Ghost Mafia - 3 out of 33 survive - Town wins!

[Hallia]

So does that mean we don't have to worry about consolidating? Will the phase actually end?

 

Unvote

[Red2111]

@ Ithi - i've stated my reasons for voting you. and hey are not inaccurate reasons.

 

1 - my case on you is my own, not borrowing from others

 

2 - you're being more aggressive and defensive than normal. this pings

 

3 - you are egging on EP. you know what he's doing, and your encouraging him to continue by going back and forth with him. ie: you're baiting him and giving him rope to hang himself

[Ithillian Turambar]

I still think we need to achieve a Majority Lynch by the end of each phase. I would just rather not be the sacrifice today.

 

I'm not a ghost and I don't want to die - especially when I've got to actually pay attention to the game for once and do something.

[Ithillian Turambar]

If you mean I'm continuing to point out the reasons why I think he is Mafia then you are correct.

 

But I have no control over him. He keeps doing things that reek. I'm not going to just ignore them when I honestly think I picked up on him.

 

Would you prefer I just let stuff slide and not tell people who I think is Mafia and why.

 

And yes - I agree that you did actually try and put together a proper case on me. I thank you for making the effort at least, but you are very wrong.

[鲍勃不是我的名字]

If you mean I'm continuing to point out the reasons why I think he is Mafia then you are correct.

 

But I have no control over him. He keeps doing things that reek. I'm not going to just ignore them when I honestly think I picked up on him.

 

Would you prefer I just let stuff slide and not tell people who I think is Mafia and why.

 

And yes - I agree that you did actually try and put together a proper case on me. I thank you for making the effort at least, but you are very wrong.

 

Looks like they just want to lynch you.

 

Personally, I'd lynch EP.

 

Has everyone checked in?

[Ithillian Turambar]

 

 

If you mean I'm continuing to point out the reasons why I think he is Mafia then you are correct.

 

But I have no control over him. He keeps doing things that reek. I'm not going to just ignore them when I honestly think I picked up on him.

 

Would you prefer I just let stuff slide and not tell people who I think is Mafia and why.

 

And yes - I agree that you did actually try and put together a proper case on me. I thank you for making the effort at least, but you are very wrong.

Looks like they just want to lynch you.

 

Personally, I'd lynch EP.

 

Has everyone checked in?

Pretty much. One down and one to go I would say. But I can't do my thing if I'm dead.

[Basel Gill]

UNVOTE; VOTE: NO LYNCH

Who had 351 PM EST on Saturday in the pool for when Red would suggest a no lynch?

 

Edit:

[Hallia]

You silly goose basel. XD

[peacesells]

 

 

I'm curious to see if I'm right.  

 

Vote Ithi

 

Now there is a wow moment.

 

Because I agree with Lily?

 

Cause you made a case for Ithi being town and are now voting here.  Wow.  Just to see if you are right? More Wow.

 

UNVOTE VOTE HALLIA

[peacesells]

are you really suggesting the Mafia has a day kill instead of a night kill, or even worst, that they have both.

 

 

I wouldn't know, as I'm not mafia.  But one never knows.

You keep playing this card.  Ham it up some more will ya.

[Hallia]

 

are you really suggesting the Mafia has a day kill instead of a night kill, or even worst, that they have both.

 

 

I wouldn't know, as I'm not mafia.  But one never knows.

You keep playing this card.  Ham it up some more will ya.

 

Since you asked so nicely.

[Gabriel Kross]

Oh Gawd EP..you've said the same yourself in the past.  Get over your mock indignation.

 

Show me where I did or I call your bluff

 

Turins kill strikes me as a DK by a vig.

 

my short list is now Peace, Halia, Darthe, Ithi and Tal in that order. Tal and Mish are runner ups.

 

I would be good with No Lynch, Peace, Halia or Ithi right now.

 

 

UNVOTE; VOTE: NO LYNCH

 

 

reasons:

 

No Lynch -> 1 death already, looming MK on Ishy. No Lynch makes sense imo

 

Peace -> scummiest person so far. I can pull a case together once I get to a computer that allows me to post outside of mobile version.

 

Ithi -> most info and 3rd scummiest. mainly her encouraging EP and defensiveness and aggression

 

Halia -> 2nd scummiest person. 1st the "omg no role PM" post; now this "omg TUrin was a mafia kill

 

 

 

 

--------------

 

notes:

 

#342 - Darthe: “Based solely on Ishy being okay with a modkill I say we lynch him. 25% chance of being mafia, useless to us either way, avoids a needless death for D1, and avoids a modkill.”

 

 

the only reason to avoid MKs is because it generally leads to a death with no info. this lynch does effectively the same thing. imo, we’d be better off doing a No Lynch if we go this route, though i get where your logic is with this; but the thing i do question is the 25% chance of being mafia. seems a bit capitalistic imo.

 

 

 

#356 - EP: a: you’re really milking the lazy angle and tbh it does nothing for your town cred. also, Mafia is not a game for lazy people, if you’re going to be lazy why even sign up?

 

 

b: “I exagerated nothing, I stated nothing on the number of votes they had, I merely suggested a place to start interpret how you will.”

 

 

you exaggerated the size by calling them trains with one vote apiece. and you leave out my 2nd question. why focus on Verb and Bob and not the other 5 people who had 1 vote on them at the time?

 

 

 

#363 - Ithi: hmm obvious sucking up attempt to me after my vote *taps chin* slightly successfull and worth noting

 

 

on a side note

 

 

*dawns her Proton Pack* let Egon go you spectral of an undead possessed mass. why do you keep the Ghost Buster in your pocket, is you afraid of dem??

 

 

 

#364: TIna: him thou doh liketh my new post style-eth … then i shall changeth it-eth

 

 

is it just the lack of quote boxes, the fact word corrects most of the miss-spellings or the linkage going on :wiggles eyebrows:

 

 

 

#366: Crusher: multiple pings in this post

 

 

#1: no retort to my “Sanchez can’t throw a sandwhich comment >:( wheres my luv chrushluv?

 

 

#2: i pretended to have a case on Ithi, but i dont cause i skimmed but lets lynch her anyways. sounds like distancing himself from the lynch.

 

 

#3: trivalizing D1 info thats gained from trains and the prolonged lynch jabber.

 

 

#4: attempting to speed up D1 by advocating a rush lynch, thereby limiting the info from D1.

 

 

 

 

#367: Ape

 

 

tl;dr version. everything is stupid, vote Verb or Ithi.

 

 

 

#374: Tal:

 

 

re: EP. pretty spot on actually. you can also think of him as Wile E. Cyote as well *nods*

 

 

 

#367: Cloud: latching onto Chrush is noted

 

 

 

#383: Mish: blatant buddying and defense of Ithi noted.

 

 

*sarcasm* yep Ithi totally won't give more info than Turin. because its not liek Turin has had all of 1 post worth anything and there isn’t a train of 6 on Ithi and she’s had the most interactions with people in this game

 

 

yep, totally no info there *eyeroll*

 

 

 

#384: TGI: interesting points, that i missed, and worth noting in the future.

 

 

 

#386: Peace: WIFOM and lynch setting up is noted.

 

 

scum

 

 

 

 

#395: Scene: hmm, so we have a day vig.

 

 

this death gives us a good shifting point for scum. there are likely a few on his wagon imo; these votes need to be re-examined in the context of Turin being town. my guess is the most vocal and leader of his wagon (not necessarily vote leader but vocal pusher) is scum on his train. the agel of “role fishing” is a legit push for scum to vocally hide behind and lead a lynch over.

 

 

 

 

#401: Halia: comment strikes highly of capitalization of a death and doesn’t sit well at all.

 

 

are you really suggesting the Mafia has a day kill instead of a night kill, or even worst, that they have both.

 

 

 

#417: Tal: ”So now Peace and verb are defending Hally and coming to her aid. “

 

Where exactly is Verb comming to her aid? pls quote.

 

So lets get this straight Red admonishes me for being lazy yet she suggests the laziest option out there, Peace being one of her other options has 2 votes but she wont vote him? Mark my words now Peace and Red are mafia team mates, again I never said anything that had anything to do with exaggerating anything on size of trains, I said we should run up trains on Verb and Notbob. Also if you had been paying attention I had given thoughts elsewhere on the other members with votes on them I was basing those 2 choices off meta as had been discussed previously I wanted to see if they were going to play any differently under pressure than I've seen before.

 

I had been wary of Ape, for being silent but he had since shown up

I had stated that I thought Ithi was town, still think that to be the case even though she sloppily revealed having an item...

I had doubts about Turin do to his reaction to my jibe at him but he is now dead so is no longer a factor

 

there was 1 or 2 others I had commented on in the same post but I'll have to go back and see who they were

 

Red is making posts of nonsense except breadcrumbing doubts on Peace just incase we go that route I agree with Ithi on the fact that she is not "encouraging me" to do anything we've barely had any back and forth at all

 

And I would like to point out that there won't be any Nights. We move from one hour to the next to the next.

 

Why is anyone talking about Day or Night actions? I know I can use mine any time.

^this on the nights thing, we've gone over the fact that you guys need to stop skimming the rules yet you still don't even know the basics of how this game is being run that is said right in the rules

However Ithi I believe it was way to early for you to admit to having an item.

[Ithillian Turambar]

Lily suggested consolidation. I have the largest Train. People were admitting they had no reasons but were going to Lynch me anyways.

 

I'm on GMT and it's gone 10pm. I will be off to bed soon as small boys love to wake up at 6am even at the weekend. And I did not want to wake up dead.

 

Hence ----> Reveal

[Ithillian Turambar]

Besides now we have more time. Last minute reveals at the end of a deadline are stupid. Everything gets rushed then and people can jump onto a Lynch saying they didn't have a choice blah blah blah need a majority blah blah consolidate etc.

 

Why give that option? Now people still have to explain their vote which means their reasons can be examined.

[Basel Gill]

 

 

 

I'm curious to see if I'm right.  

 

Vote Ithi

 

Now there is a wow moment.

 

Because I agree with Lily?

 

Cause you made a case for Ithi being town and are now voting here.  Wow.  Just to see if you are right? More Wow.

 

UNVOTE VOTE HALLIA

 

 

I think I'd just love to see Hally explain the contradiction between her vote and her casing.

 

Vote Hally.

[Gabriel Kross]

So far as far as reads, I don't have a mafia read on anyone yet, but I'll give a few insights

 

 

Ithi-classic Ithi does this every game we play together

Turin-classic Turin however he has been known to pull this as mafia to llok innocent, will watch for further development

Wombat-unusually vocal this game

Ape-somewhat quiet, could be work could be mafia will watch and see where this goes as well

 

This is the post I was referring to where I discussed other people

 

If you do something that makes you look mafia, I said the bonded comment for a reason. I liked your reaction but I'm unsure of Turin's reaction I need to go research an old game for a bit of reference data.

This is where I commented on my doubts of Turin, I had thought they were in the same post but I was mistakin, none the less he was town so moot point

[Talya]

So does that mean we don't have to worry about consolidating? Will the phase actually end?

 

Unvote

 

If we don't lynch anyone, I would suggest it goes onto the next phase and everything would probably be put back to zero on the vote front. Something else may happen, who knows.

 

 

@ Red, this below. And I think a no lynch in a game like this is a waste of time. 

 

 

I see folks saying "xxx and yyy are just doing their thing".  Think that perhaps people would use this meta to hide?  That's the problem with scumhunting (or lack thereof) based on meta - you miss the people that are playing you as a result.  Hunt based on posts/reactions/evidence in this game - forget the rest, for the most part.

That's pretty good advice.   There's many people in this game I've never played with, or very much if I have before, so I don't know their metas.

 

 

Which makes you a dangerous scumhunter if you're town - you won't be fooled by the silly meta references.

 

[Hallia]

I think I did.  Lily has a point that it's hard enough with less than 24 hours to go to consolidate on someone.  And I've seen how hard it is to get a bunch of people to change their minds once they've started voting a certain way.   Voting Ithi would've also proved me right; and now I feel proven right without having to vote her with the whole ghost thing.  So I unvoted.

[Gabriel Kross]

I guess that does make sense Ithi, I retract my previous comment about the reveal.

[_CLOUD]

are you really suggesting the Mafia has a day kill instead of a night kill, or even worst, that they have both.

 

 

I wouldn't know, as I'm not mafia.  But one never knows.

 

I thought that you would have read the rules after your little slip up where you told everyone that you received no PM when you checked in, but you still not knowing the mechanics of this game worries me. You aren't being very pro-town this way. 

 

 

So does that mean we don't have to worry about consolidating? Will the phase actually end?

 

Unvote

 

Here it looks to me like you are playing the newbie card, and are using it as an excuse for a quick unvote after Ithi claimed.

 

 

 

 

I'm curious to see if I'm right.  

 

Vote Ithi

 

Now there is a wow moment.

 

Because I agree with Lily?

 

Cause you made a case for Ithi being town and are now voting here.  Wow.  Just to see if you are right? More Wow.

 

UNVOTE VOTE HALLIA

 

 

This. 

 

 

I think I did.  Lily has a point that it's hard enough with less than 24 hours to go to consolidate on someone.  And I've seen how hard it is to get a bunch of people to change their minds once they've started voting a certain way.   Voting Ithi would've also proved me right; and now I feel proven right without having to vote her with the whole ghost thing.  So I unvoted.

 

I find this to be a really weak excuse for your vote on Ithi. Yes, lynching Ithi might have proven your little theory right but afterwards you still wouldn't have known who the mafia members were etc. etc. Also, you buddying up to Lily is worth noting (not that I take any notes, lol).

 

 

Vote Hallia

[Hallia]

I thought that you would have read the rules after your little slip up where you told everyone that you received no PM when you checked in, but you still not knowing the mechanics of this game worries me. You aren't being very pro-town this way. - We don't know what roles are in the game, so I don't know what you mean by that.  Mafia could've had a day kill, or someone else.  We don't know who.

[_CLOUD]

There are no Day and Night cycles this game (and technically there aren't any roles either), that's why I said that you haven't paid attention to the rules.

[Hallia]

Yes, I saw that.  There are still deadlines though, and people will submit actions at some point, won't they?

[_CLOUD]

Yeah you guys can submit your actions anytime you like.

[Hallia]

I reckon 'you guys' would know that.