There Goes the Neighborhood (Game Thread) - GAME OVER MAFIA WIN

[Darthe]

Hey mynd, I think you may be off on deputy dude. if not then awesome =)

[Myndrunner]

lol, how can I play un-Key like when I'm Key?

 

Not sure where you are getting that I haven't done a proper casing. I remember casing Darthe before he came out as cop, and Hoof yesterday. I also feel like I've possibly caught something with Basel, though true that I haven't cased him as of yet.

 

You were relentless in Sith mafia, but here you are hedging your votes. One casing on a player who was already being voted doesn't count. Let's hope that you do a proper KEY-style casing on Basel....I look forward to reading it.

[keyholder21]

I was relentless in Sith mafia? Are you sure it's me you are talking about? I was on vacation for most of that game.

[Myndrunner]

I was relentless in Sith mafia? Are you sure it's me you are talking about? I was on vacation for most of that game.

 

Yoda you were, powerful in the game you were.......reserved you are here. Something to hide you have?

[Ironeyes]

Iron... I'm trying to exactly place it. I feel in the past few pages a lot of what he has been doing is piggy backing. Agreeing with statements, but not making many accusations aside from the ridiculous one about how scummy I've been all game. However the Translation things, while I personally feel it has no real barring on the game could either be a noob trying to find things or mafia trying to distract on things that don't matter.

Of course I'm piggybacking. I'm way over my head in this game. It's more advanced than anything I've seen so far. I am doing my best to contribute. Be back later today.

[Ironeyes]

Iron... I'm trying to exactly place it. I feel in the past few pages a lot of what he has been doing is piggy backing. Agreeing with statements, but not making many accusations aside from the ridiculous one about how scummy I've been all game. However the Translation things, while I personally feel it has no real barring on the game could either be a noob trying to find things or mafia trying to distract on things that don't matter.

Of course I'm piggybacking. I'm way over my head in this game. It's more advanced than anything I've seen so far. I am doing my best to contribute. Be back later today.

[Razen]

I'm still skeptical of Darthe's claim because I believe that it would be quite a powerful role indeed for a game like this for him to be able to see both alignment and role in his viewings. Why would one person need to know all of that material? Usually, alignment would be enough, wouldn't you agree? So why share that Limi is VANILLA town? I'm not liking this at all, it smells too much to me of Darthe trying to direct something off of his scummate. He could have just said she was town without sharing her role.

 

It bothers me too, but we are trusting the word of confirmed scum on that as well which makes it difficult. I had forgotten about that though I knew there was some reason I was worried about a godmother... This will take some thought.

 

Then he brings up being worried about a godmother. I'm not certain why he would be worried about a godmother unless she was his teammate of some sort. However, I've had a chance to do a reread of what has happened since day began, and I'm feeling like Limi is a better lynch. However, I don't think Darthe is being completely honest with us, and Limi's flip will tell us more about that. Unvote, vote: Limi.

[Little Miss]

Those are all rehashed reasons razen, no matter how wordy you try and make it.

[Myndrunner]

"Rehashed Reasons from Razen Really Require a Re-Read!"

 

Let's look at the pros and cons of lynching Limi now:

possible scenarios

1) She flips mafia, then not only do we bag one now, it also makes Darthe look shady. Wrinkle in this is the redirection thing Limi mentioned.

2) She flips vanilla town, then it suggests that Darthe correctly viewed her. In a normal mafia game, I'd say "of course he knows who is town if he's mafia" but the fact that not only he used the words "vanilla" as well as this being a multi-mafia game, there are too many variables that would make him a LLL.

3) She flips roled town, then it makes Darthe look shady. Again, wrinkle is the whole redirection thing.

 

It bothers me that Limi is already setting the stage for "redirection" as if she already believes peacesells team viewed her.

[Little Miss]

*shrugs* I know I was not at Mynd 1.0 that game, and there have already been 2 deaths that didn't state "vanilla" in the name, meaning they had some ability of some kind. I don't think my idea is far fetched.

 

And since Darthe never got back to us on if the the difference between Mynd 1.0 just being town and me being vanilla town it looks like he might just be parroting what I've said.

 

Mynd just make up your mind, and quite flip flopping between the idea that I'm prolly town and the idea that it's better to lynch me, it's getting a bit tedious.

[Myndrunner]

Mynd just make up your mind, and quite flip flopping between the idea that I'm prolly town and the idea that it's better to lynch me, it's getting a bit tedious.

 

I'm not sure your lynch is the right move right now.

[Little Miss]

*That night = not game

[Little Miss]

Some things I just remembered.... Wasn't BG going to reveal, and if he did, how in the hell did I miss it? Not that I particularly care, however he made such a bog deal about going to do it and how he didn't want to seem wishy washy by claiming he wouldn't do it now that Nolder was dead.

 

 

Also - I think Peace (if he was telling the truth) slipped when he said "he" when referring to the tracker person in his group.

[Myndrunner]

Some things I just remembered.... Wasn't BG going to reveal, and if he did, how in the hell did I miss it? Not that I particularly care, however he made such a bog deal about going to do it and how he didn't want to seem wishy washy by claiming he wouldn't do it now that Nolder was dead.

The thing about BG is that on one hand, he's been playing very aggressively and voted me out of the gate when Nyn died, which to me suggests he was in on the decision to NK her. On the other hand, I have reason to believe he's a benefit to the town. He actively debated Mynd 1.0 on the whole probability theory, which to me, is the action of a pro-town player. I could be wrong about him, but I think it would be a mistake to lynch him today.

 

Also - I think Peace (if he was telling the truth) slipped when he said "he" when referring to the tracker person in his group.

 

Peace left us a nice bit of WIFOM before his death, didn't he.

[Myndrunner]

Reposting this from page 42....

 

Vote Count:

 

Mynd (8) - Nolder, Basel, Arez, Nae, Darthe, peace, Tina, EP

Nyn (4) - Razen, Blackhoof, Mynd

EP (1) - Nyn

BG (1) - Little Miss

Ishy (1) - Songstress

Kae (1) - Ishy

Little Miss (1) - Kae

 

EP gets Modkilled

 

Vote Count:

 

Nolder (13) - Mynd, Darthe, BG, songstress, Razen, Kaylee, kae, Nyn, Little Miss, Lenlo, Key, Ironeyes, Piano

Mynd (5) - Nolder, Arez, Nae, Tina, Blackhoof

Hoof (2) peace, Basel

Kae (1) - Ishy

 

(...Nolder lynched...)

 

Nolder's Lynch - End of Day 1

 

Mynd 1.0 killed - End of Night 1

 

Vote Count:

 

Darthe (7) -Tina, Nyn, peace, Key, Razen, Hoof, player

Hoof (2) - Basel, Kae

Ishy (1) - AH

Arez (1) - Darthe

 

Darthe claims Sherrif

 

Vote Count:

 

peace (4) - Razen, Ironeyes, AH, Darthe

Hoof (3) - Basel, Kae, Key

Darthe (1) - Piano

Piano (1) - Tina

Little Miss (1) - peace

 

Vote Count:

 

peace (12) - Razen, Ironeyes, AH, Darthe, Mynd, Arez, BG, Songstress, peace, Kaylee, Tina, Little Miss

Hoof (3) - Basel, Kae, Key

Piano (1) - Tina

Darthe (1) - Piano

Ishy (1) - Nae

Little Miss (1) - peace

 

Interesting that Basel, Kae, and Key did not vote Peace at all even after he voted himself. Kaylee and Tina look suspicious for avoiding his lynch until after he votes himself. Limi does the hammer.

 

Vote Keyholder This is the way to go.

[Little Miss]

Key claims that she thought she was the one to hammer him, and her reason was the bolded parts of his reveal. Essentially she voted on him because he said he was scum.

[keyholder21]

Really not getting why you two are coming after me, but *shrugs*.

 

I didn't vote for him before I did, because I wasn't around so I didn't see what was going on. The last six votes on him took place within an hour. My bad for not being online and on DM for that hour .

 

Furthermore, I just went back and looked at all the votes on Peace, I didn't see where he voted for himself, so that is either a typo or someone was controlling his vote.

 

Limi - you voted him for that reason, and you technically were the hammer, so if that looks scummy on me, it looks scummy on you also.

[keyholder21]

Also, I have two birthday parties to go to this evening, so I probably won't be around again until tomorrow midmorning/afternoon.

[Little Miss]

Seeing as how he had been casing me all day with weak reasons (which turns out her did the exact same thing as me for the same reasons) and he dragged my name through the mud in his final words, I don't particularly feel any regrets on being the hammer. The fact that I was the hammer doesn't change the that at the time you THOUGHT it was your vote.

 

Personally, I'm not saying that it was just that one time, I am saying that you are pinging me, along with several others.

[Little Miss]

* he

[John E. Kelley]

Oh, and Ishy! Y U NO sign up for Avengers Mafia after registering at MJ Forums?!

 

Sorry sir, thought I could fit it in before retirement, but the old folks home calls. This one will be my last.

[John E. Kelley]

Iron... I'm trying to exactly place it. I feel in the past few pages a lot of what he has been doing is piggy backing. Agreeing with statements, but not making many accusations aside from the ridiculous one about how scummy I've been all game. However the Translation things, while I personally feel it has no real barring on the game could either be a noob trying to find things or mafia trying to distract on things that don't matter.

Of course I'm piggybacking. I'm way over my head in this game. It's more advanced than anything I've seen so far. I am doing my best to contribute. Be back later today.

 

Somehow I doubt it. You're a pro now, and the noob card won't fly anymore.

[Niniel]

Have checked some of the game but not all. I´m too tired to vote right now but I will point out some things that I noticed:

 

1. Basel #1138 - says Limi visited Mynd 1.0 as it is a fact. How does he know? I might read too much into this. Other wise I agree with his suspiciouns about Razen.

 

2. Razen has defended Key. Now that Mynd voted Key he votes Limi. Afraid of a Key train? He votes Limi to vet Darthe who he is still suspicious of.

 

3. AH - #1150 asks if town might be spanish. There is nothing in my PM that indicates that.

 

I need to think about who to vote when I wake up tomorrow. BG and Ishy pings. Also Razen and AH. I´m suspicious of those that voted Darthe.

 

Sorry if it´s seems random, I´m very tired.

[Basel Gill]

Tina, it is not fact, but I am willing to guess that Peace is not from the same faction as Limi, and was willing to use the results he really did get if they will incriminate a rival mafia. Even if he was lying, a Limi lynch will still help us figure if Darthe is telling the truth.

[Naeann]

Here's more wifom for you..... What if Peace and Darthe were working together? Peace is getting alot of heat and wifoms about a watcher/tracker person who saw Limi visit Mynd 1.0 and then Darthe claims sheriff and picks Limi to view and goes on about deputys and fancy mega roles. Or perhaps Limi was working with one of them? She doesn't say Peace is lying... she says it must have been redirected.

 

Also, Aiel Heart... You ask if maybe the town is spanish. (my pm didn't say anything about it) So you are asking if the town nightkilled Nyn?

 

Also, Mynd, you gave even the laziest of mafia a big heads up on the potential deputy and healer... why? Darthe then goes even further to speculate your speculation. I'm with Iron that this game is insane. :P