[Basic] Pirates of the Caribbean (Curse of the Black Pearl) Game Thread - D2

[Sooh]

 

 

 

 

 

I haven't played with Besie before. Just modded a game she was in. Looks like she was wolf in all except one. Does she AtE like this in her wolf games?

What AtE?

"You always get me lynched :(", kind of posts

 

 

Not AtE imo.

 

Just a blatant misrep imo.

Do you think a scum Besie would openly misrep you? I mean, wouldn't she have thought to go back and check? Maybe not, her other posts are so wolfy, but this in particular makes me go hmm maybe not?

 

 

I mean its certainly possible she forgot it.

 

But in this case with it being her ONLY Town game and on top of that, the fact its me and what I did compared to someone else factors in to me having trouble thinking she forgot.

 

I forget or misconstrue games in my mind five mins after they end lol. 

 

I still think your suspicion might be good though, but using misrep from another game as a reason is kinda meh imo.

[Sooh]

Aaaand caught up!

 

Given that it's a hammer game I'm going to wait for a VC, but consider my current vote to be on Besie since she's the most wolfy atm. Tiinker breathing down her neck as well.

[Darthe]

I do that toosooh =) no clue what happened two games ago, sometimes not even what team I was on

[Sooh]

Btw, going through this I'm kinda feeling Darthe as villagery. Nothing that has pinged me the wrong way there yet. Of course last time we played he duped me completely as a wolf until the end, so meh, but I'm not lynching there today.

[Sooh]

I do that toosooh =) no clue what happened two games ago, sometimes not even what team I was on

I bet you remember the one I just mentioned

[Zander?]

 

 

 

 

Besie definitely not looking too good here.

 

Catching up.

 

I sometimes claim town. But, life is for the enjoying. Gotta mix it up.

 

Something that may be Null but I noted for prev Calder games on DM

 

Calder claims Scum as Town the first time iirc and was ML

 

Then he claims Scum as Scum

 

I love this play and always joke about wanting him to to do it.

 

Then we play some games where he's Town!Calder and he doesnt claim scum even after me badgering him about it,

 

Now he claims Scum again.  Maybe to appease me?

 

Calder is awesome and crazy and does things his way but something Im noting anyways

 

How is it worth noting if he does this as scum and not scum and back and forth like that? Sounds like a null tell, no?

 

 

 

 

Am I crazy, Z, or are you currently sussing both Besie and Darthe?

 

I am sussing Besie.

 

If you think i have any sort of read on Darthe 10 pages in you should think again imo.

 

Well, you were definitely asking critical questions, which I interpreted as sussing. It just didn't match up that you were so critical to her, and at the same time being critical to him being critical to her.

 

 

[v]Zander[/v]

 

He didn't open up with "TOWWWWN YESS TOWNN AGAIN" and went too aggressive too fast. 

Thinnest reason ever in mafia, but it is D1, so idk?

 

 

 

It is Null and I said that.

 

Im just saying that if Scum!Calder would know Town!Zander right?

 

And we all know what Town!Zander is like when I gets on to something that pings me.

 

Im saying Scum!Calder COULD be thinking imma just try to pocket Zander.

 

Again I said it was Null but something that crossed my mind.

 

Im not sure exactly what youre getting at with the besie/darthe thing.

 

But again look back I was sussing Besie but I wasnt sussing Darthe.

 

And ya some serious lolTink there dont know if its alignment indicative yet but a lot of lol.

 

I guess the reason I'm asking is because I don't understand why you said it was noteworthy if it's null at the same time, know what I mean?

 

 

Ive np with you asking hence why I explained it out.

 

I

[Zander?]

 

 

 

 

 

 

I haven't played with Besie before. Just modded a game she was in. Looks like she was wolf in all except one. Does she AtE like this in her wolf games?

What AtE?

"You always get me lynched :(", kind of posts

 

 

Not AtE imo.

 

Just a blatant misrep imo.

Do you think a scum Besie would openly misrep you? I mean, wouldn't she have thought to go back and check? Maybe not, her other posts are so wolfy, but this in particular makes me go hmm maybe not?

 

 

I mean its certainly possible she forgot it.

 

But in this case with it being her ONLY Town game and on top of that, the fact its me and what I did compared to someone else factors in to me having trouble thinking she forgot.

 

I forget or misconstrue games in my mind five mins after they end lol. 

 

I still think your suspicion might be good though, but using misrep from another game as a reason is kinda meh imo.

 

 

Maybe I used the wrong word but what she said WAS incorrect.

 

As Ive said she could have forgotten it but it seems fishy to me..

 

Also not the only reason I have for sussing her.

[Sooh]

 

 

 

 

 

Besie definitely not looking too good here.

 

Catching up.

 

I sometimes claim town. But, life is for the enjoying. Gotta mix it up.

 

Something that may be Null but I noted for prev Calder games on DM

 

Calder claims Scum as Town the first time iirc and was ML

 

Then he claims Scum as Scum

 

I love this play and always joke about wanting him to to do it.

 

Then we play some games where he's Town!Calder and he doesnt claim scum even after me badgering him about it,

 

Now he claims Scum again.  Maybe to appease me?

 

Calder is awesome and crazy and does things his way but something Im noting anyways

 

How is it worth noting if he does this as scum and not scum and back and forth like that? Sounds like a null tell, no?

 

 

 

 

Am I crazy, Z, or are you currently sussing both Besie and Darthe?

 

I am sussing Besie.

 

If you think i have any sort of read on Darthe 10 pages in you should think again imo.

 

Well, you were definitely asking critical questions, which I interpreted as sussing. It just didn't match up that you were so critical to her, and at the same time being critical to him being critical to her.

 

 

[v]Zander[/v]

 

He didn't open up with "TOWWWWN YESS TOWNN AGAIN" and went too aggressive too fast. 

Thinnest reason ever in mafia, but it is D1, so idk?

 

 

 

It is Null and I said that.

 

Im just saying that if Scum!Calder would know Town!Zander right?

 

And we all know what Town!Zander is like when I gets on to something that pings me.

 

Im saying Scum!Calder COULD be thinking imma just try to pocket Zander.

 

Again I said it was Null but something that crossed my mind.

 

Im not sure exactly what youre getting at with the besie/darthe thing.

 

But again look back I was sussing Besie but I wasnt sussing Darthe.

 

And ya some serious lolTink there dont know if its alignment indicative yet but a lot of lol.

 

I guess the reason I'm asking is because I don't understand why you said it was noteworthy if it's null at the same time, know what I mean?

 

 

Ive np with you asking hence why I explained it out.

 

I

 

Oki. Good. 

 

I do have a few villagery vibes from you so far this game, so I'm leaning that way, but it's not as many as I had hoped for, so keep it up I guess?

[Darthe]

 

I do that toosooh =) no clue what happened two games ago, sometimes not even what team I was on

I bet you remember the one I just mentioned

It's why wolfing is fun, I got to create a strat and plan and follow through that. Way more calculated than my basic town game.

[Sooh]

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

I haven't played with Besie before. Just modded a game she was in. Looks like she was wolf in all except one. Does she AtE like this in her wolf games?

What AtE?

"You always get me lynched :(", kind of posts

 

 

Not AtE imo.

 

Just a blatant misrep imo.

Do you think a scum Besie would openly misrep you? I mean, wouldn't she have thought to go back and check? Maybe not, her other posts are so wolfy, but this in particular makes me go hmm maybe not?

 

 

I mean its certainly possible she forgot it.

 

But in this case with it being her ONLY Town game and on top of that, the fact its me and what I did compared to someone else factors in to me having trouble thinking she forgot.

 

I forget or misconstrue games in my mind five mins after they end lol. 

 

I still think your suspicion might be good though, but using misrep from another game as a reason is kinda meh imo.

 

 

 

 

Maybe I used the wrong word but what she said WAS incorrect.

 

As Ive said she could have forgotten it but it seems fishy to me..

 

Also not the only reason I have for sussing her.

 

I know. I'm just suggesting that focusing on that part of your reasoning for sussing her is perhaps not the greatest idea, since it could be the truth?

 

 

Btw, who have found Besie villagery so far and why?

 

I think Monstr did, and Calder perhaps? Can you please explain what you're seeing?

[Zander?]

 

 

 

 

 

 

Besie definitely not looking too good here.

 

Catching up.

 

I sometimes claim town. But, life is for the enjoying. Gotta mix it up.

 

Something that may be Null but I noted for prev Calder games on DM

 

Calder claims Scum as Town the first time iirc and was ML

 

Then he claims Scum as Scum

 

I love this play and always joke about wanting him to to do it.

 

Then we play some games where he's Town!Calder and he doesnt claim scum even after me badgering him about it,

 

Now he claims Scum again.  Maybe to appease me?

 

Calder is awesome and crazy and does things his way but something Im noting anyways

 

How is it worth noting if he does this as scum and not scum and back and forth like that? Sounds like a null tell, no?

 

 

 

 

Am I crazy, Z, or are you currently sussing both Besie and Darthe?

 

I am sussing Besie.

 

If you think i have any sort of read on Darthe 10 pages in you should think again imo.

 

Well, you were definitely asking critical questions, which I interpreted as sussing. It just didn't match up that you were so critical to her, and at the same time being critical to him being critical to her.

 

 

[v]Zander[/v]

 

He didn't open up with "TOWWWWN YESS TOWNN AGAIN" and went too aggressive too fast. 

Thinnest reason ever in mafia, but it is D1, so idk?

 

 

 

It is Null and I said that.

 

Im just saying that if Scum!Calder would know Town!Zander right?

 

And we all know what Town!Zander is like when I gets on to something that pings me.

 

Im saying Scum!Calder COULD be thinking imma just try to pocket Zander.

 

Again I said it was Null but something that crossed my mind.

 

Im not sure exactly what youre getting at with the besie/darthe thing.

 

But again look back I was sussing Besie but I wasnt sussing Darthe.

 

And ya some serious lolTink there dont know if its alignment indicative yet but a lot of lol.

 

I guess the reason I'm asking is because I don't understand why you said it was noteworthy if it's null at the same time, know what I mean?

 

 

Ive np with you asking hence why I explained it out.

 

I

 

Oki. Good. 

 

I do have a few villagery vibes from you so far this game, so I'm leaning that way, but it's not as many as I had hoped for, so keep it up I guess?

 

 

I have the same vibes about you....tho Im not sure my is Sooh Villagery, if yes shes a Wolf and is Sooh Wolfy if yes shes Town Meta dont hold true anymore....lolololol

 

 

If YOU has said you felt strongly about me being Town this early Id be legit sketched out about you

[Sooh]

 

 

I do that toosooh =) no clue what happened two games ago, sometimes not even what team I was on

I bet you remember the one I just mentioned

It's why wolfing is fun, I got to create a strat and plan and follow through that. Way more calculated than my basic town game.

 

I don't think I've ever had a scum strategy lol. Probably why I've sucked as scum so far. I did shoot Zander in my mash on MU that ended like yesterday though, and was the only surviving scum who won the game

 

*rubs it in*

[Sooh]

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Besie definitely not looking too good here.

 

Catching up.

 

I sometimes claim town. But, life is for the enjoying. Gotta mix it up.

 

Something that may be Null but I noted for prev Calder games on DM

 

Calder claims Scum as Town the first time iirc and was ML

 

Then he claims Scum as Scum

 

I love this play and always joke about wanting him to to do it.

 

Then we play some games where he's Town!Calder and he doesnt claim scum even after me badgering him about it,

 

Now he claims Scum again.  Maybe to appease me?

 

Calder is awesome and crazy and does things his way but something Im noting anyways

 

How is it worth noting if he does this as scum and not scum and back and forth like that? Sounds like a null tell, no?

 

 

 

 

Am I crazy, Z, or are you currently sussing both Besie and Darthe?

 

I am sussing Besie.

 

If you think i have any sort of read on Darthe 10 pages in you should think again imo.

 

Well, you were definitely asking critical questions, which I interpreted as sussing. It just didn't match up that you were so critical to her, and at the same time being critical to him being critical to her.

 

 

[v]Zander[/v]

 

He didn't open up with "TOWWWWN YESS TOWNN AGAIN" and went too aggressive too fast. 

Thinnest reason ever in mafia, but it is D1, so idk?

 

 

 

It is Null and I said that.

 

Im just saying that if Scum!Calder would know Town!Zander right?

 

And we all know what Town!Zander is like when I gets on to something that pings me.

 

Im saying Scum!Calder COULD be thinking imma just try to pocket Zander.

 

Again I said it was Null but something that crossed my mind.

 

Im not sure exactly what youre getting at with the besie/darthe thing.

 

But again look back I was sussing Besie but I wasnt sussing Darthe.

 

And ya some serious lolTink there dont know if its alignment indicative yet but a lot of lol.

 

I guess the reason I'm asking is because I don't understand why you said it was noteworthy if it's null at the same time, know what I mean?

 

 

Ive np with you asking hence why I explained it out.

 

I

 

Oki. Good. 

 

I do have a few villagery vibes from you so far this game, so I'm leaning that way, but it's not as many as I had hoped for, so keep it up I guess?

 

 

 

 

I have the same vibes about you....tho Im not sure my is Sooh Villagery, if yes shes a Wolf and is Sooh Wolfy if yes shes Town Meta dont hold true anymore....lolololol

 

 

If YOU has said you felt strongly about me being Town this early Id be legit sketched out about you

 

lol do you want to try it out one more time or have all your other failed experiments made you toss out this theory? 

[Zander?]

 

 

 

I do that toosooh =) no clue what happened two games ago, sometimes not even what team I was on

I bet you remember the one I just mentioned

It's why wolfing is fun, I got to create a strat and plan and follow through that. Way more calculated than my basic town game.

 

I don't think I've ever had a scum strategy lol. Probably why I've sucked as scum so far. I did shoot Zander in my mash on MU that ended like yesterday though, and was the only surviving scum who won the game

 

*rubs it in*

 

 

i didnt even know the game started

 

sadface.gif

[Sooh]

 

 

 

 

I do that toosooh =) no clue what happened two games ago, sometimes not even what team I was on

I bet you remember the one I just mentioned

It's why wolfing is fun, I got to create a strat and plan and follow through that. Way more calculated than my basic town game.

 

I don't think I've ever had a scum strategy lol. Probably why I've sucked as scum so far. I did shoot Zander in my mash on MU that ended like yesterday though, and was the only surviving scum who won the game

 

*rubs it in*

 

 

 

 

i didnt even know the game started

 

sadface.gif

 

*chuckles evilly*

[Darthe]

Most folks dknt usually make a game strat as a wolf.

[Sooh]

Most folks dknt usually make a game strat as a wolf.

Next time I rand wolf with you you have to teach me. (Have we ever wolfed together?)

[Zander?]

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Besie definitely not looking too good here.

 

Catching up.

 

I sometimes claim town. But, life is for the enjoying. Gotta mix it up.

 

Something that may be Null but I noted for prev Calder games on DM

 

Calder claims Scum as Town the first time iirc and was ML

 

Then he claims Scum as Scum

 

I love this play and always joke about wanting him to to do it.

 

Then we play some games where he's Town!Calder and he doesnt claim scum even after me badgering him about it,

 

Now he claims Scum again.  Maybe to appease me?

 

Calder is awesome and crazy and does things his way but something Im noting anyways

 

How is it worth noting if he does this as scum and not scum and back and forth like that? Sounds like a null tell, no?

 

 

 

 

Am I crazy, Z, or are you currently sussing both Besie and Darthe?

 

I am sussing Besie.

 

If you think i have any sort of read on Darthe 10 pages in you should think again imo.

 

Well, you were definitely asking critical questions, which I interpreted as sussing. It just didn't match up that you were so critical to her, and at the same time being critical to him being critical to her.

 

 

[v]Zander[/v]

 

He didn't open up with "TOWWWWN YESS TOWNN AGAIN" and went too aggressive too fast. 

Thinnest reason ever in mafia, but it is D1, so idk?

 

 

 

It is Null and I said that.

 

Im just saying that if Scum!Calder would know Town!Zander right?

 

And we all know what Town!Zander is like when I gets on to something that pings me.

 

Im saying Scum!Calder COULD be thinking imma just try to pocket Zander.

 

Again I said it was Null but something that crossed my mind.

 

Im not sure exactly what youre getting at with the besie/darthe thing.

 

But again look back I was sussing Besie but I wasnt sussing Darthe.

 

And ya some serious lolTink there dont know if its alignment indicative yet but a lot of lol.

 

I guess the reason I'm asking is because I don't understand why you said it was noteworthy if it's null at the same time, know what I mean?

 

 

Ive np with you asking hence why I explained it out.

 

I

 

Oki. Good. 

 

I do have a few villagery vibes from you so far this game, so I'm leaning that way, but it's not as many as I had hoped for, so keep it up I guess?

 

 

 

 

I have the same vibes about you....tho Im not sure my is Sooh Villagery, if yes shes a Wolf and is Sooh Wolfy if yes shes Town Meta dont hold true anymore....lolololol

 

 

If YOU has said you felt strongly about me being Town this early Id be legit sketched out about you

 

lol do you want to try it out one more time or have all your other failed experiments made you toss out this theory? 

 

 

 

Ive been getting a little better lately tho.

 

sadface,gif

 

I was talking to Nyn before about how to read you and she advised me my Sooh!Meta was "as stupid as my face is"

 

So that kinda factored in to it!!!!

 

lolololololol

[Zander?]

 

 

 

 

 

I do that toosooh =) no clue what happened two games ago, sometimes not even what team I was on

I bet you remember the one I just mentioned

It's why wolfing is fun, I got to create a strat and plan and follow through that. Way more calculated than my basic town game.

 

I don't think I've ever had a scum strategy lol. Probably why I've sucked as scum so far. I did shoot Zander in my mash on MU that ended like yesterday though, and was the only surviving scum who won the game

 

*rubs it in*

 

 

 

 

i didnt even know the game started

 

sadface.gif

 

*chuckles evilly*

 

 

WOLFY AF

[Guest]

 

Besie, who is scum and why?

 

Not sure I want to answer this right now. Especially not after the last few pages. Would you mind if I reread the thread first? (and that only after my assignment?)

 

 

I don't mind at all.

 

Have to say I've never seen this kind of a response though. Not necessarely a bad thing!

[Sooh]

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Besie definitely not looking too good here.

 

Catching up.

 

I sometimes claim town. But, life is for the enjoying. Gotta mix it up.

 

Something that may be Null but I noted for prev Calder games on DM

 

Calder claims Scum as Town the first time iirc and was ML

 

Then he claims Scum as Scum

 

I love this play and always joke about wanting him to to do it.

 

Then we play some games where he's Town!Calder and he doesnt claim scum even after me badgering him about it,

 

Now he claims Scum again.  Maybe to appease me?

 

Calder is awesome and crazy and does things his way but something Im noting anyways

 

How is it worth noting if he does this as scum and not scum and back and forth like that? Sounds like a null tell, no?

 

 

 

 

Am I crazy, Z, or are you currently sussing both Besie and Darthe?

 

I am sussing Besie.

 

If you think i have any sort of read on Darthe 10 pages in you should think again imo.

 

Well, you were definitely asking critical questions, which I interpreted as sussing. It just didn't match up that you were so critical to her, and at the same time being critical to him being critical to her.

 

 

[v]Zander[/v]

 

He didn't open up with "TOWWWWN YESS TOWNN AGAIN" and went too aggressive too fast. 

Thinnest reason ever in mafia, but it is D1, so idk?

 

 

 

It is Null and I said that.

 

Im just saying that if Scum!Calder would know Town!Zander right?

 

And we all know what Town!Zander is like when I gets on to something that pings me.

 

Im saying Scum!Calder COULD be thinking imma just try to pocket Zander.

 

Again I said it was Null but something that crossed my mind.

 

Im not sure exactly what youre getting at with the besie/darthe thing.

 

But again look back I was sussing Besie but I wasnt sussing Darthe.

 

And ya some serious lolTink there dont know if its alignment indicative yet but a lot of lol.

 

I guess the reason I'm asking is because I don't understand why you said it was noteworthy if it's null at the same time, know what I mean?

 

 

Ive np with you asking hence why I explained it out.

 

I

 

Oki. Good. 

 

I do have a few villagery vibes from you so far this game, so I'm leaning that way, but it's not as many as I had hoped for, so keep it up I guess?

 

 

 

 

I have the same vibes about you....tho Im not sure my is Sooh Villagery, if yes shes a Wolf and is Sooh Wolfy if yes shes Town Meta dont hold true anymore....lolololol

 

 

If YOU has said you felt strongly about me being Town this early Id be legit sketched out about you

 

lol do you want to try it out one more time or have all your other failed experiments made you toss out this theory? 

 

 

 

 

 

Ive been getting a little better lately tho.

 

sadface,gif

 

I was talking to Nyn before about how to read you and she advised me my Sooh!Meta was "as stupid as my face is"

 

So that kinda factored in to it!!!!

 

lolololololol

 

Ok that made me lol. 

 

 

I was just looking at the player list btw. We're missing Hellian, and Dice has only posted twice?

 

Let's lynch Dice before he wakes up, amirite?

[Darthe]

 

Most folks dknt usually make a game strat as a wolf.

Next time I rand wolf with you you have to teach me. (Have we ever wolfed together?)

Lol idk about that, you're good at this game and there are far better wolves than i

[Darthe]

 

 

Besie, who is scum and why?

Not sure I want to answer this right now. Especially not after the last few pages. Would you mind if I reread the thread first? (and that only after my assignment?)

I don't mind at all.

 

Have to say I've never seen this kind of a response though. Not necessarely a bad thing!

I skimmed past that but upon reread kinda like it actually

[Darthe]

It's very legalistic, which could just be who she is.. I wouldnt know.

[Zander?]

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Besie definitely not looking too good here.

 

Catching up.

 

I sometimes claim town. But, life is for the enjoying. Gotta mix it up.

 

Something that may be Null but I noted for prev Calder games on DM

 

Calder claims Scum as Town the first time iirc and was ML

 

Then he claims Scum as Scum

 

I love this play and always joke about wanting him to to do it.

 

Then we play some games where he's Town!Calder and he doesnt claim scum even after me badgering him about it,

 

Now he claims Scum again.  Maybe to appease me?

 

Calder is awesome and crazy and does things his way but something Im noting anyways

 

How is it worth noting if he does this as scum and not scum and back and forth like that? Sounds like a null tell, no?

 

 

 

 

Am I crazy, Z, or are you currently sussing both Besie and Darthe?

 

I am sussing Besie.

 

If you think i have any sort of read on Darthe 10 pages in you should think again imo.

 

Well, you were definitely asking critical questions, which I interpreted as sussing. It just didn't match up that you were so critical to her, and at the same time being critical to him being critical to her.

 

 

[v]Zander[/v]

 

He didn't open up with "TOWWWWN YESS TOWNN AGAIN" and went too aggressive too fast. 

Thinnest reason ever in mafia, but it is D1, so idk?

 

 

 

It is Null and I said that.

 

Im just saying that if Scum!Calder would know Town!Zander right?

 

And we all know what Town!Zander is like when I gets on to something that pings me.

 

Im saying Scum!Calder COULD be thinking imma just try to pocket Zander.

 

Again I said it was Null but something that crossed my mind.

 

Im not sure exactly what youre getting at with the besie/darthe thing.

 

But again look back I was sussing Besie but I wasnt sussing Darthe.

 

And ya some serious lolTink there dont know if its alignment indicative yet but a lot of lol.

 

I guess the reason I'm asking is because I don't understand why you said it was noteworthy if it's null at the same time, know what I mean?

 

 

Ive np with you asking hence why I explained it out.

 

I

 

Oki. Good. 

 

I do have a few villagery vibes from you so far this game, so I'm leaning that way, but it's not as many as I had hoped for, so keep it up I guess?

 

 

 

 

I have the same vibes about you....tho Im not sure my is Sooh Villagery, if yes shes a Wolf and is Sooh Wolfy if yes shes Town Meta dont hold true anymore....lolololol

 

 

If YOU has said you felt strongly about me being Town this early Id be legit sketched out about you

 

lol do you want to try it out one more time or have all your other failed experiments made you toss out this theory? 

 

 

 

 

 

Ive been getting a little better lately tho.

 

sadface,gif

 

I was talking to Nyn before about how to read you and she advised me my Sooh!Meta was "as stupid as my face is"

 

So that kinda factored in to it!!!!

 

lolololololol

 

Ok that made me lol. 

 

 

I was just looking at the player list btw. We're missing Hellian, and Dice has only posted twice?

 

Let's lynch Dice before he wakes up, amirite?

 

 

Im straight up lock clearing Sooh