Danger in Demons Cove GAME OVER Villains win

[Ironeyes]

Okay the following posts are what make me believe that Ironeyes could possibly be a Godfather. I mean if town can rand an IC, why not the mafia a godfather.  I bolded the relevant parts, or so I believe to be.  That being said.  I think they are the ONLY two randed roles.  I believe that the rest of the PR's are gotten during the events. I also believe that there could be more than one prize given per Event depending on how the Event was played. My reasoning for this is because of how the games were played.  N1 there could be only 1 winner - the person who picked the closest number to zero AND NOBODY else chose it either.  So Tal got his 1 cop view, and mafia had their usual NK of alanna.  Then there is N2.  You have to choose between 3 pictures: a bridge, the beach, a tower.  Now there are only 3 choices and 10 people. So you know there's gonna be doubles, no matter what. I also think [and now this is purely conjecture on my part] that the earlier you put your answer in the more powerful the role you get, imo. However, here is why I think that: Last night I won a 1 X vig shot and I shot nyn...yes it was me...I was totally sure she was deep wolf but everyone had her as town that I knew I couldn't lynch her so I figured I would go for the shot. I was wrong.   anyway I put my vote in right after she posted the event. The next could've been a DOC PR cause...what about the mafia kill...They would have targeted Ironeyes as confirmed townie but he didn't die last night.  Why not?? Cause he is Godfather  OR he's town protected by a DOC last night. But I think the former for now.  Unless someone wants to claim??

 

 I've been saying that I think clovr is mafia for most of the game.  So, him and Ironeyes....eh..who's the last one or two??  I know, I know... you all say there's only 3...Okay....So lets switch things a little bit...we don't necessarily have to lynch Ironeyes first, even if he is the Godfather.  I am thinking the last one is either hallia or tress...I am thinking more tress though...however someone is already voting for clovr and hallia.  what a decision to make.......[v] clovr [/v]    

 

 

 

*rips up old reads list and mafia lists...starting from scratch* 

 

so....these are the players we have left:

 

1. The fearless WiFi - TOWN PRINCESS

2. Niniel the dauntless the terrifying Turin

3. Hallia the valiant

4. The intrepid Ironeyes

5. Clovr the legionless

6. The heroic Pral

7. Leyrann the legendary the incredible Kat

8. Talmanes the brave

9. Tress the resolute

10. Sooh the bold (giggles madly as the knife twists in your gut)

11. Nyn the b*tch (brilliant, tenacious, cunning hunter in case you were wondering)

12. Daredevil Dice

13. The annoying Alanna (ANtagonistic, NOisY INGénue)

 

I am giving clovr the benefit of the doubt for now so slightly townie for now. [unvote]  I am however using some of his posts [in the spoiler below] to point to the following mafia team: dice and Ironeyes and a mystery player???.  Let's start with ironeyes.  I just can't get over the fact that he could be godfather.  I don't think that would give the mafia OP because town doesn't have a cop anyway, we have to win it.  There is a good possibility town would NEVER win a cop view making the godfather a moot point.  He hasn't even showed up today and will not tomorrow and he has to work on Monday...do we get another DL plea?? I think not. 

 

Dang, Wifi, you really don't trust me. In light of that, I really want to know: why did you shoot Nyn instead of me? The way I see it, we were both essentially accepted as town but with some reservations, therefore not likely to be lynched. And you though we were both scum. Why, then, did you choose Nyn? She's played a heck of a lot more towny than I have this game, and she is a better player overall--meaning that the risk/reward ratio is lower for her. What I mean by that is: Nyn dies and I survive (assuming we're both townies), you lose a good player and keep a poor one. I die and Nyn survive (if we're both townies), you lose a poor player and keep a good one. But if we're both scum, then either way you get rid of a scum that wasn't going to get lynched. So the reward was essentially the same either way, but the risk of shooting Nyn was greater. So please explain why you chose that risk rather than the lower risk of shooting me. And in that same vein, why didn't you shoot Clov if you suspect him? Several of us already have posted suspicions that Clov could be a deep wolf, so you could have gained acceptance for that action even if you were wrong and he's town. 

 

By the way, I think it's perfectly possible that there was no doc last night and the scum also shot Nyn. They could have seen it the same way I explained with my risk/reward thing just now. Shoot either one of us, and the town loses a practically confirmed townie. But Nyn was the better player and therefore more likely to ferret them out. 

 

Caveat to all this: there's a decent possibility that you are scum and claiming that your kill was a vig kill rather than a scum one to distract and confuse us. Turin's point that you could be getting advice from a crafty teammate is a good one, and this suspicion ties into that. 

 

One more question that's less related than the others: Was the 1x vig shot only allowed last night, or could you have saved it? If you had the option of saving it, why didn't you wait until Day and ask peoples' opinions on who to vig? It would be easy enough to ask for a cop/doc/vig list from everyone like we did during D2. 

 

Final comment. Please don't go off on me about "he hasn't even shown up today and won't tomorrow." I know I was barely here the first weekend but my circumstances have changed, and I posted this morning several times. Now it is 10 at night in this time zone, so I'm trying to put in my piece before Sunday starts. I'll be on early Monday to see what happens tomorrow. 

[Ironeyes]

Ok one more thing for you Wifi. You asked why Dice quoted the sample role pm rather than quoting his own, and claimed that he's scum because he apparently doesn't have the same pm as the rest of us. I think he quoted the sample because it says in the rules of the game that you can't quote your own role pm. 

 

You may not directly quote or screenshot your role PM, you may character claim, you may role claim

[Ironeyes]

Hey, just curious, is anybody else here right now? I seem to have the worst of luck when it comes to being here at the same time as the rest of you. Seems like I'll be here and post three or four in a row, then give up and go do something else, only to come back three hours later and find a page of content that was posted ten minutes after I left. 

[Songstress]

I'm around, working on my Kat ISO just now.

[Ironeyes]

Wonderful, thank you. I've been struggling to get a read on her for some reason, which is infuriating since everyone else appears to have no problem with it

[Ironeyes]

Lol one more response to Wifi, because I keep rereading her last post and finding more bits and pieces. Point one, I'd like you to know that I don't work on Monday. It's a holiday here, and we're actually expecting a hurricane here. So I might be trapped inside with all the time in the world! Hopefully. 

 

Point two, I think the town getting only one shot at a cop actually makes the godfather role more overpowered and therefore less likely to be in this game. Godfathers typically get a town read only on the first time they are viewed by the cop, thus rewarding multiple views with an accurate one the second time should the cop choose to do so. If there isn't a way to do that, then that drastically increases the power of the godfather to do exactly what you accused me of doing: acting scummy to draw the (one shot) view and waste it. That's OP in my opinion. 

[Ironeyes]

Grammar mistake, should have been "expecting a hurricane too." I didn't proof read my post

[Katiora]

Wonderful, thank you. I've been struggling to get a read on her for some reason, which is infuriating since everyone else appears to have no problem with it

Apparently I'm an acquired taste marsh. people finally reading me town is a new experience.

 

Btw if town got a cop read and we start sussing a town hard then don't wait until 45 min before deadline to let us know please. *sighs*

[Ironeyes]

I haven't won any items so far, despite my best efforts.

[Ironeyes]

Kat what's your take on Wifi now?

[Songstress]

I'm almost done with my Kat ISO but the cat's being needy and I need to get my rear end out of this chair for a few.  Going for a walk, back in about half an hour and I'll finish it up and try to form a coherent opinion

[Ironeyes]

Nooo...Sunday starts in half an hour... Oh well. I'm going to leave my vote on Wifi for now and reevaluate on Monday morning when I read her answers to my questions. 

[Ironeyes]

Well good night all, see you Monday

[Songstress]

Katiora ISO:

 

 

 

#297 - first post, replacing in for Ley about 18 hours before deadline, promises reread tomorrow.

 

#368 - Posts preliminary reads lists with promise to ISO Hallia, Marsh, and possibly Sooh. A lot of "not sure" and "doesn't mean anything", except for a townish read on Nyn.  

 

#369 - Busy with work, will be back soon.

 

#406 - Wishes Hallia would post more as she doesn't feel that bad about her... states she hates to vote someone for inactivity on a weekend when she is also inactive on weekends.

 

#413 - Clarifies Hallia meant she is on the west coast

 

#447 - Assumes Niniel's "less focused" comment was about her and notes she has only known she was in the game for about 12 hours

 

#473 - Jokes about Nyn's reaction to being called "nun"

 

#475 - Says she finished her Hallia ISO, wasn't very long but she didn't see anything overtly scummy.  Says she likes her play so far today, doesn't agree with everything but likes her tone and effort and says she probably won't vote Hallia today.

 

#478 - Finds it ironic that she and Clov posted back to back with opposite takes on Hallia

 

#479 - Does her best Zander impersonation after Nyn accidentally signs her own post Nun

 

#503 - Feels like she sucks at reading Dice

 

#504 - Asks Marsh to clarify that she was supposed to be in his reads list where Sooh appears in the null section

 

#507 - Asks Marsh to specify what scum tells he was getting from her

 

#521 - States she is ISOing Niniel right now

 

#526 - Niniel ISO - doesn't understand her vote on Sooh which she took to be a joke vote... Comments on her initial reads list being just as informative as Nini's... States she is getting mixed signals from Niniel, some posts seem to be ones she would not make as mafia and some do not appear to come from a town mindset.  States she would not have as much thread presence entering the game as mafia.

 

#528 - Jokes with Nyn about depending too much on Zander

 

#551 - Agrees with Nyn that she does not feel Pral and Hallia are M/M, as well as agreeing his "give her time" followed by his vote on Hallia were sketchy

 

#553 - States Pral likes to bus teammates from what she's seen

 

#555 - Feels like she is grasping at straws

 

#624 - Feels like Pral is an easy out and it is usually a sign of a mislynch, notes she is suspicious of Marsh's sudden vehemence on lynching Pral

 

#641 - Votes Pral, states if he flips town she will have to re-evaluate everything

 

#656 - Notes if Pral flips mafia she will feel better about Nyn and Hallia, although she may tinfoil on Hallia - states there is noone she would really feel worse about.

 

#657 - States she is not fond of Niniel voting and then leaving but has seen her do it as town multiple times

 

#676 - Does not like WiFi's post about keeping her vote on Hallia (a wasted vote) rather than looking like she is sheeping.

 

#677 - Notes quote attribution in #676 broke, post she was referencing was from WiFi, not Nyn

 

#709 - Denies asking WiFi to join the Pral lynch, instead she says she is asking her to take a stand and defend her vote on Hallia if she wants to continue to vote her

 

#717 - Thanks Nyn for pointing out no night talk as she had missed that rule

 

#807 - Points out she said almost the exact same thing as Ironeyes about not fighting his lynch last time she was mafia on the chopping block

 

#810 - Quotes her post from the Harry Potter game as referenced in #807

 

#813 - Says she can't decide whether she thinks Ironeyes is mafia, does not think he and Talmanes are T/T

 

#818 - Says she thinks M/M is possible but she is more suspicious of Talmanes, thinks she saw something about his play that she didn't like yesterday and will ISO him later.  Also thinks WiFi's play is suspicious, feels good about Nyn, tinfoiling on Clov... Unsure on Hallia and the rest.

 

#822 - Responds to Clov's question that she is opposed to lynching Nyn.  Needs to re-read EOD because there are a lot of people that aren't standing out to her.  Says she feels she is bad at reading Niniel and Dice, and laments that the Alanna NK gave town no info.

 

#824 - Responds to Clov that she never knows what to think about him, would like for him to be a townie but is afraid that he isn't.

 

#919 - Apologizes for not being around due to flat tires and difficulty playing on phone, promises to look back on D1 tomorrow

 

#1007 - Would still like an answer from Ironeyes on examples of the town and scum tells he was seeing from Kat, notes he has ignored the question multiple times

 

#1008 - Does not love Hallia's post arguing that at least Ironeyes is here and posting while WiFi "has taken off"

 

#1013 - Quotes several posts from Talmanes trying to put off a lynch on Marsh D1, but promising to come back to him D2, then notes his reluctance to vote him D2 seems inconsistent, says it looks like he knows Marsh will flip town and is trying to distance from his lynch.

 

#1014 - Debates Hallia's characterizing Marsh's D2 as "involvement" although she is not sold on him being mafia... Says she does not understand WiFi but was primarily saying that her "taking off" early D2 is not a good argument against her

 

#1038 - Welcomes Turin

 

#1046 - Replies to Hallia that she quoted Talmanes' posts defending Marsh D1 in #1013

 

#1047 - Requotes #1013

 

#1076 - Replies to Hallia's Cop/Doc/Vig question that she would vig Talmanes, cop Marsh and doc Nyn

 

#1091 - Votes Talmanes, says she will be around up until deadline as work allows if needed.  Notes nobody else has stood out to her and she is not sold on Marsh

 

#1095 - Asks  Talmanes why she should think he is town, notes he has been trying to protect Marsh or he knows something we don't, and since he has been doing it since D1 she feels it is likely he is mafia.

 

#1098 - States if Talmanes is town she does not understand his D1 defense of Marsh and he cannot explain why.

 

#1103 - Asks Nyn for her opinion of Talmanes' cop view claim

 

#1107 - Notes she missed the point Turin brought up that he said he would view Marsh in his cop/doc/vig response, when he already had a view result on him

 

#1108 - Feels better that Nyn also doesn't know how to process Talmanes' claim

 

#1111 - Conflicted with regard to Talmanes' response to the Turin post she referenced in #1107 - says it is almost twtbaw

 

#1116 - Unvotes Talmanes and notes she wishes he had revealed earlier, then suggests CFD on WiFi

 

#1120 - Requests VC correction

 

#1122 - Notes Talmanes' worry about being a NK target makes no sense as a 1x cop, and states it is good for town that they can confirm one another.  States she read his case on Sooh and is not sold.

 

#1128 - Agrees with Nyn that Talmanes is not confirmed town due to his cop view, just possibly not scum

 

#1132 - "bleh Nyn" 

 

#1136 - Clarifies #1132 that she doesn't know what to do, feels if Talmanes is lynched and he was telling the truth Marsh will be killed, but if they let Tal live they could both be scum clearing each other

 

#1150 - Explains in response to Sooh's doubt that they could be scum clearing each other that her problem is that Talmanes started defending Marsh on D1

 

#1154 - Clarifies her #1150 to Sooh, votes Talmanes noting that at least they will have an idea on Marsh afterward

 

#1162 - Responds to Hallia stating that in a case like this she would vote for the claimed viewer instead of the viewee every time as mafia knows who the town is

 

#1187 - Expresses doubt as to how to proceed if Talmanes is town

 

#1188 - Replies to Dice that a cop view may be useful to mafia in order to find other PRs (seems to think it would act as a role cop)

 

#1196 - Questions how Dice knows what response a cop view would get, and how he knows there aren't roled players since Alanna was Innocent Child. 

 

#1202 - Responds to Sooh's "read twice" comment regarding misunderstandings that there isn't a lot of time left to read everything twice

 

#1205 - Agrees with Nyn that Talmanes and Marsh have been scummy and need to be resolved, notes that if Talmanes had come out with his view earlier there would have been time to find an alternate path but now there isn't.

 

#1206 - Questions Sooh's FOS on her for the end of day (unsure if this is questioning the term FOS or what)

 

#1212 - Questions what in Dice's PM makes him think there are no roles, says her own PM doesn't say anything to lead her to believe that nobody has a role, just that she currently has no abilities other than her vote.

 

#1214 - Requests the mod verify that scum can get the same abilities that town gets

 

#1218 - Tells Dice he is being dense with regard to her argument about the town role PM

 

#1221 - States Dice is grasping at straws and if Tal flips scum she plans to vote him tomorrow

 

#1223 - Emphasizes the mod's response to her question in #1214

 

#1226 - Thanks Clov for seeing the same point that it makes no sense to assume nobody is roled when Alanna was roled IC

 

#1228 - Is conflicted on Dice, part of her is frustrated and wants to lynch him, but part of her thinks that if he really believes what he's saying he must be town.

 

#1235 - Replies to Dice's "lynching me just gets you a dead townie" with "same for me"

 

#1242 - Quotes Alanna's flip in response to request from Clov

 

#1358 - Notes in response to Marsh that having people read her as town is a new experience for her... requests if town has a cop read they should not wait until 45 minutes before deadline before revealing if we are about to lynch a townie.

 

 

 

I'm holding on to this for now without adding analysis because my brain is shutting down and my eyes are glazing over.  I'll come back to it tomorrow afternoon post-coffee and food when the brain is fresh.  Tomorrow also will be for ISOing Hallia, WiFi and Clov.

[dicetosser1]

Dear ADVENTURER

 

There are mysterious goings on in Demons Cove, a haven for smugglers. Priority concern is the shipment of gooey chocolaty brownies that has mysteriously disappeared...

 

Can you help find them before the dastardly villains scoff the lot?

 

 

 

 

This is a standard(ish) game

 

Each day phase there will be events that you can enter with prizes given, do not discuss the events while they're happening

 

Days will be about 48 hours, nights will be about 24 hours, Day 1 will be longer. Phase change will be at 11PM (east coast US 6PM). This is a deadline game, this is in order to allow everyone a chance to enter events. This means there is NO early hammer if majority is reached and whoever has the most votes at deadline is lynched

 

The thread will be CLOSED at night

 

You do not need to unvote before voting again, to vote either bold and red your vote or use the vote tags

 

[v]Simmonds[/v]
[unvote]

Kill each other nicely :) if you feel somebody is attacking you then message me

 

You may not discuss this game outside of the game thread or any mod provided QT's

 

You may not directly quote or screenshot your role PM, you may character claim, you may role claim

 

If you have questions about the setup please ask me via PM or QT, I will not respond to anything posted in thread

 

I reserve the right to amend or add to the rules at any point

 

 

 

 

 

1. The fearless WiFi

2. Niniel the dauntless the terrifying Turin

3. Hallia the valiant

4. The intrepid Ironeyes

5. Clovr the legionless

6. The heroic Pral

7. Leyrann the legendary the incredible Kat

8. Talmanes the brave

9. Tress the resolute

10. Sooh the bold (giggles madly as the knife twists in your gut)

11. Nyn the b*tch (brilliant, tenacious, cunning hunter in case you were wondering)

12. Daredevil Dice

13. The annoying Alanna (ANtagonistic, NOisY INGénue)

 

Subs

 

 

Sample ADVENTURER PM

 

 

Welcome ADVENTURER

 

It has been confirmed that a crate full of brownies has disappeared. You win when the DASTARDLY VILLAINS have been brought to justice (all threats to town have been eliminated)

 

In order to help with this investigation you have access to this satchel. Currently your satchel contains a notepad and pencil, you currently have no abilities other than your vote but be on the look out for extra items that may aid you in your investigation

 

GLGL <3

 

 

 

At wildfire  try reading the OP again. Here I will quote it for you. oh LOOK it says SAMPLE PM!!!

 

that would be because its a sample! the ones we get SENT arnt samples there the real deal!

 

 

gimme a break.

 

 

 

 

Lol one more response to Wifi, because I keep rereading her last post and finding more bits and pieces. Point one, I'd like you to know that I don't work on Monday. It's a holiday here, and we're actually expecting a hurricane here. So I might be trapped inside with all the time in the world! Hopefully. 

 

Point two, I think the town getting only one shot at a cop actually makes the godfather role more overpowered and therefore less likely to be in this game. Godfathers typically get a town read only on the first time they are viewed by the cop, thus rewarding multiple views with an accurate one the second time should the cop choose to do so. If there isn't a way to do that, then that drastically increases the power of the godfather to do exactly what you accused me of doing: acting scummy to draw the (one shot) view and waste it. That's OP in my opinion. 

 

wrong marsh. thats not how GF is p[layed now. you can view a gf every day and it will still say town

[BFG]

DAY 3 VoteCount

 

WiFi (2): Hallia, Ironeyes

 

Clov (1): Dice

 

Tress (1): Sooh

 

Dice (2): Turin, WiFi

 

Not voting (3): Clov, Katiora, Tress

 

[Turin Turambar]

 

 

 

 

 

vote clov

 

 

now totally sold on clov kat team

 

 

theres nothing in the PM to suggest anyone HAS a role. If there was a doc for example wouldnt they have protected laine and nyn?

Maybe they tried? it seems at this point that abilities are given as prizes and by the MOD answer we have gotten it appears that any ability can go to anyone.

 

That being said I think it was NOT as obvious that Nyn was the only mafia nk option since Ironeyes was mostly confirmed by Talmanes flip.

NO doc worth their salt protects ironeyes last night. hes been scummy as all game people are still not sold on him despite tals view. Mafia killing him would be stupid.

 

Also theres only 1 prize. Tal won it D1 so we know mafia didnt get it and that it was a cop view.

 

So nyn WAS the OBVIOUS kill. She was never getting lynched this game.

wrt Ironeyes you saying that the green read from a confirmed dead townie with a cop view is irrevelant? Mafia can't afford to have confirmed (or even mostly confirmed) townies left alive as end game approaches. Nyn pushed 2 townie lynches in two days. She could have been mafia. I find it odd that you would say she couldn't be lynched.

 

Also, you seem to be making a huge assumption about there being only one prize. explain your thought process there.

 

Are you setting up to discredit a doc claim later on?

 

are you just trying to discredit EVERYTHING?? have you read this game? Do you think aside from wifi and maybe ureself do you think anyone didnt think nyn clear town?

 

and what im discrediting is the idea of someone being RANDED doc. Someone might win a protect but not RAND doc.

But why say that no real doc (or even someone with a 1x protect ) would fail to protect Nyn last night or Alanna N1? That sounds more like trying to discredit a person making such a claim.

 

You have made several demonstrative statements about how roles and mechanics are working in THIS GAME, ( how GF works, only one prize on N1 to name two I recall atm). I would expect that you would get a PAFO if asking those questions unless you or a teammate were a GF or you had received a cop view. I doubt the second has happened because you didn't get it N1 and I would assume if you got one last night you would have viewed Clov. Which means you would have either got a green and wouldn't be voting him or you got a red and would be claiming it directly. Holding back would serve no purpose.

 

How do you KNOW how GF works on this game?

[Turin Turambar]

And spoiling split diced quote. His last line finished with randing doc.

[Turin Turambar]

 

 

 

Okay the following posts are what make me believe that Ironeyes could possibly be a Godfather. I mean if town can rand an IC, why not the mafia a godfather. I bolded the relevant parts, or so I believe to be. That being said. I think they are the ONLY two randed roles. I believe that the rest of the PR's are gotten during the events. I also believe that there could be more than one prize given per Event depending on how the Event was played. My reasoning for this is because of how the games were played. N1 there could be only 1 winner - the person who picked the closest number to zero AND NOBODY else chose it either. So Tal got his 1 cop view, and mafia had their usual NK of alanna. Then there is N2. You have to choose between 3 pictures: a bridge, the beach, a tower. Now there are only 3 choices and 10 people. So you know there's gonna be doubles, no matter what. I also think [and now this is purely conjecture on my part] that the earlier you put your answer in the more powerful the role you get, imo. However, here is why I think that: Last night I won a 1 X vig shot and I shot nyn...yes it was me...I was totally sure she was deep wolf but everyone had her as town that I knew I couldn't lynch her so I figured I would go for the shot. I was wrong. anyway I put my vote in right after she posted the event. The next could've been a DOC PR cause...what about the mafia kill...They would have targeted Ironeyes as confirmed townie but he didn't die last night. Why not?? Cause he is Godfather OR he's town protected by a DOC last night. But I think the former for now. Unless someone wants to claim??

 

I've been saying that I think clovr is mafia for most of the game. So, him and Ironeyes....eh..who's the last one or two?? I know, I know... you all say there's only 3...Okay....So lets switch things a little bit...we don't necessarily have to lynch Ironeyes first, even if he is the Godfather. I am thinking the last one is either hallia or tress...I am thinking more tress though...however someone is already voting for clovr and hallia. what a decision to make.......[v] clovr [/v]

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

tmi my butt. use ure head.

 

what use is a cop view to MAFIA???? They KNOW who the mafia team is. It makes more SENSE that mafia wins they get a power from list x if town wins they get a power from list y. One of the few powers that could be on both is doc but cop??? i dont think so

to find cop?? or doc?? that wouldn't be useful to the??

 

 

 

tmi my butt. use ure head.

 

what use is a cop view to MAFIA???? They KNOW who the mafia team is. It makes more SENSE that mafia wins they get a power from list x if town wins they get a power from list y. One of the few powers that could be on both is doc but cop??? i dont think so

to find cop?? or doc?? that wouldn't be useful to the??

explain to me how a cop view finds a cop when u get a town not town type response? or how a role cop does the same when we dont have roles?

do we know that's the response you get though? and how do we know there aren't roled people? Alanna had a "role" she was basically an innocent child. How do you know there isn't a doc?

What exactly in your pm makes you think that? cause mine doesn't say anything about there are no people that are roled.... and everyone, regardless of alignment knows what the PM says. We've been over that once or twice. Trust me if I were scum i'd have that thing memorized. Went and looked at mine, says nothing about "all adventurers are non roled" it only says that I currently have no abilities but my vote. Doesn't say others can't.

Freak I thought I could make the deadline but u have to go right now. [v]Tal[/v]

Why are we discussing whether adventures can be rolled? Was there some pregame event Alanna won?

 

No, she randed IC.

 

 

 

I disagree to an extent about this. Maybe it is semantic. Judge for yourselves. Alanna "technically" wasn't randed as an ic in the pregame. She was just given an item at start of D1 that showed she was town. Now due to the requirements of THAT ROLE, only a townie could get it. It is conceivable that a member of the mafia was also given an item that would make them a GF. Obviously it couldn't be announced.

 

Ironeyes as GF would explain his behavior on D1 as it would be likely to draw a view. Not ready to go there yet Tho.

 

WiFi, would you talk me thru why you would use your shot on Nyn.

Well, nyn was the main pusher of the two mislynches...she stated some stuff [which I already quoted at EoD] which made me go ...so I thought she could be a deep wolf...I had thought of it earlier and posted it but nobody took me seriously...if people had talked to me and explained to me why nyn couldn't be deep wolf I might not have gone after her...as it was everyone thought her townie...so I figured there was no way I could get a lynch on her and that she was fooling everybody YES I WAS WRONG...I WAS THE FOOL...I will admit it...but I have been fooled too many times by deep wolves that I had to find out...also my very first game I was a 2 X vig: The very first day...everyone had AJ as town...but me...I KNEW he was wolf...so I shot him...HE WAS WOLF...sometimes you just have to go after your own gut...and my gut said nyn was mafia...

Fair enough. I just didn't remember you saying you had concerns over Nyn. I think the volume you used in your Clov suspicion may have drowned it out.

 

Hero shots sometimes work out. Sometimes not. If you have the role you do your best with it.

 

One repeat of a question Ironeyes asked. Were you told if your ability was good for one night only?

[dicetosser1]

 

 

 

 

 

 

vote clov

 

 

now totally sold on clov kat team

 

 

theres nothing in the PM to suggest anyone HAS a role. If there was a doc for example wouldnt they have protected laine and nyn?

Maybe they tried? it seems at this point that abilities are given as prizes and by the MOD answer we have gotten it appears that any ability can go to anyone.

 

That being said I think it was NOT as obvious that Nyn was the only mafia nk option since Ironeyes was mostly confirmed by Talmanes flip.

NO doc worth their salt protects ironeyes last night. hes been scummy as all game people are still not sold on him despite tals view. Mafia killing him would be stupid.

 

Also theres only 1 prize. Tal won it D1 so we know mafia didnt get it and that it was a cop view.

 

So nyn WAS the OBVIOUS kill. She was never getting lynched this game.

wrt Ironeyes you saying that the green read from a confirmed dead townie with a cop view is irrevelant? Mafia can't afford to have confirmed (or even mostly confirmed) townies left alive as end game approaches. Nyn pushed 2 townie lynches in two days. She could have been mafia. I find it odd that you would say she couldn't be lynched.

 

Also, you seem to be making a huge assumption about there being only one prize. explain your thought process there.

 

Are you setting up to discredit a doc claim later on?

 

are you just trying to discredit EVERYTHING?? have you read this game? Do you think aside from wifi and maybe ureself do you think anyone didnt think nyn clear town?

 

and what im discrediting is the idea of someone being RANDED doc. Someone might win a protect but not RAND doc.

But why say that no real doc (or even someone with a 1x protect ) would fail to protect Nyn last night or Alanna N1? That sounds more like trying to discredit a person making such a claim.

 

You have made several demonstrative statements about how roles and mechanics are working in THIS GAME, ( how GF works, only one prize on N1 to name two I recall atm). I would expect that you would get a PAFO if asking those questions unless you or a teammate were a GF or you had received a cop view. I doubt the second has happened because you didn't get it N1 and I would assume if you got one last night you would have viewed Clov. Which means you would have either got a green and wouldn't be voting him or you got a red and would be claiming it directly. Holding back would serve no purpose.

 

How do you KNOW how GF works on this game?

 

 

are you seriously for real?? Im making those calls based on experience and the way the mod has worded stuff. 

 

Tell me Turin when was the last time you played a game on DM that had a GF that would get a different view result if viewed twice? 

[Turin Turambar]

I don't know. I don't think it is relevant in any case because it has no affect on how BFG set up this game. I don't know how it was done.

 

I do know that BFG plays on other sites tho and she talks with people that MOD elsewhere so I am NOT going to assume how she would make her game based only on the "DM way".

 

Are you willing to consider you might just be wrong?

[Turin Turambar]

Way to break the page...

[Turin Turambar]

Seven

[Turin Turambar]

Six

[Turin Turambar]

Five