A Tale of Middle Earth: Game OVER

[Clovdyx]

 

Official Vote Count Two:

 

Hallia (2/9): Yates, TinaHel

TinaHel (1/9): Eternal Phoenix

Laine (1/9): Leelou

Dicetosser1 (1/9): Sooh

Sooh (2/9): Dicetosser1, Hallia

Taborline (3/9): AndreJ, Thane, Eternal Phoenix

Eternal Phoenix (1/9): Pizza

 

Not Voting (7/17):

, Aiel Heart, Krak, Taborline, Alannalynn, Seph, Cass, Talya

 

With 17 alive it takes 9 to lynch.  Deadline is at 12:15 PM on May 19th, 2015.

 

[Hallia]

That was mostly Yates 1.0 and you know it. We want to hear from 2.0 as it is a separate entity.

 

Talya - I never said I was BP? Not sure why you'd throw that in there.

[Yates]

That was mostly Yates 1.0 and you know it.

Was it? Go count.

[Leelou]

 

That was mostly Yates 1.0 and you know it.

Was it? Go count.

 

 

You are posting, but a bit of it was just saying that you were going to slack off and do nothing. You picked up more once day was ending and the Gladiator challenge started. Who do you have as scum though? I can't remember off the top of my head. 

[Yates]

Well, I'm voting for Hallia. For the third consecutive day...

[Leelou]

That's one person. Anyone else? 

[Askthepizzaguy]

Yates McFadden, you're nowhere near my radar in terms of scummitude.

 

That being said, could use your help here, buddy.

[Yates]

I can't express strongly enough how confident I am in a Hally lynch.

[Yates]

Someone made a post recently about chasing two hares? Hally is my bunny.

[Yates]

Also, I don't buy into this nonsense that I need to have 6 scum reads. I need to have precisely one. At a time. The dominoes fall from there.

[Leelou]

Also, I don't buy into this nonsense that I need to have 6 scum reads. I need to have precisely one. At a time. The dominoes fall from there.

 

I never said you needed 6, some more of who you are thinking besides Hallia would be nice. 

[Hallia]

Methinks he's afraid to give out more.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Thane 70

Krak 31

 

Sooh 79

Alannalynn 72

seph 88

Yates 322

 

TinaHel 51

Leelou 248

Dice 29

Andrej 212

 

Cass 70

Aiel Heart 16

 

Hallia 80

Taborline 20

Talya 70

 

Alotta Phoenix 193 <-----------Howling so loudly that it would wreck your eardrums

[Askthepizzaguy]

Hint: He'd be getting more votes right now if he were a villager.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Yates. 322 Leelou 248 Verbal32 216 Andrej 212 Sili Quirrels 204 Eternal Phoenix 193 Askthepizzaguy 160 Eldrick4221 146 Darthe 92 seph 88 Hallia 80 Sooh 79 alannalynn 72 Cass 70 Thane Vakarian 70 Talya 70 TinaHel 51 Alot 45 Zander 37 Songstress 36 manbat 33 Krakalakachkn 31 dicetosser1 29 Clovdyx 25 Taborline 20 Aiel Heart 16

 

 

We really need to hear a lot more from Krak, Dice, Taborline, and Heart.

 

 

Numbers lazily stolen from this post

[Andrej]

 

 

 

I am sure, now that you mention it!  

 

And I'll go back to

 

Vote: Thane

 

I think I was right here, unless I see something that changes it.

 

All this does is make people look at Hallia with hairy eyeballs. It makes little sense given what has gone down so far this game.

 

This is the sort of thing villagers tend to do.

 

 

Ugh.  Catching up I forgot he was cleared through Pizza. >.<

 

The general lack of any real posting besides sniping.

 

Gonna have to really read through again.

 

 

Follows the same thought pattern, doesn't feel staged. Like, oh shoot! I forgot he was cleared, vote Somebody.

 

This reads true.

 

In post 2542 EP points out she didn't unvote.

 

I think that's actually slightly clearing for her.

 

 

I didn't realize I'd played that many games with you EP

 

Are you worried there's going to be a sudden train on him then, that you're so worried I didn't immediately unvote?

 

 

I like this reaction to EP's question.

 

 

nope I'm just noting that you say he's been cleared and yet you leave your vote on him, very untown-like thought process

 

 

Bull.

 

 

well if you consider I want to be rid of the exact same people as EP 1.0 that should tell you both something

 

 

Yes, it tells me you replaced in as a wolf.

 

That nothing changed seems to indicate that you are frozen in place. Villagers' reads should be dynamic, wolves' tend to be frozen.

 

It indicates you think you can cling on to your villager self from another role and blur the two together.

 

They are not the same, and Alot was a wolf alot of the time.

 

 

 

 

Vote: Eternal Phoenix

 

 

@ Andrej- would you vote to lynch Alotta Phoenix, or is that never on your radar today?

 

EP definitely isn't a bad vote right now. My POE places him as a potential wolf and at this point I am okay with voting just about anyone in the bottom half. His vote on Hallia looks bad and Alot was a player that I had noted I needed to look at again after some of the things he did D2. The Leelou vote/unvote was weird to me, as I remember.

 

A wolf needs to lynched today, period. I don't care who or what team, or whatever but a scum dies today.

 

At this point the wolves might be glad to get rid of other wolves. Since there were a lot of people reading Andrej as scum, why wasn't he murdered?

 

There's basically no interest in lynching him either. Where did that go?

 

If the wolf teams believed he might be a wolf on the opposing team, they could get villagery credits for lynching Andrej while removing a rival.

 

Why would a wolf team not vote for someone who looks wolfy to people? Especially since wolves will have a much easier time solving for other wolves than basic villagers should.

 

I get why you don't murder Andrej, kinda. He could be lynchable.

 

But then not lynching him? Just feels strange to me.

 

I think the wolves would be pushing their top suspects for opposing wolves today. Andrej isn't even on the radar.

 

Wolves are scared to come at me, obviously

 

It's right along the lines of what I was saying revolving around you and Verb during the thunder dome. Thoughts and feelings are being floated out there for why/how I am scum (just like they were for you being scum) but when it comes down to supporting it with their vote that's essentially outing and thus avoided.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Agreed. You're not cleared-cleared, I was saying that to twist the screws a bit on Alot/EP, but at the same time I believe your wolf prob dropped significantly.

[Andrej]

Yates elaborate on Hallia please.

[Andrej]

The way her wagon got to 4 makes me think one section of scum were confident thinking she looked scummy enough to potentially be a rival.

 

The claim throws a wrench in this and now I have to decide whether she's a townie that looks scummy enough to be considered a rival from one faction of wolves or lying to save her skin atm.

 

Yates - I think I may be smelling what you're stepping in but I need you to expound a little?

[Andrej]

People that were on the wagon that look worst are EP and Tina right now. I have a growing sense of dread that Tina is a wolf and is starting to play from the shadows, which is something I have seen her do before as scum in late game.

 

This is all pending Yates and his feedback, but unless he has something solid I don't think I'll be lynching Hallia today.

[Leelou]

People that were on the wagon that look worst are EP and Tina right now. I have a growing sense of dread that Tina is a wolf and is starting to play from the shadows, which is something I have seen her do before as scum in late game.

 

This is all pending Yates and his feedback, but unless he has something solid I don't think I'll be lynching Hallia today.

 

I'm pretty sure Tina is scum. 

[Andrej]

I could get behind a Tina lynch but I also don't want to let Taborline off the hook. She's too much of a liability at this point to continue dragging along without some kind of check on her (like with Krak who is also dead weight)

 

It's almost like shooting fish in a barrel. So long as we can steer away from the scummy looking villagers we have an extremely high % of lynching a wolf.

 

One red flip likely cracks this game wide open.

[Askthepizzaguy]

Taborline is a female?

 

Not game relevant but I do strongly prefer to address and refer to people with the proper pronouns.

[Hallia]

I would consider switching off of Sooh to Tabor if she doesn't respond soon. Having nothing to go off of is frustrating, but Sooh's response really makes me want to stay here

[seph]

Aj if you think the wagon is scummy doesn't that mean you think she is telling the truth on the bodyguard role? The role is the only thing holding me back currently, I am not sure if I believe it.

 

Also question on a role. Leelou X2 vote is always a town role?

 

 

I felt like ep was frustrated townie as well there. He could just be playing the sympothy card. I personally have never had this used against me by a wolf, but have heard about it, or seen people accuse townies of using it.

 

Leelou why do you say tina? She is one I want to look over, I remember finding her explaining the vote suspicious because she said

" I probably did this"

As if she wasn't sure in herself.

 

 

On tab she posts, just nothing with content that I can remember.