[Basic/Standard] A Wind in the Door Mafia - GAME OVER, TOWN WINS

[Cory Caboose]

[unvote]

[v]Lenlo[/v]

[jmm]

Welcome to the nuthouse, Lenlo!

[Songstress]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT:

Sili (1) - jmm
Tommy (2) - Sarmtosser, Tina
Sleeper (2) - Tommy, Manbat

Lenlo (1) - CorMish


Not voting (6): Lenlo, Sili, Err, Sleeper, Pral, HalliYates


With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

No deadline has been set at this time.

[Babar Hasan Khan]

 

 

Can you tell me what all of your names are on other sites - I get a bit confused.

 

 

I don´t the emo posts. I don´t know what to do with them. Is it:

 

1. Genuine feelings? If so, I don´t get what started it.

2. Some kind of game play/checking people´s reactions/setting traps etc? If so, I don´t find it to be an enjoyable gamestyle.

3. Trolling? If so, just stop.

 

I could absolutely follow Dice and Csarmi on Tommy. I´m still on Sili because he seams to play a bit cautious. I think that a Tommy lynch would give me some info about other players. 

 

I´m not sure about Manbat. Some of his posts look townie but I didn´t like that he stopped talking to me but turned to Cory to ask about me instead and then just agreed with him. I´m not sure about his oppinions about Tommy either. He seems to be on the fence about him. But as you can see, I´m on the fence about Manbat. 

You have a nice level of paranoia. I can understand it but you have some wacky reads.

 

fwiw we don't lynch for information. that is never happening here.

 

 

Sili unwilling to vote tommy. Noted

 

 

Tommy's play has been almost opposite to that of corry. He has spent most time throwing mud at others for being mafia (monstr, sili, salami, pral, corymish, pral) then giving town reads on anyone. then there is a fact of multiple claim roles (mafia/roleblocker then survior). He has been all over the place..... and all that in day one... pretty exiting for me :) i thought he was towny first trying to push people into speaking more and get more information. then i thought he was mafia after the role claim. and now back to town after the 2nd claim. i think this night things could be decided between him and the sleeper guy.

 

hang on. So tommy claims once and that makes him mafia to you but then he claims again    and a non town role again   and now suddenly you think he's town??? WTF??

 

 

Top tier observation: Err shouldn't be on a team with someone who knows Monstr's meta well

well i also found manbat a little scummy along with dice... but a little lower on the list

 

 

Right  im getting linked into monstr things because of earlier comments. So im addressing this now.

 

im sus on manbat for these reasons  and there is definitely tinfoiling involved

 

a) so far I have never seen him roll mafia and the odds are starting to wig me out.

 

b) he keeps getting cleared by people quick and early. yes those clears have been right but im not seeing HOW he gets cleared. It seems to be entirely meta from another site. thus i dont see it. For me monstr doesn't say much. they tend to be one liner type things that dont give me enuff to work him out. the post he made on  i think  the previous page  is one of the biggest posts i can remember seeing from him and its not exactly a WoT.

 

 

So basically it boils down to me being wary of manbat because I have no way of clearing him. If those who are his quick clearers are mafia with him and i just blindly take their word for it, then im gonna get steamrolled. So he is on my to watch list. im not saying he's scummy just that im watching him.

 

 

@2: yes is someone hard claims mafia, i am going to take it seriously..... at first i thought survivor was a towny role with some sort of day time inspection powers.... until wikied the role.... that is y now i am also back tracking on sleeper being mafia... i have not much to go on for him now.

 

@3: a bit defensive?? dont you think?? no one is linking you and monstr in the post you quoted, and in the reply you are also reiterating that monstr is very little scummy enough to keep an extra eye on him. so i dont know what you were trying to clarify.

[Babar Hasan Khan]

welcome lenlo

[Cory Caboose]

Your application for derpclear status has been processed and is...

 

 

approved.

 

[Sleeper Service]

Alright, I'm back from today's IRL stuff and I just read everything. I note that I have 2 votes from monstr - whom I already called a villager - and Tom, who knows he can't read me because he just cleared me and got owned by me on night 1 of a vanilla game on POG, etc. 

 

Also nice claim bro.

 

The crunkings were poor except for cory's really long one, which was an A-. I like that one.

 

Dice is totally village.

I've not been wrong on my D1 read on him ever.

So that's another one.

 

This read strikes me as WAY too hard WAY too early since dice had like 2 posts at this point, neither of which seemed particularly interesting or meaningful to me. On the other hand, I do like the body of work from csarmi. Would appreciate information regarding whether csarmi really has any reason to be springing hard villager reads on page 2 (literally, like post 25?) of the game. It's also not like dice's body of work is impressive AFTER this, either.

 

I following player have suspected others for  Villager or  Mafia  during the course of day 1

 

 1. dawnflower8 :

 2. jmm :
 3. Sili Quirrels : Csarmi, Manbat, Err
 4. CoryMish : Tina, Monstr, DiceCsarmi, Pral, Tina, DiceCsarmi,DiceCsarmi, Tommy, DiceCsarmi, Tina, DiceCsarmi,  Tommy, Cory, Tommy, jmm,  Tina,  Tina, DiceCsar, Monstr,  Tommy
 5. Err :
 6. Manbat :Cory, Sili, Cory, DiceCsarmi, Tommy,  Tommy, Tommy,
 7. Sleeper :
 8. DiceCsarmi : Pral,  Cory,  Tommy,
 9. Tommyrod : Monstr, Sili, Salami, Pral, CoryMish, Pral,  Pral,
10. Pralaya : Tina,
11. TinaHel : Sili,  Sili, DiceCsarmi
12. HalliaYates :

 

I'm pretty excited about your effort level but you have a lot of mistakes in here. I don't even remember for sure, but I KNOW that at this point I'd called monstr a villager and halli a villager. 

 

I remember the halli one because that was a mistake, TINA is the one I liked coming in FIRING SHATS. Halli didn't fire any SHATS, but I said Halli because lol new people. 

 

Anyway, both should be on there and I find it weird that they're not since I had like 8 posts at that point. Or 10 or something.

 

No it's not a mechanical thing, it's a "hoya is being mechanical" thing

 

This isn't possible, I haven't mentioned mechanics and only had 8-10 posts at this point as well. Basically just a lie that's easily proven to be a lie. Poor Tom. Poor.

[Sleeper Service]

monstr

 

Anyway I continue to have monstr as a villager because his longer analysis of Tom, even though it was wishy-washy with regard to result, was too deep and difficult to bother with for a wolf under no heat. This read will be valid for like two days, assuming he doesn't make any posts that suck. I'm allowed to recalibrate this, but for now I like monstr.

 

tina

 

Tina strikes me as a villager for the frequent voting / HAMness / engagement. Easy read.

 

csarmi + dice

 

I really want csarmi to be a villager because he's down to analyze posts and seems to be the MOST engaged in the game out of everyone. I note that I liked his posts in the POG game I just wrecked, so it was pleasant to kill him for being peeked in that game. For these same reasons, I'm looking forward to working with him. On TONE I like him as a villager as well, but he's comfortable here and not on POG, and he DOES sound different from that game. Just not wolfy.

 

That's a problem, then, because I think dice's posts are terrible and I kinda want to lynch him. They aren't analysis, they don't actually provide pressure, they kinda pop in out of nowhere. If I'm correct that csarmi is a two-way player, and he seems like that kind of guy, that makes me hate this hybrid because all he has to do is carry the weight while dice donks around being wolfy.

 

If dice was alone I'd probably be voting him right now, because his tone and contributions are unacceptable. 

 

sili

 

I dislike sili's tone in a lot of posts, but I refuse to vote him today because I can tell he's good and I don't know him well enough to get rid of him on tone. It's not his fault, in other words.

 

Still, though. 

 

Tom

 

The fake claim from one of the worst role claimers on the planet is a fun twist I guess, but when coupled with the self-voting thing it's really just him wasting our time and intentionally not being readable, which is annoying if not wolfy. I invite him to come at me if he really wants to, though. Suspect DM doesn't get much in the way of the WIM I will bring to bear. 

 

The other thing here that kinda bugs me is he just straight up is lying about WHY he's voting me. I'm being mechanical? I don't even care about the mechanics in a basic game and I haven't spoken about them at all. You can easily go read my previous posts and see this, too. That's a fabrication. In POG we just lynch people for that, and I think we're right to do it.

 

Pral

 

I don't really understand why people had pretty hard reads after his intro posts, but I don't know him. I have no comment otherwise.

 

cory

 

I kinda believe the drunken posting / crunking / fake rage / manbat work together thing is slightly villager-y, as is the joke about me being a celebrated Go player (not true). This is not a read I will be relying on.

 

Everyone else I don't have anything useful to say, so I will be re-reading from here. 

 

Also, come at me.

[Sleeper Service]

Oh, and monstr voting me is terrible but not wolfy.

[Sleeper Service]

in fact I might rescind the monstr read because that vote is so dumb, I know he isn't concerned about getting me to post

[Sleeper Service]

of course he also can't possibly think that vote matters in the first place, so maybe I shouldn't even care

[dicetosser1]

ok that had me chuckling in RL sleeper.

 

 

in post 1 on this page you are talking like you dont realise csarmi and i are a hydra. then in post 2 you suddenly do realise it but you still dont like me.  So what,  in the 10 minute gap did someone on your team point out me and csarmi are a hydra to you??

[Yates]

Just a post to say hello [which really means to add this forum to my "posted in" list]. I will be joining Hally in this adventure as soon as I'm caught up. And that will not be tonight.

 

Good evening!

[Sleeper Service]

dice, mentioning csarmi without mentioning you is different from not knowing you're a hydra (said hybrid earlier); not only did I know that when the game began, but I keep a spreadsheet, and it says this:

 

Sarmtosser (Dice/Csarmi hydra)

 

it's purple because I like most of his posts and absolutely hate yours, if it was you alone it would be red

 

in other words you're wolfy, not my problem

[Cory Caboose]

Hoya your application for derp clear status:

 

 

denied.

 

 

Csarmi and dice are the same player. Would be a good place to start.

[Sleeper Service]

ok that had me chuckling in RL sleeper.

 

 

in post 1 on this page you are talking like you dont realise csarmi and i are a hydra. then in post 2 you suddenly do realise it but you still dont like me.  So what,  in the 10 minute gap did someone on your team point out me and csarmi are a hydra to you??

 

and this post is abysmal

 

my post isn't funny in the first place, second it's one of the worst arguments I've ever seen, and third it's DEFINITELY the worst attempt to "push scum" that I've ever seen

[Cory Caboose]

The problem with phoan post: lolninja'd

[Sleeper Service]

oh lol I AM an idiot

 

is problem

[Sleeper Service]

your post doesn't suck, actually, my bad

[Sleeper Service]

not sure how I did that

[Cory Caboose]

HoyAIDS

 

Csarmi not really a two way player and he's a pretty obvious villager when he is one

 

Dice is an obvious villager

 

So that slot is an obvious villager

 

Other than that proceed

[Sleeper Service]

so to be fair, that doesn't really solve the problem though

 

I still think the other posts remain non-contributory and that csarmi's tone is really good

[Sleeper Service]

fair enough

[Songstress]

Just a post to say hello [which really means to add this forum to my "posted in" list]. I will be joining Hally in this adventure as soon as I'm caught up. And that will not be tonight.

 

Good evening!

 

He exists! 

[Cory Caboose]

Hoya you're like 66% to my reads but can't seem to GET THERE

 

Just sheep me for now and reassess ITT after you put in the NK on me