[Advanced] Gods and Demons Mafia - All your souls belong to Shad (Triads win)

[Hallia]

Reading up overnight I don't like Celeste's catch up and sussing of Calder. Leaving my vote there. Also, Butternut, if you are indeed town, put out a read list,to help your team win should you be lynched - it seems you're bitter at the moment but it is good to do

[Calder]

Will try to check in today but its a busy one as I have to get out of DC tonight before we get 30 inches of snow tomorrow.

 

[v]manbat[/v]

 

Gonna stand by my D0 read. But, would be nice to get a few more people in here to present some other options.

[Zander?]

[V] monstr [/v]

 

His argument with zander is ridiculous. Z made one vote and monstr went crazy. From my reading it looks like he is going as far to try to bring zander's alignment into question.

 

Monstr, what was the one post you are afraid to clear me for?

 

Can you explain the bold.  He only implied i sucked at the game not my alignment,

 

Question for zander and Eldrick, did you get your pm changing your role at start of night or at end of night. anyone else that has already claimed a second role pm can weigh in here also.

 

I have a reason and will give it if asked.

 

This is the 2nd time youve asked about my switch, Id like a reason please.

[Zander?]

 

I'd hate for the try hard town hero to be a mislynch. Actual town heroes are good to keep around.

 

#Full Zander

 

Anywho, I'm off work now. Going home and to bed. See you guys tonight.

The it would be bad for us to lose a town asset angle. Most common argument for sure. When manbat kills us all i hope it gives you comfort.

 

 

 

Will try to check in today but its a busy one as I have to get out of DC tonight before we get 30 inches of snow tomorrow.

 

[v]manbat[/v]

 

Gonna stand by my D0 read. But, would be nice to get a few more people in here to present some other options.

 

 

You went from sussing Monstr D0, to basically clearing him last night during our back and forth and now voting him after he stopped posting?

 

I dont get this at all

[Zander?]

But seriously, there is no way I am going to get caught up to this point in 2 days (by then it would be another 50-60 pages)

 

So, this is what I am going to do. I am going to sheep the towniest of the towniest person at least for this phase.

 

Praise the lord, I don't have to catch up to figure out who that person is. Zander it is !

 

 

 

 

Nearly 50 pages in 15 hours?

 

Someone kill me. 

*throws an apple at Pral*

 

 

Hope it is poisoned 

 

 

You say youre not gonna get caught up yet you quote a post from an hour previous and now youre saying youre just gonna sheep me...

 

I dont like this.......

[Zander?]

 

Emo does not make you town.

 

Talking in circles about what you would or wouldn't do does not make you town.

 

Sorry.

 

Enjoy losing this game

 

And inb4 "Omg fearmongering I'm sooooooooooo perceptive

 

 

Monstr I hope youve calmed down and reset I had to do the same thing D0 so I understand.  Even if youre Town and youre mislynched here were not in any sort gonna lose the game atp.  Yes it will put us behind the 8 Ball but again the over reactions are kinda baffling me still.

[Calder]

 

 

 

I'd hate for the try hard town hero to be a mislynch. Actual town heroes are good to keep around.

 

#Full Zander

 

Anywho, I'm off work now. Going home and to bed. See you guys tonight.

The it would be bad for us to lose a town asset angle. Most common argument for sure. When manbat kills us all i hope it gives you comfort.

Will try to check in today but its a busy one as I have to get out of DC tonight before we get 30 inches of snow tomorrow.

 

[v]manbat[/v]

 

Gonna stand by my D0 read. But, would be nice to get a few more people in here to present some other options.

 

You went from sussing Monstr D0, to basically clearing him last night during our back and forth and now voting him after he stopped posting?

 

I dont get this at all

I read his D1 interactions fine. Which is what I was discussing yesterday. Dont know why you think viewing recent posts as better last night accounts as clearing.

 

But, if my option is trust my D0 read or push a potential lurker, i am gonna trust my initial read.

[Zander?]

Also if I die:

 

If Monstr is indeed the lynch and flips Town look hard at Shad Turin and Calder.

 

If he flips Scum look at Sooh and Dice.

[Zander?]

Calder's progression on Monstr Last night

 

 

 

 

 

 

I'd hate for the try hard town hero to be a mislynch. Actual town heroes are good to keep around.

#Full Zander

Anywho, I'm off work now. Going home and to bed. See you guys tonight.

The it would be bad for us to lose a town asset angle. Most common argument for sure. When manbat kills us all i hope it gives you comfort.

Will try to check in today but its a busy one as I have to get out of DC tonight before we get 30 inches of snow tomorrow.

[v]manbat[/v]

Gonna stand by my D0 read. But, would be nice to get a few more people in here to present some other options.

You went from sussing Monstr D0, to basically clearing him last night during our back and forth and now voting him after he stopped posting?

I dont get this at all

I read his D1 interactions fine. Which is what I was discussing yesterday. Dont know why you think viewing recent posts as better last night accounts as clearing.

But, if my option is trust my D0 read or push a potential lurker, i am gonna trust my initial read.

 

 

 

 

And yes, reading me wrong is your fault

I don't care how "wolfy" you think I am

Damn. Gonna be hard to vote you bc of this. I have always hated the do something random mafia attitude then if corrected take credit, if wrong oh well was his fault. (In general observation)

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

I cant even consider clearing you atp with these responses man im sorry.....you can ridicule me all you want if im wrong.

You have no idea how to play this game

Only recent post I didnt like from manbat. However, frustration attacks are pretty null for a lot of players. They rub me the wrong way, but can prob write this off bc his activity level already shows his investment level.

Didnt you have Monstr as scum all game?

Yea I have. But, trying to reavaluate as I go. I really don't mind his recent posts. Seem like frustration from legitimate time investment. He has thrown a lot out there and seems more like a frustrated player that is town and trying to be heard now than scum angered their leader ploy didnt work.

 

 

 

 

How well do you know manbat? I feel like there's a connection between you two.

Never played with him before. But he fits a classic try hard Town hero archetype. Those types are consistent.

 

 

 

At least I dont think I have played with him before. Only 1 other game on this site. If Turin is right and the questioning of D0 is nonsensical than it should be manbat today.

 

 

Will try to check in today but its a busy one as I have to get out of DC tonight before we get 30 inches of snow tomorrow.

[v]manbat[/v]

Gonna stand by my D0 read. But, would be nice to get a few more people in here to present some other options.

 

 

 

Can someone else read this and tell me if they find it a little strange or if its just me?

[Clovdyx]

Vote count:

 

• Hallia - 1 - Sooh
• Celeste - 1 - Hallia
• Turin Turambar - 1 - manbat
• Manbat - 4 - Zander, Shad, Turin Turambar, Calder
• Calder - 1 - Celeste

[Lenlo]

 

 

[V] monstr [/v]

 

His argument with zander is ridiculous. Z made one vote and monstr went crazy. From my reading it looks like he is going as far to try to bring zander's alignment into question.

 

Monstr, what was the one post you are afraid to clear me for?

Can you explain the bold. He only implied i sucked at the game not my alignment,

Question for zander and Eldrick, did you get your pm changing your role at start of night or at end of night. anyone else that has already claimed a second role pm can weigh in here also.

 

I have a reason and will give it if asked.

This is the 2nd time youve asked about my switch, Id like a reason please.

Agreed both of those are suspect. Turin is apparently caught up yet this is all he says to. I want more

 

[V]Turin [/v]

 

Going into lecture for the next 3 hours, but when I'm out and home I'm gonna ISO Turin and see what that brings up.

[Calder]

The order of those posts is weird Zander. But, I stand by all that. Day 1 felt more genuine than D0. Wouldnt even suspect him from D1 activity alone. But, D0 did happen and improvement in post vibe does not erase those initial feelings and that the read may have been correct.

[Celeste]

Reading up overnight I don't like Celeste's catch up and sussing of Calder. Leaving my vote there. Also, Butternut, if you are indeed town, put out a read list,to help your team win should you be lynched - it seems you're bitter at the moment but it is good to do

What is your read on Calder?

[Celeste]

I think some players still haven't checked in much this phase.

[Turin Turambar]

 

 

[V] monstr [/v]

 

His argument with zander is ridiculous. Z made one vote and monstr went crazy. From my reading it looks like he is going as far to try to bring zander's alignment into question.

 

Monstr, what was the one post you are afraid to clear me for?

Can you explain the bold. He only implied i sucked at the game not my alignment,

Question for zander and Eldrick, did you get your pm changing your role at start of night or at end of night. anyone else that has already claimed a second role pm can weigh in here also.

 

I have a reason and will give it if asked.

This is the 2nd time youve asked about my switch, Id like a reason please.

To me it sounded like manbat was making a Mafioso style pushback at you. He wasn't just saying your wrong he was implying you couldn't just be that wrong.

 

The reason about the second question is that to me it makes a difference in the setup if your role changed at start of night versus at end of night. It has no bearing on my read of you. You are mod confirmed either way.

 

I would not mind hearing answers from the others that Claimed role adjusting first tho.

[Zander?]

 

 

[V] monstr [/v]

 

His argument with zander is ridiculous. Z made one vote and monstr went crazy. From my reading it looks like he is going as far to try to bring zander's alignment into question.

 

Monstr, what was the one post you are afraid to clear me for?

Can you explain the bold. He only implied i sucked at the game not my alignment,

Question for zander and Eldrick, did you get your pm changing your role at start of night or at end of night. anyone else that has already claimed a second role pm can weigh in here also.

 

I have a reason and will give it if asked.

This is the 2nd time youve asked about my switch, Id like a reason please.

To me it sounded like manbat was making a Mafioso style pushback at you. He wasn't just saying your wrong he was implying you couldn't just be that wrong.

 

The reason about the second question is that to me it makes a difference in the setup if your role changed at start of night versus at end of night. It has no bearing on my read of you. You are mod confirmed either way.

 

I would not mind hearing answers from the others that Claimed role adjusting first tho.

 

 

[Zander?]

 

Reading up overnight I don't like Celeste's catch up and sussing of Calder. Leaving my vote there. Also, Butternut, if you are indeed town, put out a read list,to help your team win should you be lynched - it seems you're bitter at the moment but it is good to do

What is your read on Calder?

 

 

What are your reads?

[Turin Turambar]

If you wanna give your answer before them that is fine.

 

If they don't want to answer it is their prerogative. They came forward with that information without any pressure to speak of. If they are trying to be helpful by giving information then why not give the entire thing. No one is asking for actual role information. Mafia most likely already know what happened. I don't see how town knowing as well is harmful.

 

For me it is about determining in my own mind if alignments were in place D0 or not.

[Zander?]

If you wanna give your answer before them that is fine.

 

If they don't want to answer it is their prerogative. They came forward with that information without any pressure to speak of. If they are trying to be helpful by giving information then why not give the entire thing. No one is asking for actual role information. Mafia most likely already know what happened. I don't see how town knowing as well is harmful.

 

For me it is about determining in my own mind if alignments were in place D0 or not.

 

You asked whose roles changed.  If they say when its saying they have a role which Im pretty sure is role fishing and stupid for them to do imo.

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

 

[V] monstr [/v]

 

His argument with zander is ridiculous. Z made one vote and monstr went crazy. From my reading it looks like he is going as far to try to bring zander's alignment into question.

 

Monstr, what was the one post you are afraid to clear me for?

Can you explain the bold. He only implied i sucked at the game not my alignment,

Question for zander and Eldrick, did you get your pm changing your role at start of night or at end of night. anyone else that has already claimed a second role pm can weigh in here also.

 

I have a reason and will give it if asked.

This is the 2nd time youve asked about my switch, Id like a reason please.

To me it sounded like manbat was making a Mafioso style pushback at you. He wasn't just saying your wrong he was implying you couldn't just be that wrong.

 

The reason about the second question is that to me it makes a difference in the setup if your role changed at start of night versus at end of night. It has no bearing on my read of you. You are mod confirmed either way.

 

I would not mind hearing answers from the others that Claimed role adjusting first tho.

Zander is the only one to claim.

Stop fishing.

[Turin Turambar]

Zander is not the only one to have claimed that their role changed overnight. I believe both Lenlo and Hallia have soft claimed role adjustments. They have already put that out. I am not asking everyone. Just those that have already claimed or soft claimed.

 

Eldrick, read the first post in your reply. It specifically says to those that have already claimed.

[Zander?]

[Zander?]

Zander is not the only one to have claimed that their role changed overnight. I believe both Lenlo and Hallia have soft claimed role adjustments. They have already put that out. I am not asking everyone. Just those that have already claimed or soft claimed.

 

Eldrick, read the first post in your reply. It specifically says to those that have already claimed.

 

 

Turin you gotta understand this is a bad look for you right?  At least it is to me.

[Eldrick4221]

Zander is not the only one to have claimed that their role changed overnight. I believe both Lenlo and Hallia have soft claimed role adjustments. They have already put that out. I am not asking everyone. Just those that have already claimed or soft claimed.

 

Eldrick, read the first post in your reply. It specifically says to those that have already claimed.

Why do you keep asking, though?

[Turin Turambar]

Z, you realize I don't care how I look.

 

People made claims. I didn't make them make those claims. They did that themselves for whatever reason. Their claims mean they should have information regarding the mechanism that changed roles. That information might be vital in determining if there were mafia in D0. That could well be instrumental in finding the mafia.