[Advanced] The Dresden Files Mafia - Game Over - Ed loses, Verbal wins

[Nolder]

Players:

1. TGlems - has yet to post, probably gonna need replacing

2. Darthe - nudging, slight scum read but could be he's just playing cautious

3. Song - has made a whopping 2 posts, hopping for more when the weekend passes

4. Lenlo - 4 posts, no read on him

5. Ed - no read

6. Vambram - 3 posts, felt like he was posting just to be seen and didn't say much, slight scum read

7. Peace - Has Ishy down as town based on meta which is weak as hell D1 IMO, scum read

8. Leelou - Staying out of trouble but as Ape pointed out that's her MO regardless of alignment, would like to hear a LOT more from her on D2

9. Dap - Nulltell for me, I've got some scum reads and I've got some town reads, time will tell?

10. Ape - Playing a good game, as he pointed out I can't read him for shit so who knows but he doesn't seem obviously scummy to me atm for wiw

11. Ishy - Seems scummy to me, has made plenty of posts saying a whole lot of nothing while voting and nuding any train that looks like it might take off

12. Hybrid - Haven't played with him before but slight town read

13. Tina - Only made 3 posts so far, no read yet

14. Nolder - Town MVP

15. Verbal - 2 posts so no read, hoping he catches up on monday

16. AVM - Strong town read

17. csarmi - I don't even know, I feel like his intentions are to scumhunt but his methods and arguments are terrible

18. BooBoo - Can't tell yet

19. Crusher - Probably going to be replaced by Pac so needs to be lynched ASAP

20. Katioria - No read, needs to post more

[Nolder]

omg I am so sick of posting being messed up how am I supposed to play mafia like this??? ugh

[John McClane]

 

John, I don't recommend lynching me.

 

 

How come in my head I followed that up with "you wouldn't like me when I'm angry."  ?

 

My line, LOL. 

 

That's a nice dress you are wearing today.

 

omg I am so sick of posting being messed up how am I supposed to play mafia like this??? ugh

 

Can you fix?

 

Your hair looks lovely, btw.

[csarmi]

 

 

Players: 

1. TGlems - has yet to post, probably gonna need replacing 

2. Darthe - nudging, slight scum read but could be he's just playing cautious 

3. Song - has made a whopping 2 posts, hopping for more when the weekend passes 

4. Lenlo - 4 posts, no read on him 

5. Ed - no read 

6. Vambram - 3 posts, felt like he was posting just to be seen and didn't say much, slight scum read 

7. Peace - Has Ishy down as town based on meta which is weak as hell D1 IMO, scum read 

8. Leelou - Staying out of trouble but as Ape pointed out that's her MO regardless of alignment, would like to hear a LOT more from her on D2 

9. Dap - Nulltell for me, I've got some scum reads and I've got some town reads, time will tell? 

10. Ape - Playing a good game, as he pointed out I can't read him for shit so who knows but he doesn't seem obviously scummy to me atm for wiw 

11. Ishy - Seems scummy to me, has made plenty of posts saying a whole lot of nothing while voting and nuding any train that looks like it might take off 

12. Hybrid - Haven't played with him before but slight town read 

13. Tina - Only made 3 posts so far, no read yet 

14. Nolder - Town MVP 

15. Verbal - 2 posts so no read, hoping he catches up on monday 

16. AVM - Strong town read 

17. csarmi - I don't even know, I feel like his intentions are to scumhunt but his methods and arguments are terrible 

18. BooBoo - Can't tell yet 

19. Crusher - Probably going to be replaced by Pac so needs to be lynched ASAP 

20. Katioria - No read, needs to post more 

[csarmi]

I hope that helps Nolder.

[csarmi]

 

John, I don't recommend lynching me.

 

Why not? If you are a vanilla townie, you should understand the value in dying now. Knowing your alignment gives us great context for all the reactions we've gotten.

 

I'm afraid this game is much more complicated than that, knowing the setting (Dresden files) and the game type (advanced).

 

You do have a point. Lynching me would confirm that I'm not scum. I just don't think that sort of information would be useful. I'd rather lynch someone from one of ther scum groups.

[Nolder]

Thank you. And no I can't fix it. Posting is all screwed up for me on DM right now and I don't understand why I'm the only one having this problem. Quote buttons don't work. The post button for the quick reply box doesn't work. In order to post I have to type in the quick reply box (which doesn't have any of the fancy buttons and doodads loading, it's just a text box) and then hit more reply options. If that screen will even load (maybe 10% of the time?) I can post from that screen. Or if it's not loading that screen I can try my luck with switching the layout to mobile and for some reason that works a little bit better but it's hard to navigate so after making a post I have to switch it back if I wanna keep reading. If this problem doesn't clear up after easter I'm going to figure out who manages tech around here and bug them about it.

[John Snow]

Nol you're by far not the only one to have that problem. My best fix has been to type up what I want to say, email it to my phone, copy and paste via mobile

[Nolder]

Oh really? I asked a couple people and they said it wasn't happening to them and everyone else seems to be quoting and posting like normal so I assumed it was just me. I wonder why us? Do you use Chrome?

[John McClane]

 

 

John, I don't recommend lynching me.

 

Why not? If you are a vanilla townie, you should understand the value in dying now. Knowing your alignment gives us great context for all the reactions we've gotten.

 

I'm afraid this game is much more complicated than that, knowing the setting (Dresden files) and the game type (advanced).

 

You do have a point. Lynching me would confirm that I'm not scum. I just don't think that sort of information would be useful. I'd rather lynch someone from one of ther scum groups.

 

Knowing your alignment would absolutely be useful. What planet are you on?

 

And the red is a cryptic statement, are you implying you know there is more than one scum team? 

[csarmi]

**** OFF

 

Sometimes I can only post at all if I change theme to mobile. Like half of the time the text area just doesn't appear. I got the tip of switching to mobile theme from an admin and it works for me for now..

 

**** ON

 

Johh, I'm implying that I believe that there should be multiple scum teams. It's not a big logical leap knowing the theme. 

I'm also implying that getting my coroner's report wouldn't help getting closer to solving the game.

[csarmi]

... and yea I edit offline too, usually in my notepad++, then paste in to mobile theme and post.

Sometimes the

[quote]...[/quote]

tags works strange however.

[Nolder]

Given that you would have to know the theme to think there might be multiple scum groups I'm not sure that is an assumption anyone should be making at this time. While it's entirely possible John has overlooked that fact and thus given a slight advantage to anyone who does know the theme there is no evidence that this is the case. I think before making statements like these we should at least see how many nightkillers there are out there.

[csarmi]

true

[Hybrid]

I'm suddenly being mentioned a lot I see.  

 

Would anyone mind bringing up why Booboo?  

 

I've noted votes there but not much casework.

 

That's terrific.  Perhaps we can make Cliffs Notes for you as well.

[Hybrid]

If any of the inactives shows up and drops the usual line about "I have a life" or somesuch, I vote we quick lynch them on the spot.

[Niniel]

I have a life.   No, not really.

 

I don´t know anything about the theme. Would it be realistic with two scum teams?

 

[csarmi]

Yea I think so,

 

Several different kind of groups are quite likely (vampires, werewolves, maffia, wizards), some of those can be a mason too.

 

All sorts of alignments are possible as well. The casting is quite rich and the plot can be very interesting :)

 

This is an advanced game too.

[John Snow]

Rand is replacing Crusher.

[John McClane]

Given that you would have to know the theme to think there might be multiple scum groups I'm not sure that is an assumption anyone should be making at this time. While it's entirely possible John has overlooked that fact and thus given a slight advantage to anyone who does know the theme there is no evidence that this is the case. I think before making statements like these we should at least see how many nightkillers there are out there.

 

Agreed, too early to bother speculating on setup. FOS whomever brought this up as yet another deviation from the agenda of scum hunting.... cspasmo

 

I have a life.   No, not really.

 

I don´t know anything about the theme. Would it be realistic with two scum teams?

 

 

 

FOS you, an experience player, for encouraging the setup talk. Dwindling off on a chat about the setup serves only scum, they already know more about what's going on than we do. There's no point in opening a dialogue about setup only so that scum can nudge us off on tangents and acceptance of probable setup theories that are false.

 

Yea I think so,

 

Several different kind of groups are quite likely (vampires, werewolves, maffia, wizards), some of those can be a mason too.

 

All sorts of alignments are possible as well. The casting is quite rich and the plot can be very interesting :)

 

This is an advanced game too.

 

It's good that you know about the source material, but there is absolutely no reason for us to begin buying into setup theories at this stage. It's pretty much an open wound for scum to pick at, if we start reaching consensus on setup without having seen anything in the game to fortify those theories. 

 

In other words, let the game play out and stop talking about setup, it is scummy.

 

I'm starting to bend town on you. You were a useful fix in order to get info, but there's just no way you'd actually hit on all these scum tells if you were actually scum. Unless you are the worst scum player of all time, in which case, that's the wifom isn't it?

 

Unvote

[csarmi]

Well, if I was the worst scum player of all times, you'd have ample chances to catch me later wouldn't you :)

 

unvote

[Nolder]

Rand is replacing Crusher.

[dapianoplay3r]

Don't skim. It's just bad for and I hate skimmers

Having reply box issue on my phone--will get a vc up ASAP--also crusher has asked to be replaced, and I think I have a replacement for him

As to why he left, if guess it was a number if factors, however I'm pretty sure if you hadn't of been in the game he wouldn't of left.

Still it's done

  

 

He's calling you a skimmer because you expressed doubt that Crusher actually left the game when the mod clearly said Crusher asked to be replaced.

 

When did he say that? I never saw that post. No wonder I was missing out on this storyline.

 

 

Above and bold read it. I won't quote it again. We have also been informed that Rand is the replacement. You got that?

 

 

John, I don't recommend lynching me.

So you start crumbling for a reveal. Scummy

 

 

  

 

 

 

John, I don't recommend lynching me.

 

 

Why not? If you are a vanilla townie, you should understand the value in dying now. Knowing your alignment gives us great context for all the reactions we've gotten.

 

I'm afraid this game is much more complicated than that, knowing the setting (Dresden files) and the game type (advanced).

 

You do have a point. Lynching me would confirm that I'm not scum. I just don't think that sort of information would be useful. I'd rather lynch someone from one of ther scum groups.

 

To be snarky, I don't think the information would be the most useful part. I'm so close to policy kynching you. I've never done that before

 

You are starting fights, you are making random accusations, you aren't even reading the thread properly but still use what you don't really read to make wild statements, you also take no responsibility

 

 

 

**** OFF

 

Sometimes I can only post at all if I change theme to mobile. Like half of the time the text area just doesn't appear. I got the tip of switching to mobile theme from an admin and it works for me for now..

 

**** ON

 

Johh, I'm implying that I believe that there should be multiple scum teams. It's not a big logical leap knowing the theme. 

I'm also implying that getting my coroner's report wouldn't help getting closer to solving the game.

 

Just cos a show has more than one bad guy does t nessacarily mean multiple teams.

I also find it odd you don't remember skimmers or skimming yet multiple mafia teams is part of your lingo?

That's rare as hens teeth and yet you seem aware if it, yet something DM mafia spouts each and everyday you forgot

 

 

Well, if I was the worst scum player of all times, you'd have ample chances to catch me later wouldn't you :)

 

unvote

The problem is I'm leaning worst town, if I were mAfia and you were on my team I simply would not let you do what you have done

 

 

Also welcome rand

 

Nol I have to do all my replies on a code level

[csarmi]

Above and bold read it. I won't quote it again. We have also been informed that Rand is the replacement. You got that?

 

Yea. In the end, I've found the original post as well. It was easy to miss. I'm not used to this mobile layout.

 

You are starting fights, you are making random accusations, you aren't even reading the thread properly but still use what you don't really read to make wild statements, you also take no responsibility

 

Random accusations and wild statements? Like yours here?

 

I also find it odd you don't remember skimmers or skimming yet multiple mafia teams is part of your lingo? That's rare as hens teeth and yet you seem aware if it, yet something DM mafia spouts each and everyday you forgot

 

Why is that odd? People tend to not remember insignificant things (lingo included) and remember interesting ones. I've played several interesting advanced games, in one of them there were three maffia teams (3 groups of Black Ajah) and they wiped one another out in a few rounds. Much more memorable then remembering random english words.

 

Welcome Rand!

[Niniel]

 

 

Given that you would have to know the theme to think there might be multiple scum groups I'm not sure that is an assumption anyone should be making at this time. While it's entirely possible John has overlooked that fact and thus given a slight advantage to anyone who does know the theme there is no evidence that this is the case. I think before making statements like these we should at least see how many nightkillers there are out there.

Agreed, too early to bother speculating on setup. FOS whomever brought this up as yet another deviation from the agenda of scum hunting.... cspasmo

I have a life. No, not really.

 

I don´t know anything about the theme. Would it be realistic with two scum teams?

 

 

 

FOS you, an experience player, for encouraging the setup talk. Dwindling off on a chat about the setup serves only scum, they already know more about what's going on than we do. There's no point in opening a dialogue about setup only so that scum can nudge us off on tangents and acceptance of probable setup theories that are false.

Yea I think so,

 

Several different kind of groups are quite likely (vampires, werewolves, maffia, wizards), some of those can be a mason too.

 

All sorts of alignments are possible as well. The casting is quite rich and the plot can be very interesting :)

 

This is an advanced game too.

It's good that you know about the source material, but there is absolutely no reason for us to begin buying into setup theories at this stage. It's pretty much an open wound for scum to pick at, if we start reaching consensus on setup without having seen anything in the game to fortify those theories.

 

In other words, let the game play out and stop talking about setup, it is scummy.

 

I'm starting to bend town on you. You were a useful fix in order to get info, but there's just no way you'd actually hit on all these scum tells if you were actually scum. Unless you are the worst scum player of all time, in which case, that's the wifom isn't it?

 

Unvote

The reason I asked is because I thought it was a strange thing to mention and wondered if it might have been a slip or just logical to someone who has background knowledge.