[Basic] Pirates of the Caribbean (Curse of the Black Pearl) Game Thread - D2

[Nynaeve]

No change that I saw...

 

 

Savvy Vote Count

 

Tiinker (3): Besie, Nolder, Believer

Besie (3): manbat, Tiinker, Pral

Believer (2): Darthe, Sooh

 

 

Waiting for the opportune moment (3): dice, Wifi, Nego.

 

 

With 11 players alive, it take 6 to lynch.

 

 

Deadline: 

[Nolder]

 

 

Ok seriously people! Read Believer and please tell my why I shouldn't lynch him right now. His pushes on Tiinker have been nothing really, and that's about all he has done this game. In my experience he at least usually leaves a bit more of an imprint on the thread. 

 

Also when you have read and agree with me, please move your vote accordingly. Thanks.

I'll do that if you can explain to me why we shouldn't be lynching Tiinker in the first place.

He failed to explain his D1 vote adequately and his response to Besie was way over defensive for the level of discourse.

I'm not saying Believer can't be scum but I think it's more likely he's just busing a teammate and I'd rather sink Tiinker now and look at Believer tomorrow.

 

I think Tiinker explained his EOD1 vote reasonably enough. Zander was IMO playing scummily on D1, and for Tiinker to pick up on that isn't very strange. 

 

He has also reacted well to pressure from what I can see, and I don't think his reads are all bad.

 

I'm not talking about his EOD1 vote I'm talking about the vote he made on Nego on page 83.

[Nolder]

Also lol what?

He even admitted he didn't react well.

To echo his own words, are we even looking at the same game?

[Pralaya]

???

 

He voted Nego at the start of D2.

[Sooh]

Also lol what?

He even admitted he didn't react well.

To echo his own words, are we even looking at the same game?

Depends on what you attribute to a good reaction. Anyway, I have to go find his Nego vote.

[Sooh]

Looks to me like he did his research on the game and came up with a likely Besie/Nego scum team and voted one of them accordingly. How is this a bad vote?

[Nolder]

I got Darthe, Monstr, Sooh, Nolder as town with Nego, Besie and Dice as scum.

 

[v]Nego[/v]

Cut out 99% of this post.

You can follow it to the post proper though to review it's contents yourselves.

Just highlighting that he voted Nego since some seemed to have not noticed.

[Darthe]

He did tho

 

He was talking about a post after the z lynch

 

I remember it

Kinda my point. Post lynch it loses almost all value, and post flip its utterly useless.

[Nolder]

Looks to me like he did his research on the game and came up with a likely Besie/Nego scum team and voted one of them accordingly. How is this a bad vote?

I asked him why he thought Nego's posts "reeked" and he couldn't explain.

Why are you so hellbent on defending him?

Even if you think he's town...who do you think is scum again?

Believer I think you said? And who else?

[Sooh]

 

Looks to me like he did his research on the game and came up with a likely Besie/Nego scum team and voted one of them accordingly. How is this a bad vote?

I asked him why he thought Nego's posts "reeked" and he couldn't explain.

Why are you so hellbent on defending him?

Even if you think he's town...who do you think is scum again?

Believer I think you said? And who else?

 

I'm not hellbent on defending Tiinker. I just think what he has done makes sense. If I am hellbent on anything it is to get Believer lynched, which you seem to be hellbent against.

[Darthe]

^ditto

[Nolder]

 

 

Looks to me like he did his research on the game and came up with a likely Besie/Nego scum team and voted one of them accordingly. How is this a bad vote?

I asked him why he thought Nego's posts "reeked" and he couldn't explain.

Why are you so hellbent on defending him?

Even if you think he's town...who do you think is scum again?

Believer I think you said? And who else?

 

I'm not hellbent on defending Tiinker. I just think what he has done makes sense. If I am hellbent on anything it is to get Believer lynched, which you seem to be hellbent against.

 

I'm not hellbent against lynching Believer I just think there's more of a case to be made with Tiinker here.

What even is the case on Believer? He doesn't participate enough?

[Darthe]

 

Looks to me like he did his research on the game and came up with a likely Besie/Nego scum team and voted one of them accordingly. How is this a bad vote?

I asked him why he thought Nego's posts "reeked" and he couldn't explain.

Why are you so hellbent on defending him?

Even if you think he's town...who do you think is scum again?

Believer I think you said? And who else?

Tbf nego did stink d1, its on after that he really cleaned it up.

[Darthe]

 

 

 

Looks to me like he did his research on the game and came up with a likely Besie/Nego scum team and voted one of them accordingly. How is this a bad vote?

I asked him why he thought Nego's posts "reeked" and he couldn't explain.

Why are you so hellbent on defending him?

Even if you think he's town...who do you think is scum again?

Believer I think you said? And who else?

I'm not hellbent on defending Tiinker. I just think what he has done makes sense. If I am hellbent on anything it is to get Believer lynched, which you seem to be hellbent against.

I'm not hellbent against lynching Believer I just think there's more of a case to be made with Tiinker here.

What even is the case on Believer? He doesn't participate enough?

This is very at odds with your actions...

[monstrman]

 

He did tho

He was talking about a post after the z lynch

I remember it

Kinda my point. Post lynch it loses almost all value, and post flip its utterly useless.

You're NotWrong

[Tiinker]

 

Looks to me like he did his research on the game and came up with a likely Besie/Nego scum team and voted one of them accordingly. How is this a bad vote?

I asked him why he thought Nego's posts "reeked" and he couldn't explain.

Why are you so hellbent on defending him?

Even if you think he's town...who do you think is scum again?

Believer I think you said? And who else?

 

 

Wtf I did explain. I EVEN QUOTED IT TO YOU.

[monstrman]

TIINK QUICK

 

WHO WAS THE 32ND PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES?

 

IN A MORE RELATED QUESTION, I WILL DEFER TO NOLDER'S QUESTION AND ASK YOU WHO YOU THINK IS SCUM IN THE CASE THAT NEGO IS TOWN

 

PLS?

 

ILY <3

[Tiinker]

 

These kind of posts after also just reek. 

 

so okay, why exactly was zander lynched?

 

catching up, btw. i'm really tired though so i'm heading to bed the minute i'm done.

 

 

You played less than zero part in preventing it and are acting like there's nothing to his lynch. You didn't even participate in the Calder train which ironically might have given you more credit than not even voting. There was literally 40 pages of people spewing at each other that you've glossed over. This is not the reaction I'm expecting from town. 

 

 

 

THERE IT IS AGAIN FOR THE LAST TIME.

 

The only reason I'm continuing to answer these kind of questions because if I don't there's probably enough lazy behaviour here to say "well look, he didn't respond to this question despite it being asked and answered like five times so he must be lying." 

[Tiinker]

TIINK QUICK

 

WHO WAS THE 32ND PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES?

 

IN A MORE RELATED QUESTION, I WILL DEFER TO NOLDER'S QUESTION AND ASK YOU WHO YOU THINK IS SCUM IN THE CASE THAT NEGO IS TOWN

 

PLS?

 

ILY <3

 

Difficult to answer cause his interactions have been kind of inane since they're about his activity. I do think that you and him are most likely not w/w though because of certain posts talking about his presence and his meta. Those seem indicative that you're not working together.

[Tiinker]

This is talking about his interactions D2 over D1 mostly just fyi. I'd need to look closer.

[Pralaya]

Difficult to answer cause his interactions have been kind of inane since they're about his activity. I do think that you and him are most likely not w/w though because of certain posts talking about his presence and his meta. Those seem indicative that you're not working together.

Didn't get the connection between manbat and believer? How is it they need not be w/w?

[Sooh]

 

 

 

Looks to me like he did his research on the game and came up with a likely Besie/Nego scum team and voted one of them accordingly. How is this a bad vote?

I asked him why he thought Nego's posts "reeked" and he couldn't explain.

Why are you so hellbent on defending him?

Even if you think he's town...who do you think is scum again?

Believer I think you said? And who else?

 

I'm not hellbent on defending Tiinker. I just think what he has done makes sense. If I am hellbent on anything it is to get Believer lynched, which you seem to be hellbent against.

 

I'm not hellbent against lynching Believer I just think there's more of a case to be made with Tiinker here.

What even is the case on Believer? He doesn't participate enough?

 

I'm going to do what Believer did in terms of making a case. Tell you to read his ISO.

[Tiinker]

 

Difficult to answer cause his interactions have been kind of inane since they're about his activity. I do think that you and him are most likely not w/w though because of certain posts talking about his presence and his meta. Those seem indicative that you're not working together.

Didn't get the connection between manbat and believer? How is it they need not be w/w?

 

 

They've had some posts which just don't seem indicative of people who've talked about stuff. Manbat comments on Nego's meta being "flying under the radar" only to have Nego come in and shade him for doing so by providing links to all his games to look at. There were some others D1 IIRC but not going to dig into it.

[Pralaya]

 

 

Difficult to answer cause his interactions have been kind of inane since they're about his activity. I do think that you and him are most likely not w/w though because of certain posts talking about his presence and his meta. Those seem indicative that you're not working together.

Didn't get the connection between manbat and believer? How is it they need not be w/w?

 

 

They've had some posts which just don't seem indicative of people who've talked about stuff. Manbat comments on Nego's meta being "flying under the radar" only to have Nego come in and shade him for doing so by providing links to all his games to look at. There were some others D1 IIRC but not going to dig into it.

 

To be frank, I found that null between the two. The main reason is the fact that manbat and Nego have played mafia together and I am guessing, manbat kinda knows how Nego plays. IN a couple of the games he linked, manbat was also part of those games. It is something that can easily be faked as wolf. Not that I saying it is wolfy - just that it is null in indicating alignments.

[Tiinker]

 

 

 

Difficult to answer cause his interactions have been kind of inane since they're about his activity. I do think that you and him are most likely not w/w though because of certain posts talking about his presence and his meta. Those seem indicative that you're not working together.

Didn't get the connection between manbat and believer? How is it they need not be w/w?

 

 

They've had some posts which just don't seem indicative of people who've talked about stuff. Manbat comments on Nego's meta being "flying under the radar" only to have Nego come in and shade him for doing so by providing links to all his games to look at. There were some others D1 IIRC but not going to dig into it.

 

To be frank, I found that null between the two. The main reason is the fact that manbat and Nego have played mafia together and I am guessing, manbat kinda knows how Nego plays. IN a couple of the games he linked, manbat was also part of those games. It is something that can easily be faked as wolf. Not that I saying it is wolfy - just that it is null in indicating alignments.

 

 

Yes, true and one of them being town is not indicative of the other being scum in any case but I think the interaction speaks to two people not being the same page and I think both of them would be fairly active in a QT if they had one. Say they're w/w and Nego has talked about how he's being inactive on the QT and saying he'll pick it up soon. In that scenario I don't think that Manbat makes an outlandish statement like "Nego flies under the radar don't worry about it" since it's a really poor defence and doesn't make him look good when he gets called out for getting it wrong. In any case no one seemed to pick up on it so why would Nego make anything of it and shade him? 

 

Just trying to think of what a likely scenario for it would be. There were others but I'd have to search and I'm in class.