[Advanced] X-Men: Rise of Apocalypse - GAME OVER

[hazelkrs1]

Mafia = Mish, CS, Dice, Krak.

 

BOOM.

 

Did I win Verbal?

[csarmi]

@Despo - I don't have a read on Mish.

 

I believe her claim, however. I have no reason to think that Mish is scum - your arguments certainly didn't convince me.

[hazelkrs1]

@Despo - I don't have a read on Mish.

 

I believe her claim, however. I have no reason to think that Mish is scum - your arguments certainly didn't convince me.

 

Then you're either scum or just being willfully obtuse.

 

And you just SAID you thought both me and Mish were town. I.e. you DO have a read on her, town. If you didn't, you wouldn't consider us both town.

 

I think you're just trying to be as difficult as possible to see if I have a conniption in the hopes that it will throw my game off.

[csarmi]

Hilarious cause you were trying to breadcrumb a case about me being mafia before, now you're trying to act like you had me pegged as town the whole time. LAWLZ.

I had you pegged down as town ever since you claimed lovers and Mish confirmed the lover story.

I never had any reason to believe you were scum and never tried to imply anything like that. If that's what you got from our argument, you just have dumb brains.

 

I argued that your argument was stupid. Still is.

 

Also don't think that Mish has done NEAR enough for you to have a town read on her. She's pretty much lurked, nudged two separate trains near deadline yesterday, and then essentially claims miller after I out her. You REALLY think that's townie type behavior? Nope. You don't. You're her teammate trying to crisis-manage.

Mish's play is a null tell for me. But I have a very good reason to believe her claim.

 

I want to lynch someone I think is scum, so that I can then have a shot to potentially take out more scum. Without coroner reports, you can't be dainty here. Only way to see if town wins is to make a few bodies until Verbal decides to give us more info, or tells us we win.

Seriously, I think you should start thinking about how this game might work. Stop and think.

[csarmi]

Mafia = Mish, CS, Dice, Krak.

 

BOOM.

 

Did I win Verbal?

Why is RTE missing from your list?

[dicetosser1]

mish said something that makes me believe she is town.  You havent des

[csarmi]

Dice - so do you believe Despo is scum and wants to get his lover lynched on purpose so that he gets a shot or smth?

Cause I don't see how it makes sense for him to claim lovers otherwise (if he is scum, which I doubt).

[michellem]

Csarmi, if you have a "very good reason to think I'm town", then please just say so, instead of hinting. I have no idea how to save myself from a lynch now, and normally I wouldn't care, but right now if I die, there's a big risk we loose three townies, I'm town, and if Des is town and uses his vengeance kill, there is a big chance he'll shoot a townie too.

 

Another option Des, is this. We lynch you, and I'll sacrifice myself for you. If I'm mafia and lying, you'll get your way either way; I'll be lynched tomorrow. But this way, one of us might stay alive, and you have shown clearly that you're not willing to let that be me.

[csarmi]

Mish - I believe you're town because of your miller claim.

I'm adding that up with RTE's similar claim and what we know of the game so far and I find it very likely that both of you are telling the truth about that.

 

That, added to the fact that Verb would wanna mess with us.

 

I do not know that you're town, but it's a quite good working assumption for now.

[Leelou]

MOD NOTE:

 

Do not reveal your alignment in your bah posts

[csarmi]

That'd be nice, we got enough WiFoM already, we don't need dead people to WiFoM us more with bah posts :)

[Leelou]

Vote Count

 

Salami (1) - Lily

Lily (1) - Darthe

Mish (1) - Des

 

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

[ReleaseTheEvil]

I'm around and following the thread.

 

Just need the time to sit down and sort out my thoughts but will post soon.

[Verbal32]

 

 

My victory is just that much closer....

[Verbal32]

@Mods: Any particular reason that the phrasing of Pralaya's death says "is dead" while the others say "has been killed?"

 

Well, that's easy, it's because of the..............oh, you almost got me.  Nice try!

 

/DPR'ed

[Verbal32]

Only way to see if town wins is to make a few bodies

 

I like what you're thinking.  Let the bodies hit the floor!

[Leelou]

And I now have that song stuck in my head. Thanks, hon.

[WWWwombat]

Not digging Despo's flavorspec, but he might be right about Dap/Pralaya being lovers or siblings.

 

As long as you are flavorspeccing, Despo, why do you think Shadowcat would be mafia if this is Days of Future Past?  I haven't read much Marvel, but I can wiki as well as the next guy.

 

Also, Verbal has been planning a bastard X-Men game for a loooong time so I wouldn't bring current developments into it.

[WWWwombat]

Mish - I believe you're town because of your miller claim.

I'm adding that up with RTE's similar claim and what we know of the game so far and I find it very likely that both of you are telling the truth about that.

 

That, added to the fact that Verb would wanna mess with us.

 

I do not know that you're town, but it's a quite good working assumption for now.

 

That is a terrible reason to think someone is town btw.  It was quite clear from the start of this game that cop viewings would be extremely unreliable.  Coming up with a Miller claim as scum would be easy-peasy.

[csarmi]

@Wombat - maybe, but we only got two such claims for now.

 

Seeing how our PM looks like, it's a natural assumption that there would be at least a couple of cross-aligned players (I couldn't find a better word for it for now - players that have their "alignment / appear as" values different).

 

My current assumption is that there are at least 2-3 "millers" and 1-2 "godfathers".

 

If more such claims come, I'll revise my theory. But for now, it seems to be a pretty good assumption.

[WWWwombat]

And if you were non-Godfather mafia being pressured, wouldn't you claim miller?  Therefore Miller claims are pretty much null in this game right now.

[csarmi]

And if you were non-Godfather mafia being pressured, wouldn't you claim miller?  Therefore Miller claims are pretty much null in this game right now.

Maybe.

I disagree that Miller claims are pretty much null. Not at the moment anyway.

 

Do you think that everyone has claimed Miller by now?

[csarmi]

In other words - would you have claimed now already if you were a miller?

[WWWwombat]

Maybe, maybe not.

[csarmi]

Why yes and why no?