[Standard] - Hitchhiker's Game to the Galaxy - Game Over

[Leelou]

 

THE POST RIGHT ABOVE THIS

 

I guess I could include my actual conclusion, rather than just the research: if basing just on speed, I'd say a slightly higher likeliness to be town than mafia.  Maybe a 55 - 45 split?  If not for the final four votes coming within a few hours of each other, and the final three being only one hour apart, it would probably be reversed (maybe throw in a few extra points onto mafia).

 

 

I was on Mish until she got replaced by Vos and my vote was wiped off by the mod. I voted Dice then because I felt uncomfortable with him and wanted to give Vos the opportunity to catch up in the game. 

[Pralaya]

Heh, as usual, scum take advantage that I am inactive on weekend and push the lynch. Anyway, it doesn't matter. This should only help the town clear out the scum in the game

 

FWIW, BFG is town. This post gave it away.

 

At some point I think we need to stop ignoring BFG's case on Pral. I have them both as scum reads but she's making solid points and evidently I must be wrong about one of them because it wouldn't make sense otherwise.

Clearly, RTE is setting up both of us knowing that if I flip town, he can push the case against BFG. This should have lock scummed him down. So, is Hallia.

 

Leelou is also town, as she could have easily jumped on my train but didn't.

 

That's from me. You all figure out the others.

[Cory Caboose]

I would happily CFD Hallia

[Clovdyx]

What's Dice's full username?

[BFG]

I'm willing to move to Lazy, but I wish he'd explained his Verb comment better. Equally he had a chance to do that and didn't.

[Cory Caboose]

DM weekend tho

[Leelou]

dicetosser1

[Cory Caboose]

What's Dice's full username?

 

dicetosser1

[Leelou]

DM weekend tho

 

Holiday weekend makes it worse. 

[Clovdyx]

Heh, as usual, scum take advantage that I am inactive on weekend and push the lynch. Anyway, it doesn't matter. This should only help the town clear out the scum in the game

 

FWIW, BFG is town. This post gave it away.

 

At some point I think we need to stop ignoring BFG's case on Pral. I have them both as scum reads but she's making solid points and evidently I must be wrong about one of them because it wouldn't make sense otherwise.

Clearly, RTE is setting up both of us knowing that if I flip town, he can push the case against BFG. This should have lock scummed him down. So, is Hallia.

 

Leelou is also town, as she could have easily jumped on my train but didn't.

 

That's from me. You all figure out the others.

 

 

That's not a logical conclusion at all.  You're putting words into RTE's mouth IMO.

[BFG]

Dicetosser1

 

For Clov

[Pralaya]

That's not a logical conclusion at all.  You're putting words into RTE's mouth IMO.

You do not have information that I have - namely my alignment. If you see it based on that, it becomes apparent.

[Cory Caboose]

ISO'd Lazy and i don't know

 

Almost all of his reads are arbitrary. He arbitrary designates Verbal as Mafia and then arbitrarily says he was lying and Verbal is town (because ???) and makes a conditional read on AJ based on Verbal's alignment.

 

All I can really tell is that he's either not reading the thread or he's going onto random.org

 

I do wonder what the point of him even making a reads posts would be if he didn't feel like he needed to look like he was contributing

[BFG]

 

That's not a logical conclusion at all.  You're putting words into RTE's mouth IMO.

You do not have information that I have - namely my alignment. If you see it based on that, it becomes apparent.

 

And if RTE flipped Town?

[Andrej]

Don't like the Pral wagon. If Hallia isn't happening I'll vote Lazy

 

We've got half an hour and I won't have time to peek the thread. VCs!

[Clovdyx]

Heh, as usual, scum take advantage that I am inactive on weekend and push the lynch. Anyway, it doesn't matter. This should only help the town clear out the scum in the game

 

FWIW, BFG is town. This post gave it away.

 

At some point I think we need to stop ignoring BFG's case on Pral. I have them both as scum reads but she's making solid points and evidently I must be wrong about one of them because it wouldn't make sense otherwise.

Clearly, RTE is setting up both of us knowing that if I flip town, he can push the case against BFG. This should have lock scummed him down. So, is Hallia.

 

Leelou is also town, as she could have easily jumped on my train but didn't.

 

That's from me. You all figure out the others.

 

 

 

That's not a logical conclusion at all.  You're putting words into RTE's mouth IMO.

You do not have information that I have - namely my alignment. If you see it based on that, it becomes apparent.

 

 

That's not the issue at all.  You're insinuating that he's saying he can't be wrong about both of you - which he certainly could be.  You're turning his statement into "one must be scum", when it actually says "one must be town".  The case BFG is presenting towards you doesn't make any sense if you're teammates. 

 

On the other hand, there's no reason he can't be wrong in his read about her - making her town.  As she would have no way of knowing YOUR alignment, she (possibly erroneously) reads you as scum and cases you accordingly.  Going with the assumption that she's wrong about you, you are now town. 

 

Now, you are town.  She is town.  His reads are proven false, but his statement remains true - one of you WAS town.

 

TL;DR - One of you HAVING to be town doesn't prevent the other from being town, as well.  One of you being mafia DOES prevent the other from being mafia, too.

[BFG]

Vote count 1.xx Mobile v2

 

Verbal: 1 - Lazy

Cory: 3 - Clov, Tina, Dice

Hallia: 1 - AJ

Lazy: 4 - Nyn, Leelou, Thane, Despo

RTE: 1 - Pral

Pralaya: 4 - BFG, RTE, Hally, Cory

 

With 16 alive, it takes 9 to lynch

 

Not voting: Verbal, Vos

 

Deadline Saturday 7 pm GMT - Day 1 deadline

[Leelou]

AJ - 

 

Unofficial Vote count

Verbal: 1 - Lazy
Cory: 3 - Clov, Tina, Dice
Hallia: 1 - AJ
Lazy: 4 - Nyn, Leelou, Thane, Des
RTE: 1 - Pral
Pralaya: 4 - BFG, RTE, Halley, Cory

With 16 alive, it takes 9 to lynch

Not voting: Verbal, Vos

Deadline Saturday 7 pm GMT - Day 1 deadline 

[Clovdyx]

@AJ:

 

Verb - 1 (Lazy)

Cory- 3 (me, Tina, Dice)

Hallia - 1 (you)

Lazy - 4  (Nyn, Lee, Thane, Des)

RTE - 1 (Pral)

Pral - 4 (BFG, RTE, Hal, Cory)

 

Verbal and Vos not on the board.

[BFG]

24 mins to deadline.

[csarmi]

Zomg.

[csarmi]

Ty guys.

[Cory Caboose]

 

But I´m almost run out of Marvin quotes. :(

 

 

One of the last:

 

Trillian: What are you supposed to do with a manically depressed robot?

Marvin: You think you've got problems. What are you supposed to do if you are a manically depressed robot? No, don't even bother answering. I'm 50,000 times more intelligent than you and even I don't know the answer.

 

 

Des - is BFG still on your scum list?

Yes, as previously stated she is third on my scum list.

 

Just from memory, my list looks something like:

 

CLEAR WARLOCKS:

 

Clov

Verb

Nyn

AJ

Pray

Tina

 

Last two additions cause KaWHI NOT. #YOLOGSGDFF (go spurs go drive for five )

 

LOCH NESS SCUM MONSTERS:

 

 

Cory

Thane

BFG

 

Wary of:

 

Leelou

Hallia

Dice (even with the claim, still worth keeping an eye on)

 

Meh to Null to Whateverish (consider this group slightly townish):

 

Vos

Lazy

RTE

 

And... I think that's everyone. Meh, might as well color this list.

 

 

 

[v]Lazy[/v]

 

I'll switch for consolidation on Cory or Pral. 

 

 

vote Lazy

 

Dice, i don't know what you are doing, but you make me regret unvoting you....

 

 

(Ok, Real Talk: I had about the worst day/night you can imagine due to a co-workers incompetance forcing me to work at 12 hour caregiving shift combined with nanny work.  I feel better today, but I wasn't going to tackle this because with all the high tension in thread)

 

 

Pral: You said my vote on Mish was sheeping? How's that possible when there were only two of us on her?  I don't think that word means what you think it means.

 

Dice:  I buy the claim for now, especially with how fast his train was going up at the time.

 

So between the two left we have a train of Cory/Lazy.  I don't recall much of Lazy's posting, but from reading back, Cory seems to have reigned in the anger some, and is looking more townish.  So for now.

 

Vote: Lazy

 

Also, apparently I'm a thing as well.  I'm Vanilla Town, so that'd kind of be a waste.

 

 

Meh!

 

As well Tina would say. Hate the self-vote and AtE but Blech, I wanna give Cory a lil longer to see if he can rein in his emoness eventually.

 

[unvote]

 

Not feeling the Pray CFD at all. BFG's wots HAVE been off, and the way she has turned into a broken record about him not reading them looked fake to me, moar like scum clinging to one minor thing instead of presenting a convincing case in aggregate.

 

[V]Lazy[/v] cause I think he IS FROZEN after being called out for his possible TMI slip. Ducked out right before EOD and something significant brought against you?

 

#notgood

 

[Leelou]

 

Zomg.

 

 

[ReleaseTheEvil]

 

Heh, as usual, scum take advantage that I am inactive on weekend and push the lynch. Anyway, it doesn't matter. This should only help the town clear out the scum in the game

 

FWIW, BFG is town. This post gave it away.

 

At some point I think we need to stop ignoring BFG's case on Pral. I have them both as scum reads but she's making solid points and evidently I must be wrong about one of them because it wouldn't make sense otherwise.

Clearly, RTE is setting up both of us knowing that if I flip town, he can push the case against BFG. This should have lock scummed him down. So, is Hallia.

 

Leelou is also town, as she could have easily jumped on my train but didn't.

 

That's from me. You all figure out the others.

 

 

 

That's not a logical conclusion at all.  You're putting words into RTE's mouth IMO.

You do not have information that I have - namely my alignment. If you see it based on that, it becomes apparent.

 

 

That's not the issue at all.  You're insinuating that he's saying he can't be wrong about both of you - which he certainly could be.  You're turning his statement into "one must be scum", when it actually says "one must be town".  The case BFG is presenting towards you doesn't make any sense if you're teammates. 

 

On the other hand, there's no reason he can't be wrong in his read about her - making her town.  As she would have no way of knowing YOUR alignment, she (possibly erroneously) reads you as scum and cases you accordingly.  Going with the assumption that she's wrong about you, you are now town. 

 

Now, you are town.  She is town.  His reads are proven false, but his statement remains true - one of you WAS town.

 

TL;DR - One of you HAVING to be town doesn't prevent the other from being town, as well.  One of you being mafia DOES prevent the other from being mafia, too.

 

 

 

This. That was very eloquent and probably better than I could have worded it. Thanks,

 

Of the three trains, my preference is Pral, Lazy and Cory in that order. I should be here at deadline to help. Hope enough people are around.