[Basic] Pirates of the Caribbean (Curse of the Black Pearl) Game Thread - D2

[Zander?]

 

Who is up for a speed lynch?

 

 

 

as long as its me while i sleep im in

 

prolly legit imo

 

 

In this scenario if Dice flips Scum I should be locked cleared imo.

[Zander?]

I'm down to d1 nuke a non contributor but I feel like that's going to be at worst 1/3 wolves and at best 2/3 wolves

 

We're not near, the need to lynch a random low poster point yet imo.

 

[Darthe]

Hey earlier when I picked the wolf team did anyone notice how those players responded?

 

Cause I didn't, and that's weird.

[Calder]

Hey earlier when I picked the wolf team did anyone notice how those players responded?

 

Cause I didn't, and that's weird.

Who were the people? Dont remember seeing your post.

[Zander?]

 

Hey earlier when I picked the wolf team did anyone notice how those players responded?

 

Cause I didn't, and that's weird.

Who were the people? Dont remember seeing your post.

 

 

Calder whats the word in the Scum qt????

[Nynaeve]

Official Coin count

 

Besie (2): Darthe, Zander

Believer (1): dice

dice (1): Believer

 

 

Not voting cause all the rum is gone (9): The rest of you wankers.

 

 

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

[Guest]

Hey earlier when I picked the wolf team did anyone notice how those players responded?

 

Cause I didn't, and that's weird.

 

Didn't feel the need to respond, since I already have plenty before that.

[Guest]

Reread thoughts.

 

 

 

Zander

- seems town p1 from intro

- reacts to me asking nego whether he liked what he randed (as i predicted) on p9. i know many people think that i only like to rand wolf. i'm taking this as slight town - he's going by his meta of me to figure out the game. solving.

- jumps at opportunity of me being wolf because of my slight read on darthe - town indicative. obv trying to find anything that seems off. solving

- still seems solving on p10 when asking darthe on his opinions - town indicative

- sussing of me occurs for the next few pages but i'm just going to stick with what i said above. solving

- votes me p10 

- p16-17 explains his thoughts on me to sooh which isn't alignment indicative

- p17 #336 his thoughts on sooh, which i don't really get but it's more meta things. probably slight town indicative

- p19 was the whole thing on me liking wolf more but being excited to rand town too - which bothers z due to his meta of me (see point 2). town indicative of him, imo. he's trying to solve the game and in the meta of a person changing, he has to change his opinion too, and he knows this - thus the frustration.

 

Nolder

- not really saying anything p2.

 

Sooh

- seems relaxed when talking to zander. Of course, it is p1 so doesn't actually mean anything.

- last post p3, doesn't really answer whether i should trust her but the way she does answer seems confident - not sure whether this is alignment indicative

- p16 #305 she asks questions about people's thoughts. probably not alignment indicative

- p16 #309 she questions tiink's decisions. seems to be solving. town indicative

- #312 same as above

- p17 #329 states that darthe is village due to nothing indicating otherwise? mmm.

- #335 questions zander on his opinion of me which seems more solving. town indicative imo

 

Nego

- I like Nego's intro tone on p2. Not alignment indicative yet, i think.

- I read it but it went over my head - this is your first game on DM? Welcome :)

- I like his tone p3 - seems to be game solving to start with

- 7 of the same posts so definitely scummy on p3 (joking ofc)

- joke votes Believer on p5 (continuous joking from IC lynch of a previous game) - doesn't mean anything alignment-wise; unvotes p6

- votes me on p8 for saying "interesting" - which i'm fairly certain is not the main reason, but rather that he voted me for the same reason darthe was suspect

- unvotes p13 (#249) when finding that it's a hammer game. not alignment indicative

- p15 #286 he asks about my meta. seems game solving. towny indicative if any

- p18 #351 he explains his thoughts. i'm going to go with slight town indicative, as he's sharing his thoughts and thus making himself easier to read to others

 

Tiink

- appears p3 but doesn't really say anything I can use to figure out alignment

- votes zander on p11 for... who knows? not enought to be alignment indicative

- and unvotes on the same page.

- post pings me p12 #228 - he asks how to get on monstrman's good side. feels like pocketing? (i'm not terribly convinced that i actually know the proper definition of that word). either way, slightly scummy alignment

 

Dice

- his intor on p3 seems relaxed - not sure whether i think it's alignment indicative or no

- back on p21, #404. he shares his thoughts on other's thoughts but not much more. Not alignment indicative.

- obv dislikes the fact that believer doesn't want to participate much or even form an opinion D1 and votes him #412. Kinda want to say slight town indicative? maybe just null. it's good that he wants people to participate, but he needs to participate himself - or at least share more thoughts.

 

Monstrman

- checks in on p4 in no way that i can determine anything

- continues on p4 in what i perceive as attempting to solve something in the past whole 3 pages - initially i had thought this was towny but on reread.. damn. it's just 3 pages. I'm making that not alignment indicative

- just a note* - interacts with darthe p5-6 (to look out for pocket/distance/sheep)

- my post #122 on p7 is both me squinting at the things darthe said (mostly on the interaction notes) but also saying that he's slightly towny. monstrman immediatly asks why i think him slightly towny after squinting. I'm taking that as town indicative. feels like he squinted at the post (bad joke) and is trying to figure out my thoughts, and seeing how it compares to his - as a way to decide my alignment. so, solving.

- last post on p11 feels honest, like he's saying he wants to solve the game and will do it to the best of his ability? i believe him. slight town alignment

- answer tiink in full even though it wasn't even necessary? p12 #230. not deciding on any alignment here yet. feels like it could have been planned. maybe. just a feeling. not alignment indicative yet.

- i understand his reasoning on last post p12, and even though it looks like nego backed off of the vote on me, he didn't unvote at this point yet. nego only unvotes later (#249) when he learns its a hammer game. He still seems to be solving and i like that he picks up on the small things like these. going to go with maybe town alignment indicative

- still calmly answering questions and sharing his thought process on p14 #274. as two above. i want to say town indicative. but something. ...

- and then #278 he states that darthe is bullying him. so i'm just going to go with null on that whole thing.

- post #280: "Guarantee we have low posting wolves that are loling at whichever villagers are sussing each other though" - no one has commented on. Mmm.

- reached this point and just realized that manbat is batman in reverse. thumbsup.gif

- thoughts on p15 #285 regarding zander being towny, because of z saying he's hard to read? i missed that. thanks to zander for providing the quote - p14, #262

- p16, #310, states that sooh is probably a villager. not alignment indicative, but funny that he doesn't follow his own "how to be a villager" advice to darthe.

- annnnddd nvm cause in #313 he gives his reasoning. 

- also interested in others's opinions in #314 which isn't aligment indicative rn but could does indicate interest in where others are standing

 

Calder 

- alive on p4. his intro post slightly pings me because i don't know whether he's joking completely or just stating what he's actually doing. It's the "blending in" part that makes me wonder. for now, not alignment indicative. later, p9, zander confirms that he does it as either alignment according to his meta, so definitely not alignment indicative.

- starts asking his questions that i can't see helping anything on p6 - not alignment indicative 

- i asked him why he was posting the questions and he responded by asking me questions - which i answered p8. i took his answers as being joking but i don't get it. is this psychology or something? he finally answered sooh later (p9, #179) on why but meh - i don't get it.

- says it amuses him on p10 - which may be more accurate. not alignment indicative? unless it's some way of being in the thread without actually saying or doing anything.

- shaking things up with his first proper thought-sharing game post on p10, #190 - but not enough for me to say it's alignment indicative. he seems to just be asking questions at this stage, to see what people respond with

 

Believer

- checks in on p4 with reference to being IC in a previous game - i didn't think twice about this and still don't take it seriously at all; unvotes p7

- joke votes nego back on p5 (so obv not aligment indicative)

- states again that he doesn't like d1 on p13. bit scary that he says he would vote anyone. surely he need at least some kind of an opinion before voting? not sure what this means alignment wise. he did say it earlier though so i'm leaning null

 

Pral

- checks in on p5 with a post on chinese, which overall isn't alignment indicative

- calls me wolfqueenie on p6 - definitely wolfy - (joking ofc)

- pocket attempt at zander p9 #171 accepted p10 #197, it seems. not alignment indicative i think

 

Darthe

- comes in on p5 with the post and correction of that post which i completely misread. he might be referring to a previous game where he faked a PR but i don't know about it so i don't know what he's going on about here. not sure what to make of it so i'll just keep it not alignment indicative for now

- just a note* - interacts with monstrman p5-6 (to look out for pocket/distance/sheep)

- confident/relaxed throughout p6 - not sure what that means. originally i thought it seemed towny but then i remembered that it's Darthe. making this not alignment indicative

- my post #122 on p7 is both me squinting at the things darthe said (mostly on the interaction notes) but also saying that he's slightly towny. he comments on all the squinting things, but not on my proposed read of him at that point. still deciding.

- p8 responds to my misunderstanding by saying i'm "tryharding" which is like grasping at opportunities. i understand his response here. might be slight town indicative, as he's seemingly seeing a possible person trying to find opportunities. 

- my attempt at drawing some reaction on p8 worked to some degree and he voted me next post - voting someone for saying "interesting" to what you obv know is a typo? gonna go with the opportunity thing here. especially since i finally got what he'd meant p9, explicitly stated that i had misunderstood (#168), and he didn't remove his vote.

- states his opinion on me "finding opportunities" again on p10, #189 - not alignment indicative, i don't think

- shares thoughts on top 3 scum p14 #270

- wants to join (pocket/sheep? i don't know the correct term) in on monstrman's post about zander being village because he said he struggles to read him (p14, #262). #291 p15. Not sure what to think of this. its joking and yet

- he continues riding the train to #295 of how if zander is town, then he is too becuase if they were w/w, they'd buss. starting to see this as the "opportunities" he likes looking for. slight scum indicative

- further (intentionally?) sheeps monstrman by agreeing that sooh is villagery but not giving his reasoning for it - last post p16

- and now he's agreeing with sooh on p17, #328. another pocket attempt? it seems to succeed too, going by sooh's response in #329. not sure what i think about this

- p21 #402 another pocket attempt at z which wasn't denied? can this still be not alignment indicative when it's the 3rd/4th time?

 

 

 

[Hallia]

Nyn is a goddess.

[Zander?]

Reread thoughts.

 

 

 

Zander

- seems town p1 from intro

- reacts to me asking nego whether he liked what he randed (as i predicted) on p9. i know many people think that i only like to rand wolf. i'm taking this as slight town - he's going by his meta of me to figure out the game. solving.

- jumps at opportunity of me being wolf because of my slight read on darthe - town indicative. obv trying to find anything that seems off. solving

- still seems solving on p10 when asking darthe on his opinions - town indicative

- sussing of me occurs for the next few pages but i'm just going to stick with what i said above. solving

- votes me p10 

- p16-17 explains his thoughts on me to sooh which isn't alignment indicative

- p17 #336 his thoughts on sooh, which i don't really get but it's more meta things. probably slight town indicative

- p19 was the whole thing on me liking wolf more but being excited to rand town too - which bothers z due to his meta of me (see point 2). town indicative of him, imo. he's trying to solve the game and in the meta of a person changing, he has to change his opinion too, and he knows this - thus the frustration.

 

Nolder

- not really saying anything p2.

 

Sooh

- seems relaxed when talking to zander. Of course, it is p1 so doesn't actually mean anything.

- last post p3, doesn't really answer whether i should trust her but the way she does answer seems confident - not sure whether this is alignment indicative

- p16 #305 she asks questions about people's thoughts. probably not alignment indicative

- p16 #309 she questions tiink's decisions. seems to be solving. town indicative

- #312 same as above

- p17 #329 states that darthe is village due to nothing indicating otherwise? mmm.

- #335 questions zander on his opinion of me which seems more solving. town indicative imo

 

Nego

- I like Nego's intro tone on p2. Not alignment indicative yet, i think.

- I read it but it went over my head - this is your first game on DM? Welcome :)

- I like his tone p3 - seems to be game solving to start with

- 7 of the same posts so definitely scummy on p3 (joking ofc)

- joke votes Believer on p5 (continuous joking from IC lynch of a previous game) - doesn't mean anything alignment-wise; unvotes p6

- votes me on p8 for saying "interesting" - which i'm fairly certain is not the main reason, but rather that he voted me for the same reason darthe was suspect

- unvotes p13 (#249) when finding that it's a hammer game. not alignment indicative

- p15 #286 he asks about my meta. seems game solving. towny indicative if any

- p18 #351 he explains his thoughts. i'm going to go with slight town indicative, as he's sharing his thoughts and thus making himself easier to read to others

 

Tiink

- appears p3 but doesn't really say anything I can use to figure out alignment

- votes zander on p11 for... who knows? not enought to be alignment indicative

- and unvotes on the same page.

- post pings me p12 #228 - he asks how to get on monstrman's good side. feels like pocketing? (i'm not terribly convinced that i actually know the proper definition of that word). either way, slightly scummy alignment

 

Dice

- his intor on p3 seems relaxed - not sure whether i think it's alignment indicative or no

- back on p21, #404. he shares his thoughts on other's thoughts but not much more. Not alignment indicative.

- obv dislikes the fact that believer doesn't want to participate much or even form an opinion D1 and votes him #412. Kinda want to say slight town indicative? maybe just null. it's good that he wants people to participate, but he needs to participate himself - or at least share more thoughts.

 

Monstrman

- checks in on p4 in no way that i can determine anything

- continues on p4 in what i perceive as attempting to solve something in the past whole 3 pages - initially i had thought this was towny but on reread.. damn. it's just 3 pages. I'm making that not alignment indicative

- just a note* - interacts with darthe p5-6 (to look out for pocket/distance/sheep)

- my post #122 on p7 is both me squinting at the things darthe said (mostly on the interaction notes) but also saying that he's slightly towny. monstrman immediatly asks why i think him slightly towny after squinting. I'm taking that as town indicative. feels like he squinted at the post (bad joke) and is trying to figure out my thoughts, and seeing how it compares to his - as a way to decide my alignment. so, solving.

- last post on p11 feels honest, like he's saying he wants to solve the game and will do it to the best of his ability? i believe him. slight town alignment

- answer tiink in full even though it wasn't even necessary? p12 #230. not deciding on any alignment here yet. feels like it could have been planned. maybe. just a feeling. not alignment indicative yet.

- i understand his reasoning on last post p12, and even though it looks like nego backed off of the vote on me, he didn't unvote at this point yet. nego only unvotes later (#249) when he learns its a hammer game. He still seems to be solving and i like that he picks up on the small things like these. going to go with maybe town alignment indicative

- still calmly answering questions and sharing his thought process on p14 #274. as two above. i want to say town indicative. but something. ...

- and then #278 he states that darthe is bullying him. so i'm just going to go with null on that whole thing.

- post #280: "Guarantee we have low posting wolves that are loling at whichever villagers are sussing each other though" - no one has commented on. Mmm.

- reached this point and just realized that manbat is batman in reverse. thumbsup.gif

- thoughts on p15 #285 regarding zander being towny, because of z saying he's hard to read? i missed that. thanks to zander for providing the quote - p14, #262

- p16, #310, states that sooh is probably a villager. not alignment indicative, but funny that he doesn't follow his own "how to be a villager" advice to darthe.

- annnnddd nvm cause in #313 he gives his reasoning. 

- also interested in others's opinions in #314 which isn't aligment indicative rn but could does indicate interest in where others are standing

 

Calder 

- alive on p4. his intro post slightly pings me because i don't know whether he's joking completely or just stating what he's actually doing. It's the "blending in" part that makes me wonder. for now, not alignment indicative. later, p9, zander confirms that he does it as either alignment according to his meta, so definitely not alignment indicative.

- starts asking his questions that i can't see helping anything on p6 - not alignment indicative 

- i asked him why he was posting the questions and he responded by asking me questions - which i answered p8. i took his answers as being joking but i don't get it. is this psychology or something? he finally answered sooh later (p9, #179) on why but meh - i don't get it.

- says it amuses him on p10 - which may be more accurate. not alignment indicative? unless it's some way of being in the thread without actually saying or doing anything.

- shaking things up with his first proper thought-sharing game post on p10, #190 - but not enough for me to say it's alignment indicative. he seems to just be asking questions at this stage, to see what people respond with

 

Believer

- checks in on p4 with reference to being IC in a previous game - i didn't think twice about this and still don't take it seriously at all; unvotes p7

- joke votes nego back on p5 (so obv not aligment indicative)

- states again that he doesn't like d1 on p13. bit scary that he says he would vote anyone. surely he need at least some kind of an opinion before voting? not sure what this means alignment wise. he did say it earlier though so i'm leaning null

 

Pral

- checks in on p5 with a post on chinese, which overall isn't alignment indicative

- calls me wolfqueenie on p6 - definitely wolfy - (joking ofc)

- pocket attempt at zander p9 #171 accepted p10 #197, it seems. not alignment indicative i think

 

Darthe

- comes in on p5 with the post and correction of that post which i completely misread. he might be referring to a previous game where he faked a PR but i don't know about it so i don't know what he's going on about here. not sure what to make of it so i'll just keep it not alignment indicative for now

- just a note* - interacts with monstrman p5-6 (to look out for pocket/distance/sheep)

- confident/relaxed throughout p6 - not sure what that means. originally i thought it seemed towny but then i remembered that it's Darthe. making this not alignment indicative

- my post #122 on p7 is both me squinting at the things darthe said (mostly on the interaction notes) but also saying that he's slightly towny. he comments on all the squinting things, but not on my proposed read of him at that point. still deciding.

- p8 responds to my misunderstanding by saying i'm "tryharding" which is like grasping at opportunities. i understand his response here. might be slight town indicative, as he's seemingly seeing a possible person trying to find opportunities. 

- my attempt at drawing some reaction on p8 worked to some degree and he voted me next post - voting someone for saying "interesting" to what you obv know is a typo? gonna go with the opportunity thing here. especially since i finally got what he'd meant p9, explicitly stated that i had misunderstood (#168), and he didn't remove his vote.

- states his opinion on me "finding opportunities" again on p10, #189 - not alignment indicative, i don't think

- shares thoughts on top 3 scum p14 #270

- wants to join (pocket/sheep? i don't know the correct term) in on monstrman's post about zander being village because he said he struggles to read him (p14, #262). #291 p15. Not sure what to think of this. its joking and yet

- he continues riding the train to #295 of how if zander is town, then he is too becuase if they were w/w, they'd buss. starting to see this as the "opportunities" he likes looking for. slight scum indicative

- further (intentionally?) sheeps monstrman by agreeing that sooh is villagery but not giving his reasoning for it - last post p16

- and now he's agreeing with sooh on p17, #328. another pocket attempt? it seems to succeed too, going by sooh's response in #329. not sure what i think about this

- p21 #402 another pocket attempt at z which wasn't denied? can this still be not alignment indicative when it's the 3rd/4th time?

 

 

 

 

Explain the red for me:

 

This post isnt bad admittedly.

[dicetosser1]

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

I haven't played with Besie before. Just modded a game she was in. Looks like she was wolf in all except one. Does she AtE like this in her wolf games?

What AtE?

"You always get me lynched :(", kind of posts

 

 

Not AtE imo.

 

Just a blatant misrep imo.

Do you think a scum Besie would openly misrep you? I mean, wouldn't she have thought to go back and check? Maybe not, her other posts are so wolfy, but this in particular makes me go hmm maybe not?

 

 

I mean its certainly possible she forgot it.

 

But in this case with it being her ONLY Town game and on top of that, the fact its me and what I did compared to someone else factors in to me having trouble thinking she forgot.

 

I forget or misconstrue games in my mind five mins after they end lol. 

 

I still think your suspicion might be good though, but using misrep from another game as a reason is kinda meh imo.

 

 

 

 

Maybe I used the wrong word but what she said WAS incorrect.

 

As Ive said she could have forgotten it but it seems fishy to me..

 

Also not the only reason I have for sussing her.

 

I know. I'm just suggesting that focusing on that part of your reasoning for sussing her is perhaps not the greatest idea, since it could be the truth?

 

 

Btw, who have found Besie villagery so far and why?

 

I think Monstr did, and Calder perhaps? Can you please explain what you're seeing?

 

 

im seeing frustration.  also that squint post has me thinking of something i sometimes do

 

 

 

Who is up for a speed lynch?

 

 

 

as long as its me while i sleep im in

 

prolly legit imo

 

 

[monstrman]

 

I'm down to d1 nuke a non contributor but I feel like that's going to be at worst 1/3 wolves and at best 2/3 wolves

 

 

We're not near, the need to lynch a random low poster point yet imo.

Concentration of contributing villagers is high in this village.

 

I estimate maybe 1 wolf tops in all of you, darthe, besie, sooh, Nego and with me that's half the village

 

Imo the other half has 2 wolves in it, unless like besie and Nego played the early distancing game

[Guest]

Besie, who is scum and why?

 

Not sure I want to answer this right now. Especially not after the last few pages. Would you mind if I reread the thread first? (and that only after my assignment?)

 

I don't mind at all.

 

Have to say I've never seen this kind of a response though. Not necessarely a bad thing!

 

The "why" is indicated in post #433.

 

Atm probably town is Zander/Sooh/Monstrman/Nego

with null Dice/Pral/Nolder/Believer

and scummiest is probably Tiink/Calder/Darthe? with calder the least of the three

[monstrman]

@Zander I have had besie as a villager and I'm not inclined to toss that read away without good evidence and I just don't see it yet. Maybe by the end of d1 but that's a long way away

[Darthe]

Reread thoughts.

 

 

 

Zander

- seems town p1 from intro

- reacts to me asking nego whether he liked what he randed (as i predicted) on p9. i know many people think that i only like to rand wolf. i'm taking this as slight town - he's going by his meta of me to figure out the game. solving.

- jumps at opportunity of me being wolf because of my slight read on darthe - town indicative. obv trying to find anything that seems off. solving

- still seems solving on p10 when asking darthe on his opinions - town indicative

- sussing of me occurs for the next few pages but i'm just going to stick with what i said above. solving

- votes me p10 

- p16-17 explains his thoughts on me to sooh which isn't alignment indicative

- p17 #336 his thoughts on sooh, which i don't really get but it's more meta things. probably slight town indicative

- p19 was the whole thing on me liking wolf more but being excited to rand town too - which bothers z due to his meta of me (see point 2). town indicative of him, imo. he's trying to solve the game and in the meta of a person changing, he has to change his opinion too, and he knows this - thus the frustration.

 

Nolder

- not really saying anything p2.

 

Sooh

- seems relaxed when talking to zander. Of course, it is p1 so doesn't actually mean anything.

- last post p3, doesn't really answer whether i should trust her but the way she does answer seems confident - not sure whether this is alignment indicative

- p16 #305 she asks questions about people's thoughts. probably not alignment indicative

- p16 #309 she questions tiink's decisions. seems to be solving. town indicative

- #312 same as above

- p17 #329 states that darthe is village due to nothing indicating otherwise? mmm.

- #335 questions zander on his opinion of me which seems more solving. town indicative imo

 

Nego

- I like Nego's intro tone on p2. Not alignment indicative yet, i think.

- I read it but it went over my head - this is your first game on DM? Welcome :)

- I like his tone p3 - seems to be game solving to start with

- 7 of the same posts so definitely scummy on p3 (joking ofc)

- joke votes Believer on p5 (continuous joking from IC lynch of a previous game) - doesn't mean anything alignment-wise; unvotes p6

- votes me on p8 for saying "interesting" - which i'm fairly certain is not the main reason, but rather that he voted me for the same reason darthe was suspect

- unvotes p13 (#249) when finding that it's a hammer game. not alignment indicative

- p15 #286 he asks about my meta. seems game solving. towny indicative if any

- p18 #351 he explains his thoughts. i'm going to go with slight town indicative, as he's sharing his thoughts and thus making himself easier to read to others

 

Tiink

- appears p3 but doesn't really say anything I can use to figure out alignment

- votes zander on p11 for... who knows? not enought to be alignment indicative

- and unvotes on the same page.

- post pings me p12 #228 - he asks how to get on monstrman's good side. feels like pocketing? (i'm not terribly convinced that i actually know the proper definition of that word). either way, slightly scummy alignment

 

Dice

- his intor on p3 seems relaxed - not sure whether i think it's alignment indicative or no

- back on p21, #404. he shares his thoughts on other's thoughts but not much more. Not alignment indicative.

- obv dislikes the fact that believer doesn't want to participate much or even form an opinion D1 and votes him #412. Kinda want to say slight town indicative? maybe just null. it's good that he wants people to participate, but he needs to participate himself - or at least share more thoughts.

 

Monstrman

- checks in on p4 in no way that i can determine anything

- continues on p4 in what i perceive as attempting to solve something in the past whole 3 pages - initially i had thought this was towny but on reread.. damn. it's just 3 pages. I'm making that not alignment indicative

- just a note* - interacts with darthe p5-6 (to look out for pocket/distance/sheep)

- my post #122 on p7 is both me squinting at the things darthe said (mostly on the interaction notes) but also saying that he's slightly towny. monstrman immediatly asks why i think him slightly towny after squinting. I'm taking that as town indicative. feels like he squinted at the post (bad joke) and is trying to figure out my thoughts, and seeing how it compares to his - as a way to decide my alignment. so, solving.

- last post on p11 feels honest, like he's saying he wants to solve the game and will do it to the best of his ability? i believe him. slight town alignment

- answer tiink in full even though it wasn't even necessary? p12 #230. not deciding on any alignment here yet. feels like it could have been planned. maybe. just a feeling. not alignment indicative yet.

- i understand his reasoning on last post p12, and even though it looks like nego backed off of the vote on me, he didn't unvote at this point yet. nego only unvotes later (#249) when he learns its a hammer game. He still seems to be solving and i like that he picks up on the small things like these. going to go with maybe town alignment indicative

- still calmly answering questions and sharing his thought process on p14 #274. as two above. i want to say town indicative. but something. ...

- and then #278 he states that darthe is bullying him. so i'm just going to go with null on that whole thing.

- post #280: "Guarantee we have low posting wolves that are loling at whichever villagers are sussing each other though" - no one has commented on. Mmm.

- reached this point and just realized that manbat is batman in reverse. thumbsup.gif

- thoughts on p15 #285 regarding zander being towny, because of z saying he's hard to read? i missed that. thanks to zander for providing the quote - p14, #262

- p16, #310, states that sooh is probably a villager. not alignment indicative, but funny that he doesn't follow his own "how to be a villager" advice to darthe.

- annnnddd nvm cause in #313 he gives his reasoning. 

- also interested in others's opinions in #314 which isn't aligment indicative rn but could does indicate interest in where others are standing

 

Calder 

- alive on p4. his intro post slightly pings me because i don't know whether he's joking completely or just stating what he's actually doing. It's the "blending in" part that makes me wonder. for now, not alignment indicative. later, p9, zander confirms that he does it as either alignment according to his meta, so definitely not alignment indicative.

- starts asking his questions that i can't see helping anything on p6 - not alignment indicative 

- i asked him why he was posting the questions and he responded by asking me questions - which i answered p8. i took his answers as being joking but i don't get it. is this psychology or something? he finally answered sooh later (p9, #179) on why but meh - i don't get it.

- says it amuses him on p10 - which may be more accurate. not alignment indicative? unless it's some way of being in the thread without actually saying or doing anything.

- shaking things up with his first proper thought-sharing game post on p10, #190 - but not enough for me to say it's alignment indicative. he seems to just be asking questions at this stage, to see what people respond with

 

Believer

- checks in on p4 with reference to being IC in a previous game - i didn't think twice about this and still don't take it seriously at all; unvotes p7

- joke votes nego back on p5 (so obv not aligment indicative)

- states again that he doesn't like d1 on p13. bit scary that he says he would vote anyone. surely he need at least some kind of an opinion before voting? not sure what this means alignment wise. he did say it earlier though so i'm leaning null

 

Pral

- checks in on p5 with a post on chinese, which overall isn't alignment indicative

- calls me wolfqueenie on p6 - definitely wolfy - (joking ofc)

- pocket attempt at zander p9 #171 accepted p10 #197, it seems. not alignment indicative i think

 

Darthe

- comes in on p5 with the post and correction of that post which i completely misread. he might be referring to a previous game where he faked a PR but i don't know about it so i don't know what he's going on about here. not sure what to make of it so i'll just keep it not alignment indicative for now

- just a note* - interacts with monstrman p5-6 (to look out for pocket/distance/sheep)

- confident/relaxed throughout p6 - not sure what that means. originally i thought it seemed towny but then i remembered that it's Darthe. making this not alignment indicative

- my post #122 on p7 is both me squinting at the things darthe said (mostly on the interaction notes) but also saying that he's slightly towny. he comments on all the squinting things, but not on my proposed read of him at that point. still deciding.

- p8 responds to my misunderstanding by saying i'm "tryharding" which is like grasping at opportunities. i understand his response here. might be slight town indicative, as he's seemingly seeing a possible person trying to find opportunities. 

- my attempt at drawing some reaction on p8 worked to some degree and he voted me next post - voting someone for saying "interesting" to what you obv know is a typo? gonna go with the opportunity thing here. especially since i finally got what he'd meant p9, explicitly stated that i had misunderstood (#168), and he didn't remove his vote.

- states his opinion on me "finding opportunities" again on p10, #189 - not alignment indicative, i don't think

- shares thoughts on top 3 scum p14 #270

- wants to join (pocket/sheep? i don't know the correct term) in on monstrman's post about zander being village because he said he struggles to read him (p14, #262). #291 p15. Not sure what to think of this. its joking and yet

- he continues riding the train to #295 of how if zander is town, then he is too becuase if they were w/w, they'd buss. starting to see this as the "opportunities" he likes looking for. slight scum indicative

- further (intentionally?) sheeps monstrman by agreeing that sooh is villagery but not giving his reasoning for it - last post p16

- and now he's agreeing with sooh on p17, #328. another pocket attempt? it seems to succeed too, going by sooh's response in #329. not sure what i think about this

- p21 #402 another pocket attempt at z which wasn't denied? can this still be not alignment indicative when it's the 3rd/4th time?

 

 

 

These are my least fav sorts of posts, mainly because they're way too long, but also I find that quite frequently wolves rely on them to generate content since this requires little to no analysis.  Just effort.  

 

You did a pretty good job of adding in thoughts.  [unvote]

[Guest]

 

Reread thoughts.

 

all of the *snip*

 

in regards to zander:

- seems town p1 from intro

in regards to sooh:

 Of course, it is p1 so doesn't actually mean anything.

 

Explain the red for me:

 

This post isnt bad admittedly.

 

 

Initial thoughts/feelings. I didn't take it as alignment indicative at all.

[monstrman]

 

Nego/besie/nolder is my secret wolfteam but it's a secret because it's contingent on besie and Nego being scum together and I only put the third one in there for reasons that are best kept secret until I have more evidence

 

 

Also, lol d1 wolfteams

[Darthe]

Monstr besie tink

 

Ggwp

[Guest]

omg sorry about #438

 

it was my response to Nego. the last few tiny gray (who knows why) lines is the actual response

[monstrman]

 

Monstr besie tink

Ggwp

 

I believe I responded in the manner which I always do

 

Deny it and attempt to refute the claim with pure WIM and can do villagery attitude

 

Or bribery whichever works better

[Zander?]

 

 

Reread thoughts.

 

all of the *snip*

 

in regards to zander:

- seems town p1 from intro

in regards to sooh:

 Of course, it is p1 so doesn't actually mean anything.

 

Explain the red for me:

 

This post isnt bad admittedly.

 

 

Initial thoughts/feelings. I didn't take it as alignment indicative at all.

 

 

You may be a villager after all

 

<3 <3 <3

[Guest]

It's 2.30 am. I'll check in again after sleep

[Guest]

 

 

And stop being so addictive, mafia! I have an assignment! 

*grumbles*

 

Did Besie do these kinds of posts in her town game because I'm usually irked by posts like these?

 

 

thats pretty much just besie period

 

 

ty.

 

 

 

I'm catching up for the next ten minutes then i need to start getting ready for work

[Guest]

 

fine

 

vote believer

[v]dicetosser1[/v]

 

 

Is this something Believer does all the time or should I vote for him now?

[Zander?]

 

 

 

And stop being so addictive, mafia! I have an assignment! 

*grumbles*

 

Did Besie do these kinds of posts in her town game because I'm usually irked by posts like these?

 

 

thats pretty much just besie period

 

 

ty.

 

 

 

I'm catching up for the next ten minutes then i need to start getting ready for work

 

 

Morning Nego.

 

Let me know if you have thoughts to share if you have time.