[Basic] I <3 the 90's Mafia: Music Edition - TOWN WINS!

[Guest]

 

 

 

Hi Besie GL?

Thanks.
I properly read up to p20 ish, skimmed up to p40, and then saw the msg to sub so I've still a bit to read through. I'll only properly quote and such from here, everyone.
So up to the p40ish skim+read, my feels have been the following:
Towny:
Sili
Wish
Hallia
Alanna
Clov
Not town:
Zander
Scummy:
Seph
BFG
And neutral-ish on the rest. I'll stay caught up with the newer posts (from here), and I'll try to read the ones I missed (p40ish to p90ish) somewhere today.

Trying to think back where page 40 was. I feel like it was Monday night? If that's the case, I'm not sure what you saw that made you think BFG or Seph were particularly scummy.

I'm "okay" at reading her and thought she was incredibly more likely to be town at that point. Her activity and interest alone should have been enough for that, and I had no problems with her content. Her back and forth fighting with Zander isn't really something I've seen from her really, but I know she dislikes randing mafia and have a hard time picturing her deliberately picking a fight she knows she's going to have a hard time pushing AND is going to basically always result in 'retaliation'. She's told me before that she would have a hard time pushing Cory or me because it takes a lot of time. I very rarely get as invested as Zander, so I would assume the same caveat applies.

Still not seeing it with Seph, either, but he makes more sense at that point (and probably most of the game, tbh) tham she does. I think the best argument for him being mafia this game is, ironically, the 'contradiction' Zander posted. I still think a lot of townies could make that post, and I'm not sure thats in the pages you've skimmed anyway.

Can you pull some quotes to explain these?

 

I've explained my thoughts on seph.

On BFG is really just a feel for the first lot of posts. I'll have to catch up before putting her in a "definite scum" category. Except for me still having to catch up, from what I've seen most people don't think she's too scummy. So I'm going to take that into consideration. 

 

You are currently one of my towny reads so I’ll take your opinion of BFG into consideration – at least for now. I'll see what the future posts bring.

[Guest]

 

 

- The games I was talking about was the two I played most recently - Lost, and Stick Figure.

- Where do you mean? In those two games or in this game in total?

Neither. You said it read like had to go back and mention her to fit his scum plan. Just trying to figure out exactly what You think his angle there would be.

 

 

Oh. I thought he could possible have forgotten to add her as town - in the scenario that they're both scum. It's a theory. It's more the "posted as an afterthought" post than the actual content of the post that bothers me.

[Guest]

Random note @Alanna - I love your profile pic. I loved FFX and FFX-2! 

[Guest]

It's also been a while since people posted some music! (Sorry if I post some that's already been posted)

 

 

Macarena! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XiBYM6g8Tck 

 

 

Mambo no. 5...

 

 

Doctor Jones

 

[dicetosser1]

i like the bfg dice interactions for bfg v dice w, this response from dice: 

 

BFG  whats weirding you out?  that i didnt give a definite answer Zander is town/mafia?  I do have to take time to make a read sometimes you know and he has not been super obvious town zander that i pick up on 2 posts or so

 

is especially heinous

 

 

alannas big post (not sure how to do quotes good) is pretty decently villagery, though maybe not for the obvious reasons

 

i think the first ~half of it is meaningless and could be wolfy (but mostly null), then it feels like she actually realises she has to engage with the content and not just broadly ask questions

 

 

now that i wrote that read out its less strong, but usually that kind of progression in ONE post is more likely a villager since a wolf would just rewrite the whole thing

 

 

 

what was heinous? Can you clarify ure thinking on me and on VFG please cause im not sure what it is.

 

the last line   does that refer to Alanna?

 

i like the bfg dice interactions for bfg v dice w, this response from dice: 

 

BFG  whats weirding you out?  that i didnt give a definite answer Zander is town/mafia?  I do have to take time to make a read sometimes you know and he has not been super obvious town zander that i pick up on 2 posts or so

 

is especially heinous

 

 

alannas big post (not sure how to do quotes good) is pretty decently villagery, though maybe not for the obvious reasons

 

i think the first ~half of it is meaningless and could be wolfy (but mostly null), then it feels like she actually realises she has to engage with the content and not just broadly ask questions

 

 

now that i wrote that read out its less strong, but usually that kind of progression in ONE post is more likely a villager since a wolf would just rewrite the whole thing

 

[dicetosser1]

 

@LENLO

 

How caught up in the thread are you? are you past page 69??

 

ANSWER THIS PLEASE

Think so? No page numbers on phone.

 

 

Right so i do a big post restating ure answers  clov requotes it   i have asked you what is worth mentioning and u completely ignore it.

 

I also asked about you happening to miss 2 posts both of clovs

 

@clov  my thinking is he is scum and you may be his partner or he just didnt want to risk engaging you, the first bit is wrapped in tinfoil cause i know ure good and i feel like ure coasting along this game.

 

 

 

 

@LENLO

 

How caught up in the thread are you? are you past page 69??

 

ANSWER THIS PLEASE

Think so? No page numbers on phone.

 

 

 

One of the most Zander things I can think of, as any alignment, is that he pretty much aggros anybody who insinuates he's not town. When Zander is town, he thinks he's the most obvious person ever, even though he's not. As mafia, he either thinks hes still the most obvious person ever, or he does an exceptionally good job faking it.

 

That's beem pretty much consistent throughout this game, except I've made it very clear I haven't trusted him throughout this game and he never got that way with me. Other than maybe Cory, I'm struggling to come up with another time this happened.

 

That's why I asked him earlier what his read of me is. He answered me, but it was a very uncharacteristically cautious answer. I have a hard time thinking he'd be afraid to go toe to toe with me if he's town, and honestly, I think he'd try as mafia. So I really have no idea what to feel about it.

 

[dicetosser1]

One of the most Zander things I can think of, as any alignment, is that he pretty much aggros anybody who insinuates he's not town. When Zander is town, he thinks he's the most obvious person ever, even though he's not. As mafia, he either thinks hes still the most obvious person ever, or he does an exceptionally good job faking it.

That's beem pretty much consistent throughout this game, except I've made it very clear I haven't trusted him throughout this game and he never got that way with me. Other than maybe Cory, I'm struggling to come up with another time this happened.

That's why I asked him earlier what his read of me is. He answered me, but it was a very uncharacteristically cautious answer. I have a hard time thinking he'd be afraid to go toe to toe with me if he's town, and honestly, I think he'd try as mafia. So I really have no idea what to feel about it.

 

 

One of the most Zander things I can think of, as any alignment, is that he pretty much aggros anybody who insinuates he's not town. When Zander is town, he thinks he's the most obvious person ever, even though he's not. As mafia, he either thinks hes still the most obvious person ever, or he does an exceptionally good job faking it.

That's beem pretty much consistent throughout this game, except I've made it very clear I haven't trusted him throughout this game and he never got that way with me. Other than maybe Cory, I'm struggling to come up with another time this happened.

That's why I asked him earlier what his read of me is. He answered me, but it was a very uncharacteristically cautious answer. I have a hard time thinking he'd be afraid to go toe to toe with me if he's town, and honestly, I think he'd try as mafia. So I really have no idea what to feel about it.

 

[dicetosser1]

sonofa!!!   what is up with multiquotes lately!!!!! 

[Niniel]

I´m here. 

 

@ Hallia - I have not been here because it took me a long time to catch up. The only reason I was able to do it at all is that I don´t work today. 

 

A lot of people have me as a possible lynch candidate so I will try to explain my game so far.

 

* I had an idea of how Katiora played as mafia but that was wrong. It was a mistake.

* I said I could just follow BFG. I actually never did so but that comment was based on 

 a) She was my strongest townread.

 b) I will not be able to be active/take notes in a game like this.

 c) And a little bit of a joke. I don´t think I have ever just blindly followed anyone in a game where I haven´t got a cop result. 

* What more? I´m not her much because it´s a too active game for me. I will not be able to be very active and it will be more gut feelings based on posts that I remember. I have already forgotten about the first posts I read today.

 

 

So my impressions:

 

Wish - I only remember one game that I have played with her. Maybe there have been more and maybe I have read some game that she played but I don´t remember that. Anyway, we were mafia together in that game. She posted a lot of meaningless stuff. A lot of lols and smileys and just strange out of the blue stuff. I don´t understand her here either, and I think that her analysis of the early questions is really wrong (at least about me), but she seems more involved. She is commenting on things that happens. So my one and only experience with her before tells me she is town. But I still don´t understand her.

 

Clov - I find it easy to understand his posts because he is logical. Still, his vote on me is wrong. I could be me, since I probably haven´t explained myself any good, but it also looks like an "easy" vote. I don´t usually see Clov doing these but as I said, it could just be me playing really bad. 

 

Laine - like her.

 

BFG - have not been as active as in the start. I hope she will be. Still town though.

 

Hally - townie feeling

 

Darthe - ??? He is certainly choosing a few things to point to and I don´t know if it is because it´s the only things he think is important to focus on or if he chooses to not focus on other things on purpose. 

 

I´ll continue soon.

[dicetosser1]

i want either len or seph lynched. the only possible saving grace for len is if all those "NOT WORTH MENTIONINGS" are too obvious to come from mafia.

 

 

 

seph started off kinda sussing me   i felt like he was thinking he could mislynch me later.  then suddenly i go from needing a handle to being above null

 

I think Darthe is making sense regarding seph and the halli stuff

 

 

vote seph

[dicetosser1]

@ninel I need to see things from you. Ive seen no towntina that i know so well yet. you havent been very active so i was giving time but u need to show why i shouldnt be voting you tomorrow

[Niniel]

Zander - I still think he is mafia. It´s based on earlier stuff but I have not seen anything that makes him look better. It´s also worth nothing that Dice and Laine doesn´t have him as town. They know him well.

 

Dice - I like his posts. 

 

Lenlo - could vote him.

 

Lily - same as before. A very small +.

 

seph - he claimed vt when being confronted. Why? There weren´t a lot of votes on him and few people was arguing with him. I need to figure out what I think about that early reveal.

 

Who have I forgotten. Need to check the op.

[Niniel]

@ninel I need to see things from you. Ive seen no towntina that i know so well yet. you havent been very active so i was giving time but u need to show why i shouldnt be voting you tomorrow

 

I´m not sure I will be able to show you any ordinary townNini. I will just have to do the best I can in this game. Don´t expect anything big from me. 

[dicetosser1]

gimme what u can hun

[Niniel]

Besie - I have no idea why she has BFG as mafia that early. I don´t like it. 

 

Sili - feeling better about him now compared to earlier.

 

Kat - I don´t feel good about her. She posts a lot to tell people to stop arguing and doing fluff/lol posts. I agree with her that people should stop arguing in that way because it makes the thread unreadable for some of us, but she doesn´t seem to draw any conclusions of them even though she apparently reads them. It seems like she is just posting to be seen posting.

 

Liz - I don´t understand a lot of what she is writing. Have no idea about her. 

[Niniel]

gimme what u can hun

 

I´ll do my best but it won´t be much. <3

[Niniel]

So I guess my list after this is:

 

Dice

Laine

BFG

Hally

Sili

Wish

Lily

 

 

Clov

seph

Liz

Darthe

 

Besie

Kat

Lenlo

Zander

[Niniel]

I´ll stay on Zander for now and that is who I rather vote but I could also vote Lenlo, Kat and maybe Besie. It´s hard with Besie since she hasn´t had the time to catch up yet. 

[alannalynn]

I've been trying to read this thread, literally, for the past 9 hours and can't get into it, can't provide notes, nothing. I DID skim through those 40 pages so I guess that can be considered being caught up.

 

This is about where I am on my reads:

 

Alanna
Sili
Wistork

BFG*
Dice
Kat

Seph
Hally

Clov
Liza
Thane/Besie
Lily
Niniel

Zander
Lenlo

 

 

Sili looks really good to me and feels town, I've agreed with points he's made, and his level of interest makes me believe he's town.

Wish is a lovely lady and I haven't hated any of her posts thus far, town.

BFG probably town; was not a fan of her when her and Zander got into it but I believe she's mostly on her town game.

Dice is likely town as well, more of a gut feeling, I've liked his thread presence

Seph probably town- he's had a few strange posts but nothing inherently scummy imo

Kat- I think if she was scum she'd be a lot less comfortable on thread and those WOTs of hers are just fine to me, so I'm good here

Hally likely town, I'm thinking I misread how that comment went down earlier in the game... none of her posts have bugged me too much

Chris I'm inherently always suspicious of but he's done nothing to warrant my attention yet, so cautiously town.

Liza had a good entrance into the thread, not bothered. Would like some RT interaction

Besie null atm

Lily might be town but mostly null

Niniel ???

Zander feels off. That's really all I've got right now and I'm not sure I'm able to explain more than that. I would like to do a detailed analysis of his posts but there are too many and I never ISO Zander because it's an impossible feat. So I give up

Lenlo probably scum for reasons mentioned before.

 

 

 

 

[alannalynn]

Niniel why is Kat so low? Why is Besie so low with so little content?

[alannalynn]

It's 730am, I'm going to bed. Goodnight.

[Darthe]

I'm not on your list

[Darthe]

I don't like the Seph wagon

Idk why bit this is standing out to me and I kinda agree.. Bleh

[Darthe]

Lenlo's vote 'fits' with what he said rarlier, but him popping after yesterday without anything new is probably telling.

This and bessie could be why. That said, this is a suggestive post rather than an active post.

 

Its irksome to agree with the content and yet wary of it based on its presentation and who said it

[Darthe]

 

 

Ok Darthe serious question, name one game we've played together where you've been 'impressed' by my game?

I've liked your game most times that we played together! Think of how often I'm critical of people and their decisions, have you ever recieved that? I nommed you for champs, I think highly of you.

I think the only game in at least the past year you've 'liked' my game is Pokemon, I've 'irritated' you in every other game I can think of (admittedly we haven't actually played that many) so colour me a little sceptical here

Lol do you not know me? That puts you high on my list.