[BASIC] Discworld Mafia - MAFIA win

Nynaeve · October 8, 2014

Nyn, this is like the fiftieth game we've played together (okay not really but I'm not new to you)

You were in and followed closely in the only game I was Mafia on this site

Curiosity suddenly getting the best of you here is like bertstare-level suspicious

I could see like a Yates asking for it, but not you

Just seems like you're doing things without a purpose

95% of the games we've played together you were town. The one game we were together where you were scum I died N1 and you were absent for part of it. I don't see why this bothers you that I want to take a look at your scum range.

The point I was trying to make is that Nolder not liking you taking charge is kinda funny. It's null at best.

Cory Caboose · October 8, 2014

Think of it more as: why didn't you ask me then?

AFAICT the only difference is in previous games I correctly had you as a villager early and in this game I don't see villager!Nyn at all

Now suddenly you're interested in me

Cory Caboose · October 8, 2014

Mish/Kronos

Barm

Dice

Yates

Everybody else

Barm and Yates my third tier of villas so I like this a lot

Dice is my blueread

Cory Caboose · October 8, 2014

(Spoiled the surprise!!!)

Cory Caboose · October 8, 2014

I have Mish as blue and WBK as greenish

(Lol)

Nynaeve · October 8, 2014

Think of it more as: why didn't you ask me then?

AFAICT the only difference is in previous games I correctly had you as a villager early and in this game I don't see villager!Nyn at all

Now suddenly you're interested in me

Ask you what?

I just wanted to reaffirm that you take the lead in either alignment. Which I did. Not sure how you're translating that into me being 'interested' in you.

Niniel · October 8, 2014

I´m impressed that people can go through old games for meta reads. I had to re-read this game just to remember what happened yesterday. lol

[unvote]

I like Dice and Mish/Kronos. Cory is starting to get more townie.

I liked Barm´s post #142. Would like to see more from him.

I haven´t seen much from Nyn/Leelou so far. As Mish said, it´s weird since they have a lot of posts.

It´s a strange Krak - Nolder - Verb triangle. Nolder didn´t like Verbs answer on Krak´s joke vote and then Verb joke voted Krak but kept his vote since he didn´t like how Krak followed up. I have two posts by Nolder that I will try to find because they looked weird.

Verbal - what do you think about Nyn/Leelou?

Niniel · October 8, 2014

Oh, and Krak is probably scum.

Maybe. I was kind of wondering while catching up actually.

Not sure if I have a bad read on you or if ya'll are bussing or what.

Thinks that Krak could be scum and that Verb is or isn´t on his team.

I think I see why you're confused.

I'm not trying to say Krak actually knew you were scum.

I think he just said it as a joke/reaction test and I think you reacted poorly to it, that's all.

But here he says that Krak didn´t know if Verb was scum. Which means that he doesn´t think that Krak has any other information than town.

It seems like these posts contradict each other. Thoughts?

Nynaeve · October 8, 2014

AFAICT the only difference is in previous games I correctly had you as a villager early and in this game I don't see villager!Nyn at all

It's true that you usually read me very well. But I don't know what to tell you about your gut read other than it's wrong.

Anyways, Lee and I are talking right now, so we'll post our reads in a bit. I'll try to be more transparent so maybe you can understand my line of thought better.

Hallia · October 8, 2014

I used breakfast time to scan through the first few pages, up through page 7 I noted a couple of things.

You know what Dice?

You do you.

i do do i ??

ya know what? I do.

tosses the dice

eight

I think this is typical TownDice. I know of course that the PR for something like that wasn't likely to be harmful to game, but I just don't think that ScumDice would do that.

How come... cory is posting in the signups thread, and not here, hmmm?

Townlean on Mish for that, while it may not be indicative of Cory's alignment, because my Cory could never be scum, but it shows she's paying attention :wub:

@Nol - here is the sequence you are referring to:

Sup. But now bed. Bye.

Tease.

Worth*

Fail of the game: Accomplished.

hahahaha

^

Scum Verb makes his appearance.

Just so you know - the above is what you're looking to hang your hat on. Good luck with that.

This makes me feel good about Verb and Wolf being town, and gives me scumm vibes about Nol and Krak.

And it's Wednesday?

Vote: Nolder

Cory Caboose · October 8, 2014

I feel really good about my villagers at this point and really just need one more "solid villager" before I have a game-winning POE

F*** IT WE'LL DO IT LIVE:

Dice

Mish/WBK
Tina

Krak

Yates

Barm

Verbal

Hallia

Nolder

LouNy

Cory Caboose · October 8, 2014

Nyn you have plenty of time to turn it around if you are a villager

Deadline not til tomorrow

Cory Caboose · October 8, 2014

Halleh -

Dice's intro I had as something more likely to come from Town!Dice than Scum!Dice but wasn't clearing

But the way he engaged me later was about as town as dice can possibly get, would be very surprised if he were Mafia

I like the motion in your ocean

Nolder · October 8, 2014

Oh, and Krak is probably scum.

Maybe. I was kind of wondering while catching up actually.

Not sure if I have a bad read on you or if ya'll are bussing or what.

Thinks that Krak could be scum and that Verb is or isn´t on his team.

I think I see why you're confused.

I'm not trying to say Krak actually knew you were scum.

I think he just said it as a joke/reaction test and I think you reacted poorly to it, that's all.

But here he says that Krak didn´t know if Verb was scum. Which means that he doesn´t think that Krak has any other information than town.

It seems like these posts contradict each other. Thoughts?

1. Yeah I didn't like something Krak said when I was catching up. I don't know whether the scum is him or Verbal or they're bussing or what is going on.

I probably just don't have a good read. It's early and I'm not like putting full confidence 100% sure stamp of approval on my read or anything. It's just what I got right now.

3. I'm allowing for possibilities, including being wrong. You're reading my comments and reads as if I'm sure. I don't know Krak or Verbs alignment. Either or both or neither could be mafia and I'm trying to figure out which it is.

Nolder · October 8, 2014

lol 3

that's a typo it was supposed to be 2

Verbal32 · October 8, 2014

I´m impressed that people can go through old games for meta reads. I had to re-read this game just to remember what happened yesterday. lol

[unvote]

I like Dice and Mish/Kronos. Cory is starting to get more townie.

I liked Barm´s post #142. Would like to see more from him.

I haven´t seen much from Nyn/Leelou so far. As Mish said, it´s weird since they have a lot of posts.

It´s a strange Krak - Nolder - Verb triangle. Nolder didn´t like Verbs answer on Krak´s joke vote and then Verb joke voted Krak but kept his vote since he didn´t like how Krak followed up. I have two posts by Nolder that I will try to find because they looked weird.

Verbal - what do you think about Nyn/Leelou?

Everybody else

Oh, and Krak is probably scum.

Maybe. I was kind of wondering while catching up actually.

Not sure if I have a bad read on you or if ya'll are bussing or what.

Thinks that Krak could be scum and that Verb is or isn´t on his team.

I think I see why you're confused.

I'm not trying to say Krak actually knew you were scum.

I think he just said it as a joke/reaction test and I think you reacted poorly to it, that's all.

But here he says that Krak didn´t know if Verb was scum. Which means that he doesn´t think that Krak has any other information than town.

It seems like these posts contradict each other. Thoughts?

I agree with your conclusion.

Cory Caboose · October 8, 2014

Verbal talk more about me imo

:flamingsword:

Verbal32 · October 8, 2014

Tina is asking the types of questions I attribute to her town game.

Nolder · October 8, 2014

I used breakfast time to scan through the first few pages, up through page 7 I noted a couple of things.

You know what Dice?

You do you.

i do do i ??

ya know what? I do.

tosses the dice

eight

I think this is typical TownDice. I know of course that the PR for something like that wasn't likely to be harmful to game, but I just don't think that ScumDice would do that.

How come... cory is posting in the signups thread, and not here, hmmm?

Townlean on Mish for that, while it may not be indicative of Cory's alignment, because my Cory could never be scum, but it shows she's paying attention

@Nol - here is the sequence you are referring to:

Sup. But now bed. Bye.

Tease.

Worth*

Fail of the game: Accomplished.

hahahaha

^

Scum Verb makes his appearance.

Just so you know - the above is what you're looking to hang your hat on. Good luck with that.

This makes me feel good about Verb and Wolf being town, and gives me scumm vibes about Nol and Krak.

And it's Wednesday?

Vote: Nolder

This is the exact opposite of what I wanted to see from you.

You already said you're having a tough time at work and I was willing to give you the extra day to catch up.

You should have taken it and made a better post.

[unvote]

[v]Hallia[/v]

Verbal32 · October 8, 2014

Verbal talk more about me imo

LOL

Your reads list is close enough to mine that I'm happy to not contest the Town Leader position. You are more active and phrase your #solve posts better than I do, so I'll happily come along for the ride as long as our lists stay close together. If I disagree on anything, you'll be the first to know.

The most I can think right now is that I believe you have Krak too high up. Other than that, I'm cool.

Cory Caboose · October 8, 2014

Tina I'm glad you saw the light :wub:

I feel really good about this game, think I have a strong foothold

Cory Caboose · October 8, 2014

Verbal talk more about me imo

LOL

Your reads list is close enough to mine that I'm happy to not contest the Town Leader position. You are more active and phrase your #solve posts better than I do, so I'll happily come along for the ride as long as our lists stay close together. If I disagree on anything, you'll be the first to know.

The most I can think right now is that I believe you have Krak too high up. Other than that, I'm cool.

Krak going ~absent has sort of hurt my lean a little

Curious to see his re-entry into the game

Verbal32 · October 8, 2014

If the town core that is forming right now is accurate, the scum should probably lolcat at this point.

Cory Caboose · October 8, 2014

And there's no Darthe in here to ruin it all for everyone

Nolder · October 8, 2014

And there's no Darthe in here to ruin it all for everyone

Someone will channel him.

Can't stop the Darthening.

[BASIC] Discworld Mafia - MAFIA win

Recommended Posts

Archived

Stay Connected

Forum Topics

News items

About Dragonmount

Twitter

Facebook