Create-Your-Own-Role Mafia 7: Everybody Wins *game over*

[Gabriel Kross]

why am I RIP? am I gonna die?

[Basel Gill]

Pandy, why aren't you voting?

 

 

I get that you know who Mafia and Scum are, but how can YOU just not vote, but be counted as a voting person? It leaves the town at a disdvantage, as that means we have to get one more person from the town side to agree.

 

 

Bad form, sir. Why not just make it so you don't count?

 

I also find myself curious here.

[Christine]

Please state whether or not you are town. I want to LD you tonight.

RIP

 

He likely means me. I probably will not live through the night.

 

:(

 

Unless, of course, those points I have protect you from being killed?!?!

 

*eyes Pandy*

[Gabriel Kross]

but then how are you gonna vet me town?! I'd rather not go to the vet to be veted town so if you could vet me town that'd be great.

[Nolder]

It's all a very nice WIFOM that will probably result in Christine's death IMO

[Gabriel Kross]

Are you mafia?

[Nolder]

no

[LilyElizabeth]

Christine, did you miss Pandy's post? You can't LD the statement that he is town. Either that, or I misunderstood.

[Christine]

Christine, did you miss Pandy's post? You can't LD the statement that he is town. Either that, or I misunderstood.

 

 

Ach, but there are easy ways around it.

 

 

Let's say he states something like...

 

"I just want to help the town".

 

 

Pandy, is he telling the truth?

 

 

Well, if he is Mafia, then he is not telling the truth.

 

 

But, I am not LDing whether or not he is town or mafia.

 

 

Also, I am not done trying to convince Pandy to let me LD alignment.

 

 

 

Regardless, if EP had no been willing to state he was town, that would be a massive FoS, regardless of whether or not I can LD for it.

[Gabriel Kross]

well then Chrissy can LD this statement...

 

 

Do I want to kill townies? No (It technically gets around the can't LD the am I a townie.)

[Gabriel Kross]

Oh ninja'd

[Ironeyes]

Wait... you can't LD alignments? When did I miss that?

[Basel Gill]

Wait... you can't LD alignments? When did I miss that?

 

Apparently right when Pandy began the game thread. Chrissy should just be happy I'm not the one who submitted lie detector.

[dapianoplay3r]

Bah see you all

Should have used another role Pandy

 

Go town!

[Nolder]

well then Chrissy can LD this statement...

 

 

Do I want to kill townies? No (It technically gets around the can't LD the am I a townie.)

ambiguous IMO

 

you want to win

townies dying is just the means by which winning is accomplished if you're mafia

as mafia you technically don't have to ever directly kill a townie or even be on a lynch to win

[cosmicpanda]

Pandy player mode:

 

I said before that I had a PR: that I couldn't vote, and that I couldn't reveal the mafia.

 

~~~

 

Pandy mod mode:

 

Oh, and yes, if you give me an ambiguous question with the LD role, you'll get an ambiguous answer; if you ask me a question to which I can't know the answer, you'll also get an unsatisfactory reply.

 

 

Votecount 11:

 

Mynd: 5 (TinaHel, Nolder, Blackhoof, Wombat)

Piano: 8 (Thorum, Ironeyes, Lily, Mynd, Christine, Alanna, EP, Basel)

 

Not voting: Pandy, Piano

 

 

Pandy Points Count:

 

Christine: 13

Ironeyes: 12

Nolder: 2

Lily: 1

EP: -9

 

 

~~~

 

Piano is dead. He was a townie.

 

It is now night. Deadline is 72 hours. Send in those night actions!

[Basel Gill]

Pandy player mode:

 

I said before that I had a PR: that I couldn't vote, and that I couldn't reveal the mafia.

 

~~~

 

Pandy mod mode:

 

Oh, and yes, if you give me an ambiguous question with the LD role, you'll get an ambiguous answer; if you ask me a question to which I can't know the answer, you'll also get an unsatisfactory reply.

 

 

Votecount 11:

 

Mynd: 5 (TinaHel, Nolder, Blackhoof, Wombat)

Piano: 8 (Thorum, Ironeyes, Lily, Mynd, Christine, Alanna, EP, Basel)

 

Not voting: Pandy, Piano

 

 

That may be so, Pandy, but if you don't have a vote, you shouldn't count yourself when figuring the number of players needed for a majority. That gives scum an unfair advantage by making deadlocks more likely and creating no-lynch-friendly situations, which means balance is all shot to hell from what I can see. If you hadn't been counting yourself, majority would be 7 out of 13, meaning we would have already had a lynch and no one should have had to switch their vote last minute to make a hammer.

[Ironeyes]

Agreed.

[LilyElizabeth]

Maybe Pandy is mafia and wants them to have that advantage. *Eyes Pandy warily*

[Gabriel Kross]

Maybe Pandy is mafia and wants them to have that advantage. *Eyes Pandy warily*

 

So Pandy is a good day 2 lynch?

[Christine]

The points scare me.

[Blackhoof]

i really dotn think pandy should be a player. as he is he is merely an observer who can talk, and that is pretty much what a mod does.

 

why not just be a mod who likes to comment neutrally on everything?

[cosmicpanda]

EP, I'm not mafia. But since you lot seem quite happy not to try and go after them, I guess you could lynch me tomorrow.

[Nolder]

I can't envision a scenario in which CP is mafia and this game is balanced so I'm going to assume he's not mafia and therefore not worth lynching

[Christine]

Whoever has the ability to give out points tomorrow should fill us in.