[BASIC] Discworld Mafia - MAFIA win

[Verbal32]

I think we're both falling into the "no scum would do that" trap and you're edging into too townie territory as well.

You're trying to outwit the mafia for something they might not have even done.

We should take a step back and review the facts.

 

Dude, think about it.  You're scum.  Would you leave your vote on a usleless train EOD to be obviously scrutinized?  Their vote didn't hop to Yates when that train was looking weird and in contention, did it?  They just buried it.  Seems reasonable that they were trying to hide any connection to their partner.

[Nolder]

 

I think we're both falling into the "no scum would do that" trap and you're edging into too townie territory as well.

You're trying to outwit the mafia for something they might not have even done.

We should take a step back and review the facts.

 

Dude, think about it.  You're scum.  Would you leave your vote on a usleless train EOD to be obviously scrutinized?  Their vote didn't hop to Yates when that train was looking weird and in contention, did it?  They just buried it.  Seems reasonable that they were trying to hide any connection to their partner.

 

Maybe. Like I said this isn't necessarily a bad theory. I just think it's early to leave the obvious train of thought, it hasn't failed us yet.

 

I think today's lynch has to be between myself, Hallia, and Yates and once we roll those dice if the game isn't over we can move on to speculating about why Lee/Nyn did certain things.

[Nolder]

I'm going to go review their posts and see if I find anything interesting, haven't done that yet.

[michellem]

It took up until page 12 for LouNy and Yates to interact. As far as I can see, everyone else had have some interaction with LouNy by that point. Interesting.

[Verbal32]

It took up until page 12 for LouNy and Yates to interact. As far as I can see, everyone else had have some interaction with LouNy by that point. Interesting.

 

I do not think mafia risk avoiding each other.  This is a townsign for Yates, imo.

[michellem]

Doesn't to me; it seems forced IMO.

[michellem]

Also, if you're gonna look at it like that, there's similar reasons for how basically everyone can't be their scumpartner. All those who most agrees are the most likely suspects, have some big towntells here and there and reasons why they're unlikely to be partners with LouNy.

[michellem]

Quick impressions as of page 17.

 

I still think Dice is clear town.

Pretty sure Tina is town.

Barm is clearly town.

Verb I'm pretty sure is town.

The chance of Krak being LouNy's teammember is extremely small.

Nolder's looking unlikely too.

 

So I'm down to Yates and Hallia at this point.

[dicetosser1]

Yeah I don't normally put myself in my own lists, but I feel that I've been extraordinarily clear town game (I know some would disagree), and my constant push on LouNy from the get-go to the conclusion pretty much clears me. I'm not going to push this point because it's subjective and likely not terribly convincing, but I wanted to say it so I'm not mislynch #2 or something stupid like that.

 

FYI  posts like this make my fingers autotype VOTE such and such.

 

Sorry for not posting much today. Bad day + v. confused. And now the pizza place just delivered the wrong pizza. Is grumpy. Will continue reread and see what I can come up with after getting some food.

 

keep the one you got and make them give you the one you ordered as well for free.

[dicetosser1]

Hally   i gotta go out early this morning but will try to get on during the day.

 

So in the meantime what have you got for me?

[michellem]

The one I got was full of paprika, I hate paprika on pizza.

 

But they gave us a new one, so it's all good. Just annoyed I had to wait cause I was starving!

[dicetosser1]

i need to reread Barm. i dont have enuff of what he said stuck in my brain.

 

 

re verbs points.  scum could leave their vote off their partner but only if they had had a day like mine where they were strongly town read by everyone. However what they wouldnt have done i think is listed nyn/lee as their bottoms, woulda had them in the middle somewhere.

 

 

my lynch thinking atm is nol or krak. tho nol has been seeming more town lately i am warythat he is putting in a big effort to appear town and that it is working. Also @nol  saying the lynch should be between u and others is the same as what verb said.

 

my outliers are  tina and hallia. Want to see hallys responses today.

[dicetosser1]

who puts paprika on a pizza????

 

 

 

americans are nuts!

 

 

[Nolder]

who puts paprika on a pizza????

 

 

 

americans are nuts!

 

 

She Eruo.

 

Also I've never heard of paprika on pizza either, seems really strange.

[Nolder]

Also I got distracted and lost my enthusiasm for a reread around page 4 lol.

Maybe I'll try to pick that back up later.

[michellem]

I'm not American Dice! Norway is in Europe I think paprika on pizza is a scandinavian thing. It's horrible.

 

 

 

Dice, after rereading, I'll say gun to my head it's highly unlikely Krak or Nol is teammates with LouNy. LouNy went into way too much effort on them both D1, and it was returned. Would be really bad mafia tactic.

[WolfbrotherKronos]

Although I think it's unlikely, Verb has a good point and it shouldn't be ignored.

[Nolder]

Although I think it's unlikely, Verb has a good point and it shouldn't be ignored.

Do you think I have a point in that we should proceed with most likely scenarios first and save unlikely ones for later if necessary?

[michellem]

PAge 29. I feel confident enough to [v] Hallia [/v] at this point. Will be making my usual big posts with tons of quotes that everyone hates after I'm completly done to show why.

[WolfbrotherKronos]

 

Although I think it's unlikely, Verb has a good point and it shouldn't be ignored.

Do you think I have a point in that we should proceed with most likely scenarios first and save unlikely ones for later if necessary?

 

 

Yes

[BFG]

Locked in his tower room Leonard stared at the piece of string and wondered, 'exactly how long was it?' maybe if he tied a pendulum he could measure the arc and determine the length that way. But then he'd need to measure the weight of the bob. He could measure volume by displacing the fluid and he had a book with the density of every metal on the Discworld if he could find it... He happily scribbled away on his piece of paper

 

Current VC:

 

Nolder (1): Krak

 

Yates (1): Tina

 

Hallia (1): Wolfish

 

 

Not Voting (6): Dice, Barm, Verb, Nolder, Krak, Hallia

 

With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch

 

[BFG]

SLEEP WELL AND WAKE

[Nolder]

Will be making my usual big posts with tons of quotes that everyone hates after I'm completly done to show why.

There are people who hate posts like that?

[michellem]

I feel a lot of people are like TL:DR when it comes to mine. Mine tend to go into 3-4 posts cause they're so long. I think people really dislike reading them. I don't care though; I'm good at them.

[Nolder]

I've always been a proponent of do what you want and if people read it that's cool and if they don't oh well.

Like I don't read posts that nest responses inside quotes with colors anymore. They give me headaches and I just wont do it.

I don't care if people make them but they better not expect me to read it if they format it like that.