[Standard] Cory vs. Bad Dietary Habits & Laziness Mafia, Mafia Sweep

[Tommyrod]

It would have been better if the info would not be known for scum. Plus, as clearly seen above, it is not a claim which would be easily believed. It would be better to claim later in the game when the options to kill are reduced than at the beginning.

What? You get a shot if you get lynched. But it's better to just claim and draw a night kill -- especially when you haven't been active.

 

Saving this for endgame makes no sense to me.

 

You admitting it's not a believable claim bothers me even more.

[csarmi]

[unvote] for now

 

I won't be around, I hope Hally will be and decide. I prefer a Darthe lynch.

[csarmi]

[v]Darthe[/v]

[Tommyrod]

[unvote]

 

[v]Pral[/v]

[monstrman]

Ya I really don't like that because it's basically holding the town hostage tbh

 

But I still think I'd prefer a krak lynch

 

Ugh I can't decide

[Tommyrod]

Pral why did you say "good thing you guts didn't lynch me" on D3 if lynching you D2 would have given you a shot to use? Seems like an incongruent response.

[Tommyrod]

Looking at Pral's ISO and there's very little content.

 

He's called Arsis scum since D1. Agrees with me that Krak is town after D2 wagons. Thinks Yates is scum. Darthe is scum.

 

Such a lack of development though. His reasons for leans are very thin.

[Tommyrod]

He's called Krak town since I proposed the D2 wagons theory -- and even cites that theory as why Krak is town later on.

[Arsis]

Would Cory put in a Vengeful townie/poisoner in a standard game? I mean if Pral was the day 1 lynch that's a possible day 1 town loss.

[Tommyrod]

Yeah, dice is scum here. So is Darthe. That's two confirmed scum.

lol

 

Then his vote for SP after the Mason claim. So bad.

[Arsis]

Or day 2 lylo if my math is off.

[Tommyrod]

Would Cory put in a Vengeful townie/poisoner in a standard game? I mean if Pral was the day 1 lynch that's a possible day 1 town loss.

I can't answer that. But the timing and lack of flavor description is super bad.

[Tommyrod]

If Pral is scum it's probably why slender was killed.

 

Also think he would be odd night poisoner and needs to survive one more day.

[Arsis]

 

Would Cory put in a Vengeful townie/poisoner in a standard game? I mean if Pral was the day 1 lynch that's a possible day 1 town loss.

I can't answer that. But the timing and lack of flavor description is super bad.

The possibility of losing 4 townies day 1 with a 3rd party that could win with scum? Brutal set-up.

[Arsis]

If the whole "wawa where Cory could go either way" thing meant what I think it did.

[Tyler Glembo]

[v] Pral [/v]

 

IMO we kill scum with either Pral or Yates, but no way do we get two scum.  Either Pral is town and shoots scum!Yates or Pral is scum and would def not shoot a scum buddy.   

 

Why is nobody else tinfoiling over the SP/Dice mason claim.  Given the stage of the game it's either a huge town +EV or a very obvi scum gambit.  Tommy, I would've expected at least you to mention this unless I missed it in my catchup. 

[Tommyrod]

[v] Pral [/v]

 

IMO we kill scum with either Pral or Yates, but no way do we get two scum. Either Pral is town and shoots scum!Yates or Pral is scum and would def not shoot a scum buddy.

 

Why is nobody else tinfoiling over the SP/Dice mason claim. Given the stage of the game it's either a huge town +EV or a very obvi scum gambit. Tommy, I would've expected at least you to mention this unless I missed it in my catchup.

What is there to tinfoil over? If neither die by MyLo, then we talk about it.

[Tyler Glembo]

What is there to tinfoil over? If neither die by MyLo, then we talk about it.

 

You just answered your own question in the post. 

[Tommyrod]

 

What is there to tinfoil over? If neither die by MyLo, then we talk about it.

You just answered your own question in the post.

...so why did you ask?

[Tyler Glembo]

Because the fact that literally nobody is discussing it, or even brought it up at all before MyLo makes me paranoid.  So I asked to bring it up. 

[Tommyrod]

FTR I believed the claim. The timing was good and it sounded sincere and I had a meta town lean on SP for a while before the claim.

[Tyler Glembo]

@Dice & SP - Did you breadcrumb your mason role at all early game?  Show me where.

[Tommyrod]

TG I don't mind you covering all bases but this is likely the least productive thing you could be doing right now.

[Arsis]

The wiki says specifically that super saint doesn't pick the kill. Does dm do it differently? The pral= poisoner theory is solid imo.

 

[unvote] [v]pral[/v]

[Tyler Glembo]

FTR I believed the claim. The timing was good and it sounded sincere and I had a meta town lean on SP for a while before the claim.

 

I'm sketch on it.  Dice and SP have almost zero early game interaction.  Also, Dice explains thing in thread to SP such as the LD comment in post #2313.  Dice defends SP (post #2325) a bit early but also makes commentary about how SP doesn't get the troll type humor that seems odd to me if they share a Mason QT and makes more sense if they share a scumQT and are trying to look unconnected in thread.

 

Also, I have SP and Dice as both being on potential mafia teams, but not with eachother.  Seeing how they mostly avoided each other and made the few comments they did makes me tinfoil even harder on them pulling a gambit especially now that the cop is dead and can't check the claim to get a 2 for 1.