[ADVANCED/KITCHEN SINK] The Axe or the Hammer - GAME OVER

[bgrishinko]

Hmmm... I multi-quoted a bunch of stuff and now it is gone.

 

... and I'm too lazy to do it again. So I'm just going to hit on whatever points I remember before the memories fade.

 

Okay, so I thought Meesh's non-casing thing on Wombat was ironic since it felt like the exact same thing I did on day 1 that I got called out on so much for. I know, not quite the same, but the idea was the same. "I've gotten a funny feeling from person X." "Why?" "I'm not sure, I need to go back and look." *proceeds to quote everything*

 

That being said, I agree about Wombat. I've got a bad feeling about him too.

 

Also I think that the rule about no "Are you town?" etc. infered that there could be a Lie Detector, but I don't necessarily think it means more than one. I know that it is a personal pet peeve of Amadine's when people ask you to declare it because she prides herself on not lying when she plays... I've been in games where she's been asked that as mafia and all she does is sidestep the question. She's Aes Sedai to the bone, even when mafia. So I can understand the rule even if there weren't a LD.

 

Also Turin being a replacement I think has no relevence on whether Turin is CL or not especially since Day 1 had no recruiting. Coulda been an inactive cult leader easily.

 

and... um... I'm sure there was other stuff, alas. I guess it wasn't that important.

[Amadine]

1. Weirdest role ever to put in a game that already has a cop imo

 

*stabs Nolder*

 

Maybe you're the weirdest player to play in a game.

 

*sniffs and hugs his sister*

 

 

 

love you bro *snugglebites*

 

 

You were all warned it was a Kitchen Sink-type game right from the beginning.... the first commandment of mafia really should be DON'T MOD THE MOD *nods*

 

 

 

[hazelkrs1]

Hey, I came back after a day and there wasn't 4 pages of stuff to go through for once!

 

Not really anything else to add right now, except for OMGUS Meesh! Stop making our gambit too obvious!

[Sakaea]

*pokes teh game*

[dapianoplay3r]

*it wobbles a bit but lies still*

[ed2funy]

*throws a pokeball at the game*

[dapianoplay3r]

should'da used a master ball

[bgrishinko]

Just awaitin' on the sunrise...

 

 

[mmeeshal]

Ditto!

[Amadine]

Please welcome back Soy, he's replacing Tina!

[dapianoplay3r]

Welcome Soy. good luck and enjoy the read (it's interesting, be it longish)

[Amadine]

He's fairly up to date Player LOL, he only died a few days back...

[dapianoplay3r]

*too many games at once*

[SBoydW]

I've been skimming since I was axed last night. I'm gonna do a more detalied read and find some of the things that didn't sit right with me. I'll post something... eventually...

[Amadine]

Lacile mourned the death of her companion, even though she had proven to have been turned to the way of the Dragonsworn. It was due to her melancholy that Lacile was wandering alone late that night, near onto to midnight. She never heard the one who crept up behind her, never uttered a single sound as her throat was slit from behind.

 

Some hours later in the dawn light, one of the scouts found Lacile as he was heading out for the day...

 

Kae - Lacile Aldorwin - Lightsworn Neighbourhood Watch and Cha’Faile member was dead

 

 

It is now Day Six

13 players = 7 to lynch

[hazelkrs1]

That's very interesting... could it have been Kae's neighbor partner who offed her? Had their been any talk of a neighborhood watch before this?

[SBoydW]

Her and red had been on a team. Red was turned cult, and lynched.

[SBoydW]

feeling like I should put my vote back where it was...

 

you know guys if Maw was scum he'd know who was town and not (or at least he would have before we knew there was a cult)

just throwin it out ther

 

 

maybe he thought BG was going down no matter what? he was under some pretty heavy pressure even after the reveal

and if BG goes down as town it "confirms" Maw

except it doesn't really

 

 

yeah I guess but this hasn't seemed like a very experimental game so far

everything seems very generic and well planned

 

edit: his gameplay just isn't backing his role

he's not playing like a townie and that's my point

 

I'm gonna put my vote back on him as I find the (my own) case against Maw much more convincing than the one against Turin

 

Vote: Maw

 

 

the dude is playing by the book scummy

unless he's a jester it doesn't make sense to me at all

 

 

well what I think sucks is he really didn't defend himself much today

he accused/voted some people out of nowhere and then when the votes started piling on it seemed like he was just resigned to death

 

Okay so, Nolder super pinged me with these posts. The vote was leaning towards Turin, and then Nolder brings out this rather thin case against Maw. It was full of a bunch of and maybes and no real supporting facts. On top of that Nolder's play this game has just felt really off this game. While he hasn't exactly laid low, he's been fairly non confrontational, and has either backed down from debates/arguments, or tried to stop others from doing the same on multiple occasions. Seems like he's trying to hide in plain sight.

 

Vote: Nolder

[Verbal32]

That's very interesting... could it have been Kae's neighbor partner who offed her? Had their been any talk of a neighborhood watch before this?

 

That was not a joke, was it?

[SBoydW]

forgot to bold... Vote: Nolder

[bgrishinko]

Turin isn't sworn to the light.

 

Vote Turin

[John E. Kelley]

Turin isn't sworn to the light.

 

Vote Turin

 

Verrry interesting....

 

Vote Turin.

[mmeeshal]

Well, in light of that, I'll hold off voting Despo for now.

 

Although I really think I'd love to.

 

Vote Turin

[mmeeshal]

Oh, and welcome back, Soy!

[Sakaea]

BAH!!!! NO!!!!!! I was having so much fun with this game....Go Town!!!!

 

Ama, let me know if you need another replacement.