[Basic] Lolcats: zOMGby Apocalypse - Game Over - Town Win

[Niniel]

Yeh, it´s not likely in a basic game, just something that popped into my head. It´s unusual to not have any kills during night. I can see mafia not sending in a nk once but twice? I don´t think so. 

[Thane Vakarian]

so, people find it odd that i speak about mechanics and such, but... if there's a doc, and he/she is doing an awesome job, isn't it more likely to have a GF to balance the game?

[Thane Vakarian]

The reason i am going on about this is, if i remember correctly, a GF would show innocent..... which would have implications for Tina's viewing the rest of the game.

[Niniel]

There could be one but let´s not assume it. If we haven´t found mafia later on we can start thinking about it. 

[Niniel]

Thane, who are your suspects?

[Niniel]

Was going to iso Nyn and Verb but now we have no search function. :( Stupid pilot. 

[Niniel]

I´ve not read everyone´s posts but focused on Nyn/Verb. Then I have some random thoughts. 

 

#148 Verb questioning Sili why he had them as town but later had them as mafia.

#236 Nyn doesn´t trust Kaylee being helpful

#237 Nyn forgot to comment on Pral so adds that since he has no content he shouldn´t be on anyones townlist

#239 Ny says that Sili, Nolder and Leelou are town

#241 Nyn asks Thane and Pral to post more

#243 Nyn doesn´t like Dice´s push on Sili but says he could be town or mafia

#245 Nyn adds that Dice should know how Sili plays

#253 Nyn tells Kaylee that Sili/Nolders posts was a clear reacton test

#282 Verb has a town read on Sili but still wants to know what he asked for in #148

#289 Nyn wants Dice to give more reads

#299 Verb now understand Sili´s list

#332 Verb follows me thinking it´s strange that Lily doesn´t like fake claims

#336 Verb is on the fence about Kaylee´s helpfulness but thinks Sili, Dice, Nolder and Leelou are town.

#340 Verb says that I´m in the scum pile but more towards being townie

#362 Verb doesn´t like voting Pral for inactivity but rather vote Lily

#364 Verb votes Lily

#462 Nyn is iffy about Kaylee, Pral is null and then she posts her case on Thane

#490 Nyn votes Thane (early D2)

#521 Verb agrees with Nyn about Thane

#562 Nyn claims doc

 

 

This is of course not all of their posts but most of the ones that are game related. I have learned not to look too deep into mafia posts because bussing is possible. But I think I want to clear Thane considering Nyn´s tunelling and Verb agreeing with him. If anyone else wants to analyse it in a different way then go ahead.

 

 

Random thoughts:

 

Dice just followed Nyn´s case on Thane, which looked really scummy. But he unvoted when Thane was at L-2. Town or pretending to be? I don´t get why he is voting Leelou today without any explanation. I´m not sure why he abandoned Sili.

 

I said that I would never vote Sili and I still think he is town but the thing about not believing me and doc fishing looked bad. I know that he is not a fan of bussing. 

 

I need to check out Kay/Tress, Leelou and Nolder and read Thane´s and Dice´s posts again. I will probably not be able to do this today, maybe tonight. I´d like to hear what everyone has to say. 

[Leelou]

Today is going to be really busy for me, I'm going on vacation tomorrow and have a lot to get done in the office. I'll try to pop on during lunch and read some.

 

Dice, any particular reason?

[Pralaya]

So, Verb/Nyn had two major positions this game:

 

The first one was on the Sili/Dice argument. Both Nyn and Verb found both SIli and Dice town, even though they had some bad vibes from Dice. That was weird stance to take which could be because they wanted to take townie points from both of them during D1

 

The other big thing was the strong push against Thane starting from N1 and going all the way the next day. As Sili said, this could be a big distancing effort but I doubt they would be going so hard so early, especially with no deaths on D1. Feeling Thane is town here.

[Pralaya]

So, I'm still feeling iffy about Kaylee.  Waiting to see what Tress bring to the table.  Pral's case on Lily was good, imo, even if ultimately he was wrong. Still nullish because he needs to post more, but he's leaning more towards my townie pile. Looking forward to see his overall reads to form a more solid read on him. 

 

As far as Lily goes, she did look shady imo. Kinda hard to tell with her when she's actually scum or when she makes weird choices as a townie. 

 

 

What I have noticed and kinda bugs me is some of Thane's posts where I feel he's abusing his tendency to get mislynched. This puts me in a bit of a weird position where I actually have to agree with Sili lol  I'll pull up the quotes to demonstrate what I mean.

 

 

 

That's fine - I'm more interested in her response to what I mentioned above, though.

 

What about Kaylee?  I'm on the fence about whether her "helpfulness" with the N0 rules was honestly trying to correct, or going for town cred.

 

 

My 2 top town reads are Sili and Dice, honorable mention to Nolder.  Light town on you (Leelou) and the rest form my suspect pile.

 

One thing interesting I noted in both their posts was talking about Kaylee abruptly in the middle of their conversations. Maybe it is a confirmation bias, because I had Kaylee in my scum list, but I think they were distancing each other quite early. 

[Pralaya]

 

 

 

 

 

Deadline: Friday 2/6 12pm (Noon) CST 1HR from this post or when someone has 6+ votes

 

Vote Count

 

Dice (1/10): Tina

Lily (5/10): Pral, Kaytress, Leelou, Verboobra, Thane

Sili (1/10): dice

Pral (1/10): Nol

Thane (1/10): Sili

 

No Lynch(1/10): Lily

Lily, an innocent kitteh just tryin to make it in dis wurld has been lunched

 

its nao night. night ends Monday @11am CST or when i get all NA's

So, yeah, today's lynch has to be one of the 5 on Lily's wagon. Pretty much at least a scum is in there.

 

Out of all the votes, Kaylee's vote looks out of place for me.

 

 

Out of the three trains I don't want to vote for Sili as I feel he's likely town. I'll try ISO Lily and Dice. I feel Dice's orignal case was genuine but I'll have to look at his other posts. I know Lily started out just agreeing with Dice.

Out of Dice and Lily I'll vote Lily. Dice is typically quiet and lurking as scum. So far this game he's gone after Sili and continued it even though it's not the popular thought. Reading his posts in ISO makes it really seem he believes Sili is scum. Tunneling a bit but he seems to believe it.

These two posts looks a bit forced to me. First, why would she want to "chose" from the three trains? Second, it was more of an elimination process that she voted Lily. At least, didn;t look like she believed Lily was scum, or did she?

Wasn't sure on Lily and if you look at time stamps it was close to deadline and I didn't want a random.

 

 

Well, when you commented about "chosing", all the three trains had like 1 or 2 votes each, even though it was like 3 hrs from the deadline. So, it didn't mean you had to restrict your choices to the three trains. That is what it looked a bit forced to me.

[Kaylee]

It was close to deadline and I wasn't sure if I'd be around. Just that simple. I had said before that I had no strong scum leans, none really because I had too many I wasn't sure about. So no starting a new train wasn't going to happen.

[Red2111]

Deadline -  Thurs Feb 12 @ 5pm CST or when someone has 5 votes

 

 

Vote Count

 

Thane (1/5): Sili

Leelou (1/5): Dice

 

 

No Lynch (6/8): Thane, Pral,Tina, Kaytress, Nol, Leelou

[Kaylee]

care to elaborate?

I'd also like to hear more on this.

[Nolder]

D1 Lynch: http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/92455-basic-lolcats-zomgby-apocalypse-day-3-deadline-212-5pm-cst/?p=3412088

 

N1 End: http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/92455-basic-lolcats-zomgby-apocalypse-day-3-deadline-212-5pm-cst/?p=3412746

 

D2 Lynch: http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/92455-basic-lolcats-zomgby-apocalypse-day-3-deadline-212-5pm-cst/?p=3413426

 

N2 End: http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/92455-basic-lolcats-zomgby-apocalypse-day-3-deadline-212-5pm-cst/?p=3413522

[Nolder]

So I was thrown off by Nyn/Verb being mafia and I've had to readjust my views.

Looking at the two lynch trains though I'm gonna conclude that Pral is the last mafia. If not then I think it's Sili.

If it isn't either of them then I'm having a bad game lol.

 

[v]Pral[/v]

[Sili Quirrels]

. Yo

[Sili Quirrels]

Pral so scummy always. Dunno. Better than voting me though.

[Kaylee]

Pral so scummy always. Dunno. Better than voting me though.

Statements like this make me rethink my town read of you.

[dicetosser1]

 

 

 

 

 

Dice just followed Nyn´s case on Thane, which looked really scummy. But he unvoted when Thane was at L-2. Town or pretending to be? I don´t get why he is voting Leelou today without any explanation. I´m not sure why he abandoned Sili.

 

 

 

actually Nyns case had nothing to do with it. I had already asked him what I didnt like about his catch up post but the vote came because of something he did just before.

 

 

Today is going to be really busy for me, I'm going on vacation tomorrow and have a lot to get done in the office. I'll try to pop on during lunch and read some.

 

Dice, any particular reason?

 

Why at the end of the day with a cop view were you the only person, besides theem of course to NOT be voting verb/nyn?

[Leelou]

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Dice just followed Nyn´s case on Thane, which looked really scummy. But he unvoted when Thane was at L-2. Town or pretending to be? I don´t get why he is voting Leelou today without any explanation. I´m not sure why he abandoned Sili.

 

 

actually Nyns case had nothing to do with it. I had already asked him what I didnt like about his catch up post but the vote came because of something he did just before.

 

Today is going to be really busy for me, I'm going on vacation tomorrow and have a lot to get done in the office. I'll try to pop on during lunch and read some.

 

Dice, any particular reason?

Why at the end of the day with a cop view were you the only person, besides theem of course to NOT be voting verb/nyn?

They were already lynched by the time I got to the thread.

[Leelou]

So I was thrown off by Nyn/Verb being mafia and I've had to readjust my views.

Looking at the two lynch trains though I'm gonna conclude that Pral is the last mafia. If not then I think it's Sili.

If it isn't either of them then I'm having a bad game lol.

 

[v]Pral[/v]

Thoughts on Kaylee?

[Pralaya]

So I was thrown off by Nyn/Verb being mafia and I've had to readjust my views.

Looking at the two lynch trains though I'm gonna conclude that Pral is the last mafia. If not then I think it's Sili.

If it isn't either of them then I'm having a bad game lol.

 

[v]Pral[/v]

Last mafia?

 

And yeah, you are having a bad game.

[Pralaya]

And, D1 is fine. ..You think I led the lynch on Lily.

 

But, how does D2 tell you anything about me?

[Niniel]

So I was thrown off by Nyn/Verb being mafia and I've had to readjust my views.

Looking at the two lynch trains though I'm gonna conclude that Pral is the last mafia. If not then I think it's Sili.

If it isn't either of them then I'm having a bad game lol.

 

[v]Pral[/v]

 

Reasons? Because he was the first one to vote Lily?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Dice just followed Nyn´s case on Thane, which looked really scummy. But he unvoted when Thane was at L-2. Town or pretending to be? I don´t get why he is voting Leelou today without any explanation. I´m not sure why he abandoned Sili.

 

 

 

actually Nyns case had nothing to do with it. I had already asked him what I didnt like about his catch up post but the vote came because of something he did just before.

 

 

Today is going to be really busy for me, I'm going on vacation tomorrow and have a lot to get done in the office. I'll try to pop on during lunch and read some.

 

Dice, any particular reason?

 

Why at the end of the day with a cop view were you the only person, besides theem of course to NOT be voting verb/nyn?

 

 

That is not a very good reason.