[Advanced] Revenge of the Marlfox

[monstrman]

i think alanna is mafia.

 

 

key   might be but around the time of her claim her logic regarding her jail actions made sense to me.  I said it at the time but noone asked about it, but i wouldnt have jailed tom either. while i kinda believe his claim im not TOTALLY sold on him. i would have left him out there to allow nas to sort him out.

 

if tommy IS alive come day i will vote him. Im the one who originally floated that the BP needed to go early so it cant be used against us. Tommy being alive D3 says 2 things to me. Either the mafia are gonna use him against us later or he IS mafia and we are getting played.

 

lynching him means we either get rid of a role that could screw town over, or lynch a scum. sounds win/win to me

 

If tommy is scum he's irrelevant and we can lynch him later

 

if tommy is telling the truth good scumhunting is better than just default lynching the BP

[Verbal32]

 

Hi Dice

 

You should start town telling as hard as you can

 

When you disappear for days at a time you risk being CFD'd

 

with you in the game i could be missing for 5 MINUTES and get CFD'd.  see thane

 

 

HAHAHA

[monstrman]

And if he is the BP as long as we lynch mafia tommy is a non-issue

[Tommyrod]

I'm trying to be open minded about helpless DM villages but saying you're going to vote me on D3

knowing I'm town is insane.

[monstrman]

If alanna is scum tommy is GUARANTEED town btw

[dicetosser1]

verb

 

 

aggressive.  I admit that i do tend to be more aggressive when tommy is in the game. He usually gives me something to sink my teeth into and really get at ya know?

 

if you look back you will see that i went at tommy,and i bugged the hell out of sili. so ive been biting  just not as noticeably i guess.

[Tommyrod]

If alanna is scum tommy is GUARANTEED town btw

Which event are you thinking of?

[Verbal32]

i think alanna is mafia.

 

 

key   might be but around the time of her claim her logic regarding her jail actions made sense to me.  I said it at the time but noone asked about it, but i wouldnt have jailed tom either. while i kinda believe his claim im not TOTALLY sold on him. i would have left him out there to allow nas to sort him out.

 

if tommy IS alive come day i will vote him. Im the one who originally floated that the BP needed to go early so it cant be used against us. Tommy being alive D3 says 2 things to me. Either the mafia are gonna use him against us later or he IS mafia and we are getting played.

 

lynching him means we either get rid of a role that could screw town over, or lynch a scum. sounds win/win to me

 

Sounds like you're in agreement with me re: how to deal with Tommy.

 

Monstr is right, though - if we start catching scum, we can avoid this situation entirely.  I'm just not confident that we'll do that with the rate of success needed to ensure Tommy's role doesn't screw us over.

[monstrman]

 

If alanna is scum tommy is GUARANTEED town btw

Which event are you thinking of?

 

 

Re: Despot gambit

[monstrman]

if nothing else and she is indeed scum it proved that she knew you were town

[Tommyrod]

if nothing else and she is indeed scum it proved that she knew you were town

Very good.

 

People, pay attention. This kind of specific event recall is a very strong villager tell.

 

One that Verb lacks. COUGH!

[dicetosser1]

i dont KNOW your town tom. I THINK you might be but believe me on my list you are only just on the town side of the list.

 

heres why

 

BP can be a great fake claim. everybody waits for you to get NKd    but you never do!  make it to end game, we got screwed

 

that no NK??  the conjecture about mafia NOT shooting?? It IS possible. Unlikely but possible and i can only see 2 people doing that. You and Yates. and i dont think yates has the clout to get his team to go along with it.

 

 

these things cause me doubt in regards to you.

[Leelou]

I hate everyone. 

 

 

 

Verb, I think we need a bigger boat. 

 

 

[Tommyrod]

For the record Dice never would I ever holster scum kill on N1. Just shoot some likely to get clear but not yet clear townie who won't be tampered with. Always better than holstering on N1.

 

Scum doesn't win games by opting to not kill townies.

[dicetosser1]

 

i think alanna is mafia.

 

 

key   might be but around the time of her claim her logic regarding her jail actions made sense to me.  I said it at the time but noone asked about it, but i wouldnt have jailed tom either. while i kinda believe his claim im not TOTALLY sold on him. i would have left him out there to allow nas to sort him out.

 

if tommy IS alive come day i will vote him. Im the one who originally floated that the BP needed to go early so it cant be used against us. Tommy being alive D3 says 2 things to me. Either the mafia are gonna use him against us later or he IS mafia and we are getting played.

 

lynching him means we either get rid of a role that could screw town over, or lynch a scum. sounds win/win to me

 

Sounds like you're in agreement with me re: how to deal with Tommy.

 

Monstr is right, though - if we start catching scum, we can avoid this situation entirely.  I'm just not confident that we'll do that with the rate of success needed to ensure Tommy's role doesn't screw us over.

 

 

 blue   actually you are agreeing with ME!! 

 

red    totally this

[dicetosser1]

but scum DOES win by tricking townies   and that is a good way to do it

[Tommyrod]

but scum DOES win by tricking townies and that is a good way to do it

At the cost of not killing someone? Good luck.

 

I would never do that, but FSM bless someone that tries.

[dicetosser1]

do you really think anyone is going to believe you saying I would never do that as scum?

[monstrman]

Okay I was saying sili was a lock townie and no one listened to me and look what happened

 

LEAVE TOMMY ALONE

 

LEAVE HIM ALONE

[Tommyrod]

do you really think anyone is going to believe you saying I would never do that as scum?

When it goes staunchly against my playstyle and game philosophy? Yes.

[Leelou]

Lets think logically for a few minutes. Do we think scum withheld their NK -OR- that they took the bait of Des going to shoot Tommy so why waste their kill and go hunting elsewhere and get blocked? 

 

Gone goldfishin

[monstrman]

if scum withheld their nk they are playing against their wincon

[monstrman]

no amount of wifom can make up for the loss of a nk

[Tommyrod]

no amount of wifom can make up for the loss of a nk

Yeah I can't imagine holstering except at a very tight F5.

[Verbal32]

I'm trying to be open minded about helpless DM villages but saying you're going to vote me on D3

knowing I'm town is insane.

 

He is saying he doesn't know you're town.  Which I expect factors into the decision (it does for me).  By the way, does it make you feel super cool to insult DM town players like you've been doing? 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Btw quite my post and tell me if you get the reference.

Quote

I don't understand what you're saying....

A couple before

 

 

 

Can you pull it for me?  I still can't find it....

 

 

 

 

 

if nothing else and she is indeed scum it proved that she knew you were town

Very good.

 

People, pay attention. This kind of specific event recall is a very strong villager tell.

 

One that Verb lacks. COUGH!

 

 

My specific event recall sucks.  So you can't use that for a towntell from me.  Your point?