November 7th, 1606: Day 4 (CONCLUDED)

[lolguy26]

 

its also an uncomfortable wifom for town too, its a fairly easy thing for mafia to claim salami, and it cant really be proven (well it can i guess but its highly unlikely)  

 

is your OMGUS vote on BG based on only that?

My vote is based on the fact that he's voting a claimed town PR on D1 for no good reason. Yea others voted too, but this reasoning stood out for me.

As for being unprovable - I would be surprised if there were no other town BPV's out there.

 

 

how does the fact that there are other BPV's prove anything?! 

 

and you did the copy paste thing again 

 

Okay, just a few thoughts I had when going home.

 

1) You're going at this from the wrong direction. I promised that I was town in all three games. Prove me I'm scum in one, and you can lynch me for being an LLL in all three of them.

2) Lynching someone three times to test whether he's scum in at least one of them is as silly as trying a witch by keeping her underwater: if she doesn't survive, she wasn't a witch afterall.

2) The BPV I have in T2 is actually much more useful as it seems at first sight - and the longer the game goes, the more powerful it gets.

[csarmi]

Sure it's gonna be very effective to do 3 mislynches at once, a BPV townie included.

 

And the mask meta argument is as BS as it gets. Incredible.

[csarmi]

and you did the copy paste thing again

OFC I did - this belongs on all three threads. And it's global. We don't have a fourth gameplay thread for general posts.

[lolguy26]

Sure it's gonna be very effective to do 3 mislynches at once, a BPV townie included.

 

And the mask meta argument is as BS as it gets. Incredible.

 

 

 

and you did the copy paste thing again

OFC I did - this belongs on all three threads. And it's global. We don't have a fourth gameplay thread for general posts.

 

 

you wanna know what's BS, the fact that you keep on using "Global", its the same people reading the same threads, you can post it once, people will read it 

[Darthe]

Official Vote Count FINAL VC:

 

Yates (1/12): Krak

Cloud (1/12): Ishy

Salami (12/12): Nol, Cloud, Yates, Verb, Leelou, Chuckles, Razen, Dap, Laya, Serra, BG, Des

Dap (1/12): Crush

BG (1/12): Salami

 

Not Voting (7/23):

Mishh, Hally, Lenlo, Peace, Tiink, Tina, Ree

 

SCENE INCOMING

[John E. Kelley]

Wow Des, don't even catch up on this thread, just jump in and throw the hammer vote with no information at all. Terrible.

[csarmi]

Whyt dumbfounds me is how could someone with half a brain claim I was masking meta. Terrible.

[csarmi]

Feeling better now? Go on.

[Hallia]

That I agree was a shoddy hammer

[Darthe]

The death of two so well respected men naturally made its way into the news. It was a scandal, and everyone loved sold papers. People were squawking about so unusual a thing, but one group was silent.

 

The Rose family should have known such a thing would draw attention. It happened in their neighborhood after all. People were scared, wanted answers. When Marian Rose couldn't provide any that seemed proof enough. They hung her from a rafter.

 

Csarmi: Marian Rose, townie with a BPV has been lynched!

 

It is now Night in Thread Two. You have 24 hours to submit your actions.

[Tiinker]

Haha Des did the same 6 posts in every thread and no one gives a shit.

[John E. Kelley]

Haha Des did the same 6 posts in every thread and no one gives a shit.

This. Call Salami out on doing it, yet Des gets a pass?

 

You're all idiots.

[Nolder]

Haha Des did the same 6 posts in every thread and no one gives a shit.

Except that they do. It was poor play. If he caught up at all he should have seen he needed to fully catch up on all three threads before commenting.

[Lenlo]

 

Haha Des did the same 6 posts in every thread and no one gives a shit.

This. Call Salami out on doing it, yet Des gets a pass?

 

You're all idiots.

 

I jabbed at Yates for doing the exact same thing with his vote on Csarmi and no one cared there either.

[John E. Kelley]

This plan, the lynch-Salami-in-all-three-threads? It's horrible.

[bgrishinko]

My point was CS, that your play was inconsistent with what you should do if you have a power role. And I'm not going to just NOT lynch a PR because someone claimed, that's how DPR didn't get killed Day 1 in Nolder's game and Verbal snaked a win for mafia.

 

A claim needs to be backed up by the play to go with it, if you don't play town, then expect what you get. And unfortunately it looks like was wrong, but I stand by my points as you played it poorly to the point where it sounded like a fake claim.

[Verbal32]

This plan, the lynch-Salami-in-all-three-threads? It's horrible.

And if he's indeed scum in one of them, will you still think it horrible?

[Leelou]

 

This plan, the lynch-Salami-in-all-three-threads? It's horrible.

And if he's indeed scum in one of them, will you still think it horrible?

 

 

Yesterday he was pushing the trains for the lulz, now it's a horrible idea.

[John E. Kelley]

 

This plan, the lynch-Salami-in-all-three-threads? It's horrible.

And if he's indeed scum in one of them, will you still think it horrible?

If he's scum in ONE of them, I intend to catch him and lynch him. I've already stated, and my play will continue as such, that I consider each thread its' own separete, unique game. What happens in one, has zero bearing on the other two. You want to play it a different way? Fine, go ahead, but I'm not.

[hazelkrs1]

Sigh. Thought I would end up quoting less from this one since I caught up in the other one first, and I ended up quoting more. Will have to trim some of the fat... anyways yeah I'll once again try to keep responses to each concise:
 
 
 

Vote Yates
 
For self voting. Ugh.

 
Man... pinging in this thread too Cloud. Are you implying that a self-vote is a scumtell?
 
It was a blatant bandwagon vote man. No need to overjustify it.
 
You later bandwagon to Csarlami as well.
 

 

ZOMG but it was the bestest trap eva!

 

 

 

HERE WE GO, LYNCH SALAMI, HERE WE GO!!!!!
 
 
Sorry, I couldn't help it.

 

 

What's brilliant about this plan is that his buddies can't follow the plan in one thread then NOT follow through in another.  So his buddies will HAVE to bus him in however many games he's scum in!

 
Exactly what I was thinking. I like the cut of your jib Yates.
 

 

 

Why would the Csarmi train take off so fast. Did I miss something?

 
Not much.....just the main event in all 3 threads.......
 
>_>

 

 
 
That and Yates being a Dillhole.

 

 
Worth noting - Krak trying to go against the flow. I think BG does as well later, don't think I grabbed that quote. Pretty significant should Csarlami flip scum.
 

 

NO BRAKES

 

CHOO CHOO

 

 

 
Yall are so mean to me
 
*cries*
 

 
ROFLCOPTER
 
That was one of my favorite episodes of IASIP
 

Here.

 
Interesting... Tina made a pretty lengthy post in her first post in the first thread, but this is all she says in this one?
 

I don't think that a scum team would bus their teammate this early. It would be a big sacrifice and I think they will just try to break it down instead.

 

 

I don't think that a scum team would bus their teammate this early. It would be a big sacrifice and I think they will just try to break it down instead.

 
i think this was in response to me or atleast commenting on my post
 
the whole scum team wont bus at once, they'll do it at various points, and a sacrifice for town cred is most likely worth it when someone plays like salami has

 

 
You're both doing it wrong.
 
"Mafia would do this" and "Mafia would never do that" statements are just poor poor play. To keep pounding at that same rock (mebbe one of these days it will crack and people will stop making these statements), Mafia will do WHATEVER it takes to get a win. Bus early, bus late, or they could even go all in like the recent mafia team in Nolder's game and all try to basically openly defend their teammates every lynch.
 

 

---

 

Had to end up editing out Peace's multiquote post cause I had too many quotes, but yeah I thought most of it was reaching

 

---

 

 

 

I meant due to the fact that you are currently the most suspicious person in all three games.
You made your BPV (if it's real) useless before claiming.

I see. I'm not suspicios though. You're just trying to push it.
I claimed town and I am town. I don't lie.

 

 
I'll remember that for the next time I see you flip scum.

 

 
*nod*
 
Verbal said this btw, quote got messed up while I was editing other stuff out. 
 

Okay, just a few thoughts I had when going home.

1) You're going at this from the wrong direction. I promised that I was town in all three games. Prove me I'm scum in one, and you can lynch me for being an LLL in all three of them.
2) Lynching someone three times to test whether he's scum in at least one of them is as silly as trying a witch by keeping her underwater: if she doesn't survive, she wasn't a witch afterall.
2) The BPV I have in T2 is actually much more useful as it seems at first sight - and the longer the game goes, the more powerful it gets.

Bolded doesn't jibe with his earlier claim:
 

Full claim:

Marian Rose, a wise woman who's always prepared. Town with a BPV (Vest+Helmet), good vs 1 NK.

Looks like he was trying to do everything he could to stay alive in THIS game. Pretty confident he's scum in this one.

[Niniel]

I see I´m late to the party. Des hammered while I read the thread. 

[John E. Kelley]

 

 

This plan, the lynch-Salami-in-all-three-threads? It's horrible.

 

And if he's indeed scum in one of them, will you still think it horrible?

 

Yesterday he was pushing the trains for the lulz, now it's a horrible idea.

Don't even try this, you know damn well that we push the lulz angle to get a reveal, not to blind lynch them.

 

Unless it's Verb.

[Tiinker]

ROFL

[Leelou]

 

 

 

This plan, the lynch-Salami-in-all-three-threads? It's horrible.

And if he's indeed scum in one of them, will you still think it horrible?

 

Yesterday he was pushing the trains for the lulz, now it's a horrible idea.

Don't even try this, you know damn well that we push the lulz angle to get a reveal, not to blind lynch them.

 

Unless it's Verb.

 

 

I was never pushing this as a lulz vote, so that is all on you. 

 

And -_- rule 14 on JN

[Tiinker]

I didn't even realize that was the hammer. Oh god.