[Basic] I <3 the 90's Mafia: Music Edition - TOWN WINS!

[BFG]

My reads are awful :/

[BFG]

Hallia, what's your current read on Lenlo?

[BFG]

I probably need to look at Besie properly :/

[keyholder21]

Official Vote Count:

 

Not Voting (11): Besie, BFG, Hallia, Sili, Katiora, Lenlo, Clov, Lily, Wistork, Alanna, Lizabeth

 

With 11 alive, it's 6 to lynch.

 

Deadline is longer due to DM weekend and me having a crazy Monday.  So, enjoy? 

 

[Hallia]

I was pretty firmly town, I should reread, but I'm more certain of Laine. No one else thinks so, though.

[BFG]

I was pretty firmly town, I should reread, but I'm more certain of Laine. No one else thinks so, though.

Ok, what do you think of Liz/Kat/Lily?

[Guest]

Oh god *hides face* I was wrong on darthe too.

[Guest]

I would love it if everyone could weigh in on Liz/Darthe

Okay, Darthe know now, and liz I'm not sure yet. I've time to do one iso so I think I'll do hers, and see if I can come up with something.

 

 

I do want to say you're solid town, BFG. There's no way someone would go to that much trouble to reread & cliffs (I certainly didn't), try to see that many options (thinking differently than the rest of us), and read so many wrong reads - as mafia.

 

 

Town core: myself, bfg, Hallia, clov, Sili

[BFG]

 

I would love it if everyone could weigh in on Liz/Darthe

Okay, Darthe know now, and liz I'm not sure yet. I've time to do one iso so I think I'll do hers, and see if I can come up with something.

 

 

I do want to say you're solid town, BFG. There's no way someone would go to that much trouble to reread & cliffs (I certainly didn't), try to see that many options (thinking differently than the rest of us), and read so many wrong reads - as mafia.

 

 

Town core: myself, bfg, Hallia, clov, Sili

 

Ok, Hallia's obvious

 

You explain why you're choosing not to tinfoil on me...

 

Why are Chris and Sili so solidly town for you?

[Hallia]

They're lower in the totem pole, except for Kat

[Guest]

 

 

I would love it if everyone could weigh in on Liz/Darthe

Okay, Darthe know now, and liz I'm not sure yet. I've time to do one iso so I think I'll do hers, and see if I can come up with something.

 

 

I do want to say you're solid town, BFG. There's no way someone would go to that much trouble to reread & cliffs (I certainly didn't), try to see that many options (thinking differently than the rest of us), and read so many wrong reads - as mafia.

 

 

Town core: myself, bfg, Hallia, clov, Sili

 

Ok, Hallia's obvious

 

You explain why you're choosing not to tinfoil on me...

 

Why are Chris and Sili so solidly town for you?

 

 

With clov, i've gotten the feeling that he's truly trying to solve this game since beginning d1. I've just not changed my read on him since i've felt that he's town in d1, and he hasn't done anything to change my mind - except a faulty reason for voting me. I understand that he was annoyed at that point in time, though.

 

With sili it's a meta i have for him (like a growing, wannabe meta for him, for myself). In the last game, even though he was sk, he was playing as a town to get rid of mafia. As sk he also didn't know who the scum were and he had the same goal as the town - to get rid of them. (And of the towns too, ofc, later). So it can be said that, to a degree, he was town. This game, he's not playing differently. I guess he could be sk again, if there is one. But yeah, overall he's playing as i believe town!sili would. He posts a load of posts - and even though the number of posts doesn't matter much, it's the content. He is constantly changing his mind, tinfoiling?, making half-serious jokes to get people to react, noting people's reactions when he pushes certain other people.

 

I'm choosing not to tinfoil my town reads. I'm either right, or wrong. If I'm wrong, well, it'll be something to learn from. If I'm right, at least i'll have the satisfaction of knowing that i'm starting to read people right.

[Guest]

Is that a good enough reason as to why I'm not tinfoiling?

 

As the day goes on I might start tinfoiling... depending on how I read Liz, Lily, Kat, Alanna, Lenlo and Wish.

[wish-tree]

Wish can I get your thoughts on Liz?

 

She needs to be around more, I'm looking at possible connections between her and Chris. She doesn't seem to care as much about this game, and the few posts that she's made seem kind of emotionally distraught, and idk how to really read that. >.<

 

uhhhh

 

the stuff she's said about my meta is all true for her (irt not understanding my thought process as town but understanding my thought process as mafia), but Liz usually town reads me as default and only rescinds that if she thinks I'm being really weird. 

 

Chris/wish you still here?

 

Here now.

 

What do you make of Liz's read that wish is town?

 

See above. 

 

Y'all are aware that im completely and utterly outside of my wolf range, right? Like, its fun to wafltch you attenpt to fit me in as a wolf from an academic sense but I am vastly different as a wolf.

 

Then again I don't think either of you have had me as town in many unspoilered DTs you were in?

 

I don't know what your wolf range is... 

 

 

What do you make of Liz's read that wish is town?

I don't think she has been around enough to honestly make that read but I also think you've been around enough to never not make it.

 

Lol me right?

 

 

Can you explain both parts, please?

[wish-tree]

OH WAIT WHAT

 

LOLLLLLLLLLL

 

>.<

 

please deny my derp tell

[wish-tree]

Darthe was NKed, along with Niniel

 

lol >.<

[wish-tree]

I was pretty firmly town, I should reread, but I'm more certain of Laine. No one else thinks so, though.

 

What does this mean, "I was pretty firmly town"? More certain of Laine being scum? 

[BFG]

Page 31-40

 

Chris doesn't like Zander's framing on Seph, doesn't like Niniels reason for voting Zander - surprised me a little that Chris didn't get the 'joke' here

 

Hallia thinks Chris's intervention in Seph/Zander is good

 

Lenlo summarises Seph as Sili 'wolfiest' in notes but votes Zander

 

Clov happy with a lynch between Niniel/Lenlo/Zander

 

Zander votes Niniel

 

643 from Hallia is pretty apt, town!Lenlo doesn't let go, it's the lack of follow through that has me concerned. Who are his mafia reads now? Which ones has he pushed?

 

Sili votes Niniel #raisins?

 

Hallia asks Sili for reads

 

VC:

 

Zander (2): Niniel, Seph

Niniel (3): Hallia, Zander, Sili

 

Sili reads:

Town: Hallia, Clov, BFG, Laine

Maybe town: Zander, Darthe, Seph

Maybe: Lenlo

Maybe wolf: Niniel

 

658 isn't great from Lenlo - "I'm not gonna let you slip out of this"... sounds like a mafia read, where's the vote? I know Lenlo/Chris argue this, could be resolved already

 

662 first reads list from Kat:

Blue: Zander, Hallia, Dice

Green: Lenlo, Sili

Grey: Darthe, BFG, Chris, Laine

Orange: Niniel, Seph

Read on Chris seems odd, Darthe/Laine/Me are all null, no read, Chris has a negative point but is null for ???

 

Lily - BFG/Laine seem town

 

Wish OP analysis

Hallia, Thane, Sili townish, me slight town Lily null Zander slight mafia

 

Kat defends Zander against Wish, has Darthe trending down

 

Wish seeing similarities to Zanders mafia play

 

(NULL exchange)

 

Sili explains vote - Nini's vote on Zander and lack of 'pursuit' of Sili

 

Wish read is just bizarre - basically saying that Zanders post by post catch up is scummy, but it's just Zander, but she doesn't know town meta :baffled: he's been 'present' in thread a fair bit, not just catch up mode, thinks serious as town (I know this is hashed out later) admits to provoking Zander to get him to tunnel

 

Ugh so sorry for the me/Zander thing :(

 

Wish disappears without sharing thoughts (Kat points this out)

 

Kat hopes Zander isn't mafia cos they're defending each other.... doesn't like wish disappearing without explaining the not town read on Kat

 

Lily volume, wish town feels

[BFG]

Is that a good enough reason as to why I'm not tinfoiling?

 

As the day goes on I might start tinfoiling... depending on how I read Liz, Lily, Kat, Alanna, Lenlo and Wish.

Sure?

[BFG]

Wish what are your feelings aorn?

[BFG]

Chris, incidentally I'm not ignoring your Lenlo ISO, I just want to read as much of the thread and get context for myself first :)

[Lenlo]

So, people had Clov/Darthe as a team right? Does Darthe flipping town throw any sort of wrench into that?

 

With 2 kills either 

A) Town has a Vig and they shot Darthe, simply because shooting Nin isnt a towny shot

B) Wolves have a Vig, unlikely if they also have an RB.

C) SK.

 

The two more likely ones are A and C imo. The question is, if town has a Vig why would they not shoot me? Im clearly being wolf read by alot of people so odds of the vig being one of them would be pretty high. So why shoot Darthe over me? This leads me to believe its actually an SK that either got blocked or holstered N1.

 

With that im really sketch of Sili, he has third party equity imo.

[Lizabeth]

and this is a strange game

Tell me about it...

 

 

(sorry, backreading but had to respond to this because my sentiments exactly...well...that and more...)

 

 

(BFG I really hope you're town because you're one of the only ones who is making me not want to cry at the moment!)

[BFG]

Liz :)

 

Whose making you want to cry?

[BFG]

So, people had Clov/Darthe as a team right? Does Darthe flipping town throw any sort of wrench into that?

 

With 2 kills either 

A) Town has a Vig and they shot Darthe, simply because shooting Nin isnt a towny shot

B) Wolves have a Vig, unlikely if they also have an RB.

C) SK.

 

The two more likely ones are A and C imo. The question is, if town has a Vig why would they not shoot me? Im clearly being wolf read by alot of people so odds of the vig being one of them would be pretty high. So why shoot Darthe over me? This leads me to believe its actually an SK that either got blocked or holstered N1.

 

With that im really sketch of Sili, he has third party equity imo.

Who do you think is mafia?

[Lizabeth]

this is why people think I'm bonkers

 

 

>.<

 

no bully pls

 

 

:X

 

<3