[Basic] Pirates of the Caribbean (Curse of the Black Pearl) Game Thread - D2

[Nolder]

I'm not a villager monstr.

[Darthe]

So, wild and besue gotta duke it out pretty much. We are gonna win either way, it would be nice to see a concede.

[Tiinker]

nice

 

[v]nolder[/v]

[Guest]

Lesse what sooh said about nolder

 

[Vote]unvote[/vote]

[V]unvote [/v]

 

Just a note: You can just use

 

[unvote]

to unvote.

 

Ok so dyachei I reread sooh's iso and the funny thing is, sooh says a lot about killing besie d1, but all that's gone d2 when she notably doesn't ever put a vote on besie and even starts talking to her as though her opinions mattered

 

Besie also had the most notable activity drop d2 I think, she went from one of the top posters to not saying much at all and afaict the trend is only continuing

 

So idk I'm not convinced she can't be on a team with sooh

 

This may be considered AtE to some so don't read. For Monstrman's eyes.

 

This is completely true and is mostly due to our mislynch D1. 

 

Not because it was a mislynch, but because I love playing Zander with mafia and it's just not as fun for me without him.

 

 

 

Like ok look back at her read of besie first where she says "besie looks good coming out of the monstrman/besie engagement" but she follows it up a few posts later with "why are people finding besie villagery?" Did you forget that wolves can be villagery? Why the constant need to bring up her name like that?

 

It is worth noting that Sooh is an incredibly objective player. She will always fight for what's right. She never changed her opinion of me (I never perceived it as such anyway), and most of the quotes you posted she wasn't making me "townie", but was saying things she would say as either alignment. If something is wrong to her, regardless of alignment, she'll say it. You can read any of her past games to find proof of that.

 

I'm going to look at the quotes you posted of Sooh again, and I'd like to see one where she explicitly says "besie going up" or "besie town". In fact, I'll post it when I find them.

[Tiinker]

 

Like ok look back at her read of besie first where she says "besie looks good coming out of the monstrman/besie engagement" but she follows it up a few posts later with "why are people finding besie villagery?" Did you forget that wolves can be villagery? Why the constant need to bring up her name like that?

 

It is worth noting that Sooh is an incredibly objective player. She will always fight for what's right. She never changed her opinion of me (I never perceived it as such anyway), and most of the quotes you posted she wasn't making me "townie", but was saying things she would say as either alignment. If something is wrong to her, regardless of alignment, she'll say it. You can read any of her past games to find proof of that.

 

Is this something you consider when you consider her "defence" of me? 

[Nolder]

nice

 

[v]nolder[/v]

Lucky break wolf. It wont save you though.

[Guest]

Okay so there's none of the "Besie is villagery" in the posts you quoted of Sooh, Monstrman.

 

Going to search function to see if there's any posts like that.

[Tiinker]

 

nice

 

[v]nolder[/v]

Lucky break wolf. It wont save you though.

 

 

if your goal is to survive why would you claim tracker.

[monstrman]

I never said she said she found you villagery

 

I said she said you looked good coming out the engagement and that she never voted you

 

She never explicitly called you anything afaict

[Guest]

 

 

Like ok look back at her read of besie first where she says "besie looks good coming out of the monstrman/besie engagement" but she follows it up a few posts later with "why are people finding besie villagery?" Did you forget that wolves can be villagery? Why the constant need to bring up her name like that?

 

It is worth noting that Sooh is an incredibly objective player. She will always fight for what's right. She never changed her opinion of me (I never perceived it as such anyway), and most of the quotes you posted she wasn't making me "townie", but was saying things she would say as either alignment. If something is wrong to her, regardless of alignment, she'll say it. You can read any of her past games to find proof of that.

 

Is this something you consider when you consider her "defence" of me? 

 

 

Good point. That should definitely be considered. Unless she says "townie" or "going up" or whatever term she uses, she is not taking it as alignment indicative.

[monstrman]

Catching up from where I left off last night.

 

p 46-48. To those of you who say that Z and I are bussing wolves, just stop. We're not bussing. At least one of us is town, and while I have iffy feelings about the other this is never bussing. 

 

Monstr-Besie is interesting. I feel like both ends of that conversation held up pretty well under scrutiny. Actually feeling kinda dizzy after that. Not sure I like Darthe poking in and trying to tilt the conversation against Besie. It seemed like an attempt to antagonize imo with his "Let's see how she can get out of this one". It's parphrased, but that was the general idea of the comment. I think both Monstr and Besie came out of it looking better.

 

 

These reads are in no particular order:

 

 

Will not lynch: Monstr, Nego, Besie, Calder, Believer.

 

Unsure: Tiinker, Kat/Pral, Dice, (Hellian), Darthe

 

WTL: Zander, Nolder.

 

I feel like Monstr has had pretty solid solving posts throughout the game so far. He's attacking where he sees fit and investigating, and if he gets satisfactory responses he's not pursuing it anymore and rather clearing people over it. I've seen Pizza do the same as town in the past so I get this kind of behavior.

 

Nego has this air of the wise man coming into the thread with his wisdom. I don't get why people have him as suspicious. 

 

Besie started out oddly to me, but she has come a long way since then. Her latest back and forth with Monstr looked really good to me. I think if she was scum this game she would have been a lot more defensive in her posts and tone. Here she quite calmly explained her view, even with the pokes from Darthe in the mix.

 

Calder and I have just been seeing a lot of the same things and mindmelding. Also if what Darthe said about him being relaxed being a good look, then I definitely feel like he is this game. 

 

Believer is up in my will not lynch mainly based on a gut feeling. 

 

Unsure list:

 

Tiinker has been looking better, but only in short spurts at a time. I want more from him going forward, because currently it feels like he's doing "just enough" to get by in the game. 

 

Kat/Pral will be interesting to observe when Kat comes into the game. Classic Pral so far, but he has always been one of those I have difficulty placing.

 

Dice is more of the same. I don't trust my ability to read him D1, so that's why he's here on my list.

 

Hellian is off the plate until replaced.

 

Darthe was initially a high read for me, but I didn't like his actions in the recent Besie/Monstr spat.

 

WTL: 

Zander. I feel like I've explained my thoughts on Zander many enough times this game. His most recent reads list does look pretty well thought out, though consensus-y.

 

Nolder: His catchup was underwhelming and he has zero real time interactions.

 

You went from her scum list to her will not lynch list immediately following our argument

[Nolder]

 

 

nice

 

[v]nolder[/v]

Lucky break wolf. It wont save you though.

 

 

if your goal is to survive why would you claim tracker.

 

I was trying to help the town win. I figured if I was going to die it would amuse me more to be killed by the mafia than to be lynched by the town.

Also Tracker is a pretty easy role to fakeclaim. The odds of faking a no visit on a vanilla in a basic game are good enough. I just got unlucky by picking Darthe but I thought it would be part of a story people would buy.

[Guest]

I never said she said she found you villagery

 

I said she said you looked good coming out the engagement and that she never voted you

 

She never explicitly called you anything afaict

 

Oh okay, thanks.

 

You're completely right. She said she would but never voted me. At that point in time I thought she was waiting to see what happens, especially since there was quite a bit of time before DL, and my train had picked off quite a bit then. This was in the mindset that she was town though. 

[Guest]

 

 

Catching up from where I left off last night.

 

p 46-48. To those of you who say that Z and I are bussing wolves, just stop. We're not bussing. At least one of us is town, and while I have iffy feelings about the other this is never bussing. 

 

Monstr-Besie is interesting. I feel like both ends of that conversation held up pretty well under scrutiny. Actually feeling kinda dizzy after that. Not sure I like Darthe poking in and trying to tilt the conversation against Besie. It seemed like an attempt to antagonize imo with his "Let's see how she can get out of this one". It's parphrased, but that was the general idea of the comment. I think both Monstr and Besie came out of it looking better.

 

 

These reads are in no particular order:

 

 

Will not lynch: Monstr, Nego, Besie, Calder, Believer.

 

Unsure: Tiinker, Kat/Pral, Dice, (Hellian), Darthe

 

WTL: Zander, Nolder.

 

I feel like Monstr has had pretty solid solving posts throughout the game so far. He's attacking where he sees fit and investigating, and if he gets satisfactory responses he's not pursuing it anymore and rather clearing people over it. I've seen Pizza do the same as town in the past so I get this kind of behavior.

 

Nego has this air of the wise man coming into the thread with his wisdom. I don't get why people have him as suspicious. 

 

Besie started out oddly to me, but she has come a long way since then. Her latest back and forth with Monstr looked really good to me. I think if she was scum this game she would have been a lot more defensive in her posts and tone. Here she quite calmly explained her view, even with the pokes from Darthe in the mix.

 

Calder and I have just been seeing a lot of the same things and mindmelding. Also if what Darthe said about him being relaxed being a good look, then I definitely feel like he is this game. 

 

Believer is up in my will not lynch mainly based on a gut feeling. 

 

Unsure list:

 

Tiinker has been looking better, but only in short spurts at a time. I want more from him going forward, because currently it feels like he's doing "just enough" to get by in the game. 

 

Kat/Pral will be interesting to observe when Kat comes into the game. Classic Pral so far, but he has always been one of those I have difficulty placing.

 

Dice is more of the same. I don't trust my ability to read him D1, so that's why he's here on my list.

 

Hellian is off the plate until replaced.

 

Darthe was initially a high read for me, but I didn't like his actions in the recent Besie/Monstr spat.

 

WTL: 

Zander. I feel like I've explained my thoughts on Zander many enough times this game. His most recent reads list does look pretty well thought out, though consensus-y.

 

Nolder: His catchup was underwhelming and he has zero real time interactions.

 

 

You went from her scum list to her will not lynch list immediately following our argument

 

 

That definitely counts as her saying I'm town. Agreed.

[dyachei]

 

 

 

Darthe, I'm not against lynching him, but there's no hurry, is there?

No, I just wont tolerate a question hanging that leaves doubt. He is a wolf, and we are not wriggling on that. When we actually hammer today is irellevant to me.

right but i want to think through things without being told what to think or that it's "basic"

Dont post them on my thread. I. Know better than to let players like besie, wifi, even manbat wifom these things because youll process them and move on but they'll actually never vote him as a result of them. Trust me that I know this group.

 

newsflash: it's not your thread.

 

And I can post my thoughts if I want.

 

You may know them, but you don't know me. So I'd appreciate your patience.

[Nynaeve]

[Nynaeve]

Mod announcement: Any and all questions/requests/whinging towards the mods will be sent via PM. Anything on thread will be either ignored or ridiculed. Probably ridiculed. 

[Darthe]

 

 

 

 

Darthe, I'm not against lynching him, but there's no hurry, is there?

No, I just wont tolerate a question hanging that leaves doubt. He is a wolf, and we are not wriggling on that. When we actually hammer today is irellevant to me.

right but i want to think through things without being told what to think or that it's "basic"

Dont post them on my thread. I. Know better than to let players like besie, wifi, even manbat wifom these things because youll process them and move on but they'll actually never vote him as a result of them. Trust me that I know this group.

newsflash: it's not your thread.

 

And I can post my thoughts if I want.

 

You may know them, but you don't know me. So I'd appreciate your patience.

 

Def town, nvm my tinfoils they were just spooky

[Nynaeve]

Official Vote Acount

 

Nolder (4): Pral, Besie, manbat, Tiinker

Tiinker (3): Nolder, Wifi, dyachei

 

Not voting (1): Darthe

 

 

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

[Nynaeve]

I'm off for about an hour or two. Try not to miss me too much.

[Guest]

 

No! This must a pirates one!

 

[Nolder]

Please don't let Darthe hammer me. :/

 

Dyachei give me a mercy killing.

[Guest]

Mod announcement: Any and all questions/requests/whinging towards the mods will be sent via PM. Anything on thread will be either ignored or ridiculed. Probably ridiculed. 

 

*cough*

 

Ignore my post about the gif then.... 

 

<3 you nyn

[Nynaeve]

Please don't let Darthe hammer me. :/

 

That's what she said? >.>

[Darthe]

Please don't let Darthe hammer me. :/

 

Dyachei give me a mercy killing.

Lol this