Belichick - Mafia Eternal Night

[Shad_]

 

 

I remember those days, thank god they are over.

I'm not in a rush to hurry it along...

 

 

are you thinking this is Scum!Dice or Town!Dice?  im really just seeing his SW game here on the wrong read like he was with Durin,  thoughts?

I'll let you know. I'm not struck with immediate warm and fuzzies, though.

 

 

 

Shes so cute!!!  Obv shes very towny!!!  and shes not wearing pants....wonder which parent she gets that from....lololololololol

 

 

That might be the funniest thing I've heard all week.

[Zander?]

Yates and AJ feeling strongly town ITT

 

Yes

[Shad_]

Someone describe scum AJ to me.

[Thane Vakarian]

scum AJ is hard to find. That's my experience. I haven't found the subtleties yet that distinguish his wolf from his town game.

 

tbh: if town, really helpful. So, not someone i'd lynch right away. The longer he survives and the more townies die, he becomes more suspicious.

[Zander?]

Someone describe scum AJ to me.

 

well he was practically a wolf in SW......sorry AJ...I had too.....

[Talya]

Someone describe scum AJ to me.

 

I don't know he was scum in the Middle Earth game, but I can't remember much about that, except I know I had a bit of an argument about something with him, but saying that that happened in the last game, but he was third party. He feels a lot different in his approach so far to me. doesn't say in such an argumentative, if that makes sense.

 

Thank you BFG for the answer, I saw him answer Yates on it, but he just seemed to say that town had to get rid of all wolves, and then later used Yates actions for something that he did to you using AJ.

[Andrej]

Middle Earth was a bit unconventional in a sense because it had two scum teams so even as a wolf I could genuinely town/scum hunt. Probably also one of my (if not the) best games to date so I wouldn't consider the standard for how I play imo.

 

Anyway - good morning :)

[Andrej]

 

yates test seemed jokey in nature yet he is calling poeple town off it.

How confident are you that I'm not just spinning my own derp theory into a "test?" I mean, you know I've been daddy day care all week and you know what sleep deprivation does to an addled brain. I guess I don't see what made it seem "jokey" outside of the fact that someone else later characterized it as possibly a joke?I don't know, brother. I find myself siding with Lainey in her assessment of your play thus far...

I actually would've preferred you saying as much after you realized if that's the case instead of adding the spin. The reaction test bit was pretty hokey imo. I think the same reactions and analysis could've been made without you labeling it as a test and in the end you would've sounded a lot more genuine to me.

[Shad_]

 

Whatcha thinking Andrej?

Like I said, mostly a hunch. I don't really understand his progression on BFG or the explanation he provided.

 

It also seems that he's more off topic than not (he isn't the only guilty one of this) but there have been places in the game where I feel like opportunities were there to make observations and he didn't. For instance, the Yates test and the Thane posts a few of us have commented on. I don't remember him saying anything about these and instead he's telling us about his house. Which is great and all but doesn't catch wolves.

 

 

 

Responding to these then I have to go :)

 

Stuff like Yates reaction test, there have been several instances where people have confused things people have said. I have Shad down as a 'fact checker' this is an easy game to do that in so far, so is he missing t, doesn't think it matters, doesn't care???

 

It's all little things, but so far he's liked AJ, myself, Thane and you for town (?). I haven't seen him find anything suspicious yet. I don't know if I can explain this yet, and part of it may be down to the difference between what he posts and the notes he has (some of which were shared on the QT last game)

 

His observations when he makes them are generally well thought out, it's just everything feels overworked(?)

 

Incidentally this is why I need Clov playing - so he can find the right words :(

 

 

 

And I have someone to sheep/tunnel/tinfoil on

 

 

 

 

Those statements are very similar in unusual ways.

 

But it's true that I've been more chatty.  Is the fact that I didn't comment on particular events which you both found significant a legitimate town concern?  Or are you thinking I have not commented on enough things in general?

 

Thing is though, in my QT with BFG last game I made a TON of comments that I didn't actually post in the thread.  She's not seeing the same Shad because we don't have a private chat and I'm more cautious with my thoughts in-game, so her concern makes perfect sense to me.  She's spewing a volcano of town imo and if she flips scum I permit you all to laugh at me later.  AJ's feels a little more odd, and it would have seemed really fishy to me had he made it after BFG, but AJ posted first.

[Shad_]

Also, two things I should clarify:

 

1) I'm not town reading Thane yet.  That's why I didn't comment on him until the fact that I hadn't was brought up.  I think town!Thane should become obvious pretty soon given what I saw of his scum game.  But he was also a hydra in that game so he might have sat back more than he usually does as wolf.

 

2) I mentioned in the sign-up thread that I would be less active in this game.

 

 

Feeling good right now about BFG, Laine, Zander, Yates, and Talya kind of.  Town Talya comes out when she has more substantive material to base reads on, but her reaction to Yates was a good start.

I know I shouldn't ever feel good about Yates, but I do.  Can't stop that feeling.

AJ's more of a "gut says town but I'm not going to trust that for a while yet".

I didn't like Dice on a first read but I need to look at him again tonight.  I thought he was scum for the majority of Star Wars until I got NK'd and I was wrong.

[seph]

Official Vote Count 6:

 

Verb (1/7): Rand

Laine (2/7): Shad, Dice

No lynch (2/7): Yates, Talya

Shad (1/7): AJ

 

Not Voting (7/13):

BFG, Verb, Laya, Laine, Thane, Zander, Hally

 

[Andrej]

I said I liked you.  You asked why.  I said "It's the slowest start of the three games I've been in, and most wolves don't mind that one bit.  You're already asking questions."

 

Did I initially like you because you were trying to pick up the pace, or because you were asking questions?  The former is (potentially) true.  The latter is necessarily a lie.  Are scum trying to figure out who is lying? They are assuming I'm telling the truth, so they instinctively interpret the statement in the sense in which it is true.  That is: "I like you because you are trying to pick up the pace.  For example: you just asked me a question."  Or they assume you did ask other questions and do not investigate such a trivial matter.  Or they pounce on my apparent error to incriminate me, or let the whole thing slide because they might come out the worse for wear.

 

Do they cautiously ask for clarification in the hopes that I say something outlandish and dig myself a hole?  Maybe a small minority do, but the path of least resistance says BFG is probably town.

Firstly I would like to say that formatting this on my phone wasn't easy - coloring the parts I want to address was the easiest way so excuse that.

 

Overall this posts sounds like a bunch of crafted bull. First and foremost.

 

Red: what's really the point of this? Honestly. It was like page 4 of the game so the explanation about laying a trap seems... fake. Also, correct me if I'm wrong, but didn't early you say something that you'd noticed the "mistake" but left it on purpose? The problem I am having getting my head around is how you could make a mistake when describing something you liked about my play so early in the game. In other words - were you making the read up from the start?

 

Blue: Lying - not necessarily. Misinformed or stating things that aren't factual? Absolutely. Wolves need to find reasons to pressure/suspect people so BFG pointing something out that could be easily fact checked wasn't really alignment indicative or at the least not worthy of a town read with what you supported it with.

 

Green:BFG essentially did what you're describing here as far as what scum would do. I don't think she passively asked for clarification - she saw the error and questioned you over it. Tbf I actually thought it came across a bit aggressive for her but I think that's mostly because I'm not used to her showing teeth. So again - the conclusion you're drawing doesn't really line up for me. BFG as either alignment spots that discrepancy imo and you trying to characterize it now as an intentional mistake really pings me.

[Shad_]

 

 

<3 Shad

 

I'm so down

 

LEAVE ALANNA ALONEEEEEE

Thank youuuuu

 

 

 

@Laine - Disappoint because you're bashing on my favorite beverage

Maybe a little bashing. I also don't like chocolate ice cream, tomatoes, oranges (they make my skin break out), cherries, watermelon, and an assortment of other random things including people and going outside.

 

This plus bacon and anything smoked or grilled and you have listed my favorite things. Die, scum.

I LOVE BACON

 

Mostly the things I don't like are because of consistency or acidity. Thinks like oranges and tomatoes literally give me rashes. Anything too seedy also makes me squirmish

 

 

obviously crawling for town cred

 

unvote vote LAine

 

 

 

lets look at this.  Have I been here?  No. Is that my first post on return? YES. Could it have been a joke while i was catching up? YES.

 

Did you react badly? YES.

 

 

I didn't realize the first time I read Dice's vote that he had highlighted "I LOVE BACON".  So it probably was a joke, but what an odd post to pick out of 16 pages of content.  Now he's tunneling Laine and that's pretty much exactly what he did with Durin in SW.  Meh, I'm not going to get into a habit of accepting Dice as town every time he goes off on a single track and rides it all D1.

[Shad_]

 

I said I liked you.  You asked why.  I said "It's the slowest start of the three games I've been in, and most wolves don't mind that one bit.  You're already asking questions."

 

Did I initially like you because you were trying to pick up the pace, or because you were asking questions?  The former is (potentially) true.  The latter is necessarily a lie.  Are scum trying to figure out who is lying? They are assuming I'm telling the truth, so they instinctively interpret the statement in the sense in which it is true.  That is: "I like you because you are trying to pick up the pace.  For example: you just asked me a question."  Or they assume you did ask other questions and do not investigate such a trivial matter.  Or they pounce on my apparent error to incriminate me, or let the whole thing slide because they might come out the worse for wear.

 

Do they cautiously ask for clarification in the hopes that I say something outlandish and dig myself a hole?  Maybe a small minority do, but the path of least resistance says BFG is probably town.

Firstly I would like to say that formatting this on my phone wasn't easy - coloring the parts I want to address was the easiest way so excuse that.

 

Overall this posts sounds like a bunch of crafted bull. First and foremost.

 

Red: what's really the point of this? Honestly. It was like page 4 of the game so the explanation about laying a trap seems... fake. Also, correct me if I'm wrong, but didn't early you say something that you'd noticed the "mistake" but left it on purpose? The problem I am having getting my head around is how you could make a mistake when describing something you liked about my play so early in the game. In other words - were you making the read up from the start?

 

Blue: Lying - not necessarily. Misinformed or stating things that aren't factual? Absolutely. Wolves need to find reasons to pressure/suspect people so BFG pointing something out that could be easily fact checked wasn't really alignment indicative or at the least not worthy of a town read with what you supported it with.

 

Green:BFG essentially did what you're describing here as far as what scum would do. I don't think she passively asked for clarification - she saw the error and questioned you over it. Tbf I actually thought it came across a bit aggressive for her but I think that's mostly because I'm not used to her showing teeth. So again - the conclusion you're drawing doesn't really line up for me. BFG as either alignment spots that discrepancy imo and you trying to characterize it now as an intentional mistake really pings me.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Calling all Villagers:

 

I am one of you this time. I would love to continue this trend of DM wolf stomppages.

 

Let's make it happen again

Pretty tempted to believe that from what I've seen in 3 pages.

 

How come?

 

 

It's the slowest start of the three games I've been in, and most wolves don't mind that one bit.  You're already asking questions.

 

Where?

 

So far AJ's 'rallied the troops' a couple of times, but I hadn't seen any questions until after you'd given your town read

 

 

Highlighted in red.  There would have been no explanation without it.

 

I went fishing and caught a BFG town read.

 

 

Gotta take off for a while but food for thought: this was my immediate response to BFG.  If I'm making up my reasoning after the fact, that was some epic foresight.

[alannalynn]

I'm here, catching up on thread. I have more time than I thought because my overtime was canceled for the night.

[Shad_]

 

I said I liked you.  You asked why.  I said "It's the slowest start of the three games I've been in, and most wolves don't mind that one bit.  You're already asking questions."

 

Did I initially like you because you were trying to pick up the pace, or because you were asking questions?  The former is (potentially) true.  The latter is necessarily a lie.  Are scum trying to figure out who is lying? They are assuming I'm telling the truth, so they instinctively interpret the statement in the sense in which it is true.  That is: "I like you because you are trying to pick up the pace.  For example: you just asked me a question."  Or they assume you did ask other questions and do not investigate such a trivial matter.  Or they pounce on my apparent error to incriminate me, or let the whole thing slide because they might come out the worse for wear.

 

Do they cautiously ask for clarification in the hopes that I say something outlandish and dig myself a hole?  Maybe a small minority do, but the path of least resistance says BFG is probably town.

Firstly I would like to say that formatting this on my phone wasn't easy - coloring the parts I want to address was the easiest way so excuse that.

 

Overall this posts sounds like a bunch of crafted bull. First and foremost.

 

Red: what's really the point of this? Honestly. It was like page 4 of the game so the explanation about laying a trap seems... fake. Also, correct me if I'm wrong, but didn't early you say something that you'd noticed the "mistake" but left it on purpose? The problem I am having getting my head around is how you could make a mistake when describing something you liked about my play so early in the game. In other words - were you making the read up from the start?

 

Blue: Lying - not necessarily. Misinformed or stating things that aren't factual? Absolutely. Wolves need to find reasons to pressure/suspect people so BFG pointing something out that could be easily fact checked wasn't really alignment indicative or at the least not worthy of a town read with what you supported it with.

 

Green:BFG essentially did what you're describing here as far as what scum would do. I don't think she passively asked for clarification - she saw the error and questioned you over it. Tbf I actually thought it came across a bit aggressive for her but I think that's mostly because I'm not used to her showing teeth. So again - the conclusion you're drawing doesn't really line up for me. BFG as either alignment spots that discrepancy imo and you trying to characterize it now as an intentional mistake really pings me.

 

 

 

Quick response while the wife gets ready:

 

"In other words - were you making the read up from the start?"  --  "I like you because you are trying to pick up the pace."  This was true.  Did I have ulterior motives for actually commenting on you in the first place rather than keeping this thought to myself?  Yes, I wanted to see where it would lead.

 

I have never played with BFG before.  If you find her reaction to me unusually aggressive, hold on to that.  I am totally capable of being wrong about her.  It didn't seem aggressive at all to me but I haven't played an actual game with her before.

[alannalynn]

@Talya, re: Thane

 

 

 

 

 

i get the feeling that we're still missing a few players..... hopefully they will get in before DL
 
i contemplate voting Yates... he rands wolf way too often, so it'd be an excellent D1 guess imo

 
According to the CCSOWH if Yates looks towny D1 ignore him if not,,,,,,,,lolololol
 
Yates actually looking more towny thus far then in SW imo.

Agreed. Need more time to figure him out though. Remember, if he claims mason, we lynch him immediately.
 
I don't like Thane's comment

 
This is the first post you say you don't like his comments

for the moment, Zander is the only one i trust here. I can always Vig him if he betrays me in another game.
 
As for Verb and Pral, they'd be 0 info lynches. Would be nice to wreck some wolves without too much town casualties this game, and we'd need to gather info to do so, right?
 
I'll be coming and going this weekend, depending on how the kids want to spend their time *nods*

 

  

Well who would have figured on July 4th nowhere would be open? I really really wanted Asian food of some sort but all closed. At least I have booze. I'll just make a pizza
 
Thane always pings a little. I would feel bad lynching him though after Star Wars

  
So he pings a little but would feel bad after SW game Why. He was wolf there, why would you feel bad here
/snip

 

/snip

 

Why? He was scum in Star Wars

He's pinging but not the same way. I wasn't even sure he was mafia last game until I got the guilty read, so there's that. I'm less sure this time, but could probably use more time to see.
(would feel bad even if scum because I don't like pushing the same lynches-- makes me feel like a terrible person lol)

 

Just rereading for overall summarizing, wanted to get a feel for the topics that have been brought up in the game so far
 
pg 1-2 all rollover from the last game
pg 2-6 I'm getting voted (Shad, Hally, Yates) for disliking normal things; this is where Shad comes in with his town read of BFG after Andrej asks
pg 6-8 Sports talk??
pg 7-9 Vig talk: holding +ev for town (started by Yates/AJ)
pg 10 a lot of spam
pg 11-13  Yates and his "no lynch" plan that he clears Zander/Talya for; really don't like Thane's post #260, which Andrej and Zander point out as well; I mention he's pinging but differently than in Star Wars; Also don't like the post quoted below
pg 14-15 July 4th, revisiting Shad's reasoning
 

for the moment, Zander is the only one i trust here. I can always Vig him if he betrays me in another game.
 
As for Verb and Pral, they'd be 0 info lynches. Would be nice to wreck some wolves without too much town casualties this game, and we'd need to gather info to do so, right?
 
I'll be coming and going this weekend, depending on how the kids want to spend their time *nods*

I'm all for clearing Zander already, but why bring up Verb and Pral like we're going to lynch them? They haven't even made a post yet in the game. Feels like a weird thing to mention. Second sentence in the underlined is odd too, it seems like you want an info lynch more than a wolf lynch. But you bring up Verb and Pral as if they're on the table.

 
Ok these are you other posts I found for Thane. I think in amongst that you talked to AJ about shad and said you like his posts hence the mix up I got, it was Shad's posting you liked. You seem to say a lot about Thane, not liking posts and generally making pionts about him, but you still have him as null?
 
I'm posing more, because I don't have 50 pages to read before being able to post, lol...a refreshing change, plus It's weekend off and I have a couple of days off next week (yes I'm gloating there).

 

I do still have him as null, mainly because I'm seeing some good posts mixed in there with the bad, so I guess I'm more mixed on his read than anything. In the last game I was really sure after I cased him and Verbal and that's why I copped them that night to get a stronger read. Here, I'm getting mixed results, so I'm not sure if that's a good sign or a bad sign as of yet. I guess my wording could have been better, sorry.
 

@ BFG - What makes you feel like Shad isn't paying attention?
 
About Dice, he was like that in the SW game, he seems to grasp something and go for the juglar, doesn't mean he is always right, but I haven't seen him do it when he was wolf.

 I disagree on this comment, we were in the Mass Effect game together and Dice (mafia) jumped on Ley (town) in the same manner as here. I don't think it's alignment indicative.
 

 

I have read Shad, he responded to an obvious post of Yates but missed lots of other stuff. Not sure responding to the obvious gets him a pass. What do you make off all the fluff in his posts?

 
theres a lot of fluff D1 with people still yet to post or have only done a few posts.  i feel Shad is playing the same way with what is available.  last game atp there was WAY WAY more to go off of and less filler posts and spam. I feel hes getting more comfortable with the people he;s playing with and he's still making good solid posts that make sense imo.  I mean look ay my progression, Ive been trending the same way.
 
tbh im liking Shad more as town then you atp.  your really into it but are you doing that to compensate for something?

 ^I agree with your statement on Shad, I think I pretty much said the same earlier; as for BFG, I like her style and feel like I could put her in my town pile if not for her weird reservations with Shad. Something feels off about her read of him, like she's trying to find something out of nothing
 

 

I remember those days, thank god they are over.

I'm not in a rush to hurry it along...

are you thinking this is Scum!Dice or Town!Dice?  im really just seeing his SW game here on the wrong read like he was with Durin,  thoughts?

I'll let you know. I'm not struck with immediate warm and fuzzies, though.

 OMG WHAT A CUTIE <3 <3 <3
 

*yawn*
 
Give us time to wake up Zander!
 
West coast is early coast.  
 
I don't really remember anything from yesterday so I'm gonna reread real quick.

 Hally come back yet?
 

Someone describe scum AJ to me.

 I only played one game with Andrej as scum (Middle Earth) and we were on the same team. I guess I found him too towny to be town, which I commented on. But as the game progressed it's like he was riding his town equity to the end. idk that's just the overall impression I got. Not sure if that's indicative of his normal scum play, see below:

Middle Earth was a bit unconventional in a sense because it had two scum teams so even as a wolf I could genuinely town/scum hunt. Probably also one of my (if not the) best games to date so I wouldn't consider the standard for how I play imo.

Anyway - good morning :)

 
 

Official Vote Count 5:
 
Verb (1/7): Rand
Laine (2/7): Shad, Hally, Dice
No lynch (2/7): Yates, Talya
Shad (1/7): AJ
 
Not Voting (5/13):
BFG, Verb, Laya, Laine, Thane, Zander
 

  Hally unvote me, see? lol
 

 

 

 

<3 Shad

I'm so down
 
LEAVE ALANNA ALONEEEEEE

Thank youuuuu
 

 

 

@Laine - Disappoint because you're bashing on my favorite beverage

Maybe a little bashing. I also don't like chocolate ice cream, tomatoes, oranges (they make my skin break out), cherries, watermelon, and an assortment of other random things including people and going outside.

This plus bacon and anything smoked or grilled and you have listed my favorite things. Die, scum.

I LOVE BACON
Mostly the things I don't like are because of consistency or acidity. Thinks like oranges and tomatoes literally give me rashes. Anything too seedy also makes me squirmish

obviously crawling for town cred
unvote vote LAine

 

lets look at this.  Have I been here?  No. Is that my first post on return? YES. Could it have been a joke while i was catching up? YES.
 
Did you react badly? YES.

I didn't realize the first time I read Dice's vote that he had highlighted "I LOVE BACON".  So it probably was a joke, but what an odd post to pick out of 16 pages of content.  Now he's tunneling Laine and that's pretty much exactly what he did with Durin in SW.  Meh, I'm not going to get into a habit of accepting Dice as town every time he goes off on a single track and rides it all D1.

 

[dicetosser1]

 

yates test seemed jokey in nature yet he is calling poeple town off it.

How confident are you that I'm not just spinning my own derp theory into a "test?" I mean, you know I've been daddy day care all week and you know what sleep deprivation does to an addled brain. I guess I don't see what made it seem "jokey" outside of the fact that someone else later characterized it as possibly a joke?

 

I don't know, brother. I find myself siding with Lainey in her assessment of your play thus far...

 

 

what made it jokey to ME was that while yes its true I dont think its something you would seriously do.,

 

red   you obviously need more sleep bro. Want me to babysit?

[Talya]

@ Alanna, I forgot that bit in mass effect 2 I had my own issues with Ley. I need to go read Dice that game because I didn't think he was like that.

 

@ Dice, who are your top reads now and bottom ones at present?

[Hallia]

>.<

 

Well that was frustrating.  Couldn't get on all day.

[Thane Vakarian]

just got in myself... ugh. Frustrating indeed. Wanted to use the first quiet hour at work to re-read... 

 

Morning all (or, evening)

[Hallia]

Anyways!  Up through pages 5, I have early town reads on three people:

 

Andrej - early game talk when people still fluffing, encouraging activity without the spam

Shad - Saw what I meant with regards to AJ

BFG - Went after Shad for clarification regarding his post on AJ

 

 

 

Calling all Villagers:

I am one of you this time. I would love to continue this trend of DM wolf stomppages.

Let's make it happen again

Pretty tempted to believe that from what I've seen in 3 pages.

How come?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Calling all Villagers:

I am one of you this time. I would love to continue this trend of DM wolf stomppages.

Let's make it happen again

Pretty tempted to believe that from what I've seen in 3 pages.

 

How come?

 

 
It's the slowest start of the three games I've been in, and most wolves don't mind that one bit.  You're already asking questions.

 

Where?

So far AJ's 'rallied the troops' a couple of times, but I hadn't seen any questions until after you'd given your town read

 

 

Highlighted in red.  There would have been no explanation without it.

 

I went fishing and caught a BFG town read.

 

 

 

Onwards and upwards!

[Hallia]

Up to page 10 and I've added more townies to my townie pile

 

Was it Tal that said AJ started the vig thing?  Because Yates did indeed.

 

 

 

over/under on NK's N1

5

If anyone in this game learned anything from NB? I'll take the under.

Ditto.

Holstering initially probably +EV. Let's get a POE or suspect pool formed first and then the vigs can shoot from within that - still wanna lynch wolves though.

 

 

 

 

Alright. Going to bed.

Good work.
Sleep well.
Most likely vig Lainey in the evening.

Where's the love?!

 

Agreed to the above, we can't just have vigs shooting everywhere N1, more likely to hit town than maf.

 

I am adding Yates and Laine to my town pile.

the best way to play this after looking at the set up again is to preserve the vigs. So VTs need to town tell like crazy and vigs shoot from within the pov. Hero shots probably aren't gonna win this

Yus

*snip*

And AJ is seeming town to me so I'm worried.
 

This post seems kind of awkward.

hello all..

 

i mostly agree that not all vigs should shoot N1.. that'd be a massacre and town suicide imo. Now that i'm on the good side again, let's wreck some wolves and get the lynching spree going!

 

If only i had found a susect yet.... but i will!!!

 

*hands drinks all around*

 

i'll peek in during the weekend *nods*

After the first one or two people agreeing with something, I stop giving them credit, because scum of course wants to sheep along the town thoughts.

 

 

i get the feeling that we're still missing a few players..... hopefully they will get in before DL

 

i contemplate voting Yates... he rands wolf way too often, so it'd be an excellent D1 guess imo

 

According to the CCSOWH if Yates looks towny D1 ignore him if not,,,,,,,,lolololol

 

Yates actually looking more towny thus far then in SW imo.

Agreed. Need more time to figure him out though. Remember, if he claims mason, we lynch him immediately.

 

I don't like Thane's comment

 

I agree Laine, it looks like backtracking to me.

 

Town is AJ, Shad, BFG, Yates, and Laine

 

Null to Scummy is Talya and Thane

[Hallia]

Had to stop at page 12 due to all the things that are wrong in this picture.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

1. In the event of a draw wolves win by default.

2. Wolves have no nightly kill.

3. Mafia Role PM:
Darthe - You are Otto Graham, Wolf 1x Vigilante. Once , during the night phase of the game, you may submit a kill on a single individual. Your team wins by eliminating all members of the town from the game.

There are 10 Town.

There are 3 wolves.

Wolves get 4 kills.

If we no lynch all game and never use our vig shots we win 6-3.

[v]No lynch[/v]

Game is solved.

 

 

 

It was AJ that first mentioned about not vigging n1.

However I now think you are also towny

[v]No lynch[/v]

 

 

Yates, you know that's not gonna fly - right?

 

 

 

 

Yates, you know that's not gonna fly - right?

We can do it by not making a hammer lynch every day...so what is the difference

 

That's true but also more consequential versus actively choosing to not play in a sense.

 

I mean - yeah - it auto wins for town but I don't think that was Darthe's intent when he put this together.

 

 

 

 

 

1. In the event of a draw wolves win by default.

2. Wolves have no nightly kill.

3. Mafia Role PM:
Darthe - You are Otto Graham, Wolf 1x Vigilante. Once , during the night phase of the game, you may submit a kill on a single individual. Your team wins by eliminating all members of the town from the game.

There are 10 Town.

There are 3 wolves.

Wolves get 4 kills.

If we no lynch all game and never use our vig shots we win 6-3.

[v]No lynch[/v]

Game is solved.

 

 

Yates not just a man with a pretty face and no pants!!!

 

[v] No Lynch [/v[

 

Yates GOAT

 

 

 

 

It was a joke.  >_>
 
All wolves have to die for a town win.

Not a joke. A test.

Because GOOD is DUMB!

 

Talya and Zander are officially welcomed to my village pile.

 

 

 

 

Are you saying that just because they sheeped a stupid idea that they're town?

Pretty much. They saw a mathematical solution that resulted in a game solve and just went with it. Scum would be like - step back. What? They can't win like this, right?
 

Also, I'm curious where you people find these gifs lol

There are these two great sites worth checking out. Not sure if you've heard of the but one is www.google.com and the other is www.yahoo.com.

I remember lots of movie quotes. So I googled "good is dumb." That easy.

 

 

 

 

 

Not sure what you meant by "the Under" assumed some American Football talk..so didn't get it..

 

so he copied you then?

I handed him the rock and he carried it.  

 

This isn't a sports metaphor it's a gambling question.  Zander wanted to know how many kills there would be N1.  He set the bar at 5 and wanted to know if it would be OVER five or UNDER five.  I suggested that if we learned anything from the last game, it should be UNDER five.  In other words, I'm suggesting people don't go nuts with their N1 shots.  AJ didn't copy me so much as agree.

 

 

Now that makes more sense. Not a gambling person, but I get it now. Thanks

 

Tbh, I still like the look of AJ as town lean

 

 

 

 

 

Well technically we have to kill all the wolves, as Shad and Andrej pointed out, I believe.

Doesn't make Talya or Zander less Town.

I'll trust you on Talya then, I can never read her; it's extremely frustrating. As for Zander, I have no doubts he's town.

 

What does your test say for Shad and Andrej though?

 

 

 

 

What does your test say for Shad and Andrej though?

Inconclusive? They are equally likely to just be critical thinkers as wolves. So they basically ended the test. But not before Talya and Zander derp cleared themselves, imo.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

I dislike this entire thing.  I have seen Yates try gambiting before and I wouldn't put it past him to actually try this.  I don't buy the Talya/Zander derp clear.  It does make me feel even better about AJ and Laine, but it knocks Yates down out of my comfortably townie pile.

 

Town: AJ, Shad, BFG, Laine

 

Null: Zander

 

Null to Scummy: Yates, Talya, Thane

[Hallia]

Yates's test pretty null for me personally. Not really alignment indicative for him even if it was a little hokey.

Mmmmm.  Maybe that describes it a little better for me than what I was trying to say.  I didn't like it though.

 

i find all the football talk quite distracting..... must be me, i guess.

 

I doubt we'll see either Verb or Pral this weekend (verb is never on and Pral doesn't do D1 i guess).

 

No real suspect from my part at the moment, but i'll try to check a bit more tomorrow.

 

*hands more booze around*

 

it's weekend after all

 

wolfy imo

 

teammates of yours?

 

no thoughts on anyone?

 

villagery imo

 

Conclusion: Null on Thane.

 

I disagree on the null.  There was lots to comment on and he picks Verb/Pral's being mia?

for the moment, Zander is the only one i trust here. I can always Vig him if he betrays me in another game.

 

As for Verb and Pral, they'd be 0 info lynches. Would be nice to wreck some wolves without too much town casualties this game, and we'd need to gather info to do so, right?

 

I'll be coming and going this weekend, depending on how the kids want to spend their time *nods*

And still going down that vein alone...  I'm not even finished reading but

 

Vote: Thane