A Tale of Middle Earth: Game OVER

[Darthe]

As punishment I am suspending him for four games, taking away his first and fourth scum pick and fining him 1,000,000 quid.

[Leelou]

As punishment I am suspending him for four games, taking away his first and fourth scum pick and fining him 1,000,000 quid.

 

Heh. At least you still have more proof than possibly and most likely. 

[Gabriel Kross]

can you make it uld? because everyone loves sword art online

[Darthe]

 

As punishment I am suspending him for four games, taking away his first and fourth scum pick and fining him 1,000,000 quid.

 

Heh. At least you still have more proof than possibly and most likely. 

 

Red2111 is that you?

[Gabriel Kross]

 

 

As punishment I am suspending him for four games, taking away his first and fourth scum pick and fining him 1,000,000 quid.

 

Heh. At least you still have more proof than possibly and most likely. 

 

Red2111 is that you?

 

lol

[Leelou]

 

 

As punishment I am suspending him for four games, taking away his first and fourth scum pick and fining him 1,000,000 quid.

 

Heh. At least you still have more proof than possibly and most likely. 

 

Red2111 is that you?

 

 

Did you not see the report? 

[Darthe]

can you make it uld? because everyone loves sword art online

I can make it gil #2007scape

[Sili Quirrels]

-_-

[Sooh]

I shall be back after work tomorrow to continue my hunt! See you all then!

[Gabriel Kross]

 

can you make it uld? because everyone loves sword art online

I can make it gil #2007scape

 

we shall rename this game Final Fantasy Middle Earth Mafia

[Clovdyx]

 

As punishment I am suspending him for four games, taking away his first and fourth scum pick and fining him 1,000,000 quid.

 

Heh. At least you still have more proof than possibly and most likely. 

 

 

My laptop now has a hole in it.  Thanks for that, you two.

[Yates]

Okay, so here are the chain.

Tina. Wow. That was a perfectly laid out and well articulated case. Respect.

 

What I particularly liked about that case is that it not only gave me HUGE Town vibes on you but also moved Sili up a couple of notches in my book for how he handled the situation; which I hadn't really noticed until it was laid out like this.

 

Stellar work.

[Yates]

 

@Tina, lets just leave it at I have a good feeling.

 

Oh, the good feeling argument again. 

 

He's obviously hinting at something along the lines of masons. I'd keep my eye on it but let it go for now.

[Yates]

and zander I took sooh's first two votes jokingly. I found her yates vote to be her first real stance.

Agree.

[Gabriel Kross]

 

 

@Tina, lets just leave it at I have a good feeling.

 

Oh, the good feeling argument again. 

 

He's obviously hinting at something along the lines of masons. I'd keep my eye on it but let it go for now.

 

a good town thing to do if that is the read you got is to not say it blatantly.

[Yates]

Why do you think you and man bat viewed the post differently?

Different meta?

Different process?

Different experience?

Different perspectives?

Different alignments/roles?

 

Pick one. Or several.

[Yates]

a good town thing to do if that is the read you got is to not say it blatantly.

Don't see the sense in beating around the bush. It's not like you are being subtle about it. And if I'm scum I feel like I'd just chat up my scum bros in our QT rather than post that info here, yeah?

[Yates]

Sili has been vote jumping all game, and while he claims to wield it like a sword. It can be double edged.

I see it as him casting suspicion on multiple people, trying to keep the votes spread out.

He is my top suspect. [unvote] [v]sili [/v]

Seems an odd reason to vote someone. How is that any different from how a cop would approach the game to try to find the best investigation target at night or a vig might go about identifying a target for his NA?

 

To me it looks like game solving. And that's the opposite of the conclusion you came to. Why do you think that is?

[Yates]

Weird. These are my words in post 668:

Seems an odd reason to vote someone. How is that any different from how a cop would approach the game to try to find the best investigation target at night or a vig might go about identifying a target for his NA?

 

To me it looks like game solving. And that's the opposite of the conclusion you came to. Why do you think that is?

[Yates]

 

 

As punishment I am suspending him for four games, taking away his first and fourth scum pick and fining him 1,000,000 quid.

 

Heh. At least you still have more proof than possibly and most likely.

 

 

My laptop now has a hole in it.  Thanks for that, you two.

 

I loled. That ruling was absolutely fair. I'm sure it will be reduced after a challenge but good on Goodell for levying a fair punishment out of the gate.

 

I think the funniest part is that the Pats will almost certainly have a much higher pick next year since they are very unlikely to repeat. So that's what you get for postponing the release of the report until after the draft...

[Yates]

I'm lonely.

 

I'd like to order a Pizza.

[Clovdyx]

 

 

 

As punishment I am suspending him for four games, taking away his first and fourth scum pick and fining him 1,000,000 quid.

 

Heh. At least you still have more proof than possibly and most likely.

 

 

My laptop now has a hole in it.  Thanks for that, you two.

 

I loled. That ruling was absolutely fair. I'm sure it will be reduced after a challenge but good on Goodell for levying a fair punishment out of the gate.

 

I think the funniest part is that the Pats will almost certainly have a much higher pick next year since they are very unlikely to repeat. So that's what you get for postponing the release of the report until after the draft...

 

 

It's not the least bit fair, and any objective fan knows that.

[seph]

Weird. These are my words in post 668:Seems an odd reason to vote someone. How is that any different from how a cop would approach the game to try to find the best investigation target at night or a vig might go about identifying a target for his NA?To me it looks like game solving. And that's the opposite of the conclusion you came to. Why do you think that is?

I have never thought about viewing it from a cop perspective to be honest.

I don't think a vig would vote jump like that, as they are not going to want that attention on them.

 

That was my point yates it could be taken both ways. I feet early on he was game solving.

Then he felt the need to tell us he was wielding it that way for a reason.

I didn't really understand his reasoning for jumping on ep. I agree with ep it was weird for him to answer aq post directed a pizza.

I remember EP saying silli unvote looked natural, but I don't even recall that he gave a reason.

[seph]

 

When I was posting with ep he was my most suspicious suspect, after arguing I re read everything and there was points I missed. My goal was to see how ep would react here, and see if he would get more involved.

I think he has been making good posts since then, for the most part anyways. And his interaction with Sili made him seem more towny to me,i tried to see what Sili was talking about. But I could not. it makes me more suspicious of sili.

He defends pizza two or three times, one of which, he answered a post for pizza.

Sili has been vote jumping all game, and while he claims to wield it like a sword. It can be double edged.

I see it as him casting suspicion on multiple people, trying to keep the votes spread out.

 

 

I'm going to be blunt. I don't think you know what a villager is or what they're supposed to do day 1.

Maybe we just have a different way to go about things. With my few games of experience I have never seen anyone hunt like that.

The first time I found vote jumping like this suspicious was in my first game with turin

I believed him though, and he turned scum as they steam rolled that game. So please don't accuse me of not knowing anything.

[Yates]

I agree with ep it was weird for him to answer aq post directed a pizza.

Which reminds me, I have an opinion to offer up that I haven't followed up on yet...

 

WRT Sili responding to a question directed at Pizza? Yeah. I get that. It annoys me when people do that stuff. But it isn't necessarily scummy, either. This is Pizza's first game here and I think Sili felt like he had *some* meta knowledge on Pizza to offer up. He's done it before and will likely do it again. This is my take anyway. But I'm Town reading Sili pretty hard right now so take it for what it's worth...