[BASIC] Disney Mafia Game Thread - GAME OVER: SK WINS!

[Razen]

Red (5) - Rand, Peace, AH, Tina, Darthe

Rand (2) - Red, Song

Peace (2) - Basel, Isabella

Izabella (2) - Nolder, AJ

 

Not voting (1) - Ironeyes

 

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch. There is no deadline set at this time.

[RandA lThor]

Tina: Not pushing elsewhere than Red, applying pressure. I'd like to see more from this Red/Rand/Song/Peace thing before deciding on it.

 

Who are you asking for more from on this? Rand, Red and I have beat this horse to death.

 

Yeah, I think all of us have given all of our arguments already, we're pretty much repeating ourselves now.

[alannalynn]

I didn't word that correctly, I want to hear what others views are or whether they have anything to add, otherwise, I'm waiting for one of you to slip up BECAUSE all you're doing now is repeating the same stuff.

[RandA lThor]

I didn't word that correctly, I want to hear what others views are or whether they have anything to add, otherwise, I'm waiting for one of you to slip up BECAUSE all you're doing now is repeating the same stuff.

 

that's because we have already voiced all our views. :) Or most of them, from time to time a new one comes up.

[Nolder]

So I just reread the thread

I don't like that some people are sitting on the sidelines regarding this whole Red/Song/Peace/Rand thing

 

Vote Iza

 

dude i'm getting sick of you donig this and i'm gonna start policy voting you when you fake vote. its distracting and manipulative and does nothign to beneift the town imo. major FoS!

So I missed this post earlier

 

First of all you're bringing things that happened in another game and applying them here. That's not cool on a few different levels.

Secondly you are flat out wrong about it being a "fake vote". And after being corrected by the mod you...just act as if it never happened. Cool.

[Red2111]

in this game its not a fake vote, but general rule of thumb says it is a fake vote Nol. if you guys want to lynch me, fine; but i'm Beast from Beauty and the Beast, and protector. i'll try to get back on during he weekand but no promises.

[RandA lThor]

Sorry, I swear sometime I will know all the roles. What is a protector?

[Basel Gill]

All right, I withdraw the bit about Rand. I got the quotes mixed up there. However, I still wonder about what game you are playing regarding Red and Song. My money says that at least one of them is town, because it would not be a good scum strategy IMO for you to plant suspicion at two scummates at once, especially on D1. Planting suspicion on one teammate is understandable for distancing, but doing so on two scummates is too risky. This doesn't eliminate the chance of them both being town and you trying to set up multiple lynches.

 

And I had to look up "strawman routine.".

 

i agree with your previous casing on peace but dislike how quickly you backed down from your case. yours and peaces interaction is pinging and i dislike how your ignoring mine, songs and rands interaction and instead focusing on peace. especially since i think peace is playing puppet master.

 

FoS

 

Wow, Red, did you actually notice the entire rest of my post beyond the first sentence? I backed down from part of my case based on the fact that I got what you and Peace said mixed up. I only withdrew the bit concerning Rand. The stuff concerning Peace's interactions with you I left as is. And you'll notice I didn't change my vote. So you seem to have a funny definition of "backing down". As for you playing like you normally do, I will agree with you here... if you mean normal as building a case full of holes and then calling scum on anyone who catches the holes. How well did that work out for you in Avengers?

 

i call it purposefuly acting scummy because i know i'm exagerating a reaction or case that most will find ping worthy.

 

And yet, the quandary you present to town never seems to occur to you. When you are a townie, acting scummy on purpose is going to convince town that you are scum, and get you lynched, which hurts your own side with a mislynch.

 

when i flip town,

 

Which game is that going to be in? You are giving off quite a bit of pinginess, and it has me thinking that I've found Peace's scummate. Nice gambit between the two of you.

 

Please explain Red how I proceeded to "manipulate it". All I did was point out a possibility, and you jumped on me like a red trying to pretty someone.

 

for a 3rd time. becuase instead of using it to case me, you used it to link myself and song together.

 

 

The problem with your theory is it hides you when you are scum. So you can't be too surprised when you get lynched early as town. It's your fault. You may be helping yourself in determining the alignments of others but you are helping town as a whole.

 

1st - you can GFY since your on a high horse

 

2nd - no where did i say i'm afriad to be lynched. this is never the case in any game i play in, if it was i wouldn't play with the style i play with. so i repeat, GFY

 

3rd - it helps the town to, becuase they can use interactions and who pushes my lyncha dn how they push it to help shift out the scum.

 

4th - i don't change my playstyle, i play the same reguardless of role and alignment. so no it doesnt hide me as scum it just makes meta on me useless. whcih is just fine by me since i disagree with using meta as a way to determine alignments.

 

 

 

keep on pushing hard peace, cause once i flip your goign down and that alone is enough for me.

 

Wow, taking things a bit hard here. It's only a game, Red.

 

and no Rand, your vote reason was on my over-reaction, of which i did on prupose; your case (reason behind your pressure no me) was to push the linking of me and song.

 

Uh-huh. You did it on purpose. How do we know you aren't saying you did it on purpose to cover your own scumslip? I could not look where I am going, walk right into a brick wall, and claim to have done it on purpose. Doesn't make it so.

 

And now you've gone and claimed doc. I don't know if I am buying this, but I don't know that I am willing to put a vote on a claimed, uncountered doc. I am sticking with Peace for now, but you have a big FoS from me.

[Basel Gill]

Sorry, I swear sometime I will know all the roles. What is a protector?

 

Rand, I think Red is trying to claim doctor but with a different name.

[RandA lThor]

Oh, OK. Now, even though I am probably the youngest person in the game, I don't remember an instance where Beast is a protector, but I probably missed something.

[Red2111]

Beast protected Belle from the wolves twice and from that jerk Gahston at the end.

 

Wow, Red, did you actually notice the entire rest of my post beyond the first sentence? I backed down from part of my case based on the fact that I got what you and Peace said mixed up. I only withdrew the bit concerning Rand. The stuff concerning Peace's interactions with you I left as is. And you'll notice I didn't change my vote. So you seem to have a funny definition of "backing down". As for you playing like you normally do, I will agree with you here... if you mean normal as building a case full of holes and then calling scum on anyone who catches the holes. How well did that work out for you in Avengers?

 

by backing down i mean your case started with bite and then you put a muzzle on it. like you were scum, saw you mucked up and decided to back down before it sent off red flags and you dug yourself a nice grave. funny you mention the avengers, cause in that game i had a pretty important roles as well. while that game it didn't work well for me, its worked pretty damn well in other games. look at the Monty Python game, where i faked a PR and outed alot of scum with my antics cause it drove them nuts.

 

no ones playstyle is perfect, whats important is the results and info it gives. and i like the results my playstyle gets.

 

 

And yet, the quandary you present to town never seems to occur to you. When you are a townie, acting scummy on purpose is going to convince town that you are scum, and get you lynched, which hurts your own side with a mislynch.

 

it only hurts if if i go down without giving you guys loads of info.

 

 

Which game is that going to be in? You are giving off quite a bit of pinginess, and it has me thinking that I've found Peace's scummate. Nice gambit between the two of you.

 

well i was town in Chrissy's game, and i'm town in this game. as you know i flipped town in Chrissy's game so ofcourse i mean this one.

 

yeah, nice linking me with peace. not bad enough i'm linked with Song but now you link me with Peace. tell me, are you and Rand trying to setup another townie lynch or just tryign to clear a scum buddy?

 

 

Wow, taking things a bit hard here. It's only a game, Red.

 

no, i saw his post as being condescending and reacted as such. yes it was defensive, which is why i stepped away fromt eh game ealier. i already said as much

 

Uh-huh. You did it on purpose. How do we know you aren't saying you did it on purpose to cover your own scumslip? I could not look where I am going, walk right into a brick wall, and claim to have done it on purpose. Doesn't make it so.

 

 

because i'm more subtle than that. i made a dangerous play and was trying to appear scummy enough so the scum team didn't suspect me of a power role and so they'd fall over themselves trying to set up my lynch. its worked, you can thank me after you get their corner reports; i prefer gummy worms and butterfingers to cookies though. i've done thsi before, numerous times. and each time i snare atleast 1 or two scum in my trap.

 

 

And now you've gone and claimed doc. I don't know if I am buying this, but I don't know that I am willing to put a vote on a claimed, uncountered doc. I am sticking with Peace for now, but you have a big FoS from me.

 

basically doc, yes but Razen called it Protector. i dont care if you're buying it or not because i know what my PM says. i will note you tryign to discredit me even though your too scared to put your vote where your mouth is. what, afriad my corner report will seal your fate as well?

 

 

 

mine is in blue

[RandA lThor]

This seems like a reasonable claim for now, and I don't want to restrict lynching the doc.

[peacesells]

unVote Vote basil/b]

 

I think I can finally see what Red was doing.

 

Ithi did thIs to me in the lab game when I was goblin king. I played too town with too much logic. It's what basil is doing here yet not voting who he has cased the most.

[peacesells]

This seems like a reasonable claim for now, and I don't want to restrict lynching the doc.

 

You gonna unvote red?

[RandA lThor]

oh yeah, unvote

[Basel Gill]

This seems like a reasonable claim for now, and I don't want to restrict lynching the doc.

 

So you believe her claim, and you are still willing to lynch her? If you take her claim at all seriously, then why are you still voting her?

 

unVote Vote basil/b]

 

I think I can finally see what Red was doing.

 

Ithi did thIs to me in the lab game when I was goblin king. I played too town with too much logic. It's what basil is doing here yet not voting who he has cased the most.

 

So you are saying I should be willing to put a claimed and un-cc'ed doc at L-1? (L-2 now, but it would have been L-1 at the time I posted that). I had been all set to vote Red up till her claim. You did catch my FoS on her, right? And since you are most likely scum yourself, I'm betting you would be opportunist enough to accuse me of being willing to lynch the doc and then vote me for that had I changed my vote. Red's claim is the only thing keeping me from voting her (that and I've already found you to be scum), and she is on very thin ice, with her feet dangling over the edge.

[Basel Gill]

Ninja'ed by Rand.

[Razen]

CURRENT VOTE COUNT:

Red (3) - AH, Tina, Darthe

Rand (2) - Red, Song

Peace (2) - Basel, Isabella

Izabella (2) - Nolder, AJ

Basel (1) - Peace

 

Not voting (2) - Ironeyes, Rand

 

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch. There is no deadline at this time.

[peacesells]

Basel you've found me to be scum? You claiming a role?

[Basel Gill]

Basel you've found me to be scum? You claiming a role?

 

I have deduced that you are scum by your behavior.

[Aiel Heart]

Will catch up some point tomorrow. Today was nuts and I'm brain fried

[peacesells]

Basel you've found me to be scum? You claiming a role?

 

I have deduced that you are scum by your behavior.

 

I'd say you are a little bit more Watson than Holmes sir.

[Niniel]

So I have been thinking about how to do but I´m going to just come out and say it. Red is lying. I´m the doc. I know that one of the reasons she claims protector is to draw me out but I figure that this is a basic game with 3 scum. If we lynch her today we are one down. I think I have a good guess on who is cop so even if they kill me tonight the cop will at least get to view one person. I think this day´s actions have given us a lot of information that the cop can use and also for the town to use tomorrow.

 

This is a basic game. There is no way that there are two docs, whatever you may call them. Red is lying and I want us to lynch her.

[Basel Gill]

Well, since I was already suspicious of her, I think this is the last nail in the coffin. Unvote. Vote Red.

[peacesells]

UNVOTE, VOTE RED.

 

Tina..you should be able to stay alive at least until the cop reveals. Then it's a 50/50 chance on who they target.