A Tale of Middle Earth: Game OVER

Andrej · May 11, 2015

I think there's been enough to have some sort of read on a good majority of the players.
Probably not the majority of the players. Unless, of course, you can read 1/3 of the players here in 5 posts or less.

Meh. It feels like a lot of people have been talking but then again with a roster of this size even half of it can still be considered a lot of voices.

Lemme correct myself: I think there's enough content to get some kind of read on the more vocal players at this point.

Verbal32 · May 11, 2015

Who is Corn?

Zander? · May 11, 2015

Cory's kind of a tool :(

nah Cory's cool! "haters gonna hate"

Darthe · May 11, 2015

I believe we are missing one person but I am not sure who it is.

Darthe · May 11, 2015

Who is Corn?

CornCurrnel

Sooh · May 11, 2015

My horrible mentor and I do not negotiate with terrorists.
Also, if you are somehow Town, tell Corn there's a madness to my method. I know what he thinks he knows. But he is mistaken. And I'm specifically using his one "reliable" tell on me to discern the alignment of a specific player. This should make a TON of sense if he knows what I'm talking about.

Cory can barely contain himself and says you made his day.

Leelou · May 11, 2015

So I'm up to post 280 and I have to say you DM'ers are too damn noisy and your quotes are ugly as hell. I'll continue trying to catch up at work, but I'd greatly appreciate it if you all would SHUT UP FOR A FEW HOURS.

That's 279 more posts that I read for that point in the game. You have.......wait for it..........alot of reading to do. :-)

I'm reading the end of his post as a challenge. Is it a challenge?

It might be. I'm down.

I've got 5 minutes. Ready?

Sooh · May 11, 2015

Who is Corn?

Apparently it's Darthe's loving nickname for Cory...

Yates · May 11, 2015

Cory can barely contain himself and says you made his day.

That was fast. I will reveal in thread later if it becomes pertinent. As you guys can see - if you've figured it out - the results are kind of meh right now.

Clovdyx · May 11, 2015

EBWOP: Cory GOAT. <3 <3 :wub: :wub:

Hallia · May 11, 2015

I thought I would have a nice quiet day at work and be able to play on mobile - I was so so wrong. WHO IS FEEDING SMACK TO THESE CAREGIVERS?!

v.v catchin up when I get home

Sili Quirrels · May 11, 2015

@Tina - how did you make that sort of mistake?

I feel like if you felt Sili's post was compelling enough to basically sheep you would've quoted the correct one. Now it appears to me that you just grabbed a random quote with someone voting another person (one of the main wagons atm, mind you) as a clean and easy way to hop on without adding any of your own input.

Yes, and also I feel like I made much better posts on Zanders than the ones she quoted.

the speed with which you people keep posting, i'll never get caught up in this game

You haven't said anything about the game yet.

the speed with which you people keep posting, i'll never get caught up in this game

^ This.

Where you at Cass?

My point being is that zander lynch seems like it probably has mafia behind it regardless of his alignment and I think he's prolly lynchbait

Also zander I love that song <3

Who are the scum iyo? I am contemplating voting Tina right now but I'm willing to at least hear her out first.
Idk if you've played with me lately but I've kind of adapted into this style where I read the flow of the thread surrounding lynch wagons and then try and figure out which wagons are bad.

I have a more general "tthis is where a high concentration of scum are" approach as opposed to a "this specific person is wolfy"

It gets me heat a lot but it works for mw

Yeah, I think it's been a few months since we played last. The last time might've been the Space Balls game?

And okay. Fwiw I think you're probably right about Zander being lynchbait.

Aj do you think its more likely:

a) i am mafia

b) im being misread

c) or being setup by wolves

Bro, you need to start commenting on the game and exploring your read of Sooh.

So I'm up to post 280 and I have to say you DM'ers are too damn noisy and your quotes are ugly as hell. I'll continue trying to catch up at work, but I'd greatly appreciate it if you all would SHUT UP FOR A FEW HOURS.

Deal with it.

My horrible mentor and I do not negotiate with terrorists.
Also, if you are somehow Town, tell Corn there's a madness to my method. I know what he thinks he knows. But he is mistaken. And I'm specifically using his one "reliable" tell on me to discern the alignment of a specific player. This should make a TON of sense if he knows what I'm talking about.

You make bad reads? And that makes you town?

You've made at least one this game.

You told me my vote of EP was good, but not sure if genuine compliment.

alannalynn · May 11, 2015

I think all but Jon Snow has checked in..
"5 new replies" For serious?

@Dice, what do you mean by "clearer" when referring to Seph?

Well I can't sleep, so I might as well eat. Sleeping and eating, my two favorite hobbies.I am leaning voting for Zander, I have not done so because I see others have voted for him and I do not wish to create a runaway wagon which may harm discussion and relieve pressure on everyone else as well.If the game is multiball, as I understand the term, that means we have a large number of guilty parties.The discussion will, invariably, die if there are a large number of guilty parties and almost no reason for them to feel under pressure.What will happen next is easy smokescreening. It is more pro-village to keep the tally low.But for the record, Zander is my lynch choice today.Sooh seems villagery, only because I've spoken to her before the game.I have not a whole lot to read the rest of you based off of.If you would interact with me more, it would be helpful. Vote me, say why I'm guilty or not guilty, ask me questions, engage in a joke contest, anything.

Saying Zander is your lynch choice today implies that you intend to move your vote there. It doesn't add up with you calling it a runway train. You're just waiting for the right moment to put your vote on him, and that looks really bad. If you really do think he's scum, there is no reason to not put your vote on him.

I'm going to have to agree with Eldrick here on the Zander vote. I really don't see why, if you think somebody to be a good lynch, or scummy in the least, that you don't put a vote where your suspicion lies? I think it was Tina that said this is a big game and it's not like lynch trains will build that fast. I've always thought pressure got good reactions (from both the potential lynchee and the reactions surrounding).

FWIW I dont mind facing persection for that post. Sooh is one of the few players that I know and her quick and early vote changes was very unSoohlike to me. I didnt like. I dont like it hence my vote stands there. My job is to sort out Scum...its early and this is my read of her.

Thank you for the explanation, I'm starting to lean less scum on you, but I still don't see why a few vote changes warranted all that hassle? And you say you haven't played a lot of games, I feel like you're focusing a little too much on one target based on not much (she'd only had like 5 posts at that time).

For the record I'm somewhat suspicious of Eld, for a newish player he is doing a lot of speculatory talk on game setup, and that feels a bit off to me.

I think one of the previous games I was in with Eld he was running probabilities to find scum, Though there isn't much to go on at the moment for setup, unless he knows something we don't. As for EP's comment, why aren't you calling out others who were talking about game set up? That's what feels off to me.

Does this mean I need to read the last 19 pages?

The majority of it, dear. <3

It's what I'm doing now....(shoot me, please??)

Sorry.

[v]Seph[/v]

I hate when people just drop votes and don't give any explanation. Are you agreeing with what's already been said or did you see something new?

I'm leaning town for SIli, Andrej, null on EP, kinda scummy on Zander still. As for the rest, I'm unsure at the moment. I haven't played in a while so things are still coming back to me. I'll Unvote because I don't want my vote there.

Andrej · May 11, 2015

Cory can barely contain himself and says you made his day.
That was fast. I will reveal in thread later if it becomes pertinent. As you guys can see - if you've figured it out - the results are kind of meh right now.

You're kind of meh right now, bro.

alannalynn · May 11, 2015

Everybody but Tayla at this point, Verb.

Yes this too, Talya and Snow.

Cass · May 11, 2015

the speed with which you people keep posting, i'll never get caught up in this game

^ This.

Where you at Cass?

Currently p. 14, with half a miserable gut-reads/observations list and some 20ish tabs of quotes open and waiting to be looked into if they haven't already been addressed by the time I get to the end of the thread...

Have skimmed from p. 20ish though trying to keep up with current interactions, so if you've got specific q's throw 'em at me.

Sili Quirrels · May 11, 2015

the speed with which you people keep posting, i'll never get caught up in this game

^ This.

Where you at Cass?

Currently p. 14, with half a miserable gut-reads/observations list and some 20ish tabs of quotes open and waiting to be looked into if they haven't already been addressed by the time I get to the end of the thread...

Have skimmed from p. 20ish though trying to keep up with current interactions, so if you've got specific q's throw 'em at me.

Yeah.

Question 1. Is Yates scum?

Question 2. Is Dingus scum?

That's all for now.

Sili Quirrels · May 11, 2015

Hopefully you can answer these questions for me.

Gabriel Kross · May 11, 2015

For the record I'm somewhat suspicious of Eld, for a newish player he is doing a lot of speculatory talk on game setup, and that feels a bit off to me.

You just fos'd me for defending Pizza from Eldrick when you think Eldrick might be scum -_-

[v]Eternal[/v]

Go read my post again I didn't FoS you, I didn't even say I was suspicious of you. I said I noted your defense of pizza logic. My statement in and of itself was ambiguous and you fly out of left field saying I FoS'd you, so lets change that, I now FoS you for these shenanigans. You are on my short list congratulations.

There's a good chance EP is mafia after failing to connect his reads. First he approves of Eldrick's case on Pizza, expresses a desire for Pizza to respond in his own words, and doesn't like me defending Pizza, and then he says he's suspicious of Eldrick.

His read on me and Pizza, and his approval of Eldrick's case on Pizza is disharmonious with his scum read of Eldrick. He both has a town read of Eldrick, and a scum read of Eldrick. It can't be both, so he's faking his reads, and so I'm sticking my vote on EP over Zanders at eod.

Cheers.

I also didn't approve of Eldrick's case, I just wanted Pizza to speak for himself.

For the record I'm somewhat suspicious of Eld, for a newish player he is doing a lot of speculatory talk on game setup, and that feels a bit off to me.
You just fos'd me for defending Pizza from Eldrick when you think Eldrick might be scum -_-

[v]Eternal[/v]

This is a good vote.

not really read up.

For the record I'm somewhat suspicious of Eld, for a newish player he is doing a lot of speculatory talk on game setup, and that feels a bit off to me.

I think one of the previous games I was in with Eld he was running probabilities to find scum, Though there isn't much to go on at the moment for setup, unless he knows something we don't. As for EP's comment, why aren't you calling out others who were talking about game set up? That's what feels off to me.

Because my reason was more than just his speculation. The fact that he is new and is speculating this early is why my suspicion is there.

Taborline · May 11, 2015

I thought I would have a nice quiet day at work and be able to play on mobile - I was so so wrong. WHO IS FEEDING SMACK TO THESE CAREGIVERS?!

v.v catchin up when I get home

It's a lot to keep up with!

Andrej · May 11, 2015

Gun to my head I would say EP is probably a villager.

Darthe · May 11, 2015

Official Vote Count Five:

Pizza (1/13): Eldrick

Talya (1/13): Dice

EP (2/13): Seph, Sili

Sooh (2/13): Hallia, Zander

Seph (3/13): EP, Pizza, Leelou

Zander (1/13): Tina

Tina (1/13): AJ

Yates (1/13): Sooh

Not Voting (12/24):

Alot, Alanna, John Snow, Thane, Verbal, Talya, Krak, Taborline, Tress, Yates, Batassery, Laine

With 24 alive, it's 13 to lynch! Deadline is 12:15 AM EST on Wednesday, the 13th.

Gabriel Kross · May 11, 2015

I thought I would have a nice quiet day at work and be able to play on mobile - I was so so wrong. WHO IS FEEDING SMACK TO THESE CAREGIVERS?!

v.v catchin up when I get home

It's a lot to keep up with!

curious, of all the posts about catching up, why did you specifically respond to Hallia?

alannalynn · May 11, 2015

EP you didn't answer my question.

Taborline · May 11, 2015

I thought I would have a nice quiet day at work and be able to play on mobile - I was so so wrong. WHO IS FEEDING SMACK TO THESE CAREGIVERS?!

v.v catchin up when I get home

It's a lot to keep up with!

curious, of all the posts about catching up, why did you specifically respond to Hallia?

It was the first one on this page, which I just clicked onto.

A Tale of Middle Earth: Game OVER

Recommended Posts

Archived

Stay Connected

Forum Topics

News items

About Dragonmount

Twitter

Facebook