[Standard] - Hitchhiker's Game to the Galaxy - Game Over

[Cory Caboose]

That was the role PM for every townie in the game.

 

Let Clov tell you more about it.

KOBE

[Thane Vakarian]

thanks AJ

 

I really don't recall anything in particular about Hallia.... i'll try to catch up on her when i got some sleep. This week's been hard, and the weekend won't be much better i fear.

[Hayl3y]

Votecount 1.08

Leelou: 1 - Dice
Verbal: 1 - Lazy
Dice: 4 - Clov, Leelou, Thane, Tina
Thane: 1 - Despo

Despo: 1 - Cory

Hallia: 1 - Andrej

Lazy: 1 - Nyn

With 16 alive, it takes 9 to lynch

Not voting: BFG, Pray, Verbal, Hally, Nervositee, RTE
 
Deadline Saturday 7 pm GMT - Day 1 deadline

 

 

[Nynaeve]

I think Hallia is a good place to start. This type of play is kind of congruent with her meta, but she does it both as town or mafia so there isn't much to differentiate. Looking at the reasons she voted for Mish and how she has responded recently I would lean more towards her being mafia though. Another one of my scum leans, Nyn, voting someone other than her while leaving her at null also interests me. So her coroner would potentially clear up my view on Nyn a bit too.

 

Most seem to disagree with my opinion of Nyn, which is fine. I think the push on Dice was bad but Despo explained the potential thought process behind it pretty well I think. I can see how she could come to that conclusion based on her personal knowledge, but it's the conclusion that I disagree with. Or the implied conclusion anyway.

 

Hallia posts little content regardless of alignment. When she's scum she's more hyper and jokey and as a townie she's more subdued with light joke posts. She hasn't raised any alarms thus far so I'm fine with her.

 

And don't worry about it. Most people seem to disagree with my opinion on you but that doesn't phase me. ;)

 

 

 

Nyn

[Leelou]

Yeah, this day became no fun real fast.

 

...Go to work for one day and the game falls apart. :p

[Clovdyx]

 

Yeah, this day became no fun real fast.

 

...Go to work for one day and the game falls apart. :p

 

 

watido :(

[Cory Caboose]

yeah, what did Clov do?

[BFG]

 

Interesting interlude

[Leelou]

 

 

 

 

Yeah, this day became no fun real fast.

...Go to work for one day and the game falls apart. :p

watido :(

You skipped our couples massage at lunch. You better make it up to me.

[Pralaya]

 

Yeah, this day became no fun real fast.

 

...Go to work for one day and the game falls apart. :p

 

 

All because of 

 

[Nynaeve]

Awe, I miss Dawn.

 

 

 

Nyn

[Hayl3y]

lol ! *applauds Pray*

 

 

and a gift from ur mod for this

 

[Hallia]

Been doing what I can, been so super busy it's not even funny >.< 12 hour shift today due to stupid caregivers.  I'll post more of a catch up tonight, but been trying to read the thread.  Blow up between Des/Cory is likely town on town.  I <3 Cory, but the whole getting angry thing makes me shy away in general.  Also, the last time I saw his play so impassioned he was scum.  He's likely town after the claim, but still.  

[Pralaya]

Town: 

 

Nyn

Des

Verbal

Clov

Tina

 

Town Lean:

Andrej

Thane

Dice

Pral

Corey

 

Null:

 

Vos

Leelou

 

Scum lean:

 

BFG - Something seems off about her posting and moreso the content. Like the ISO someone did on her. Don't like what I see  from it.

Hallia - Too much sheeping, not enough reads and independent thinking. Or posting for that matter.

Lazy - That ISO by Nyn was great. Lazy has been posting much ado about nothing at all and it escaped me till 

 

Anyway, back to business.

 

What is really apparent from this list is that you have more or less the active players as town and the less active posters as scum. I don't exactly like it because it looks to me as if you are trying to target a least-resistance path. 

[Hallia]

That is indeed.  It always seems strange for people to do that, because mafia members can often be just as active (if not moreso) than townies.

[Pralaya]

lol ! *applauds Pray*

 

 

and a gift from ur mod for this

 

 

In Flames - awesome !

 

(Unfortunately, I cannot listen now as my baby is sleeping and i dont have my headphones :(   )

[Nynaeve]

corycurren 194 Nynaeve 146 Leelou 114 Verbal32 114 Andrej 80 Despothera 72 Clovdyx 50 BFG 47 Thane Vakarian 44 csarmi 36 Lazy 29 ReleaseTheEvil 27 TinaHel 18 dicetosser1 16 Hallia 15 Pralaya 13 Chaelca 12 Misheru 9 nervositee 3

 

For reference.

 

 

 

 

Nyn

[Leelou]

Hallia - reads

[BFG]

I'm breaking Nyn's post up to answer.

 

BFG - 46 posts.

 

 

20 fluff posts where she's doing the rhyming thing. She actually posts all of these in the space of 3 hours on the 20th. At one point Verbal questions her if it's a PR and she says it's just for fun.

 

She's completely AWOL on the 21th. Not sure if she had a busy IRL but she didn't mention anything so her absence seemed to stand out after her burst of posting. Especially since things were taking a serious tone and her lack of input is bothersome.

Minor point, from my time zone I was around very late on the 21st, was why my posts then were so hurried.

 

1 post of her welcoming Vos yesterday.

 

1 post where she says she likes the exchange between Clov and Leelou and agrees with Leelou that if she had a vig shot she would shoot Des, but disagrees about Thane. She asks Clov if he agrees with her on Des. Points at Lazy's OP as best, RTE's as worst. Then she prods Leelou twice. First for her lack of reaction to tina's vote, even though she responded to Verbal's... and secondly because of Leelou's response to me that didn't make sense. Only Leelou already explained these points earlier. So not sure why she brought it up again.

To expand. It's actually Des's second post that stood out when he said he was catching up, it seemed unusually self conscious.

 

I asked Clov because it seemed strange that he ignored Leelou's other choice.

 

I'll get back to the OP later.

 

At this stage I was reading the thread, and grabbing posts as I went so I hadn't got to her response yet.

 

 

1 fluff post.

 

1 post of her prodding at Des again. She says he misreped Leelou in his case, in regards to her interaction with Verbal once he votes her, her lack of response to tina's vote on her and saying that she mentioned PRs loads when she only did it twice. This bothers her. Seems weird to me since she was questioning Lee about some of this as well and prodding her 15 minutes before that. lol

I pointed out the stuff in Des's case that I didn't like. I also stated that the second part made more sense, which includes the stuff I was asking Leelou about.

 

1 fluff post.

 

1 post of her questioning Thane on what interesting reads he's seen, since he was vague and didn't expand. She quotes dice's post where he's voting Leelou for no reason. Aka she quotes it and says "This is an early vote from dice". No insight that follows. Okaaaaaaaaaaay. She also prods Pral to participate more and share his thoughts.

Violins, but this was posted just before 2. At that stage Dice's vote stood out. I have never seen Dice vote that early and didn't/don't know how to interpret it, I'm still waiting for more data. I also stated that I didn't understand why he answered/unanswered for Leelou, I think Clov asked this as well, but I'll need to check to see if he ever answered.

 

1 fluff post.

 

1 post of her quoting dice's vote on Lee again. Only this time she asks why dice thinks it makes Lee too knowing and not AJ or Verb, both of who have brought up the possiblity of a PR first. This is actually an excellent point.

 

1 post of her saying she's not following Des at all about his read on Clov. She quoted him some to show why. I THINK what she's trying to convey is that I joked about lynching all the girls, clov followed up and said that we should lynch all the guys and Des FOSed clov for it, but not me. I think it's a valid point to make.

Thanks.

 

It's actually about the timing of the Clov/Des comments, Des vote... I'll get back to this as well, as Des has also replied to this since.

 

1 fluff post.

 

1 post of her saying that she's getting a town lean on me and Tina. Leelou as well, but with a couple of reservations. She questions Leelou again about her interaction with me and how she out of the blue questioned me if she should have a scum or town read on me already. Again, Leelou already explained it. Either BFG missed it or she's choosing to ignore it. Not sure which it is.

I didn't understand why Leelou stating that it was too early for people to have a read on her explained why she was questioning if she should have a read on you.

 

1 post of her fosing RTE for claiming she's been posting more than she usually does. She explains her schedule. Reads genuine to me.

 

 

Some bla bla posts (yes, I'm getting tired lol).

 

1 post where she questions dice again, pointing out how odd it is that he remembers well enough to name Leelou, but not the other people that were talking about it. Valid point, as I mentioned before. She even quotes all the PR mentions by peeps.

Wasn't all the PR mentions, just some to get a sense of the discussion.

 

1 post of her responding to Des where she says she simply mentioned her like/dislike to lazy and RTE's ops. That it didn't mean mafia/town reads. I'm actually surprised that she had to clarify this. Who's gonna determine a lean based on OP alone? *shrugs*

 

1 post congratulating Lee.

 

1 post where she clarifies to Verb her stance on dice. That is seemed weird that he has a selective memory but that ultimately it's all null, given the context of conversation and fluff at the time. I don't really agree with her on this.

The null bit was my opinion of the conversation around the possible PRs. Not around Dice. If you read the thread around the initial PR discussion , other than that it was mostly fluff, so the PR talk didn't distract from other gameplay. I also think Tina, Mish's and mine posts were all meant as fun. I'm not so sure about RTE's since it's making it harder to read his posts, but he's implied it's from the mods, so meh.

 

1 post of her asking Thane to expand on his scum leans after he delivers a read list.

 

1 post of her pointing out Verb and Leelou's interactions and points out that Des saying that Leelou ignored Verb till the Spiderman gifs is false.

 

2 Des related posts: http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/89426-standard-hitchhikers-game-to-the-galaxy-day-one/page-39?do=findComment&comment=3254685

 

http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/89426-standard-hitchhikers-game-to-the-galaxy-day-one/page-40?do=findComment&comment=3254736

 

I kind of see where BFG is going with these two posts, but it's not entirely clear, so I rather not give my take on it till she clarifies what she meant.

I'll get back to this as well. Some of it is a repeat of earlier stuff, as it was an (evidently failed) attempt to clarify my points to Des.

 

@BFG, I found that a lot of times you display quotes and say very little. If you could explain in your own words more it would really go a long way to understanding the point you're trying to get across. I struggled with it a bit when I was reading your posts... took me a while to get what you were trying to convey. Which is a shame cause people might be missing legit points or misinterpreting you.

 

 

All in all I haven't played with BFG before, so I don't know her meta. She had fun at first like we all do at the beginning of D1. I didn't love the fact that she was absent when the whole dice/mish trains formed but she showed up later and poked at previous events, so that makes up for it imo. It seems to me that she shifted into gear and had some really good finds and points. She's been poking around quite a few people Des, dice, Thane, Leelou. I think she's probably wrong about Des but I like the way she's casing him. I want to see more of her but right now I feel a bit better about her than I did before the ISO.

 

 

 

 

Nyn

I'll be back in an hour to finish responding, but if you have other questions let me know

[Nynaeve]

1 post of her fosing RTE for claiming she's been posting more than she usually does. She explains her schedule. Reads genuine to me.

 

 

 

 

In case this was misinterpreted I'll clarify. Your response seemed genuine. So not sure why the annoyed smiley.

 

 

 

Nyn

[BFG]

 

 

1 post of her fosing RTE for claiming she's been posting more than she usually does. She explains her schedule. Reads genuine to me.

 

 

In case this was misinterpreted I'll clarify. Your response seemed genuine. So not sure why the annoyed smiley.

 

 

 

Nyn

 

That was meant for RTE's original post. Communication clearly isn't my thing this game.

[Nynaeve]

xD

 

 

 

Nyn

[Leelou]

I still don't understand how the hell des bugged you that much.

 

I'm bored at the train station.

[BFG]

I still don't understand how the hell des bugged you that much.

 

I'm bored at the train station.

Is that to me or Cory?

 

How's work gone?

[Leelou]

I don't think I agree with pral's reads, but I have to wait until there is wifi on the train or I get home to read them all.