[Basic] Peg + Cat Mafia -- TOWN WIN

[LedZepMan]

Cass, since I don't know if I have the skillz to chop quotes up in mobile, I'll just answer best I can.

 

So, GTH- right now Alex seems town to me. Pushy town. Like that person in your neighborhood that always comes over wanting you to sign up with the neighborhood watch, when all you wanna do is drink beer naked on your couch. Good hearted but pushy.

 

Now, Ed. I could never tell when he was scum except when I was scum team. And I never seen him last past D3 as town. But, I'm five years outta date here. I could lean either way here.

 

GTH- as to town I'd say Alex, but that's about it. Scum on the other hand, I'd say the same as I always say. Look to the back of the class. The lurkers. Skulking about like vagrants, asking for cigarettes and roofing around through the trash.

[Cass]

Top part of last quote - Eld questioning Alex/applying pressure is +1

 

Don't personally think the switch was odd though. 

 

@Alex, why didn't you answer?

[Darthe]

[v]Spadeszee[/v]

good vote :)

 

 

 

post #171 reeks

 

 

 

 

 

With a grand total of 4 wolfy posts, you lead this thread by a country miles spades. Might have to lunch u today

Just because you call something wolfy, doesn't make it so. What have I said that makes you think I'm a wolf, specifically? Share with the class your thought process.

 

I had this issue early last game. I think I just have a personality defect or something :P

Also all the wolfs ended up being the ones accusing me of being a wolf. There is that too.

 

I'm not too worried, I think it's too early to point fingers. Takes more than 4 posts to convince me of anything.

 

@Cass - spades sounds fine to me currently

 

@Alex - I'll call you That unless you betray me

 

Having a hard time taking Redd seriously

Those are my at work brief takes

You checking in during your 5 is a good sign. Might be able to clear Hallia soon, we'll see if she keeps the posting up.

Lets see here

 

Exactly, might be able to clear her if she keeps posting. Her showing interest while at work is a good sign that she is a villager. She is known for posting very little when she rands wolf, so we shall see if she can keep it up or not. 

You doing more drive by accusations Redd? :P

 

 

Well I'm missing something apparently.  

[Darthe]

Always in a weird position when you're trying to figure out if wolfs are trying to bait votes on you or if they are villagers actually trying to figure things out. I don't think they are wolfbros, but with how much I speak I could make an easy first kill target.

 

Anyone who's been reading all of this have an outside perspective? 

You don't think they're wolfbros?

[Darthe]

also why do you say "play against" you instead of "play with" you. thats an interesting choice of words @Tigraine

Idk where you're from but do they nitpick like this at that place?  

[Darthe]

 

 

 

[V]tigraine[/v]

Because.....

I think youre a wolf

[V] Redd [/v]

 

Call it an OMGUS vote or whatever but I truly think you are playing scum play. Randomly changing your vote with nothing more than a "I think you're wolf" is just distracting.

 

If you truly feel that someone is scum then you should have reasons to back it up. You should show evidence of such, not just expect everyone to take your word for it just cause.

 

I like this response but I can't say why rn.  Quoting for the future.

[Darthe]

 

 

 

 

[V]tigraine[/v]

Because.....

I think youre a wolf

[V] Redd [/v]

 

Call it an OMGUS vote or whatever but I truly think you are playing scum play. Randomly changing your vote with nothing more than a "I think you're wolf" is just distracting.

 

If you truly feel that someone is scum then you should have reasons to back it up. You should show evidence of such, not just expect everyone to take your word for it just cause.

 

tigraine looks a bit better after this post. tone shows that she believes what she is saying. she acknowledges she is omgusing but goes with it anyway. kinda towny

pretty sure tho (in american english) that reddboiler is town. vote for someone else.

 

ideally for whoever im voting. you can do that for the whole game if you want, i dont mind

 

 

 

[V]alexander7[/v]

lold hard here

 

[v] alex [/v]

[Cass]

Cass, since I don't know if I have the skillz to chop quotes up in mobile, I'll just answer best I can.

 

So, GTH- right now Alex seems town to me. Pushy town. Like that person in your neighborhood that always comes over wanting you to sign up with the neighborhood watch, when all you wanna do is drink beer naked on your couch. Good hearted but pushy.

 

Now, Ed. I could never tell when he was scum except when I was scum team. And I never seen him last past D3 as town. But, I'm five years outta date here. I could lean either way here.

 

GTH- as to town I'd say Alex, but that's about it. Scum on the other hand, I'd say the same as I always say. Look to the back of the class. The lurkers. Skulking about like vagrants, asking for cigarettes and roofing around through the trash.

 

You always say that? Where would you apply it/who's looking scummiest for it here?

 

WRT Alex, I mostly agree. What about the emotional outburst after the initial pushiness, and the change in his playstyle after then?

 

WRT Ed, kk for now.

[Darthe]

The AtE drawing votes off made that whole thing look planned.

[Darthe]

 

there is no motive. it's a random vote. for the purpose of getting people to react to it and push the game forward

 

but saying this outloud kind of defeats the purpose. i feel a bit rustled for answering this

This is contradictory too. You random vote to get people to react. Hally does react. She questions it.

 

Your response is to get flustered that she questioned it. What other reaction could you possibly want?

 

To be fair, she's right that you switching from Hally to Shanti so quickly is odd. Why didn't you wait to see if anything happened from the Hally vote?

 

Wolfy

[Darthe]

 

 

 

Thats alot of responses that dont really say much tigraine. You werent even on my radar 2 mins ago and now the urge to place my vote on you is strong.

I get the feeling you're going to place your vote on literally everyone at some point :P

Trying to keep it confined to just the wolves

I don't like this response.

 

I liked the way Redd was going at the thread. Felt like he was going at everyone to see what happens. But when he's called out for it, he responds that he's trying to keep it to the wolves.

 

Which doesn't make sense. Only wolves would know who is wolves before voting. And the voting and pushing is how town finds out who the wolves are. This response was weird.

 

More wolfy

[Darthe]

 

i have an urge to vote for tigraine aswell but i dont want to be seen as im sheeping reddboiler. i know this is scummy for me to say but i dont care

Always a red flag when someone is paying attention to if they sound wolfy.

 

better

[Darthe]

 

 

 

 

[V]tigraine[/v]

Because.....

I think youre a wolf

[V] Redd [/v]

 

Call it an OMGUS vote or whatever but I truly think you are playing scum play. Randomly changing your vote with nothing more than a "I think you're wolf" is just distracting.

 

If you truly feel that someone is scum then you should have reasons to back it up. You should show evidence of such, not just expect everyone to take your word for it just cause.

Would you have felt this way if he had voted someone else?

 

Why is "because I think you're a wolf" not a good enough reason at this stage?

 

So yeah. Calling it OMGUS

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Checking in

...is here

\o/

 

I just realized that the most logical hydra name for you would be DiceAss.

I just realised your logic is wonky...

 

Good morning everyone! Hope everyone slept well and is ready for that all to change now that this started.

\o

 

and

 

<.<

 

What is sleep?

 

Wolf post

Not disagreeing with you there. It reminds me of what I gave her town cred for last time.

 

So I'm skeptical, but it's way too early to make a call yet for me.

this is a true wolf post, whyd u respond so seriously?

Cuz I was already thinking along those lines. I agreed with you.

 

 

 

much better

 

 

 

Yes it is other Darthe.

 

Yes it is.

Calling you Barry now.

 

 

I had a Barry avatar for a long while

[ed2funy]

 

Whew.

Would be a little awkward if you were a wolf, please don't be.

 

Even worse if you were a villager in one game and wolf in another! hahaha

I've done this before!

 

Or was I wolf in both? Either way, got confused. Tigs Lynched me, the rude witch.

[Cass]

 

 

i have an urge to vote for tigraine aswell but i dont want to be seen as im sheeping reddboiler. i know this is scummy for me to say but i dont care

Always a red flag when someone is paying attention to if they sound wolfy.

 

better

 

 

nuh. 

 

I protest this on grounds of blanket shallow/generalised/overly picky.

 

 

*Watches Darthe*

[ed2funy]

I'm barely handling being a villager in each of them. I don't think I'm ready to be a wolf.

 

Proud townie here.

*smacks*

 

I am neither confirming nor denying anything, but shoosh!

[Darthe]

Frustrated at that skimming.gif

 

 

Eldrick's involvement looks good for him, I like the activity level there.

 

Also

 

 

Led - v

Slight scum lean, you're not really going anywhere

[Cass]

 

 

Whew.

Would be a little awkward if you were a wolf, please don't be.

 

Even worse if you were a villager in one game and wolf in another! hahaha

I've done this before!

 

Or was I wolf in both? Either way, got confused. Tigs Lynched me, the rude witch.

 

 

Ed, I think this is the second time you've replied to this post...

[ed2funy]

 

 

 

I'm not proving or disproving anything. I am pointing things out that I find interesting or suspicious.

 

I figured it was implied, but in my opinion it doesn't count because people generally feel the need to respond when you call them out specifically. Quoting the vote count leaves everyone in a vague group, while you get to say "yuh huh, I did call everyone out HERE!!" and that just doesn't fly with me.

Well, the people who were actively voting and speaking I did ask directly. I mentioned that they were early votes and that they usually don't hold much to them, but wanted to hear cases if they had them. *shrug* I don't think I really need to be more specific than that.

Also doesn't feel right, I had hardly posted and you asked about my vote. Not lining up. You're also feeling a little too defensive with all of this.

 

[v]Spadeszee[/v]

Fair enough

Adella: "You're being too defensive!"

 

Spades: Oh shoot, she's right, act cool!

"Yeah, totes"

[ed2funy]

 

 

 

Whew.

Would be a little awkward if you were a wolf, please don't be.

 

Even worse if you were a villager in one game and wolf in another! hahaha

I've done this before!

 

Or was I wolf in both? Either way, got confused. Tigs Lynched me, the rude witch.

Ed, I think this is the second time you've replied to this post...

The first time was me marking my place because I was leaving work. *nods*

[Darthe]

 

Cuz Darthe is my peek.

 

KK. 

 

 

 

But you know Darthe is always Wolfy, right??

 

 

 

Kill it now

[ed2funy]

 

there is no motive. it's a random vote. for the purpose of getting people to react to it and push the game forward

 

but saying this outloud kind of defeats the purpose. i feel a bit rustled for answering this

This is contradictory too. You random vote to get people to react. Hally does react. She questions it.

 

Your response is to get flustered that she questioned it. What other reaction could you possibly want?

 

To be fair, she's right that you switching from Hally to Shanti so quickly is odd. Why didn't you wait to see if anything happened from the Hally vote?

Eldrick coming in with some sound logic.

[Darthe]

 

 

I just did a quick reskim so I may have missed somethibg

But I dont see where Tigraine has done any game playing whatsoever

Just kind of quoting and responding when prodded or agreeing with people or just joking to cut tension

 

Are you reading this as Wolfy, or vetting people's reactions?

 

Why the change from "POSSI_WOOFY BEHAVIOUR! VOTE!!!        " ?

 

 

People (Alex) calling you Town for aggression is one thing in content that comes to mind.

 

Thoughts?

 

WRT Tigs, there's a couple of posts that I wanna follow up on but apart from her push/OMGUS vote at you I agree.

 

Need more to get a read though, essentially I had the same thoughts/feeling about her early play last game (2 page [sortKey]=date&search_app_filters[forums][sortDir]=1&cType=topic&cId=100501&search_content=both&search_app_filters[forums][sortKey]=date&search_app_filters[forums][sortDir]=1&search_app_filters[forums][noPreview]=1&search_app_filters[forums][pCount]=&search_app_filters[forums][pViews]=&search_term=&search_app=forums]ISO here).

 

 

Do you have fleshed out reads/thoughts on other players?

 

I kinda think spades is a villager now

 

The only real strong villager I have is the new pretty girl

 

I'm sure I have other villagers but I don't really pay attention to those. I only care about the wolf hunting portion of this game.

 

k but why male models spades?

[Darthe]

also "i dont pay attention to villagers" is aids, redd

[Darthe]

Morning all...

 

I've spent this morning beginning to organize thoughts and impressions and starting on a reads list to post tonight. 

 

Quick notes:

 

Hopefully LZM has not fallen off the face of the earth and will turn up today.

 

Cass, if you could poke your hydra partner and get him to give me a bit more action, I'd much appreciate it.  Otherwise, i guess we'll see what happens N1.  

 

Will stay as current as possible during work today and respond to any questions if time allows, but as usual I can't do much in depth during the work day as I'll be on my phone and trying to keep it out of sight so I don't get in trouble, and they do expect me to do actual work for my paycheck.  Whaaaaat.

Tress r u a wolf? Ur doin that wolf thing u do.