Alien mafia [BASIC] - Game Over - Town won

[Sili Quirrels]

Seems hallia is on her own island intent on making reads and solving the game. Ther eisn't a lot of sniping which is her characteristic wolf tell.

[Sili Quirrels]

Town -> Scum

Shad

Halia

 

Talya

Laine

 

Notbob

DArthe

Sooh

 

 

AH

 

This would be a strong scum game from LAine.

 

Not much to say about not bob other than, if he is a wolf, he bussed.

 

Sooh still town, but she might be my weakest town read. Although I don't think her being a hypocrite means anything for reasons I'll unspecified.

 

Shad is like, he has a lot of content and stuff but sometimes i get the feeling he's driving mislynches and I get panicky.

 

Darthe is like, ya, he doesn't care... and I believe him, but... it's way too easy for scum to hide like that and I really really dislike it the more I think about him.

 

Talya is acting like a cleared townie, which is villagery considering the circumstances. Plus Dae started the wagon.

[Sili Quirrels]

9 ppl

 

7 w/1mislynch

5 w/2 mislynch

loss after 3 mislynch

 

2 wolves.

 

hm.

[Sili Quirrels]

Seems hallia is on her own island intent on making reads and solving the game. Ther eisn't a lot of sniping which is her characteristic wolf tell.

 

^upon reading her iso.

[Aiel Heart]

Still, it seems like I'm missing something and it's queer.

 

Could be hallia, but I don't want to add weight to her wagon since she tends to be an easy mislynch if she's town.

I'm getting that too. Additionally I have the feeling there's a wolf going "haha they aren't looking at me hard enough"

 

And I'm back

[Sili Quirrels]

 

Still, it seems like I'm missing something and it's queer.

 

Could be hallia, but I don't want to add weight to her wagon since she tends to be an easy mislynch if she's town.

I'm getting that too. Additionally I have the feeling there's a wolf going "haha they aren't looking at me hard enough"

 

And I'm back

 

And what gifts have you brought?

[Clovdyx]

Vote Count
 
Sooh (2) - Talya, Shad
Hallia (1) - Notbob
Heart (2) - Darthe, Sili Quirrels
 
With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

[alannalynn]

Hallia why so many null in post 508? You have AH, Sooh, Darthe. I'm leaning scum on the first two, hoping for town on the latter

 

Let's see what I have... I need to go back and ISO maybe later tonight once I've slept, but quick reads

 

Alanna

Sili

Talya

 

Darthe

Hallia

 

NotBob

Shad

 

Heart

Sooh

Might move Hallia down a little bit after reading her ISO, feels like she's floating a bit this game which I don't like.

 

I'll go ahead and Vote Sooh though

[Sili Quirrels]

I am significantly more confident on ah than sooh.

 

i would really rather ah.

 

but if sooh is a general consensus then maybe we should lynch her first, i dunno =/

[Aiel Heart]

Last major WoT
As of back then:

 

 

Scummy:

Shad
Daet
Sooh
Talya

Town:
Laine
Verbal
Darthe
Sili

Null:
Hallia
NotBob

 

Ok, Daet was mafia and Verbal was town.

Verbal being town and his comments on Talya combined with how Talya responded under pressure makes me feel better about her, so I’ll lift her from the scum list for now. I’ve continued to feel good about her play.

Hallia mentioned not liking NotBob, and Shad he didn’t like him soon after (noticed this when working earlier, and can’t refind it now), and Laine did before too long as well. She said Laine’s lack of action on the Daet/Talya lynches makes her feel better about Laine, and while I comprehend the reason she gave that still seemed strange to me. I’m still really not sure how to feel about her. Looking at her ISO, she was confident that Eldrick was derptown, which kind of reminds me of Daet to be honest. Put pressure on Alanna because of her interactions with Yates, which is also interesting. Hallia could be a really informative lynch at this point. Said she liked my posts when Sili was putting the heat on me (Sili—is this the “buddying you mentioned in #559?), and felt better about Alanna later on, to the point that she was listed as solid town on the latest reads list. NotBob being mafia came out of nowhere. There’s just something missing about all of this, and it’s not just a number of posts.

Laine has continued to include me and Sooh in her Scum lists but hasn’t really developed her cases with the onslaught of posts. She also said she’d try to get more reads up later, so I’ll await that. Also want to know more of her reasoning behind NotBob and Shad. Will leave as town but I’m not feeling very certain of it.

Shad has continued to be very interesting in this game, and I’m trying to decide what is from his newness but seeming to know a lot, and what is from potentially scummy play. I still really don’t like how much his thinking is trying to get into the mind of the mafia so strongly… That’s part of this game but when you start doing it a ton it seems it’s like you are them. But I’m strangely feeling better about him. Lift?

Darthe—acting like he doesn’t care, has been carrying that on for a while. It’s definitely not helping town play, but he’s nonchalant about that. Something about how he’s posting seems off to me and has, but perhaps it’s as Verbal pointed out. Kind of want to vote him out of frustration. At best, he’s town, pressure would somehow engage him to play, then we can all unvote and get on to actual mafia. At also good, he’s mafia, and would get lynched. At bad, we’d lose a townie who really isn’t helping the game. At worst, we’d lose a power role who still wasn’t helping the game much. Darthe, please don’t make me vote you just because you’re being frustrating with your activity. I respect you far too much as a player and don’t want it to come to that.

Sili—his interactions with Darthe have been strange, as he’s gone around with whether Darthe is scum or not throughout the game, and it’s not really seemed to correlate with anything Darthe is or isn’t doing. Have liked his activity and that he seems to be trying to solve and I’ve liked a lot of what he’s said, but I’m also wary for a reason I can’t quite describe.

Sooh—still is seeming very careful, and it doesn’t seem to be the new sort of careful anymore. She has given explanations for various things when prodded, and has given a few thoughts on her own, but there is also a significant amount of her posts that just kind of jump in, commentate on why someone is reading someone else wrong, then pop back out.

NotBob—am liking him and agreeing with a lot of what he says. Will have to watch him closely because of that but will choose to believe him for now.

Scummy:
Sooh
Hallia?
Darthe?

Town?
Shad
Laine
Darthe
Sili
Talya
NotBob



So there is where my logical side is trying to lead me. Going by gut feelings alone, things look a little different:

Town:
NotBob
Shad
Talya

Townish but fear may be a lurking scum:
Darthe
Sili
Laine

Mafia:
Sooh

Can’t figure out for some reason:
Hallia



Take all of that as you will.



So, Sooh is my strongest mafia lead, though I feel like it’s whisps still at this point. There are already three votes on her. I could get behind her lynch but right now for the interests of hearing what she has to say and gleaning more information, I’m going to [v]vote Hallia[/v]


Darthe and Sili—what are your reasons behind voting me right now? Do you feel I am your strongest mafia lean or is it some other reason?

[alannalynn]

I'm willing to go for either at this point, really. Competing trains, see what happens?

[Aiel Heart]

I suppose the ninja post answered that for sili somewhat. Laine, your reasons for not liking me?

[Darthe]

AH just waffled on me so hard.

 

I'm prob town but there's no way voting me could go bad guys.

[alannalynn]

Before it was mainly a feel off of your posts, but this last one made me feel a lot better, I can see that you're actively casing and putting out what you think, which is nice. I've been a little distracted with the Mass Effect game, but I can definitely put more effort in here and I apologize.

 

I actually get you Sooh and Hallia mixed up a lot and my notes are reflecting that, because I just noticed something in my notes on you that weren't for you. *d'oh*

 

I'm happy with where my vote is on Sooh now that I've cleared up my head. Hallia has also been sliding down my list, but I'm not quite getting the same feel from her that I did in Middle Earth where I was literally the only person that called her out as mafia, so idk.

[Aiel Heart]

"Prob" is a very strong word. Possibly, but certainly not acting like it, and definitely not doing town any good if you are. So if you are town and especially if you end up leading a mislynch on me, please do grow up and help town win. 

 

 

 

I tend to seem scummy to people. That's just one of the factors of me playing. It usually keeps me from being nightkilled because the mafia tries to push me, so if I die look hard at what lead to it. Some of them will be just honestly mistaken but others are going to be taking advantage of how scummy tend to seem in games. Might be worth me reading into tonight just to see what I can unearth...

 

 

 

Oh and Laine just saw your post and thank you for it. 

[Aiel Heart]

*Some of [those voting me] will just honestly be mistaken but others are going to be taking advantage of how scummy I tend to seem in games

[Aiel Heart]

Oh and that first part was addressed at Darthe, just in case that wasn't clear

[Shad_]

but if sooh is a general consensus then maybe we should lynch her first, i dunno =/

If we're already approaching a general consensus this round will not be very productive.

 

[unvote]

 

On my phone, too tedious to say much atm

[Aiel Heart]

It's been a short time period, but I feel like a lot has been said so it could be quite productive still. 

 

Are you unvoting purely for that reason?

[alannalynn]

Shad what?

[Sili Quirrels]

The reality is darthe has very little content. To read him I need to build a character read, but I don't know darthe that well so I waffle all the time.

[Clovdyx]

Vote Count
 
Sooh (2) - Talya, alannalynn
Hallia (2) - Notbob, Aiel Heart
Heart (2) - Darthe, Sili Quirrels

 
With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

[Sili Quirrels]

 

but if sooh is a general consensus then maybe we should lynch her first, i dunno =/

If we're already approaching a general consensus this round will not be very productive.

 

[unvote]

 

On my phone, too tedious to say much atm

 

I really don't know if sooh is.

 

Just seems that way at a glance.

 

I think we have a poe issue.

 

Only viable candidates for most are hallia, sooh, and AH.

[alannalynn]

 

 

but if sooh is a general consensus then maybe we should lynch her first, i dunno =/

If we're already approaching a general consensus this round will not be very productive.

 

[unvote]

 

On my phone, too tedious to say much atm

 

I really don't know if sooh is.

 

Just seems that way at a glance.

 

I think we have a poe issue.

 

Only viable candidates for most are hallia, sooh, and AH.

 

What do you mean by issue? Do you want to go outside of these three?

[Sili Quirrels]

I dont knpw