Greek Mythology: Man Vs. Gods [Advanced] - GAME OVER - TOWN WINS!

[csarmi]

Dice can ONLY be in love with MAFIA at this stage if Mish flips 3rd party, assuming a town Lover wouldn't lie about Coroner.

 

There are only 3 teams, Mafia, Town, Lovers, and 1 3rd party. That makes any non-town remaining Liars Mafia.

 

Ergo I believe they should out. Dice is dead anyway.

I think something's iffy here. I know that a Town Coroner being in the game is not exactly a given, but it's very likely, knowing that there was a Janitor.

This makes me think that's something doesn't add up here.

 

Maybe Dice asked the wrong question, or didn't interpret the answers 100% right. Maybe he's lying. Maybe the mod didn't include that role at all - knowing full well that people would count on it.

[csarmi]

By the way: if we want to follow Darthe's plan (I think we shouldn't, I find Cloud a better lynch), we shouldn't hurry with the lynch, more time = more time for Dice to ask questions.

[Thorum]

Good luck, RTE !

[berf]

CS you can see that there is a lot of WIFOM surrounding the Oracle, yes?

 

Can you understand the benefits of this game needing some information locked down at this stage?

 

How much further use can the oracle be, WITH a 3rd party/Mafia Lover, compared to the value gained from knowing if the information is true or not?

 

At this stage, if we are sniffing at false trails, we need to know.

[WWWwombat]

Omg Salami is still spamming drivel.

 

I don't see where Darthe said Dice's lover is town. It looks to me like she's mafia.

 

Lynching a claimed survivor is almost always a good idea. Survivor can win with mafia.

 

Semi-open setups are not imbalanced in general, but they are more pro-town than they would be closed. I suspect that is why the mafia had a Janitor this game. Janitor is a good way to give the mafia fake claims in an open setup. All mafia needs to do is Janitor a power role. Too bad for them we lynched Despo D1.

[WWWwombat]

I suspect Csarmi is Dice's scum lover and is therefore slightly biased with regards to this issue.

[csarmi]

Where am I spamming drivel, Wombat?

 

CS you can see that there is a lot of WIFOM surrounding the Oracle, yes?

 

Can you understand the benefits of this game needing some information locked down at this stage?

 

How much further use can the oracle be, WITH a 3rd party/Mafia Lover, compared to the value gained from knowing if the information is true or not?

 

At this stage, if we are sniffing at false trails, we need to know.

I can.

 

But as I said before - and I'm holding to it:

 

1) I don't think lynching a survivor is a good idea at this point (and no I believe that the survivor's claimed role is more likely to help town than to hurt it).

2) As I explained above, I'm not convinced that Dice's lover is maffia.

 

 

Omg Salami is still spamming drivel.

 

I don't see where Darthe said Dice's lover is town. It looks to me like she's mafia.

I don't think "Darthe said that Dice's lover is town". I certainly didn't mean to give such words into Darthe's mouth. I think Dice's lover is probably town.

 

Lynching a claimed survivor is almost always a good idea. Survivor can win with mafia.

Only if the survivor might be a maffia false claiming too, or if the town is in a relatively bad position. As long as town is up, we can trust a survivor to make their best to help town win.

 

Semi-open setups are not imbalanced in general, but they are more pro-town than they would be closed. I suspect that is why the mafia had a Janitor this game. Janitor is a good way to give the mafia fake claims in an open setup. All mafia needs to do is Janitor a power role. Too bad for them we lynched Despo D1.

A good point. But how would the maffia know there was no town coroner in the game? Because Dice's lover haven't been CC'd.

Just a ballsy move to try and claim that?

 

Do you really find it likely that there's no town coroner in the game with a Janitor around?

[csarmi]

Because Dice's lover haven't been CC'd. <-- I mean Dice's lover haven't been CC'd on the Coroner role, of course.

[WWWwombat]

In my experience, Janitor appears without a Coroner as often as it does with a Coroner. But that's not very relevant.

 

Dice claims there is no Coroner. Either Dice is lying and needs to die, or Dice's lover is lying and needs to die. Time to kill two birds with one stone.

[WWWwombat]

And you are spamming drivel all over. Your points are awful and you take way too much space to make them.

 

Anyways, time for a 7 hour car ride and my phone has limited juice, so peace.

[berf]

And a mixed up Lover story never = good news. I suspect we're in for some chop.

[WWWwombat]

Hopefully we don't suffer terrible terrible damage.

[ReleaseTheEvil]

Do you guys want the result and me to write the scene later? I would have to wait a couple of hours.

[berf]

OH GOD YES.

[berf]

Wait...

[berf]

YES

[ReleaseTheEvil]

If I hear yes from a few more people I'll do it. If not you wait for the scene.

 

Sorry, on top of everything today (which turned out ok) I'm moving today but that shouldn't be too bad.

[csarmi]

I'd prefer the result now and the scene later. But it's absolutely your call. We can certainly wait a couple of hours.

[berf]

Holy hell. Good look with that.

 

What a game

[ReleaseTheEvil]

Ah I'll let you guys get on with it. Result coming up. I'll add scene later. Be sure to read it, I take time with those things.

[ReleaseTheEvil]

She was the first. She was their punishment. She was to punish them for the theft. For His theft.

 

"Gifts" they said. And in this little pretty box... But she was not to open it...

 

How could they think to give her such a precious box and expect her not to open it?

 

She knew she shouldn't... They warned her...

 

But she was only human after all... The first woman....

 

Maybe if she only took a peek...

 

And a peek she did take... And that was all it took...

 

Released were all the evils of humanity... and trapped in the box she finally closed all too late...

 

...Hope...

 

 

Mish - Pandora - Third-Party Survivor Clumsy Switch has been lynched.

 

It is now Night. You have 24 hours to get all Night Actions in.

 

Scene will be up soonish.

[Darthe]

Not bad.

 

And that pic woukd make a good siggy

[berf]

ooooooooooh.

 

 

 

CS = Mafia. Earlier God reveal by MCS should never have slipped the radar. What purpose does MCS have for claiming this? nil. Lynchable right there, but combined with the recent chainsaw defense of a 3rd party, well that is asking too many questions for me to find answers too without killing at this stage. 

Thorum = verdict is out. But with our 1 third party gone (pending Dice flipping true) and no CC you look better and better. My god do you sow some WIFOM you son of a bitch.

Dice = thanks for all the fish or so long you devil. Either Oracle or Mafia. Leaning Oracle based on below

Wombat - making the right wombatty moves for the most part.

Darthe Turning up to fight the good fight at the end, brownie points there. Still some near interesting votes coming forth at times, but leaning town. Don't know why we need to kill the Oracle either, on second thought... (See Below)

Cloud - A very strange end of D1 but mostly leaning town scapegoat. D1 end itself though along with the info on all your trains make you someone to look at later if all other leads come up empty.

Tina - Good casing if infrequent but has been busy. Town.

Praya - unfocused town, but posting on the most random of things, and might have missed the entire Mish reveal... Unknown quantity, especially given the Thorum situation with the shot.

Ithi - TAF 4EVA

Halli - Town but come on girl work that grey matter

Krak + Song- Who?

 

 

 

WHY ARE WE LYNCHING THE ORACLE BY THE WAY? -----> MISH WAS NOT TOWN AND CLUMSY SWITCH - DICE MUST HAVE GAINED THAT INFO SOMEHOW.

[Darthe]

Because we need clarity, lover is likely mafia so he can't live anyhow, and Oracle doesn't have to be a town aligned role.

[Darthe]

Btw, if you believe Dice then shouldn't you believe that the titans and Thorum are tfs?