Ghost Mafia - 3 out of 33 survive - Town wins!

[Nolder]

 

I do have a bit more to add, even if it was intended the way you claim Nolder it implies you know more about the recruiting, so either you are a possessed or you outed yourself to be be the next target of the recruiter so that you won't hinder their plans. Either way by the end of this phase, you'd be a threat

How does it imply that I know more about recruiting?

 

[Gabriel Kross]

To nolder since my quote thingies are broke

 

Why would you ask it if you didn't know? Asking an open ended question for the sake of asking it does nothing except run people in circles. You sir are mafia.

[DPR]

 

 

@ MOD, if there is no lynch achieved, are more people possessed? If there is a lynch does this effect the possession? What would happen in this respect if we all vote NO Lynch?

 

A No Lynch majority vote will only result in moving on to the next hour. There is no Mod penalty.

 

Your other questions are too vague to answer.

 

 

@ MOD - How many people are possessed (extra to those already possessed) at the end of an hour if no one is lynched?

 

How many people are possessed (extra to those already possessed) at the end of an hour if someone is lynched?

 

If a No lynch is achieved how many people are possessed (extra to those already possesed) at the end of an hour?

 

And can I have a shiney object too...I like shiney :-D

 

 

There is no clear answer to these questions. I will say that each hour will include a count of the Possessed. For the Town to win, all Possessed must be eliminated.

 

As to the last, we will see my dear, we will see.

 

And a small bonus for you: do you remember the first Vampire Hunter game? That served as a bit of an inspiration for this one.

[Darthe]

Hello all I will have to check in tonight and catch up. Until then unvote vote rand

 

@red, I don't have to back that up more. It's common knowledge that an anti-town portion of the game should in total equal roughly 25% under almost any circumstance.

[Nolder]

To nolder since my quote thingies are broke

 

Why would you ask it if you didn't know? Asking an open ended question for the sake of asking it does nothing except run people in circles. You sir are mafia.

What you are saying in a roundabout way is that what I said was rhetoric and you're correct. I did not ask because I wanted an answer I asked for effect.

In essence I was accusing Wombat of the same thing you are accusing me of. That is, knowing more than one should.

 

As for points 2 and 3:

 

2.  With the mafia having 2 members and the town having only 1 lynch, there is no way that the town as a whole can stop the Possessed from recruiting.

 

3.  We can be damn sure we will get more info later.  I suspect that this isn't the last FLIR camera scene we will see and even if it is, eventually we will start lynching players when the time is right and the info payoff is worth the numbers cost.

 

 

Ok I'll agree there are 2 possessed right now, DPR's language is clear on that count. That does not mean there are only 2 scum. There could easily be more than one scum team not to mention third parties.

 

What I don't understand Wombat is why you think we can't stop recruiting. How do you know there aren't a limited amount of recruitment opportunities? What if there is a cult leader and killing them stops the recruiting? Not sure if you're slipping or what but that doesn't add up at all.

 

I am not the one who knows more than he should. I do not know the mechanics of recruiting. But Wombat seems to. 

If you like "slips" so much why are you questioning "mine" but not his?

[Gabriel Kross]

Hello all I will have to check in tonight and catch up. Until then unvote vote rand

 

@red, I don't have to back that up more. It's common knowledge that an anti-town portion of the game should in total equal roughly 25% under almost any circumstance.

except that this time it doesn't. Not only that why are you voting Rand in the new hour phase?

 

Also yay a couple refreshes fixed my quotey things

[Darthe]

Shit it's new phase? I'm on page 30 mate and gotta split! Ill figure this out tonight.

[Darthe]

Oh, unvote rand

[Gabriel Kross]

Well Wombat's comment made sense, generally speaking there is no way to stop cults from recruiting.  Only possibilty I could think of to stop a cult is a Shrink? Or does that only get used on serial killers? Yea like I said generally don't see an obvious counter balance to the recruit, but you generally don't know about it by the end of the first phase either.

[Talya]

@ the MOD...ahhh yes I do and I was thinking of those. Thank you.

[Gabriel Kross]

Shit it's new phase? I'm on page 30 mate and gotta split! Ill figure this out tonight.

This is why you don't post if you're not caught up, had you been dead you would have broken the rules. (I've done it, speaking from experience)

[Gabriel Kross]

@ the MOD...ahhh yes I do and I was thinking of those. Thank you.

please elaborate.

[Nolder]

Well Wombat's comment made sense, generally speaking there is no way to stop cults from recruiting.  Only possibilty I could think of to stop a cult is a Shrink? Or does that only get used on serial killers? Yea like I said generally don't see an obvious counter balance to the recruit, but you generally don't know about it by the end of the first phase either.

Generally speaking, that's completely false.

To "balance" (and I use that term very loosely in this case) cults power there is almost always a dedicated recruiter or "cult leader" which is the cults only means of gaining new members.

[Gabriel Kross]

 

Well Wombat's comment made sense, generally speaking there is no way to stop cults from recruiting.  Only possibilty I could think of to stop a cult is a Shrink? Or does that only get used on serial killers? Yea like I said generally don't see an obvious counter balance to the recruit, but you generally don't know about it by the end of the first phase either.

Generally speaking, that's completely false.

To "balance" (and I use that term very loosely in this case) cults power there is almost always a dedicated recruiter or "cult leader" which is the cults only means of gaining new members.

 

yes but you made it sound like there was another way. How often do you snag the recruiter day 1 or even day2? We snagged you on what day 3 in the avengers game? It didn't even stop the recruiting so my point stands there is generally no counterbalance to a cult, it's about luck and skill

[Nolder]

 

 

Well Wombat's comment made sense, generally speaking there is no way to stop cults from recruiting.  Only possibilty I could think of to stop a cult is a Shrink? Or does that only get used on serial killers? Yea like I said generally don't see an obvious counter balance to the recruit, but you generally don't know about it by the end of the first phase either.

Generally speaking, that's completely false.

To "balance" (and I use that term very loosely in this case) cults power there is almost always a dedicated recruiter or "cult leader" which is the cults only means of gaining new members.

 

yes but you made it sound like there was another way. How often do you snag the recruiter day 1 or even day2? We snagged you on what day 3 in the avengers game? It didn't even stop the recruiting so my point stands there is generally no counterbalance to a cult, it's about luck and skill

 

Avengers was an extremely unique game and debatably broken.

 

I agree that cults are unbalanced but that's not the issue here the issue is how Wombat knows the recruiting mechanics.

It could have just been a one time deal for all anyone should know.

[Talya]

Okay so at this moment in time we know that EP is Town. 

 

I'm wondering if Nol would really ask something like that to Wombat, if they were both possessed. The only thing I can think of for people to stop anyone being possessed would be an object of some kind as there are no roles. I'm guessing that at the end of the hour someone else will be possessed, unless stop (object) somehow. I don't think a no lynch would work. We need to find the possessed. If it is like the vampire games, then the main one would be best. I'm guessing this is the first person who was possessed. 

 

The best way to think of this is there are town and there are possessed, no third party and no cult. No roles, there is no night because the possessed would not have a night kill in this game. The kills would come from lynches and from objects giving someone what ever power it maybe. There maybe a few other things going on, but I think that looks like the basics. So we do need to lynch someone otherwise we just sit and wait until we are all possessed. 

 

A lot of people haven't even popped in today and are quiet, they maybe the ones we need to go after first. If you are possessed and want to have others possessed to increase your numbers, who are you more likely to go for...those that are hiding under the radar.

[Gabriel Kross]

 

 

 

Well Wombat's comment made sense, generally speaking there is no way to stop cults from recruiting.  Only possibilty I could think of to stop a cult is a Shrink? Or does that only get used on serial killers? Yea like I said generally don't see an obvious counter balance to the recruit, but you generally don't know about it by the end of the first phase either.

Generally speaking, that's completely false.

To "balance" (and I use that term very loosely in this case) cults power there is almost always a dedicated recruiter or "cult leader" which is the cults only means of gaining new members.

 

yes but you made it sound like there was another way. How often do you snag the recruiter day 1 or even day2? We snagged you on what day 3 in the avengers game? It didn't even stop the recruiting so my point stands there is generally no counterbalance to a cult, it's about luck and skill

 

Avengers was an extremely unique game and debatably broken.

 

I agree that cults are unbalanced but that's not the issue here the issue is how Wombat knows the recruiting mechanics.

It could have just been a one time deal for all anyone should know.

 

except with there only being 2 it's blatantly obvious that it's not a 1 time deal. That would make the game entirely too one sided because then you could lynch anybody until you found them, is that what you are suggesting we do? If so we start with you.

[Talya]

This is the vote count so far:

 

 

ho posted in: Ghost Mafia Game Thread

Member name Posts

Eternal Phoenix 110

_CLOUD 51

Nolder 45

Hallia 44

Ithillian 42

peacesells 42

WWWwombat 40

John McClane 40

鲍勃不是我的名字 39

The Crusher 37

TGlems 32

DreadPirateRoberts 28

dapianoplay3r 27

Verbal32 22

Leelou 21

Talya 19

Misheru Sedai 19

LilyElizabeth 18

WolfbrotherKronos 14

Darthe 14

RandA lThor 11

Basel Gill 9

Red2111 9

ineedfourberfs 7

Turin Turambar 7

Songstress 6

TinaHel 6

Vambram 3

Sakaea 3

Kaylee 1

 

Edited for the count going funny

[Gabriel Kross]

Holy jeebus I've made twice as many posts as the next highest

[Talya]

You talk too much...

 

Dap is slacking...he is usually a lot higher, maybe an ideal recruit? or maybe down the bottom, Kae or Kay, Vam or Tina?

[Gabriel Kross]

Or maybe you? Who knows? Lets see how this plays out.

[Talya]

In fact the last ones, I don't think have come up on anyone's mafia list. I could easily start there. 

[Talya]

Current Vote Count:

 

TGlems (1) - Ape

Leelou (1) - Mish

No Lynch (1) - Wombat

Wombat (1) - Nolder

Nolder (4) - EP, Cloud, Peace, Hally

 

With 32 players, it takes 17 to lynch. The hour will turn on Tuesday, May 21, 9:00 am EST unless a lynch is reached first.

 

So this is the vote count so far. We need to get a lynch by the end of today...

 

VOTE NOL

[RandA lThor]

I'm confused, am I dead?  If so, bah go town etc etc.  If not I have a bunch of stuff to post.

[peacesells]

I'm confused, am I dead?  If so, bah go town etc etc.  If not I have a bunch of stuff to post.

 

You are not dead yet.  Are you playing the Hallie card claiming ignorance?  Trying to look unpossessed?