A Tale of Middle Earth: Game OVER

[Sooh]

My reads as of now: 

 

Tina

EP

Thane

Hallia

AJ

Krak

Eldrick

 

Yates 2.0

Pizza

Batass

Leelou

 

Taborline

Alot

 

Talya

Laine

Seph

Dice

 

 

 

Blue are my town reads for now. Green are my "more town than not" list. Black are nulls and red are scum. 

 

I know there are wrong reads in there, because my scum pile is too small, but that's where I stand right now.

[Eldrick4221]

 

I know I'm not the target of your discussion, but did you get any other information from your peeks, or was it just alignment?

 

Its entirely possible I got their roles and not their alignment and extrapolated from there.

 

I wouldn't discuss it with pending night actions, however.

 

Why not? They are already targets, and you may not be around to provide whatever other information you have. I thought that was the point of your question.

[Eldrick4221]

Okie, I'm liking hearing this. If you're planning to go back and ISO can you give me your thoughts on Talya or Hallia? I want to hear some definitive opinions that you're not gonna back away from

 

No prob. Talya first.

 

Her Day 1 game didn't have anything worthwhile. I didn't get a town vibe or a scum vibe from any of it.

 

Night 1 was her line about losing Yates

 

A quick catch up. Shame we have lost a good role.

 

As I mentioned then, this kind of line I attribute with mafia trying to sound town.

 

Now that I've looked more at the interactions between AJ and Talya, it's starting to feel like they are mafia together, which is weird because I had AJ pegged as town. If Talya is mafia, I'm willing to bet AJ is too.

 

I didn't see anything villagery D1 From Talya, but AJ did. Talya didn't like that he wasn't comfortable with someone being this confident about her. It reads as distancing to me.

 

Then Talya builds a case against AJ on D2. Maybe this is because of what happened between AJ and Yates on D1. I don't know.

 

I'm also not happy with the level of content Talya has provided. It's Night 2, and she only has 3 pages of posts.

 

All things considered, slight scum read on Talya

 

[Eldrick4221]

Hally

 

Most of Day 1 went by with no contributions. Some welcomes and liking posts, but nothing of substance.

She voted Yates because his multiquotes felt like backtracking, then followed Verb off the train.

 

Day 2 she points out that Sooh has a scum read and an anti-town read, and that she voted the anti-town. Votes Sooh for this reason.

 

Yates said he got a guilty vote on one of Hally or Thane. Hally switches to Thane. (This makes sense, from her perspective)

 

I would like to hear more from her, but not finding anything scummy. Keeping Hally in null for now.

[Eldrick4221]

For the record, if Yates and Pizza are both telling the truth about their peeks, that makes Hally scum.

 

Pizza checks Thane and Krak, and get town from both (or extrapolates they are town from his result)

 

Yates checks Thane and Hally and gets 1 maf and 1 town.

 

Being Thane is the common element here, that would put Hally as the scum read.

 

I don't believe Yates, though. He could be telling the truth, but I have learned to not believe his claims.

[Sooh]

Hally

 

Most of Day 1 went by with no contributions. Some welcomes and liking posts, but nothing of substance.

She voted Yates because his multiquotes felt like backtracking, then followed Verb off the train.

 

Day 2 she points out that Sooh has a scum read and an anti-town read, and that she voted the anti-town. Votes Sooh for this reason.

 

Yates said he got a guilty vote on one of Hally or Thane. Hally switches to Thane. (This makes sense, from her perspective)

 

I would like to hear more from her, but not finding anything scummy. Keeping Hally in null for now.

The person with the scum read and the anti-town read was not me. That comment was made to Krak after this post:

 

 

My reads from before the Yates lynch:

 

 

AJ is anti-town.

 

Sili is villager

 

Sooh is a scum

 

EP is scum lean

 

 

 

 

I haven't seen too much to change my mind since then. I need to reread the pages leading up to the lynch, but I'm happy to run train on those three.

 

 

As far as general thoughts on the game thus far:

 

 

Not comfortable with getting off the fence regarding Verb and Leelou. If pushed I would probably fall off with Leelou scum and Verb town but atm it's pretty much a toss-up imo.

 

I'm alright with Pizza for the moment.

 

I like Cass as town.

 

 

I assumed she voted me because I asked for VC before the Day was ended early.

[Eldrick4221]

You're right. I read that wrong. It reads differently out of context

 

#ISOProblems

[Leelou]

EP, you frustrate me. 

[Yates]

EP, you frustrate me.

 

 

Sexually.

 

[Yates]

Someone turn on the lights in this joint. Let it be day time already...

[Leelou]

EP, you frustrate me.

 

 

Sexually.

 

 

EP, you should ask Yates if he's wearing pants. 

[Yates]

Hint: If it's before 7 AM, past 7 PM, or the weekend? I'm not.

[Leelou]

I have to go clean my house. Hopefully it's day by the time I'm done. 

[Talya]

@Eld, I can't post more, during the week I can get on in the evening, which means by the time I have caught up I don't have much time left. I try to catch up on my phone at work, which is very difficult, if I get caught I'm in serious trouble...Plus I have an exam in two weeks and I have a teenage daughter to keep in control, plus housework etc...so lack of posts is a null.

[Alot]

This may sound weird, but I am kind of weirded out by people that still have me as null.  I'd have myself in a scum lean right now.  I've only been up to date enough to be part of active conversations at like 2 points in the game, and I've skimmed most of this game just to keep up, including the last 15 pages. 

[Thane Vakarian]

so, is it day already?

[Clovdyx]

Can't write scene till letter because moving is taking too long so sori about that.

 

Verbal- Beorn - town 2x gladiator has been bested in the arena. It is now night, you have 18 hours.

This has passed. It is now limbobphase until a writeup appears.

[Thane Vakarian]

ok... limbo.... even worse than night....

[Darthe]

Totally passed out, sorry guys.  

 

Scene incoming.

[Yates]

Totally passed out, sorry guys.  

 

Scene incoming.

Hate you. Yates games don't have these kinds of shenanigans and delays.

[Darthe]

The night was dark and full of terrors.  It was also long, at least too long for most to be comfortable with.  One Man, a man of Rohan in particular, had some very choice words to say about the choice of camp-sight that night because he didn't see the honor in bedding down at the edge of a bramble.  Twice now he had rolled in his sleep and pricked himself, this time in a huff because of a piece that had fallen inside his chainmail and sent him hopping about trying to get it off.  The elves found that quite funny and everyone seemed in a fairly merry mood but the truth of the matter was that they were all ignoring the truth.  Whenever sleep came, whenever the fires grew dim, darkness would truly follow and in that darkness would come peril.

 

That image, of a potentially tipsy elf laughing a lilting mirthy laugh at a Warlord with no decorum, was the last you recall before sleep took you over.  Morning was like waking from a bad dream.  

 

The first thing you saw when you woke was the laughing elf, sprawled out on the ground near the fire, his throat cut nearly to his spine.  His lifeless eyes were looking right at you.  It took a moment to realize that this wound was fresh.  He wasn't quite dead.  You sprung up to rush to him when suddenly you felt a chill.  The Elf rose his hand with a final act and pointed directly behind you.  Everything seemed to slow.  His hand fell, life faded in that final moment of energy.  You began to turn to your left slowly.  Too slowly.  An ember cracked in the fire and wisped out into the wind where it began to cut a short ringlet in midair.  The pines, still soft with morning dew, bristled.  With every moment your panic grew until you saw it.  A blade cutting the wind with a soft whine, directing itself at your own head, and you knew you would never see it's wielder.  

 

What a pretty place to die.  

 

When the others woke they found the bodies of:

 

Eternal Phoenix: Finwe, Town Mason Killed Night Two

 

and

 

Eldrick: Tar Atanamir, Town Vanilla Killed Night Two

 

 

 

IT IS NOW DAY THREE.  WITH 17 ALIVE IT TAKES 9 TO LYNCH.  YOU HAVE 48 HOURS.

 

Somewhere, up in the skies of the great beyond, Eru sang a song that seemed to question if the forces of evil were aware that they were supposed to not like one another.

[Yates]

Really? EP? What a dumb kill. You should feel ashamed of yourself.

[Yates]

[v]Hally[/v]

[Thane Vakarian]

17 players left.... how many wolves... 6? 7?

[Thane Vakarian]

it troubles me that no wolf has been found and killed yet.