[Basic] Pirates of the Caribbean (Curse of the Black Pearl) Game Thread - D2

[Guest]

 

 

And stop being so addictive, mafia! I have an assignment! 

*grumbles*

 

Did Besie do these kinds of posts in her town game because I'm usually irked by posts like these?

 

 

I think this is the first game I'm doing these posts? I didn't have assignments in the previous ones, I don't think. 

 

But let's rather wait for people with better memories to tell you. 

 

 

Oh, and the main reason I'm repeating myself is so that there's no weird reasoning for my disappearance. 

I do see your point, and I will stop saying such things.

[Darthe]

 

And I would buss the hell out of zander

This may be the 1st legit thing weve ever agreed on!!!!

 

lolololololol

Stahp linking us

[monstrman]

Zander you said "darthe seems free flowing so villagery" which is "I think darthe is a villager" which is "I don't want people to lynch darthe"

 

No, you did not explicitly defend darthe but you put yourself in a position of being immediately capable of doing so by making that post

[Darthe]

Youre only accountable for your words and their implications in mafia. Never your thoughts.

[Sooh]

Besie definitely not looking too good here.
 
Catching up.

 

I sometimes claim town. But, life is for the enjoying. Gotta mix it up.

 
Something that may be Null but I noted for prev Calder games on DM
 
Calder claims Scum as Town the first time iirc and was ML
 
Then he claims Scum as Scum
 
I love this play and always joke about wanting him to to do it.
 
Then we play some games where he's Town!Calder and he doesnt claim scum even after me badgering him about it,
 
Now he claims Scum again.  Maybe to appease me?
 
Calder is awesome and crazy and does things his way but something Im noting anyways

 

How is it worth noting if he does this as scum and not scum and back and forth like that? Sounds like a null tell, no?
 
 
 

 

Am I crazy, Z, or are you currently sussing both Besie and Darthe?

 
I am sussing Besie.
 
If you think i have any sort of read on Darthe 10 pages in you should think again imo.

 

Well, you were definitely asking critical questions, which I interpreted as sussing. It just didn't match up that you were so critical to her, and at the same time being critical to him being critical to her.
 

 

[v]Zander[/v]

 

He didn't open up with "TOWWWWN YESS TOWNN AGAIN" and went too aggressive too fast. 

Thinnest reason ever in mafia, but it is D1, so idk?

[Zander?]

Zander you said "darthe seems free flowing so villagery" which is "I think darthe is a villager" which is "I don't want people to lynch darthe"

 

No, you did not explicitly defend darthe but you put yourself in a position of being immediately capable of doing so by making that post

 

 

 

Monstr besie tink

 

Ggwp

 

fwiw darthe seems pretty free flowing.

 

i didnt read all of Shads game and i dont read Darthe all that well but its not a BAD look imo.

 

 

Can you show me how you got that from what I said?

[Zander?]

 

 

And I would buss the hell out of zander

This may be the 1st legit thing weve ever agreed on!!!!

 

lolololololol

Stahp linking us

 

 

Im a Villager just speaking truths brah.

[monstrman]

Thats exactly the kind of soft defense a wolf says about a wolf bro

 

"He seems like a villager but I could be wrong"

 

I have voted neither of you because I am aware that villagers say the exact same things, and regardless you cannot argue that saying "it's not a bad look" is not the same thing as "I think it's villagery" even if you think it's only slightly villagery.

[Sooh]

 

 

He kinda did. Post 1 non-mod of the game

This was to tinker

 

 

lol god damn it. [unvote]

 

Whoa. Wait a second.

 

You vote Z in something that looks like super thin reasoning, but it doesn't come across as a joke, and then as soon as you're corrected (which btw I can't believe you didn't go check this actually. It was like right there) you unvote? 

 

Afraid to step on anyone's toes?

[monstrman]

Sooh is probably a villager

[Tiinker]

 

 

 

He kinda did. Post 1 non-mod of the game

This was to tinker

 

 

lol god damn it. [unvote]

 

Whoa. Wait a second.

 

You vote Z in something that looks like super thin reasoning, but it doesn't come across as a joke, and then as soon as you're corrected (which btw I can't believe you didn't go check this actually. It was like right there) you unvote? 

 

Afraid to step on anyone's toes?

 

I just don't think that's who I am. 

[Sooh]

 

 

 

I haven't played with Besie before. Just modded a game she was in. Looks like she was wolf in all except one. Does she AtE like this in her wolf games?

What AtE?

"You always get me lynched :(", kind of posts

 

 

Not AtE imo.

 

Just a blatant misrep imo.

Do you think a scum Besie would openly misrep you? I mean, wouldn't she have thought to go back and check? Maybe not, her other posts are so wolfy, but this in particular makes me go hmm maybe not?

[monstrman]

Let me rephrase

 

Sooh is probably a villager because, though she is not the first person to come in the thread with an express suspicion of tink, she brought up a suspicion that to me made sense and that I agree with

 

There is wolfy motive in backing off

[monstrman]

Tiink, what do you think about zander and darthe's alignments?

[Zander?]

Besie definitely not looking too good here.

 

Catching up.

 

I sometimes claim town. But, life is for the enjoying. Gotta mix it up.

 

Something that may be Null but I noted for prev Calder games on DM

 

Calder claims Scum as Town the first time iirc and was ML

 

Then he claims Scum as Scum

 

I love this play and always joke about wanting him to to do it.

 

Then we play some games where he's Town!Calder and he doesnt claim scum even after me badgering him about it,

 

Now he claims Scum again.  Maybe to appease me?

 

Calder is awesome and crazy and does things his way but something Im noting anyways

 

How is it worth noting if he does this as scum and not scum and back and forth like that? Sounds like a null tell, no?

 

 

 

 

Am I crazy, Z, or are you currently sussing both Besie and Darthe?

 

I am sussing Besie.

 

If you think i have any sort of read on Darthe 10 pages in you should think again imo.

 

Well, you were definitely asking critical questions, which I interpreted as sussing. It just didn't match up that you were so critical to her, and at the same time being critical to him being critical to her.

 

 

[v]Zander[/v]

 

He didn't open up with "TOWWWWN YESS TOWNN AGAIN" and went too aggressive too fast. 

Thinnest reason ever in mafia, but it is D1, so idk?

 

It is Null and I said that.

 

Im just saying that if Scum!Calder would know Town!Zander right?

 

And we all know what Town!Zander is like when I gets on to something that pings me.

 

Im saying Scum!Calder COULD be thinking imma just try to pocket Zander.

 

Again I said it was Null but something that crossed my mind.

 

Im not sure exactly what youre getting at with the besie/darthe thing.

 

But again look back I was sussing Besie but I wasnt sussing Darthe.

 

And ya some serious lolTink there dont know if its alignment indicative yet but a lot of lol.

[Sooh]

 

 

His reaction was... none of the reaction. Noneee of it.

 

Moving on.

 

What other reason do you have for voting me, Nego?

Also, does it count that you said "interesting" in your post about me saying "interesting" and if so, do you count as part of the 90% that say "interesting"?

 

 

Hmm.... When you put it that way...

 

 

And nah, I don't have any other reason for voting you yet. The phase won't end until Saturday so consider this just a warmup joke vote.

This is a wolfy post because it backs off of the vote that seemed kinda serious

 

It seemed kinda serious, but also it was based on pretty thin evidence at the time, no? Wasn't he like quite early with his vote on her?

[Darthe]

Isnt that the sort of soft defense anyone says about anyone? It's basically saying the person doesnt feel comfortable enough to commit which makes a lot of sense this early.

 

Is this a real point or an attempt to get conversation going?

[Darthe]

Somewhere beyond at believer, that is.

[Zander?]

 

 

 

 

I haven't played with Besie before. Just modded a game she was in. Looks like she was wolf in all except one. Does she AtE like this in her wolf games?

What AtE?

"You always get me lynched :(", kind of posts

 

 

Not AtE imo.

 

Just a blatant misrep imo.

Do you think a scum Besie would openly misrep you? I mean, wouldn't she have thought to go back and check? Maybe not, her other posts are so wolfy, but this in particular makes me go hmm maybe not?

 

 

I mean its certainly possible she forgot it.

 

But in this case with it being her ONLY Town game and on top of that, the fact its me and what I did compared to someone else factors in to me having trouble thinking she forgot.

[Darthe]

Sooh is probably a villager

I agree

[monstrman]

Isnt that the sort of soft defense anyone says about anyone? It's basically saying the person doesnt feel comfortable enough to commit which makes a lot of sense this early.

Is this a real point or an attempt to get conversation going?

Everything I say is an attempt to get a conversation going

 

It often fails

 

You once said that I tend to make irrelevant nonsense posts in the game

 

They are not irrelevant

 

They are not nonsense

 

Every one of them has purpose in establishing for myself my own history of my reads, what and why I'm thinking something, and how I approached that conclusion

 

They also serve the dual purpose of often getting people to ask me questions about my read, whether through pure inquisitive means or an attempt to get me to make a mistake and subsequently vote me. I am good at telling the difference between the two.

[Sooh]

Zander tunnels in both alignments so until I start seeing him talking about me I have a hard time reading him

 

From an outside perspective I'm leaning villager, and especially so if besie is scum (still don't think she is though)

Ok, from my limited experience with Monstr I believe that he's a villager this game. I feel like his sorting through the players into villagers and wolves before digging in is part of his town play and there doesn't seem to be anything agenda-y about his posts so far. More like an open mind trying to form reads. 

[Darthe]

Monstr basically playing aggressive defense, its a good style.

[Sooh]

 

 

 

 

 

 

He kinda did. Post 1 non-mod of the game

This was to tinker

 

 

lol god damn it. [unvote]

 

Whoa. Wait a second.

 

You vote Z in something that looks like super thin reasoning, but it doesn't come across as a joke, and then as soon as you're corrected (which btw I can't believe you didn't go check this actually. It was like right there) you unvote? 

 

Afraid to step on anyone's toes?

 

 

 

I just don't think that's who I am. 

 

Ok, well forgive me for squinting in your direction for a while then.

 

<.<

 

>.>

[Sooh]

 

 

 

Besie definitely not looking too good here.

 

Catching up.

 

I sometimes claim town. But, life is for the enjoying. Gotta mix it up.

 

Something that may be Null but I noted for prev Calder games on DM

 

Calder claims Scum as Town the first time iirc and was ML

 

Then he claims Scum as Scum

 

I love this play and always joke about wanting him to to do it.

 

Then we play some games where he's Town!Calder and he doesnt claim scum even after me badgering him about it,

 

Now he claims Scum again.  Maybe to appease me?

 

Calder is awesome and crazy and does things his way but something Im noting anyways

 

How is it worth noting if he does this as scum and not scum and back and forth like that? Sounds like a null tell, no?

 

 

 

 

Am I crazy, Z, or are you currently sussing both Besie and Darthe?

 

I am sussing Besie.

 

If you think i have any sort of read on Darthe 10 pages in you should think again imo.

 

Well, you were definitely asking critical questions, which I interpreted as sussing. It just didn't match up that you were so critical to her, and at the same time being critical to him being critical to her.

 

 

[v]Zander[/v]

 

He didn't open up with "TOWWWWN YESS TOWNN AGAIN" and went too aggressive too fast. 

Thinnest reason ever in mafia, but it is D1, so idk?

 

 

 

It is Null and I said that.

 

Im just saying that if Scum!Calder would know Town!Zander right?

 

And we all know what Town!Zander is like when I gets on to something that pings me.

 

Im saying Scum!Calder COULD be thinking imma just try to pocket Zander.

 

Again I said it was Null but something that crossed my mind.

 

Im not sure exactly what youre getting at with the besie/darthe thing.

 

But again look back I was sussing Besie but I wasnt sussing Darthe.

 

And ya some serious lolTink there dont know if its alignment indicative yet but a lot of lol.

 

I guess the reason I'm asking is because I don't understand why you said it was noteworthy if it's null at the same time, know what I mean?