[Basic] Pirates of the Caribbean (Curse of the Black Pearl) Game Thread - D2

[Nolder]

glgl I'll be dead tonight anyway now that the doc is dead.

[Believer]

[v]Darthe[/v]

[Sooh]

 

Not having the best night atm. Got some strange chest pains going on. Nothing serious though I don't think. Dunno. Husband is taking really good care of me. 

 

Monstr, if you think I'm a wolf, go ahead and make a case on me and I'll respond when I get back here. Right now it's just a thought in your head and nothing concrete that I can refute in any way except shouting "BUT I'M TOWN YOU GUIZ", and that's not going to help any of us.

If you're town, underplaying my work by claiming that all I've done this game is claim "I'm Town you guys" isn't helpful to either of us

 

I was literally feeling unwell and not seeing anything that I could respond to at the time. If it came across as underplaying your efforts that was not my intention.

[Guest]

Morning guys

[dicetosser1]

unvote

 

 

nol  what exactly is ure role? and why did you choose darthe?

[Guest]

oh look i was right on calder.

 

 

We should absolutely examine those trains and should [v] vote Besie

 

1. Yes, you were right on Calder. And I was right on Zander.

2. You drove a Zander lynch. I did not drove the Calder lynch. imo you're more towny for this because you actually chose someone you thought were scum and went full out on it, where as I did not. I just wasn't going to vote Zander and was wtl Calder or Nolder.

 

Okay, I am caught up to page 49...yeah I fell asleep most of my catch up time meds...happens every morning nowadays.  Anyway, I don't think I can do a full catch up and keep current....I have some posts from my last catch up that I am going to go through...but it would be really nice if a few of you (3+)  would please give me a summation of what you think are the most important parts of the game going briefly from beginning of game cause tbqh I don't remember that much from it and it would be nice to have it all in one post

 

Euhm. See my comment to the post above? Other than that you would have seen by now that I had a train starting off, which switched to Zander & Calder. Darthe drove the Zander lynch, with some help from Calder before that. Monstrman switched between votes quite a few times. Nolder was a third for most of us and if there had been more time he could possibly have been lynched. Other than that no one has really been uniformally cleared i think.

 

When you're done catching up, please could you give your thoughts and reads? It's difficult to figure out what your actual thoughts on anyone is atm.

 

 

@ darthe: I don't suppose you'd want to throw out a summary for me, while I read the EoD and night to see if I can get caught up. Please....

Afraid not, sorry. Im a bit to RL busy this weekend. But, in short, nol besie calder and zander were d1 suspects that went somewhere, a lot of people floated around or popped in and out, and the game has no focus.

 

 

In addition to the answer above ^

 

 

I think the game should focus on besie/sooh/believer/nolder for now

 

I like what pral has been saying, though kat has been conspicuously absent as his hydra partner.

 

Dice feels like he could have some deepwolf equity because he's played so many games before, but like darthe said that one post that he made that darthe pointed out was town dice to a T was the same reason I had townread dice so I feel like he's probably just a villager?

 

I've seen flashes of villageriness from tink, I'd like to see more in depth analysis more often, though.

 

Nego is trying and he said he'd do more today so maybe nego try isoing those people and let me know what reads you come up with and I'll do the same

 

Wildfire has been posting okay enough today to not get lynched I think, but I'm not 100% confident they are a villager.

 

Darthe seems okay unless he's playing really well

 

What do you mean with the bold? 

I've not thought of deepwolves yet - also don't think I'm going to in D2.

[Guest]

This is the last vote count of D1.

 

 

D1 FINAL VOTE COUNT:

 

Zander (5): Calder, Sooh, Tiinker, Darthe, monstr

Calder (4): Besie, Zander, Pral, dice

Nolder (1): Believer

dice (1): Nego

 

Not voting cause all the rum is gone (2): Hellian, Nolder

 

 

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

 

I never noticed that Nolder didn't vote at all.

 

 

Keeping these literally-in-the-last-minute posts in mind:

[v]zander

[V] zander

(was on Nolder before this, but not very long - just long enough to get the train to move from Calder)

i was wrong

 

unvote vote nolder

[v]calder

[v]zander

unvote vote calder

 

 

[Pralaya]

That was a completely weird ass kill. Calder was a mislynch target and it is surprising why the scum killed him.

 

That flip kinda throws my theory off and makes Darthe look better. Also manbat. Sucks we lost the doc though. But, set up just enough to solve the game through POE.

[Pralaya]

Did Calder give any PR hints? I don't see to remember any. If he did hint it somewhere, I wouldn't even be surprised if they tried to lynch him EoD at the last minute.

[Pralaya]

Hmm....

 

Calder/Darthe scum?

Nego also looks good here. If he was scum, why would he push Calder and then NK him?

[Pralaya]

Makes no sense from the scum perspective

[Nolder]

unvote

 

 

nol  what exactly is ure role? and why did you choose darthe?

Tracker.

 

I chose Darthe because I can't see his posts so I thought it would give me some kind of read on him for later.

I don't see any sense in going to the grave with that info though.

[Guest]

That was a completely weird ass kill. Calder was a mislynch target and it is surprising why the scum killed him.

 

That flip kinda throws my theory off and makes Darthe look better. Also manbat. Sucks we lost the doc though. But, set up just enough to solve the game through POE.

 

I'd like to see you attempt this 

[Guest]

 

unvote

 

 

nol  what exactly is ure role? and why did you choose darthe?

Tracker.

 

I chose Darthe because I can't see his posts so I thought it would give me some kind of read on him for later.

I don't see any sense in going to the grave with that info though.

 

 

Nolder, why didn't you vote D1?

[Pralaya]

This is the last vote count of D1.

 

 

 

D1 FINAL VOTE COUNT:

 

Zander (5): Calder, Sooh, Tiinker, Darthe, monstr

Calder (4): Besie, Zander, Pral, dice

Nolder (1): Believer

dice (1): Nego

 

Not voting cause all the rum is gone (2): Hellian, Nolder

 

 

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

 

Looking at that vote count, I agree with what manbat said. Definitely scum in zander and calder trains. Given that it was a v/v train, the scum would also not be too much bothered EoD and would have just let the lynch pass in whichever direction it went. (Unless of course, if there was a hint that Calder was a PR and tried to capitalise on the opportunity).

 

Given that premise, I would say there is scum most likely in sooh/tinker/besie. As said before, Darthe cannot be scum based on Calder's flip and how the EoD went. Manbat very unlikely to be.

 

Dice, I am not sure - he did end up voting Calder at the EoD and tried to push the lynch to Nolder. But, would a scum be willing to take that risk on a v/v lynch?

 

I would bet my whole money that there is scum in the other group who were never involved in this. Kind of staying out of the trouble and let the villagers fight it out. Nego/BEliever/Hellian/Nolder.

 

Nolder claimed tracker. Nego, I don't think is wolf based on above.

 

If there is scum there and I believe there is, it would be between wifi/Believer.

[Guest]

DM just ate my post...

[Nolder]

 

 

unvote

 

 

nol  what exactly is ure role? and why did you choose darthe?

Tracker.

 

I chose Darthe because I can't see his posts so I thought it would give me some kind of read on him for later.

I don't see any sense in going to the grave with that info though.

 

 

Nolder, why didn't you vote D1?

 

I was in constant catch up mode because I spent all my free time playing a video game (sorry  ).

I did say I was ok with lynching a few people but I never felt right committing when I wasn't really involved in the day to day posting.

Also I was asleep when the actual lynch went down. 

 

It shouldn't be a problem again.

[Nolder]

DM just ate my post...

It was hungry.

[Darthe]

Given the claim we should back off nol for now.

 

[V] besie [/v]

 

Believe why are you voting me?

[Guest]

Retyping the post that DM lost for me. 

 

 

This is the last vote count of D1.

 

D1 FINAL VOTE COUNT:

 

Zander (5): Calder, Sooh, Tiinker, Darthe, monstr

Calder (4): Besie, Zander, Pral, dice, Monstr

 

Nolder (1): Believer, Monstr, Dice, Darthe

 

dice (1): Nego

 

Not voting cause all the rum is gone (2): Hellian, Nolder

 

 

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

 

I never noticed that Nolder didn't vote at all.

 

 

Keeping these literally-in-the-last-minute posts in mind:

[v]zander[/v]

[V] zander[/v]

(was on Nolder before this, but not very long - just long enough to get the train to move from Calder)

i was wrong

 

unvote vote nolder

[v]calder[/v]

[v]zander[/v]

unvote vote calder

 

 

 

 

Added the purple last minute changes.

 

I think I can assume there's one scum in Sooh/Tiinker/Darthe/Monstr, and one in Pral/Dice/Monstr.

If we believe Nolder's claim, then there may also be one in Believer/Monstr/Dice/Darthe.

 

Not part of this vote-for scenario is HellianWildfire and Nolder, since they didn't vote. 

 

 

* I currently have Darthe as my strongest town lean. From mid D1 he's been acting towny to me, and the end D1 events set it in stone.

He refused to vote Calder. He changed his vote from Zander to Nolder in an attempt to get a Nolder train going, and thus to get the train off Calder. He was on Nolder for long enough to see whether the train took off and then went back to voting Zander, as that was the only other train that could save Calder. This is town indicative imo.

* Not too different from Darthe, Dice refused to vote Zander. Dice was willing to follow Darthe's vote on Nolder, as it would remove the train on Zander. He switched back to Calder to save Zander. Town indicative, imo.

* It is worth noting that I was on Calder for the same reason. I wasn't willing to vote Zander, and Calder was the next highest train. I had both Calder and Nolder as possible scum at that point in time. I also missed the seconds/short minutes in which the Nolder train could've developed so I never switched to Nolder.

* In comparison to the above three, I don't completely understand Monstrman's votes. He was wtl all three. He followed along to Nolder when that was a possibility but switched back before it could become a proper train. And it just went this or that or this or that further. It feels like he didn't mind which of either Zander of Calder died. 

 

 

When just looking at end D1, I'm going to [v]Monstrman[/v].

I still want to see what Wildfire comes up with and what some others say.

 

Monstrman, did you have both Zander and Calder as strong scum candidates?

 

 

 

Mod approved for edit.

[Guest]

Aaahhh why did it go red? Mod, can I change the colour?

[Darthe]

Das a bad monstr vote

[Guest]

You were already voting me, Darthe.

[Darthe]

Oh that relieves so much stress.

 

Hey, why are people voting you iyo?

[Guest]

In summary I think there's at least one scum in

 

Sooh/Tiink/Monstr/Pral/Wildfire/Believer

 

I'm not wtl Darthe, Dice, Nolder or Nego D2.