipple bribe should work.

[Believer]

If anyone has experience on playing with Believer, could you please comment on thoughts/meta regarding Believer?

I've played 2 games on this site before this, Taron Gaidon and Disney.

 

On MU as well as The Org I go by this same nickname, if you want to look at my previous games.

 

As to meta, It's not my place to say.

[Sooh]

Flyby, but

 

Believer gives very easy reads for ~uncertain or next to no reason to myself/Z/Dice and in part Besie. Zander jumps on him, not for the emptiness of those reads, but because he has reads? This reads so weird to me Z.

 

Following that the exchange between Believer/Zander ends with me feeling better about Believer and worse about Z.

No time for more details atm.

[Tiinker]

as long as its on believer or tink  im in

 

How people get these reads after such little interaction is beyond me.

[Tiinker]

as long as its on believer or tink  im in

 

How people get these reads after such little interaction is beyond me.

[Tiinker]

Also, I signed up this game could start. I'm trying to keep pace with it amongst other things I'm involved in.

[Tiinker]

 

as long as its on believer or tink  im in

 

How people get these reads after such little interaction is beyond me.

 

 

Actually after no interaction. We haven't even spoken to each other yet itt. What's the deal Dice?

[dicetosser1]

im here briefly   just got home from work so too tired for a 10 page catchup.

 

 

@tink  I didnt like the way you backed off ure zander vote

[Tiinker]

im here briefly   just got home from work so too tired for a 10 page catchup.

 

 

@tink  I didnt like the way you backed off ure zander vote

 

So you think I should've ploughed on along with it rather than recognizing I was wrong? Okay. 

[Pralaya]

Ok, caught up from yesterday. Thankfully not as much pages as I expected !

 

I do not have experience with a lot of people in this game. Haven't played with Besie, Nego. Played just a handful of games with manbat and calder, don't remember much how they play. 

 

That said, I wanted to know how Blesie played because I kinda saw some kind of appealing tone in this game. I know that she has only played one town game so far and I went ahead and checked it (Lost Mafia- notice her tone. She sounded similar as she is here - excited, analyzing etc. She got mislynched D2 in that game.

 

I don't see anything that has stood out from her so far this game. 

[Pralaya]

im here briefly   just got home from work so too tired for a 10 page catchup.

 

 

@tink  I didnt like the way you backed off ure zander vote

 

Tiinker plays quite safe when he is scum. I know it because I was scum with him in a recent game. I don't see him going for aggressive early votes like in this game as scum. 

[Pralaya]

Sooh and Zander are looking like I have always seen them D1. Never been able to read them right. I like sooh better of the two. She looks more focused and reasoning. 

[Nynaeve]

Nyn is a goddess.

 

Mod confirmed.

[dicetosser1]

was a weird reason for a vote and then way too easy for you to get off

[Nynaeve]

Official Coin Count

 

Believer (2): dice, Zander

dice (1): Believer

 

Not voting cause all the rum is gone (10): The rest of you wankers.

 

 

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

[Tiinker]

was a weird reason for a vote and then way too easy for you to get off

 

So after I voted what would have been the towniest thing for me to do? Lol you've already decided you want me to be scum and literally just "filled" in the rest. Feel like this was done earlier by someone irt my vote but can't remember who.

[Nynaeve]

Tiink, you never acknowledged my gesture on the compliment thread :/      Might have to slave you off to Davy Jones. Tell me, do you fear death? :P

[Tiinker]

Tiink, you never acknowledged my gesture on the compliment thread :/      Might have to slave you off to Davy Jones. Tell me, do you fear death? :P

 

 

[Nynaeve]

[Nynaeve]

I'm kinda disappointed no one jumped at the obvious quote joke.

 

 

Jack Sparrow: I know those cannons. That's Nyn. 

 

 

 

LDO. WAKE UP PEOPLE.