[Advanced] Blackhoof's Cthulhu Mythos Mafia Game- Day 1

[Tommyrod]

The players voting for Des should probably move to Dap as well, unless someone can show me prior Des scum meta where he acts this hard-headed and full of himself to the point where he exhibits paranoid town delusional grandeur. I don't know what his range is like. I'm hoping he comes in today and is more reasonable.

[ReleaseTheEvil]

The players voting for Des should probably move to Dap as well, unless someone can show me prior Des scum meta where he acts this hard-headed and full of himself to the point where he exhibits paranoid town delusional grandeur. I don't know what his range is like. I'm hoping he comes in today and is more reasonable.

 

Ugh. Worried that this is what he knows we will think and is still scum.

 

Fine, still on my scum list though.

 

[unvote] [v] Dap [/v]

[Tommyrod]

 

 

The players voting for Des should probably move to Dap as well, unless someone can show me prior Des scum meta where he acts this hard-headed and full of himself to the point where he exhibits paranoid town delusional grandeur. I don't know what his range is like. I'm hoping he comes in today and is more reasonable.

Ugh. Worried that this is what he knows we will think and is still scum.

 

Fine, still on my scum list though.

 

[unvote] [v] Dap [/v]

If you are SUPER DUPER sure about it based on previous experience with him, I don't want to talk you out of a correct read (though Dap should be scum regardless so is therefore the optimal lynch for today) but I attribute his godawful stubbornness and tunneling and "look at me I'm so great and everything you say supports my greatness" play to his town game. LMK if he's emulated that successfully as scum in the past.

[Tommyrod]

 

 

*stab*

 

*stab*

 

I'm stabbing you Des

 

*stab*

 

*stab*

 

*stab*

 

Does it hurt?

 

*stab*

 

Good.

 

*stab*

 

*stab*

 

BECAUSE SO DO MY FEELINGS.

 

*stab*

 

Because you are ignoring me

 

*stab*

 

Slighting me

 

*stab*

 

Mocking me

 

*stab*

 

And not leveling with me

 

*stab*

 

I feel alienated

 

*stab*

 

I feel disrespected

 

*stab*

 

I feel jilted

 

*stab*

 

And when I most need a helping hand

 

*stab*

 

You turn your back on me to pat yourself on the back

 

*stab*

 

That's the same behavior that got us into this mess

 

*stab*

 

So if you could stop bleeding me out unnecessarily

 

*stab*

 

I'll stop making you bleed with my stabs

 

*stab*

 

Jerk

 

When did this whole appeal to emotions thing become such a force on DM? This is the first time I've ever really seen it used this much.

 

[v]Dap[/v]

 

Let's go for it then. I have town reads on everyone posting right now, let's go for the non-participants.

I appreciate the move away from the aforementioned emotional thing.

 

When I started catching up just now (fifteen pages ago), all I was getting was page after page of Des and Tommy going back and forth. Now, fifteen pages later, Des has gone quiet and Tommy- a leading scum candidate in some people's opinions- is now calling the shots. Does anybody else find this strange?

 

That being said, I think that Des is a better option to lynch than Tommy. Part of this is the fact that I had to wade through a further fifteen pages of posts that mostly consisted of relatively weak arguments combined with constant harassment and a refusal to consider other options.

 

My alternative is just a hunch, but I feel that there might be something to learn from lynching Wombat. I can't point to a single thing to justify it, though, so take from that what you will.

So wombat is giving you the heebie jeebies?

 

Slight town lean for admitting you are uncertain but having a gut hunch, AND for not just hopping on an existing wagon but instead introducing an opening on wombat where none currently exists.

 

Please post more. Spill your soul into this thread.

[Blackhoof]

Vote Count

 

ReleaseTheEvil(2)- Darthe, Nervo

Player(5)- Lenlo, Pral, Tommy, Mynd, ReleaseTheEvil

Des(2)- Red, Tsuki

Tommy(2)- Des, Wombat

 

With 18 alive it takes 10 to lynch

 

Deadline: 2AM 29 June EST

[Red2111]

@ Tommy

 

 

 

 

 

Oh you think I need despots approval! Right. Well I do appreciate his WOTs I really don't need approval, that'd be way against my meta and I'm not that sloppy am I.?

 

 

Well, if you're town you wouldn't really worry about that? If you are town, you play like normally and that is your town meta.

If you are scum, you would worry about not being sloppy. About being on your town meta.

 

Did you just slip scum for us mate?

 

I try to cultivate a common meta as town and mafia (it improves my mafia game, and game overall)

Petty but a thing I do.

I like to try keep myself in check so I can be a better player overall

 

It helps hide me regardless of alignment or PR, so far it seems to work

 

 

I don't think that's petty- in fact to me it's plain and simple common sense to try and make your scum and town metas as similar as possible.

 

In general, I play mafia like the Spurs play basketball- I try and remove as many competitive disadvantages as possible. If your opponent has a harder time using meta against you, it's better in the long run (for both alignments- since that way scum can't try to lead a mislynch on you if you seem to be on your "scum meta")

 

 

the bold is why i dont think you should be basing your judgement of Des based on Meta.

 

the underline doesn't sit well with me at all. Des spoke of big game hunting in casing and this is exactly what he's doing. any of the big game in this game that aren't on his wave length hes actively trying to get lynched. look at his scum list, full of nothing but big game and only people who are goign at him.

 

he's playing heavy D, and has no O to speak of. a townie doesn't see competitors in a game and work on the mentality "your either with me or against me". a townie is suspicious of everyone but makes a judgement based on actions whether a person is scum and especially trys to get a feel of whether or not the big game (like Mynd and Wombat and Darthe for example) can be trusted somewhat to not drive the town over a cliff.

 

Despo = Brazen scum whose playing his meta so hard its becoming a thin veil.

 

 

once i finish my catch up i'll go back and re-examine the player case, but as of page 30 the only real thing i saw was the one post, which i already commented on. how he doesn't want to touch anything dealing with Cory, yet wanted to go at a mod confirmed silenced Len. anyone who goes at a silenced person is scummy imo and being way too opportunistic. its easy to spin what ever tale you want when a person can't talk and defend themselves.

[Tommyrod]

@ Tommy

 

 

 

 

 

 

Oh you think I need despots approval! Right. Well I do appreciate his WOTs I really don't need approval, that'd be way against my meta and I'm not that sloppy am I.?

 

Well, if you're town you wouldn't really worry about that? If you are town, you play like normally and that is your town meta.

If you are scum, you would worry about not being sloppy. About being on your town meta.

 

Did you just slip scum for us mate?

I try to cultivate a common meta as town and mafia (it improves my mafia game, and game overall)

Petty but a thing I do.

I like to try keep myself in check so I can be a better player overall

 

It helps hide me regardless of alignment or PR, so far it seems to work

I don't think that's petty- in fact to me it's plain and simple common sense to try and make your scum and town metas as similar as possible.

 

In general, I play mafia like the Spurs play basketball- I try and remove as many competitive disadvantages as possible. If your opponent has a harder time using meta against you, it's better in the long run (for both alignments- since that way scum can't try to lead a mislynch on you if you seem to be on your "scum meta")

the bold is why i dont think you should be basing your judgement of Des based on Meta.

 

the underline doesn't sit well with me at all. Des spoke of big game hunting in casing and this is exactly what he's doing. any of the big game in this game that aren't on his wave length hes actively trying to get lynched. look at his scum list, full of nothing but big game and only people who are goign at him.

 

he's playing heavy D, and has no O to speak of. a townie doesn't see competitors in a game and work on the mentality "your either with me or against me". a townie is suspicious of everyone but makes a judgement based on actions whether a person is scum and especially trys to get a feel of whether or not the big game (like Mynd and Wombat and Darthe for example) can be trusted somewhat to not drive the town over a cliff.

 

Despo = Brazen scum whose playing his meta so hard its becoming a thin veil.

 

 

once i finish my catch up i'll go back and re-examine the player case, but as of page 30 the only real thing i saw was the one post, which i already commented on. how he doesn't want to touch anything dealing with Cory, yet wanted to go at a mod confirmed silenced Len. anyone who goes at a silenced person is scummy imo and being way too opportunistic. its easy to spin what ever tale you want when a person can't talk and defend themselves.

Not bad, actually. I see a few people I believe are town are still suspicious of Des, so maybe he is playing me. I don't know.

[Tommyrod]

My preference is to lynch Dap and see what happens with Des; be interested to see what Lenlo has to say about all this when he's no longer silenced.

[dawnflower8]

Just to let you know, I will not be able to post on this game on Saturday or most of Sunday.

[ReleaseTheEvil]

Just to let you know, I will not be able to post on this game on Saturday or most of Sunday.

 

Good thing you've been posting so much today then...

[Blackhoof]

She probably has school, to be fair :P

 

 

 

I'm pretty stoked with these activity levels, guys :) yay all of you!

[dawnflower8]

I'm actually going on a camping trip. Although I do have summer school. The reason why I haven't been posting much today is because I was sleeping and woke up less than an hour ago.

[Tommyrod]

She probably has school, to be fair :P

 

 

 

I'm pretty stoked with these activity levels, guys :) yay all of you!

#@$%*!

[Blackhoof]

Hey, I've modded games with 3 posts a RL day. 3 posts a minute is preferable aha, even if they are mostly from a few of you. Only three players have been inactive, really, one has an excuse, and one is gonna get his ass replaced if he doesn't talk to me.

 

pretty decent, out of 18.

 

40 pages in 3 days, that is damn impressive.

[dawnflower8]

For once, I'm not one of those inactive players.

[Blackhoof]

My activity levels have been a bit bad because i sleep when most of the action happens. And the fact that so much of it happens.. You know what i mean

[Red2111]

up to page 34

 

first - o.0  i thought thunderdome was when two people have a battle of WoT's, like what Despo and Tommy were doing (Caser vs Casee).  i didn't realize its another term for competing trains. *sigh*

 

 

as of right now my list is this  red = scum, orange = heavy scum lean, purple = unsure, if your not listed then you need to post more (only exclusion to this is Len for mod confirmed silence)

 

Despo - multiple reasons. all of which i've already listed and wont be listing again

Mynd - bromance with Despo and has a case on Tommy based souly on the interaction with Cory.  his play has also been off this game, he's being much more reserved and docile, like he's had a leash put on him.

Vos - his vote on RTE was opportunistic scumtastic.  his trying to paint my suggestion of a competing train on Tommy and Despo as random.  labeling my cases on Despo and Tommy as fake scum hunting.  defending Despo and Tommy by attacking one of their main casers.

 

RTE - dropped down from the scum list for his reaction to Despo.  scumminess comes from teh OP "hey guys i'm town too" and the early reveal.  but his post quoted below which has a town feel could be just more piggy backing off of Tommy since he saw the reaction Tommy's response to Despo got.  idk

Player - mainly for the "not touching the cory situation" but going at a mod confirmed silenced player.

Darthe - went to unsure to scum lean for the bromance with despo. he's also lurkdome right now which makes me unease and has done no real scum hunting this game.

Wombat - gut feeling.  we're on the same page, which makes me distrust him.

Nyn - because she's Nyn

Quibby - is starting to climb the list with his posts.  he's lurking, chiming in but not giving anything of real substance and not scumhunting.  its a "hey guys i'm still here, yeah i agree with *insert name*" and goes back to the shadows.  plus its Quibby, you never trust teh Quibmister

 

Tommy - current reactions to Despo and push by both despo and mynd have knocked him down the list.  it seems genuine enough and he's actually scum hunting rather than focusing on defending himself, but i'm still wary of the timing of his Cory vote/push and the possible reasons behind going at cory like that.

 

 

 

 

 

Can you explain what you're even talking about? Because I think there's a huge difference in approach here.

 

My vote does not reflect my in-brain real time thought process. I do not change votes during arguments to match my current thoughts because they can change from post to post to post in the heat of the moment. I voted you primarily to get your attention and see how you would respond to me. I think your response is misguided but PROBABLY not scum driven because you're so convinced in your own theories that you're spinning everything I do or say to support them. That's more likely to be town Des because I THINK scum Des would have trouble with my rage. Therefore, you pass the tone meter.

 

But I haven't read barely any of the thread and don't know who to vote. That's why I asked you for your help and to consider the game from the perspective of me being town. Please please PLEASE reason with me.

 

I don't have a single thing going for me other than passion and sincerity. I don't know enough about the game to call people out other than my thin reads:

 

Mynd town lean

Nyn town lean

Red town lean

Des town lean

 

So I prefer to not vote these people today. From the remainder, who has been scummiest? I see talk of Vos, RTE, but I don't know the details. This is why I asked you for your understanding, because I'm way behind and I think trying to prevent my own lynch is the most beneficial thing I can do right this second because I know for a fact I am town and if I can prevent my own lazy lynch, then I should. Nobody even has to draw lines and take stances on me due to what happened with Cory, I'm basically a free lunch. Preventing that scenario where town gains almost zero information from my death is my top priority. After that, I can start getting into the game.

 

I hope that makes sense because that's my thought process.

 

see i drop you down my list, but then you have posts like this.   you're trying too hard to convince Despo your town and get him back on your side and now you're asking him to tell you who to vote and why.

 

why you want to be a sheeple?

 

 

Hey everyone!!!!  It's a READ UPDATE!!!!  From the Myndrunner Global Mafia Network!

 

Town (in no particular order) 

 

Vos - I hate to place someone in the Town category because of someone ELSE's posts, but here we go.  Prior to Red's onslaught, I had a slight town read on Nervosito.  He's not pushing for much but he's also not letting anything slip by either.  Red's attack makes me feel very good about Vos in this game.  He's looking big picture with pro-town posts like this here.

 

 

 

Slightly Town (in no particular order)

 

Wombat - The only think keeping me from putting Womby in my Town category is that he usually comes at me harder when truly scumhunting.  Granted, I haven't been startling the snakes like I used to.  I disagree with his take on Despo, but townies don't need to agree to be pro-town.  The dude is business.

 

Lenlo - Waiting for Lenlo to thaw.....though freezing players is not a pro-town role.  Can't move him either way until he can post again.

 

Despo - I felt like Despo's posts during the ugliness were more for levity.  He's now back in the game and I can't say I disagree with his reads at this point.   He's participating more than most which could mean scum, but his posts are making sense to me. 

 

Darthe - Kinda the same vibe I am getting from Despo, I almost even got a couple of their posts confused.  Hasn't done any real casing yet, but I think he was kinda trying to wait for the ugliness to die down.  This might change if he does something squirrelly and I've town-read him before when he was scum, but for now....town.  Sorta.

 

Quibby - Placing Quibbs in this category makes me nervous because he's evil incarnate, but in this game, he's acting like a scumhunter.

 

Nyn - Almost just want to place her in the scum pile just because.  I agree with her reads on Tommy and Tsukitup 

 

 

 

Null and Boring (in no particular order) 

 

TGlems - HEY!!!! THERE IS A GAME GOING ON HERE!!!!! YOOOHOOO!!!!

 

Zer0 - Trivia Question: Whose name equals the number of posts and contributions they've had in this game?

 

Pral - This is actually his playstyle, so I wouldn't say boring but a definite null read at this time.  I'm gonna have to gauge him more on his voting patterns rather than posts at this point.  My only other real interaction prior to this game was when Cory told me he was vig so...yeah.

 

 

 

Slightly Scum (in no particular order)  

 

Myndrunner - anyone who isn't at least slightly suspicious of me is likely scum!

 

Dawnflower - When Dawn is more active than you, either she's scum or you suck at mafia.  I'm leaning scum, possibly has her team coaching her, but at this point its just a read.  No real evidence.  I actually don't blame her for the Cory vote.  Still, scum feeling here. If she starts acting more....well.....Dawnish....then I will feel better.

 

Pianoplayer - He seems a bit self conscious about his meta.  I don't like that.   His vote on RTE here seemed opportunistic, but then he goes BLAH BLAH BLAH SCUM READ BLAH BLAH before unvoting RTE without a reason. 

 

 

 

SCUM SALAD! (in order of scumminess)

 

Tommyrooni - At first, I felt like Tommy really meta'd a scum cory, but then it just turned into ugliness.  His finger pointing sounded more like projection to me.  When cory flipped town, he tried to deflect the heat my way, then just kinda went paranoid himself.  Have we even heard from his hydra partner?  WE SHOULD LYNCH ALL THE HYDRAS!!!! ;)  ....oh now he is mad. 

 

ReleaseTheEvil - I really don't like his overreaction and paranoia when he only had two votes on him.  Many of us have been at L-2 or even L - 1 and didn't flinch this bad.  I'd like to see his casings.   Posts like THIS ONE do not a townie make.

 

Tsukibana - Acted aloof until pressed. Now defensive but not providing any actual casing or scumhunting.  He's really doing nothing I would consider pro-town.  The Tsuki I have seen before is much more of a casing specialist.  This is not that Tsuki.  He Tsucks at it in this game.

 

Red - Always famous for TL:DR (Too Long, Didn't Red)  but I actually read them.  A town Red starts off with thinking everyone scum.  This is not a town Red.  She isn't reading the thread, she is reacting to it.  Also, how can I be opportunistic on Cory when I actually was the lead vote? And MY case on RTE?  I didn't vote him.  I just called him out for being paranoid.  Maybe your own posts are TOO LONG, EVEN RED DIDN'T READ.  

 

 

 

I'm fine with a D1 lynch on anyone in the Salad.

 

your reason for putting Vos on the town list is mainly because i'm going at him.  thats weak.  it's a big red flag when a someone clears a person based souly on another players interaction with them.

 

the WIFOM on Len you posted reeks.  what are you trying to suggest?  that Lenlo is a silencer and silenced himself?  i dislike you trying to WIFOM a mod confirmed silenced player.

 

placing yourself on the scummy list as a joke seemed forced.  it might have been meant to be tongue in cheek, but you already did one in the joke phase with your other list which was a copy of Cory's "Red's Read list" in the Buffy game.  seems like a blatant play for town cred imo

 

i find it ironic that you claim Dap's vote on RTE was opportunisic, but mention nothing about Vos's blatantly opportunistic vote on the same lynch and have Vos in the town category for absolutley no good or valid reason.

 

your reason for putting Tommy in the scum category is lazy and reeks as well.  you're entirely ignoring anything post cory meltdown and your bit about the Hydras felt forced and as a plee for town cred.

 

RTE is parroting what others have already said

 

and your reason on me is just plain and utter bullshanks it doesn't even deserve a response.

 

 

 

 

Just lol

 

Moving on... I've read about 20% of the thread.

 

I'd really like it if everyone lists their top 2 scum leans with brief explanations for why.

 

Despo - Read teh thread

Tommy - Howtroll

 

 

Tommy mebbe this is why Wombat aint conversing with you?

 

/shrug

 

And yeah, just looks like Wombat going with Red re: setting up Tommy and me thunderdome to distance and stuff.

 

But I dunno, I could be mortal after all and Red wanted to set up a thunderdome with two townies, and Wombat followed her up on it. If it wasn't for Tommy's last three pages I'd have an easier time believing that. Wombat's tunnel on me is making him look scummier by the post

 

But, if I'm right about all dem, then again, I guess this is scum's best idea of #DAMAGE CONTROL

 

 

Despo you're the only one here right now settign up lynches like a scumster.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Sorry about taking so long

I ended up going rock climbing cos I could

---

Right so I'm writing this as I read

 

Firstly Cory is emoing but I see a banned above his name so i might refrain from talking about his posts till the end cos I don't know where it's all headed.

thats a weaksauce reason to dodge any interactions he had on thread and to pressure people about it. and the banned thing appears to be a self-title, as its in the user title area of his bio. i'd have to ask verb to be sure, but that still has no bearing on how people who are still in this game reacted to him.

 

as Mynd said, we have to make lemon aid out of the situation, at best we have a known townie now to base our reads off of, which gives us a better chance to lynch scum today.

 

i dislike how you want to distance yourself from the info.

 

 

Lenlo does a summary post

 

In it he calls me out for now denying I'm mafia (with regards to when RTE called one of the two people voting him mafia...)

Yea I wasn't voting him at that point dude...

Vote Count

Nyn(2)- Wombat, Des

ReleaseTheEvil(2)- Darthe, Nervo

Darthe(1)- cory

With 18 alive it takes 10 to lynchDeadline: No deadline

Actually you say that I only vote him at the end of your wot, I feel like I'm missing the connection? Why do I need to defend him calling one of the people on his train mafia when I'm not on his train nor am I mafia?

 

Anyway more interestingly is how you go for Darthe in this post. You call his list crap, but it seems largely due to you disagreeing on who he finds scummy. It's a rather deep line in the sand for a relatively new game IMO

You also go pretty far in your defence of RTE and it's purely based on meta in summary (dudes a walking magnet for votes I believe was the phrase)

 

Oh you think I need despots approval! Right. Well I do appreciate his WOTs I really don't need approval, that'd be way against my meta and I'm not that sloppy am I.?

 

Biggest stand out issue I have with this post is this however

Also here on this page though was Tsuki coming in and making jokes which is odd. From what ive seen from Tsuki is hes generally much more into the game and pretty good at casing. Want more.

That plus quoting Tsukis post about the keep calm poster then this:

As for the scum list I might be able to see Tsuki, as hes generally a much more focused player than this, but hes still not that scummy compared to Vos and Dap imo.

Are all you really say on the dude.

The last bit is an almost throw away line that seems placed just to verify the read you throw on him later (scummy)

 

That worries me Lenlo, why have him on that list when you really don't seem convinced.

 

 

Ok dam, Len is silenced. I expect an explanation on the Tsukis thing and that RTE and me thing when you get back please.

 

so you're hesitant to analyze the cory situation, yet you start thunderdoming with a silenced player. FoS, i'm not the buying the "ok damn Len is silenced" bit.

 

 

 

 

Oh you think I need despots approval! Right. Well I do appreciate his WOTs I really don't need approval, that'd be way against my meta and I'm not that sloppy am I.?

 

 

Well, if you're town you wouldn't really worry about that? If you are town, you play like normally and that is your town meta.

If you are scum, you would worry about not being sloppy. About being on your town meta.

 

Did you just slip scum for us mate?

 

Been my experience that players worried about their meta are worried about their meta showing.

 

i think meta is over rated personally. but Vos brings up a fair point, the only players worried about their meta are scum.

 

theres a difference to being worried about how your meta is being shown in games and being concerned with being consistent about it; and taking issue with people developing cases based souly on meta. the first is what Player is doing, the 2nd gives me the warm in fuzzy's to see people relying on meta get played by it

 

you are now starting to ping me Mynd, your play this game is off. why so docile?

 

 

 

@ mynd ya srsly. Despo = lockscum & Tommy near lockscum for his stunt on Cory. Obv now Cory wasn't scum yet tom posted that bit of "kill myself so obv Cory = scum" why else would tom push so hard unless he was worried about Cory soul reading him. There's also his vote on cory which was convenient given how much pressure and the wagon on RTE at the time. And now RTE is MIA

 

 

Posted from my new droid. DM mobile does suck

Shouldn't we look at a Tommy vs RTE train instead....since RTE is still the lead train?  If we need to switch to a Tommy vs Despo train tandem, sure thing but RTE got popular for a reason.

 

RTE is getting heat for 2 things, i agree they're scummy but imo Tommy and Despo are far more scummier and give more info right now. i'm not saying to rush a lynch on them, still plenty of time before deadline. but i want more pressure on Despo and Tommy because they are top of my list.

 

hell we've got enough players (if everyone would start being more active and check in <_< ) we could do three trains easily.

 

 

 

 

Blech @ this post.

 

She says Dap was trying to thunderdome with Lenlo, a silenced player, which would look bad if there was ANYTHING about Dap's post that indicated he wanted to thunderdome with Lenlo. Instead it just makes Red look MEGA sketchy for trying to misrep Dap like that.

 

Then she pulls the "I don't normally like _____, but you talking about ______ is a good point regarding her comment about Mynd and meta. Gross.

 

Lastly, the ol "RTE looks scummy, but there other two players look scummier" obligatory attempt at leading town part (as far as saying who the competing trains should be on)

 

 

bold - i took thunderdoming to mean hard core casing Despo. and Dap was going at Len hardcore there. its not a misrep, literally Len is the ONLY person Dap has cased. it pings when people are casing those who cant defend themselves.

 

green - i'm confused by this, can you restate it

 

blue - so posting my reads and cases on people (ie: scumhunting) is scummy eh? me thinks the only problem you have with this is that your name is #1 on my scum list.

 

 

 

 

 

Wombat,

 

Are you town? Can I trust you? How do you like your eggs? What do you think of the argument between myself and Des?

 

I'm town.  You can trust me barring recruitment.  Over easy or sunny-side-up depending on the place and my mood.  I think you have been towntelling lately and it's frustrating because I don't wanna lose to your wolf game.  As for Despo, he's still pretty scummy imo, but a couple of the things he has said have come off as psychotic townie.

 

 

quoted for two reasons.

 

1 - the mention of recruitment pings as early WIFOM. granted this is a Cthulhu game but it always puts my hair on end when someone starts throwing around the big R in games.

 

 

bold - omg Womby likes his eggs the same way i do i love over easy eggs and them jamming up a good piece of toast and soaking up the yoke with it *drools a bit* or making a nice egg sammie with over easy eggs so when you bite into it the yokes pop all their goodness and drizzle the sammie with the golden lovely flavor

 

 

IF YOU ARENT SURE ON YOUR SCUM READS, TRY TO CLEAR PLAYERS WHO FEEL LIKE TOWNIES AND REDUCE THE SUSPECTS FROM THERE.

 

It's far more reliable and I've been getting better at it lately.

 

i'm lockclear on Despo being anti-town at this point. i'm almost lock clear on Mynd right now as well, and Vos is a good runner up.

 

 

 

Does nobody here understand that Cory is not omniscient, and neither am I? I was quite convinced he was scum due to his behavior -- others even agreed with me on this. What changed between then and now that makes me lock scum for believing that? Why is nobody considering the obvious -- that both of us were just wrong? I am NOT scum and I am frankly getting annoyed at your results oriented play that allows scum to EASILY place me on the lynch list with NO RESISTANCE from the town because Cory made an unbelievably stupid play.

You placed yourself on the lynch list.  You didn't just think he might be scum, but you were off the charts convinced. I agreed he was scummy, in fact, I lead the lynch, but you were pulling out YE OLDE BIBLE OF CORY'S PLAYSTYLE on us.  Aside from the ugliness that occurred, Cory flipped town.  Your push looks very scummy.

 

imo your beating an old dead horse here and being opportunistic. this is what i mean by casing Tommy without taking anything post cory melt down into account.

 

 

 

Des has two choices, which he picks will depend on his alignment and his stubbornness:

 

1. Retract his absurd "case" on me that says my reaction was fake. Guess what, tough guy? It can't be fake if I meant it.

 

2. Double down on his read and ensure he gets himself lynched after me because his myopia will be scummy instead of just lazy play.

 

You let me know which you're up for, I really am about out of patience.

 

VOTING ME IS LAZY, pure and simple. I am not scum and I cannot believe how many people have come out of the woodwork yet nobody is saying "huh, I wonder if they were both just wrong." You're giving scum not one but TWO free town deaths in a game this small by continuing to FOS me over a MISUNDERSTANDING.

 

KNOCK IT OFF. PLAY BETTER.

I didn't know the "I'm not scum because how dare you think so" was a reasonable defense, but apparently so.  This is a bully post.  One that reeks of a scum whose plan blew up in his face because Cory bailed. Misunderstanding?  Maybe you should take your own advice and "play better."

 

imo his reaction was a legit reaction to Despo trying to bully Tommy to unvote him. the reaction was the legit part imo, the squirming Despo did from one single vote was not.

 

notice Despo didn't try to bully anyone else on his lynch at this point, even though myself and womby were on his wagon and a few others joined in later. Tommy was the only one he tried to strong arm to get to back off his vote. you note picking up on this screams of being scum.

 

 

 

I invited Mak to hydra with me so he could try playing with a new crowd and a different culture, one I had hoped was more mature. Instead, we're having emotional meltdowns and town-town suicide pacts based on NOTHING that escalated for NO REASON. I even told Cory I wouldn't have time to push him and his reaction was to turn around and call me lock scum and then purposefully bait me into killing myself? That's ridiculous, even if he was right. All he's done is detail D1 and I want to try and piece this game back together.

 

 

 

.....

 

And yes, I'm a little mad that nobody seems to understand these basic concepts when I brought my friend here to play BETTER GAMES with BETTER PLAYERS.

 

You can start by teaching him how to post in this thread.  Maybe that is a good idea for you as well given your recent posts. 

 

Dude, just own that you made a colossal mistake and expect that you reek scum at this point.  If you are indeed town, reel back the "HOW DARE YOU" and try some more "sorry town, my bad" posts instead.

 

i agree with Mynd that Tommy's other head should jump in at any point XD dont worry man we may look like a den of vipers but its only because we like eachother that were being so damn cut throat. here a stab means luv XD

 

 

but i disagree witht he bolded. he did "own up to it" Mynd. stop skimming.

[Red2111]

 

Just to let you know, I will not be able to post on this game on Saturday or most of Sunday.

 

Good thing you've been posting so much today then...

 

wow, so the kettle is calling the pot black. what do you have, like 5 more posts then her?

 

atleast she has a legit reason like school to explain her disappearing acts, whats yours?

 

cause when you got pressure over that fantastic OP and so called reveal with like 3 votes on you you activated lurkmode like a champ

[ReleaseTheEvil]

Lurkmode what? I've been at work during the day and been busy at night. And I avoided Despodiarrhea.

 

I have given reads several times and I am present and following the thread and not planning to be gone at deadline. If you won't be here at deadline you sure as hell better give a complete read list before you go anywhere, even if all you say is town or scum. 

 

Dawn doesn't need defending, and don't pull this "your first post was scummy" crap on me. There was absolutely nothing wrong with my first post. Nothing anyone says will change my opinion of that. 

[Tommyrod]

I've reminded my better half to post; he's been busy with IRL crap. I'm hoping he posts soon so you will all clear him.

[Tommyrod]

Lurkmode what? I've been at work during the day and been busy at night. And I avoided Despodiarrhea.

 

I have given reads several times and I am present and following the thread and not planning to be gone at deadline. If you won't be here at deadline you sure as hell better give a complete read list before you go anywhere, even if all you say is town or scum.

 

Dawn doesn't need defending, and don't pull this "your first post was scummy" crap on me. There was absolutely nothing wrong with my first post. Nothing anyone says will change my opinion of that.

You didn't know? "Villager checking in!" = lock scum.

[Tommyrod]

I love how Red can change her mind five times within one post. So zany.

[ReleaseTheEvil]

 

Lurkmode what? I've been at work during the day and been busy at night. And I avoided Despodiarrhea.

 

I have given reads several times and I am present and following the thread and not planning to be gone at deadline. If you won't be here at deadline you sure as hell better give a complete read list before you go anywhere, even if all you say is town or scum.

 

Dawn doesn't need defending, and don't pull this "your first post was scummy" crap on me. There was absolutely nothing wrong with my first post. Nothing anyone says will change my opinion of that.

You didn't know? "Villager checking in!" = lock scum.

 

 

You mean like Cory and everyone else who posted that a few posts before me right?

 

Also really do not think anything at all of my reveal. In a different situation or game maybe but here? Nah. 

[ReleaseTheEvil]

I love how Red can change her mind five times within one post. So zany.

 

You read that monster? 

[Red2111]

@ RTE - not defending Dawn i'm pointing out how hypocritcal it is for you to call someone inactive who you only have like 5 more posts then and how its yet another example of you sheeping your way onto yet another thread trend.

 

you seem to be making a habit of wagoning onto trends this game.

 

firs the OP with the villager stuff with Cory.

 

then echoing the"ugh gawd just stop" response to Despotheria (nice word btw XD )

 

now your hoping on the Dawn-lurker-bash.

 

 

dude, be a trend setter, not a lemming

 

 

 

as for your OP

 

 

we surveyed the entire thread, survey says

 

 

" *thumbs up*

 

observe ...

 

 

I wasn't even worried looking at my Role PM

 

Knew I'd be a villager

 

corycurren never wrong (except those times he's hilariously wrong but this was not one of those times)

 

So yeah, get @ me, all that stuff, yadda yadda

 

Lock me in

a few hours later in the Cory/Despo love fest

 

 

Villager checking in!

^ read "hey you guys, i'm town too" teehee