SCOOBY GAME THREAD - TOWN WINS

[Mafia-8]

A bus drive could make sense in an effort to create a false read.  If you are scum trying to create a false read, you swap at least one scum with one Town.  But yeah.  I have no idea.  Something tells me one of Miner, Creeper, or Tar Monster is scum.

[Mafia-1]

Vote Black Knight

 

He's a  lying sack of scum.

 

 

Vote Black Knight

 

Liar is a liar.

 

100%

 

 

Well. See Jaguaro here proves my point. A lying scumbag.

 

 

 

I'm assuming that steal ability is for roles. Unless someone randomly has a steal ability as well and stole it successfully or Mr. Jaguar here was blocked for some reason, it seems to me that Black Knight is lying. My reasoning is the stalled out lynch yesterday.

 

I'm interested in what Knight has to say about all of this though.

 

Interesting.

 

1) You called Black Knight a liar before Jaguaro told us about his steal attempt.

2) If there is someone else out there with stealing ability, well, Black Knight would be a likely target.

3) There are more ways for a NA to fail: JAGUARO - what were you told exactly?

 

 

 

 

Vote Black Knight

 

He's a  lying sack of scum.

 

I'm assuming that steal ability is for roles. Unless someone randomly has a steal ability as well and stole it successfully or Mr. Jaguar here was blocked for some reason, it seems to me that Black Knight is lying. My reasoning is the stalled out lynch yesterday.

 

I'm interested in what Knight has to say about all of this though.

 

Which one is it now?

 

 

 

I know how we can resolve this.

 

We kill it.

 

 

 

vote black knight

 

FOS: Ptero + Tard

 

This is what was going on while Mummy was stalling.

[Mafia-8]

At Coffin and Bird Brain, you are missing some crucial information in your scum read on Black Knight.  Exposing Mummy makes no sense plus he has a potential cop clear.

[Mafia-8]

Ninjaed/misunderstood.

 

I'm good with looking at Tar and Ptero.

[Mafia-1]

 

I can verify that there are other thief roles in this game as I had something else stolen from me.

 

So, scum will have to kill me tonight.

 

Lynch Charlie tomorrow.

This guys scum. He never mentioned me before this then out of nowhere tells you to lynch me because I vote him. Also, with multiple thief roles revealed its an easy claim for him to make and likely something the mafia would have anyhow, but worse than all of that is the bolded.

 

What makes him think that he is worth killing? Relatively low contribution and kosher standpoints combined with poor logic means that he should be their best friend.

 

 

I agree with Charlie, Jaguaro is scum.

 

I'm a tracker, and I'm town. I've given my results and I'll leave it to Mummy to confirm or deny. If he answers poorly then I'll reveal the info I got from him. For you viewing me as town, what do you want me to say? I'm not? I'm f***ing town.

Here is the reveal from BK.

 

 

Black Knight votes = people that deserve to die.

Mafia Godfather.  Nuff said.

 

Here is Jaguaro, creating a basis for continuing to vote BK.

 

@Black Knight - would you please full claim for us?  100% honesty is the only thing that will save your hide.

 

Thanks.

Here is Jaguaro role fishing, for details from BK - which would afford scum a better context for fake reveal.

 

FOLKS, we got magistrates, pick the train speeds up, if DPR gives us more than one possible lynch a day, that's for a good reason - we'll need it.

Here is Werewolf trying to hurry things up, before Mummy comes back and has to reveal.

 

Well that clears Black Knight completly. Thanks DPR and Pterowhatever (I'm just gonna call you Peter from here). 

 

Now here's something interesting for you all. The wolfie PMed me this:

 

"Hello, Any way we can confirm that you did a CopX1 indeed on TBK? Did you message TBK about it btw? Wolfy"

 

And then this:

 

"FYI: PM's can be shared, it can be used for things as "Last Will" and more, if done properly."

 

I replied with this:

 

"How you expect me to confirm it I have no idea; we're not allowed to quote communications with the mod. Why would I message the black knight about it? And why are you asking me this in PM instead of the open thread, hm?"

 

No answer yet. 

 

 

So... Why indeed feel the need to ask those things in PM? And why is he fishing for if I have more than one cop shot? FOS on the Werewolf. 

 

Now I'm gonna 

 

Vote Mummy 

 

Now that we know theBlack Knight can be trusted, I'm more and more worried about his viewing on the Mummy. Seeing a person visit several people can mean a mafia that has a PR + submitted the mafia kill. I want the Mummy to get in here and answer some questions pronto. 

Phantom makes strong case for voting Mummy, and believing BK.

 

Fair points to me Phantom Pain.

 

Vote Mummy

Then Ptero, my other suspect coming out of D2, votes Mummy - stinks like a bus vote.

 

I don't think Black Knight is cleared.  Just that pursuing him at this stage in the game is counter-productive. 

Ghost - undermining BK, this was argued about already - he says move-on for now, but not before he casts doubt on whether we should believe BK. Comes across as seeding doubt, and hedging in case momentum swings back to BK (perhaps after the pending reveal from Mummy).

 

Convinced that Ghost is scum, or has been basically making the game easier for them.

 

Yea it would be damned nice if we knew that PHANTOM was town. I don't think we do. But his reveal looks genuine.

Hated this post, it implies we lynch Phantom to vet BK, and leave Mummy alive to be dealth with later. Let's play this out... we lynch Phantom, then what? Someone I'm sure would point out that it doesn't really vet anyone, and then Mummy remains a question and walks away from the situation.

 

Unvote

 

I may have jumped the gun a bit on Black Knight. I didn't like his game, saw him as scum, then wasn't able to steal his role and assumed it was bogus. *shrug*

 

You live you learn.

 

On a first read?

 

What stands out to me the most is that MUMMY isn't talking on D2.

This is a good point. Mummy isn't talking. At all. Are you pushing this angle because you know he has been silenced by one of your scum buddies?

 

Vote Wax Phantom

 

I would like to know the tracking information on mummy if he doesn't respond by the end of the day tomorrow [real time not mafia time].

 

This post, especially the blue, is absolutely disgusting. I threw the "silencer" thing out there first, knowing full well if Mummy ended up as scum, there'd be some scum pig that runs with it. Tar Monster knew not to bite on it, perhaps knowing I like zee trapz... but this guy bit, hook, line and sinker.

 

Jaguaro might actually be my #1 suspect right now.

[Mafia-1]

At Coffin and Bird Brain, you are missing some crucial information in your scum read on Black Knight.  Exposing Mummy makes no sense plus he has a potential cop clear.

 

I do not read BK as scum, not sure wtf you are talking about there. LOL

[Mafia-1]

I can't keep my re-read going, don't have time this morning - the outcome so far is that we should be hunting from the pack of Jaguaro, Ptero, Ghost and Tar.

 

If I had time I could probably isolate 1-2 more players, I can't right now though. Apologies.

[Mafia-1]

Oh, a couple more observations from my 2nd window before I get to work here... 

 

Vote Ghost

 

 

A) we need a lynch

B) I don't want to blind lynch this Mummy situation away

C) FOS on Dr Coffin dependendt on the flip.

 

Didn't like this post at all, 1000 volts has sounded very pro-town throughout things, but here he/she diverts from the Mummy lynch by voting Ghost, but then attributing the vote on Ghost to worrying about deadline, and then he/she hedges by making statement about NOT wanting to blind lynch the Mummy situation away... and then basically sets up a lynch on me next, if Ghost flips town. 

 

Can't be too concerned about the Mummy situations, if you are voting Ghost and using it to frame me. This post alone makes me feel like Ghost is probably town, and you are not.

 

Alright, Black Knight, it has been long enough.  Who did Mummy visit?

Still pining for more info from BK - again, info would help scum prepare an adequate false claim.

 

DR ZAIUS COFFIN is doing his stupid Ape scum thing. He makes terrible cases and won't shut up when they get destroyed. Anyone who defends against him is OMGUSing and anyone else he ignores. But he accuses other of cratering. LOL. What a clown.

Yes, I made an OMGUS vote on DR COFFIN for lulz. The I removed it (which he FoS too because he's a stupid monkey). That doesn't mean he gets to call everything I say against him as OMGUS even when I'm not voting him.

HUGD FOS on everyone pushing the Silencer angle. If you had actually read the thread you would know that Mummy has posted once today. It was early on and about a stupid clown outfit and how it clashes or something.

False meta about how I play, and complete drivel about what I can and cannot call OMGUS, what a pansy.

 

Also, I don't get the impression at all that this goon is reading the thread, but he was quick to point out that Mummy posted already, which is why I feel like Tar went the bus route from the get-go on Mummy.

 

Anyway, current list: Jaguaro, Volt, Ptero as my top 3, and Tar and Ghost on the bubble.

 

Happy hunting peeps!!! 

[Mafia-14]

I wasn't able to get back online yesterday. Interesting attempt from Mummy I see. (By that I mean claiming a role nobody's heard of).

 

Dr. Coffin makes some good points about Jag.

[Mafia-1]

Werewolf is the one I forgot. He's the one that was trying to encourage speed lynching while Mummy stalled. 

 

In fact no, my list: Jaguaro, Volt, Ptero, Werewolf --- with Tar and Ghost on bubble.

 

Okay - out.

[Mafia-8]

No Dr. Coffin doesn't make any good points about Jaguaro at all.  Jaguaro is mod confirmed Town.  His play is also as Town as Town can be.

 

Creepy Heap acting like Coffin makes good points is scummy.

 

I had a conversation with Jaguaro.  He knows who stole his role.  He told me what role was stolen.  So if either of us are NKed, the other will still be able to verify the third person if they choose to use Jag's former ability and if it nets us scum.  Jags had a conversation with mod and had it confirmed that an ability may exist where someone can take over another person's account.  Keep that in mind as you PM each other.  I'm deleting all my conversations and keeping copies of those messages in a notepad.txt file.

[Mafia-1]

No Dr. Coffin doesn't make any good points about Jaguaro at all.  Jaguaro is mod confirmed Town.  His play is also as Town as Town can be.

 

Creepy Heap acting like Coffin makes good points is scummy.

 

I had a conversation with Jaguaro.  He knows who stole his role.  He told me what role was stolen.  So if either of us are NKed, the other will still be able to verify the third person if they choose to use Jag's former ability and if it nets us scum.  Jags had a conversation with mod and had it confirmed that an ability may exist where someone can take over another person's account.  Keep that in mind as you PM each other.  I'm deleting all my conversations and keeping copies of those messages in a notepad.txt file.

 

I didn't see where this happened, can you point it out? I skim over the mod's posts when re-reading, tbh.

[Mafia-10]

 

Why is this all familiar to me. It's as if I've seen this game already. Only déjá vu?

 

-----------

 

Now what sort of role targets three people? Or multiple people. for that matter.

 

Care to explain to those of us who aren't feeling déjá vu?

 

 

 

 

Why is this all familiar to me. It's as if I've seen this game already. Only déjá vu?

 

-----------

 

Now what sort of role targets three people? Or multiple people. for that matter.

 

Care to explain to those of us who aren't feeling déjá vu?

 

This made me laugh :)

[Mafia-18]

I agree with Charlie, Jaguaro is scum.

Jaguaro is quite unlikely to be scum. He was the first one coming out with a stealing on TBK, and someone viewed him town. Note that it is not impossible however, the scum were probably told about the stealfest and by the time Jag's view was posted, 1xCop views must have been easy to fake too.

 

 

FOLKS, we got magistrates, pick the train speeds up, if DPR gives us more than one possible lynch a day, that's for a good reason - we'll need it.

Here is Werewolf trying to hurry things up, before Mummy comes back and has to reveal.

 

Here is Werewolf trying to hurry things up. So do you think time should stand still because someone is stalling? 

 

 

Yea it would be damned nice if we knew that PHANTOM was town. I don't think we do. But his reveal looks genuine.

Hated this post, it implies we lynch Phantom to vet BK, and leave Mummy alive to be dealth with later. Let's play this out... we lynch Phantom, then what? Someone I'm sure would point out that it doesn't really vet anyone, and then Mummy remains a question and walks away from the situation.

 

At first I didn't even understand how you could come to that conclusion. No, I'm not suggesting that we lynch Phantom at all. Actually, I think that was suggested by Phantom himself.

[Mafia-1]

 

I agree with Charlie, Jaguaro is scum.

Jaguaro is quite unlikely to be scum. He was the first one coming out with a stealing on TBK, and someone viewed him town. Note that it is not impossible however, the scum were probably told about the stealfest and by the time Jag's view was posted, 1xCop views must have been easy to fake too.

 

 

FOLKS, we got magistrates, pick the train speeds up, if DPR gives us more than one possible lynch a day, that's for a good reason - we'll need it.

Here is Werewolf trying to hurry things up, before Mummy comes back and has to reveal.

 

Here is Werewolf trying to hurry things up. So do you think time should stand still because someone is stalling? 

 

 

Yea it would be damned nice if we knew that PHANTOM was town. I don't think we do. But his reveal looks genuine.

Hated this post, it implies we lynch Phantom to vet BK, and leave Mummy alive to be dealth with later. Let's play this out... we lynch Phantom, then what? Someone I'm sure would point out that it doesn't really vet anyone, and then Mummy remains a question and walks away from the situation.

 

At first I didn't even understand how you could come to that conclusion. No, I'm not suggesting that we lynch Phantom at all. Actually, I think that was suggested by Phantom himself.

 

 

As I said above, I don't see where Jaguaro was modconfirmed - missed it playing unspin the BS from Ghost probably.

 

I didn't say time needed to stand still, don't try and spin it into me exaggerating the fact that you made over 5 posts urging us to hurry up and lynch someone, not Mummy, while the majority of us were waiting to see what Mummy had to say for himself after BK gave his results. Given that Mummy was mafia, I don't think I should need to tell you how it looks.

 

I also don't think I should have to tell you how it looks when you make the statement "it would be nice if we knew Phantom was town", because you know as well as I do there's only one true way to find that out. 

 

Take some accountability for your statements.

[BLACK KNIGHT mafia]

 

I agree with Charlie, Jaguaro is scum.

Jaguaro is quite unlikely to be scum. He was the first one coming out with a stealing on TBK, and someone viewed him town. Note that it is not impossible however, the scum were probably told about the stealfest and by the time Jag's view was posted, 1xCop views must have been easy to fake too.

 

Indeed. And who did you view?

[Mafia-18]

No Dr. Coffin doesn't make any good points about Jaguaro at all.  Jaguaro is mod confirmed Town.  His play is also as Town as Town can be.

Mod confirmed town?!

 

Creepy Heap acting like Coffin makes good points is scummy.

 

I had a conversation with Jaguaro.  He knows who stole his role.  He told me what role was stolen.  So if either of us are NKed, the other will still be able to verify the third person if they choose to use Jag's former ability and if it nets us scum.

If you say so. But you seem to have strange ideas on verification. Especially if we consider the next part of your post.

 

Jags had a conversation with mod and had it confirmed that an ability may exist where someone can take over another person's account.  Keep that in mind as you PM each other.  I'm deleting all my conversations and keeping copies of those messages in a notepad.txt file.

I hate this. Sawing mistrust. Sounds scummy. Also if you're deleting all your PM conversations, you won't be able to confirm anything, ever.

[Mafia-18]

 

 

I agree with Charlie, Jaguaro is scum.

Jaguaro is quite unlikely to be scum. He was the first one coming out with a stealing on TBK, and someone viewed him town. Note that it is not impossible however, the scum were probably told about the stealfest and by the time Jag's view was posted, 1xCop views must have been easy to fake too.

 

 

Indeed. And who did you view?

 

Fishing for Cop view info in the middle of the night? If you're town, you're just dumb.

[BLACK KNIGHT mafia]

 

 

 

I agree with Charlie, Jaguaro is scum.

Jaguaro is quite unlikely to be scum. He was the first one coming out with a stealing on TBK, and someone viewed him town. Note that it is not impossible however, the scum were probably told about the stealfest and by the time Jag's view was posted, 1xCop views must have been easy to fake too.

 

 

Indeed. And who did you view?

 

Fishing for Cop view info in the middle of the night? If you're town, you're just dumb.

 

Because of the evident NK?

[Mafia-18]

I didn't say time needed to stand still, don't try and spin it into me exaggerating the fact that you made over 5 posts urging us to hurry up and lynch someone, not Mummy, while the majority of us were waiting to see what Mummy had to say for himself after BK gave his results. Given that Mummy was mafia, I don't think I should need to tell you how it looks.

I'm not really concerned about how it looks. I made a lot of posts about how we should hurry up because we should. You can spin it around and base you cases on that if you will.

 

I also don't think I should have to tell you how it looks when you make the statement "it would be nice if we knew Phantom was town", because you know as well as I do there's only one true way to find that out.

You do, actually. I'd never have guessed that someone would take that as wanting to kill PHANTOM.

 

Take some accountability for your statements.

Sure.

[Mafia-18]

Due to TBK's derp, I guess I should say this much:

 

I had a 1xCop view that I used on someone. I've got an innocent view.

The person I viewed can prove that (via PM) anytime they choose to. They can also prove that I told them so at the very beginning of D2.

[Mafia-1]

 

 

 

I agree with Charlie, Jaguaro is scum.

Jaguaro is quite unlikely to be scum. He was the first one coming out with a stealing on TBK, and someone viewed him town. Note that it is not impossible however, the scum were probably told about the stealfest and by the time Jag's view was posted, 1xCop views must have been easy to fake too.

 

 

Indeed. And who did you view?

 

Fishing for Cop view info in the middle of the night? If you're town, you're just dumb.

 

 

There are no NK's ... explain what you are implying here. Comes across as superficial pro-town speak.

[Mafia-1]

 

I didn't say time needed to stand still, don't try and spin it into me exaggerating the fact that you made over 5 posts urging us to hurry up and lynch someone, not Mummy, while the majority of us were waiting to see what Mummy had to say for himself after BK gave his results. Given that Mummy was mafia, I don't think I should need to tell you how it looks.

I'm not really concerned about how it looks. I made a lot of posts about how we should hurry up because we should. You can spin it around and base you cases on that if you will.

 

I also don't think I should have to tell you how it looks when you make the statement "it would be nice if we knew Phantom was town", because you know as well as I do there's only one true way to find that out.

You do, actually. I'd never have guessed that someone would take that as wanting to kill PHANTOM.

 

Take some accountability for your statements.

Sure.

 

 

Ladies and gentlemen, I give you Nolder.

 

Unreal.

[Mafia-1]

Due to TBK's derp, I guess I should say this much:

 

I had a 1xCop view that I used on someone. I've got an innocent view.

The person I viewed can prove that (via PM) anytime they choose to. They can also prove that I told them so at the very beginning of D2.

 

I'm not sure I understand how anything can be "proven" via PM... PM's cannot be seen by all, I'm not sure wtf you are talking about to be honest. Or how we should just take it as a given that whatever it is you are talking about is obviously town vetting town.

[Mafia-18]

PM's can be shared.

 

As for NK: I will believe that there is no NK in this game the minute the mod tells me (either on thread or in PM) - not sooner.