[Basic] Peg + Cat Mafia -- TOWN WIN

[Shad_]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

 

Ed (3) - Eldrick, Spades, LZM

 

Not Voting: Songstress, Tigraine, Ed, Hallia, Adella, Shanti

 

 

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

 

[Tigraine]

Ed has been on my radar since my ISO. I've seen nothing from him at all.

 

[V] ed [/v]

[Tigraine]

Sorry shad

[Eldrick4221]

Are we gonna get our first actual of the game?

[Eldrick4221]

Aws. The hammer pic didn't post

[Eldrick4221]

I'm annoyed that I didn't stick with alex. I got him on his wording, but decided that wasn't a good enough reason.

 

Still proud of figuring Darthe out tho

[Eldrick4221]

Sorry. Assuming we already won lol. I'm confident it's ed.

[Songstress]

I'm good to hammer, if you all like - it has to be either Ed or Adella according to my notes last night.

 

and lolme bad at this game

[Shad_]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

 

Ed (4) - Eldrick, Spades, LZM, Tig

 

Not Voting: Songstress, Ed, Hallia, Adella, Shanti

 

 

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

 

[Eldrick4221]

I'm good to hammer, if you all like - it has to be either Ed or Adella according to my notes last night.

 

and lolme bad at this game

I'm cool with it. I don't see today going any other way and no need to drag it out.

[Songstress]

*nods* Le'z do dis then.

 

[v]Ed[/v]

[Eldrick4221]

Problem solved.

The problem is solved.

We solved the problem, problem solved.

[Shad_]

FINAL VOTE COUNT

 

Ed (5) - Eldrick, Spades, LZM, Tig, Tress

 

Not Voting: Ed, Hallia, Adella, Shanti

[Shad_]

 

Ed has been lynched.

 

He was:

 

 

Mac, Vanilla Town

 

 

[Shad_]

[Shad_]

Night 3

 

[Shad_]

Note: day will start when I go to bed and end at 8pm est Monday, to avoid making either phase excessively long while keeping us on the same timetable.

[Shad_]

Ask a mod: If wolves don't kill anyone, does anyone die?

 

Answer: No. 

[Shad_]

"Hi Peg."

 

"Ramooooooooooooone?        What are you doing here?"

 

"Oh, I'm just hunting wolves with my Scumdar 500 Honing Rod! Every night, it tells me whether someone is a villager or a wolf! Want to give it a try?"

 

"Totally! That's amazing!"

 

"I do what I can!" Ramone handed Peg the rod and left the episode, obligatory cameo complete.

 

"uhhhhhhh Peg?"

 

"What is it Cat?"

 

"Do you actually have any idea how to use the rod?"

 

".........oh no!"

 

Hallia has been night killed.

 

She was:

 

 

 

Ramone, Town Cop

 

 

 

[Shad_]

 

 

Day 4

 

 

You may post.

[Eldrick4221]

Dang. Thought we had it there.

Well LZM and Spades are definitely confirmed town now.

 

digging through the thread for interactions the rest of you had with or about each other or Alex and Darthe.

 

Up to page 10:

 

 

Ahhh, this is much better on a computer. Mobile for this place is difficult. >.<

This is my first day on DM. My sister got me here (she even signed me up because I was too drunk yesterday)

for the purpose of joining this specific game. I am quite the newbie but not to be mistaken with a n00b. 

I catch on quick, but hopefully quickly enough for this.

 

[v]Alexander7[/v] for being wayyyyyy too defensive way too early. Just as you are voting to get reactions,

people will ask you why you vote for who you vote for to get reactions. So far, your reactions are very defensive.

 

Can someone please pass the popcorn?

 

 

Wow, 5 pages before lunch. I'm gonna have fun just keeping up with all of this during the day.

[V]Shanti[/v]

Hey Shanti, welcome to DM! I'm in that other game with you too.

  

-VC snipped-

 

So unless people are busing ( I think I'm using this correctly!) Dice/Cass and Eldritck are not a wolf team and Alexander and Shanti aren't either. Or early busing while they can get away with it to throw off later cases against them. Anyone else have thoughts on this?

 

I would love to hear why people are voting for who they are.  I know day 1 a lot of votes just get tossed around to get reaction reads, but I would like to hear some real cases.

Going to go back and see if anyone hasn't checked in yet. I don't think we're all here or an impression hasn't been made. Still too early to find an inactive wolf, but worth a look.

 

 

 

 

 

Confused. Isn't Alexander's vote on me at the moment?

 

Are you just voting Alex because he voted you, or is there more there?

 

I gave my reasoning in my vote comment. He was entirely too defensive when asked why he voted how he voted. 

It didn't sit right with me and his defensiveness seemed scummy.

 

 

 

why not?

 

earlier i voted you. why didnt you ask me about it then, but now you are asking me about my new vote?

 

 

 

there is no motive. it's a random vote. for the purpose of getting people to react to it and push the game forward

 

but saying this outloud kind of defeats the purpose. i feel a bit rustled for answering this

 

 

These came off as defensive to me, and are hence part of the reasons I voted for Alex.

 

 

I like the work Shanti is putting in here. *thumbs up*

 

 

 

there cant be both aggresive and defensive vibe in the same thing

 

 

And actually, defensive aggression is a thing. 

  

 

 

why not?

earlier i voted you. why didnt you ask me about it then, but now you are asking me about my new vote?

there is no motive. it's a random vote. for the purpose of getting people to react to it and push the game forward

but saying this outloud kind of defeats the purpose. i feel a bit rustled for answering this

These came off as defensive to me, and are hence part of the reasons I voted for Alex.

She has seriously only played one day phase! She's good at this....I think I've brought her over to the dark side of my mafia addiction

 

 

 

 

no. you are talking like that not only to haleesi

 

i was about to go look up your iso and quote everything but then i remembered

 

there is no iso

 

 

Dice answered that for you.

 

 

 

  

 

@(Not) _Eb_"Are there many differences in setup/game start etc between the games you've played RL and ones you've read online? Would you say you tend to be more of a gut feel or direct logic kind of player?"

 

definitely different, but i read a decent amount of games online. i read mostly based on tone and gut rather than direct logic

 

spades is being really scummy atm

 

You and dice will have a brilliant time deciphering tones :)

 

 

there cant be both aggresive and defensive vibe in the same thing

  

Yes there can

Spades and Alexander sre wolves together. Neither care about the questions theure asking each other

  

I could buy this theory.

 

there cant be both aggresive and defensive vibe in the same thing

 

And actually, defensive aggression is a thing. 

 

What she said :)

 

 

 

@alex, if you are mobile you have to go to the full version to get it properly and before you click on the magnifying glass make aure it says "this topic" beside of it.

I am always on mobile guys so it's going to be highly difficult to do all of this multiquoting stuff. You will have to deal with a quote by quote from me....sorry.

 

tigraine you seem to agree with shanti alot. then why arent you voting me? would i not be your biggest wolfread atm?

I agree with her a lot? Just because I know there is such a thing as defensive aggression doesnt mean I am agree with her.

I'm proud of her because she hasn't played but one day phase in another game and she seems to be picking up on stuff, like your defensive aggression.

However, that is the the personality and play style of certain players and as I have never played against you before, I'd like to take a little time to see your TONE for myself.

 

 

Shanti going after Alex already is good. And she explains her reasoning when asked.

 

Tress saying Shanti is looking good is null.

 

Adella welcome voting Shanti is null.

 

Tigs discussing the validity of both aggressive and defensive tone and ISO with Alex is null. it comes off as weird, though, that she is talking Shanti up. Why not let her prove herself?

 

I quoted Spades' mention of early bussing only to refresh the discussion. I don't think Shanti and Alex are bussing each other.

[Eldrick4221]

Post preview is acting up. It's making preparing my post excessively annoying. This will be slow going because of it.This is what my preview looked like

Dang. Thought we had it there.Well LZM and Spades are definitely confirmed town now.digging through the thread for interactions the rest of you had with or about each other or Alex and Darthe.Up to page 10:

<blockquote class='ipsBlockquote' data-author="Shanti" data-cid="3792775" data-time="1494871166">Shanti, on 15 May 2017 - 10:59 AM, said:<p>

[Eldrick4221]

That's ok. I'm definitely in no rush. I gotta go through the whole thread and find a new lead.

[Eldrick4221]

So far the only one I've moved out of my wtl today is shanti. And I don't even know if it will stay that way. Ed flipping town caught me way off guard.

[Eldrick4221]

 

tigraine you seem to agree with shanti alot. then why arent you voting me? would i not be your biggest wolfread atm?

I agree with her a lot? Just because I know there is such a thing as defensive aggression doesnt mean I am agree with her.

I'm proud of her because she hasn't played but one day phase in another game and she seems to be picking up on stuff, like your defensive aggression.

However, that is the the personality and play style of certain players and as I have never played against you before, I'd like to take a little time to see your TONE for myself.

 

 

 

 

 

tigraine you seem to agree with shanti alot. then why arent you voting me? would i not be your biggest wolfread atm?

 

I agree with her a lot? Just because I know there is such a thing as defensive aggression doesnt mean I am agree with her.

I'm proud of her because she hasn't played but one day phase in another game and she seems to be picking up on stuff, like your defensive aggression.

However, that is the the personality and play style of certain players and as I have never played against you before, I'd like to take a little time to see your TONE for myself.

you didnt answer my question friendo

 

why arent you voting me? would i not be your biggest wolfread atm?

oh i just reread tigraine's post. she says she is not voting me because she doesnt agree with shanti

 

not sure i buy that

@alex- I agree with her that you were being defensively aggressive.

Don't twist my words.

@Redd- I can see that you and I have very different play styles. I like to quote people I find scummy so others can see what I'm referring to. I think that's a big part of being a team player so that fellow townies don't have to spend their time searching my reasoning. It gives them time to give their own reads on people

Things that make you go hmmm.

 

First post you're clearly saying you acknowledge that what she says in possible, but not that you agree with it. Alex challenges that, and you retort with that you DID say you agree.