Ghost Mafia - 3 out of 33 survive - Town wins!

[Verbal32]

 

 

 

Actually this would be different if some are one shot, then yes they should tell us what they did. As the objects can move around then knowing what an object does is not so important than in a game where they have roles. It's the person who has it. And they should say anything until they have done what they have etc. Ithi's is different she claimed because she was on the lynch path. 

 

Also we have now had two kills. If there is an object that has a killing power, is it a one off then moved on or does it stay with one play for a while like Ithi's. If it stays, it might suggest that whoever had the object yesterday may still have it today and got recruited over the hour...hence the difference in the scenes, one definitely killed by a ghost. It could be that the object moved this hour to someone else and they were a ghost. 

 

What is the point of all the questions? All we need to know is that we've seen 1 death per "hour" in the game.

 

I don't understand the point of all this... feels like you are trying to deter from the goal of lynching.

 

 

What questions. We need to know more than there is 1 death an hour... That information could provide us clues to who the mafia. Lynching gives us the chance to prove that information. an Object was given out not long before Turin was killed. There is information in DPR's posts...so why don't we use it! 

 

because you are advocating letting the mafia know what to expect, I'm willing to vote you even if you are town at this point if you cannot see why this is bad...

 

 

 

Ironic - I've wanted to lynch you plenty of times even if you were town.  ;-)

[Gabriel Kross]

Just going with my gut. Still suspicious of you, Hallia, but more so of Vam. Hence my vote.

Nice ignoring of my post

 

up to page 32.

 

@ Mod: can you link your scenes in the OP please *sweet smile*

 

Peace is still top of my list, i still didn't like the Rand lynch, Cloud is now #2 and i'm not sold on Halia being innocent.also, t

 

he Ape is being his usually hairy lazy self.  that is all for now.

 

 

 

notes -

 

#462: EP[/url] - ”So lets get this straight Red admonishes me for being lazy yet she suggests the laziest option out there, Peace being one of her other options has 2 votes but she wont vote him? Mark my words now Peace and Red are mafia team mates, again I never said anything that had anything to do with exaggerating anything on size of trains, I said we should run up trains on Verb and Notbob.

Red is making posts of nonsense except breadcrumbing doubts on Peace just incase we go that route I agree with Ithi on the fact that she is not "encouraging me" to do anything we've barely had any back and forth at all

”

 

the No Lynch isnt lazy and i explained my reasoning, stop trying to twist shit.

 

nice linkage of me and peace, noted for the future.  and bread crumbig doubt for Peace, how exactly am i doing that considering i’ve been FoSing him since my first post and even posted a case on him there captain obvious?

 

and you exaggerated the size of the trains by stating that they were trains with only 1 vote on them a piece.

 

#467 - [url=http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/82002-ghost-mafia-game-thread/?p=2909874]Tal[/url]:  i dont see that post as Verb defending Halia, just stating the obvious on a person who doesn’t have Meta on players.

 

#468 - [url=http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/82002-ghost-mafia-game-thread/?p=2909875]Halia[/url]:  so you;d lynch a person you think is town just to prove yourself right to the rest of us?  why would you do that if you’re town.  why do you feel its more important to prove your town rather than keeping a person alive whom you think is town.  

 

#478: [url=http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/82002-ghost-mafia-game-thread/?p=2909909]Cloud[/url]: setting up future lynches, same as Peace.  big ping imo

 

#492: [url=http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/82002-ghost-mafia-game-thread/?p=2909942]Halia[/url: ping again.  generally, nilla townies are willing to the the opposite.  why would you want to lynch someone you believe is town and has an item over yourself with no item?

 

#499: [url=http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/82002-ghost-mafia-game-thread/?p=2909954]Cloud[/url]:  you should take your own advice.  you do realize its rather hypocritical to FoS someone for something you yourself are doing correct.

 

#564: [url=http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/82002-ghost-mafia-game-thread/?p=2910243]Tress[/url]:  i agree about Peace.  he’s continually FoSd Ep, but hasn’t built a case on him and all of his posts towards EP seem to be aimed to incite a reactionary Emo post from EP, rather than discrediting his ploys.  its one reason Peace is high up on my list.

 

#597: [url=http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/82002-ghost-mafia-game-thread/?p=2910460]Cloud[/url]:  this post pings big time.  

 

- the parroting of the Rand lynch reasons, after not really mentioning it until it gained traction

- the fence sitting on Halia with this line ”Hallia.. most players are seeing her mistakes to be genuine but I still have my doubts regarding her. I have more of a town read on her now than last night though because TG is so certain that she will flip town.”

- then parroting the TGI train.

i especially dislike his stance on Halia, he’s trying to be on both sides, either you want to lynch her or you think she’s town.  you cannot think she’s town but still place doubt on her alignment. you’ve just jumped up to the #2 spot on my list.

 

#600 - [url=http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/82002-ghost-mafia-game-thread/?p=2910475]Crusher[/url]:  Ithi explained this.  skimming much?

 

#602: [url=http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/82002-ghost-mafia-game-thread/?p=2910482]Ape: ”don't agree with the idea that we should be analyzing and incriminating people for being on trains, before we know the alignment of the person whose train they are on. This also reeks of sloppy scum opportunism. Like you are either trying to divert a lynch from a scum partner, which is less likely, or like you are trying to seed cases for lynches that'll take place AFTER Turin is lynch... setting up future lynches.”

 

hey einstine, you do realized Turin was killed right?  or are you just skimming you lazy Ape. your post reeks of sloppy scum opportunism.

 

#603: [url=http://www.dragonmount.com/forums/topic/82002-ghost-mafia-game-thread/?p=2910484]Ape[/url]:  you want an analysis of Rands wagon, get up off yer lazy hairy rump and do it yerself.

Well for someone who is caught up Red you sure are making a few backwards comments, setting up so many poor trails and one on a currently confirmed townie

 

referring to the part in red again I never called them trains. so you say I should stop twisting shit when it is clearly you that is doing the twisting. Also as we now know durring day 1 game play there was at most only 1 mafia and that was after page 15 so any linking that was made is trash in the wind now. Again I'd like to point out she tried to post seeds of doubt on someone who is currently confirmed until the end of this phase.

[Gabriel Kross]

Orz I skimmed that first part so she isnt caught up, let me go see what happened up to pg 32

[Nolder]

 

Has anyone ever actually seen a Freudian slip happen during a forum game? 

 

I've seen Vicious post an entire copy/pasted defense meant to go into his scum QT in the game thread. I think that counts.

 

Well point to you then. I have never seen such a thing and didn't think it was actually something that ever really happens.

[Gabriel Kross]

Ok confirmed that as of page 32 I was not confirmed town however Red should have just fully caught up before posting. Her post has completely no validity there by making my response invalid too

[Nolder]

 

There's 31 players alive right now and we need to lynch someone by tonight, where is everyone?

 

Get me a vote count.

 

At this point, we've seen what happens when town doesn't reach consensus and misses the lynch. I'd like to see what happens when we do get our lynch on.

 

 

(Unofficial) Current Vote Count:

Tina (1) - Verbal

Leelou (1) - Mish

Rand (6) - Wombat, EP, Vam, Hally, Berf, Tina

Nolder (6) - Peace, Basel, Darthe, Ithi, Ape, WolfBrotherKronos

Vambram (8) - NotBob, TGlems, Nolder, Crush, Rand, Dap, Leelou, Cloud, Talya, Sakaea

 

 

With 31 players, it takes 16 to lynch.

[Gabriel Kross]

Ok confirmed that as of page 32 I was not confirmed town however Red should have just fully caught up before posting. Her post has completely no validity there by making my response invalid too

[Gabriel Kross]

Hmmm weird, it showed my post didnt post so I reposted it but then the original did post...

[WWWwombat]

Rand Freudian slipped the first two times he was mafia iirc. It happens.

 

Also, I don't know why anyone thinks Turin was killed by a townie. Read the scenes.

[Gabriel Kross]

Rand Freudian slipped the first two times he was mafia iirc. It happens.

 

Also, I don't know why anyone thinks Turin was killed by a townie. Read the scenes.

So you think the first ghost has the ability to recruit and kill? or do you think that only if there is a death there are possesions? Actually that second option makes sense, why else would there be no Mod penalty for no consensus. I think the number of recruits is based on the number of deaths. If we stop kills we stop recruits.

[WWWwombat]

I don't know what the exact mechanics are right now and I don't care to speculate. My argument for the possessed killing Turin is almost all flavor. I highly doubt that a vig kill would have been accompanied by sabotage of cell service and vehicles. Furthermore, the possessed just obviously killed Lily, so it is quite clear they can kill. Lily was voting Rand btw iirc. Can we kill him already?

[Gabriel Kross]

I don't know what the exact mechanics are right now and I don't care to speculate. My argument for the possessed killing Turin is almost all flavor. I highly doubt that a vig kill would have been accompanied by sabotage of cell service and vehicles. Furthermore, the possessed just obviously killed Lily, so it is quite clear they can kill. Lily was voting Rand btw iirc. Can we kill him already?

I say we just go ahead and lynch Rand, if Wombat is wrong it will probably prove the validity of my theory, however if wombat is right we get rid of a mafia.

[WWWwombat]

Cases on Vambram and Nolder are pretty crappy imo btw. Vambram seems more inexperienced than scummy and Nolder is mainly getting in trouble because he is somewhat abrasive and unorthodox. Nolder has not shied away from the heat coming his way, while Rand barely posts at all unless someone is directly casing or voting him.

[Gabriel Kross]

Cases on Vambram and Nolder are pretty crappy imo btw. Vambram seems more inexperienced than scummy and Nolder is mainly getting in trouble because he is somewhat abrasive and unorthodox. Nolder has not shied away from the heat coming his way, while Rand barely posts at all unless someone is directly casing or voting him.

I think Nolder is still mafia as well but we can debate that later

[WWWwombat]

Then again, Ape does have a point about Nolder sheeping/enflaming the crappy train on Vambram. That was kind of gross. He also seems to be engaging in a lot of mechanics speculation which is counterproductive, but not necessarily scummy imo. A lot of people have done as much or worse imo.

[Nolder]

Then again, Ape does have a point about Nolder sheeping/enflaming the crappy train on Vambram. That was kind of gross. He also seems to be engaging in a lot of mechanics speculation which is counterproductive, but not necessarily scummy imo. A lot of people have done as much or worse imo.

As far as mechanics speculation goes I've mostly been trying to shut down what I see as unlikely suggestions of whats going on rather than really trying to push my own version.

I think it's dangerous to let bad ideas go unchallenged.

[DPR]

Current Vote Count:

 

 

Leelou (1) - Mish

Rand (5) - Wombat, Vam, Hally, Berf, Tina

Nolder (6) - Peace, Basel, Darthe, Ithi, Ape, Kronos

Vambram (9) - NotBob, TGlems, Nolder, Crush, Rand, Dap, Leelou, Cloud, Talya, Kae

Tina (1) - Verbal 

 

With 31 players, it takes 16 to lynch. Deadline is Tuesday, May 21st at  9:00 am EST.

[The Crusher]

I don't know what the exact mechanics are right now and I don't care to speculate. My argument for the possessed killing Turin is almost all flavor. I highly doubt that a vig kill would have been accompanied by sabotage of cell service and vehicles. Furthermore, the possessed just obviously killed Lily, so it is quite clear they can kill. Lily was voting Rand btw iirc. Can we kill him already?

 

 

Im ok with Vabram getting a pass if he truly is an inexperienced player.  I can see how he could come in sheepishly and not commit.  i did it the first year I played mafia.  Nolder I have a hard time voting for because he is Nolder and I have never found him not scummy.  His style of play makes most people want to just kill him because he is him.  LOL  So Rand?  Ok m game.

 

unvote vote rand

[DPR]

He flicks the switch on the FLIR camera and pans the room. Nothing strikes him as odd as he plays the camera over his fellow investigators.

 

The scene spins around and a wide grin is suddenly displayed on the screen.

 

NOLDER IS HUMAN (TOWN).

[John McClane]

Cases on Vambram and Nolder are pretty crappy imo btw. Vambram seems more inexperienced than scummy and Nolder is mainly getting in trouble because he is somewhat abrasive and unorthodox. Nolder has not shied away from the heat coming his way, while Rand barely posts at all unless someone is directly casing or voting him.

 

 

Then again, Ape does have a point about Nolder sheeping/enflaming the crappy train on Vambram. That was kind of gross. He also seems to be engaging in a lot of mechanics speculation which is counterproductive, but not necessarily scummy imo. A lot of people have done as much or worse imo.

 

 

Dude, I was just going to say... there's nothing crappy about the case I put forth on Nolder. LOL

 

Better than insinuating that Lily got killed, and was voting Rand, therefore it's an indictment of Rand... that's some turd logic right there. 

[Nolder]

Suck it scum

[LilyElizabeth]

Loved my death scene, DPR! Go town!

[John McClane]

LOL, good.

 

 

He flicks the switch on the FLIR camera and pans the room. Nothing strikes him as odd as he plays the camera over his fellow investigators.

 

The scene spins around and a wide grin is suddenly displayed on the screen.

 

NOLDER IS HUMAN (TOWN).

 

Unvote

Vote Rand

 

Possible he was defending Nolder because he already knew his alignment.

[John McClane]

In the grand scheme of things, I just can't imagine a circumstance where scum is proactively trying to influence anything right now. I actually think it makes more sense to divert to someone who is maybe trying to look active, while not actually pushing anything. Like Tina or Talya, those 2 stand out to me a lot. 

[John McClane]

Not saying we need to divert now, but give what I just said consideration going forward. IF the situation is such that there are only 2-3 possessed at the moment, why would any of them stick their neck out? 

 

Quiet players biding time while numbers shift is where we should probably put our attention.