[Basic] Peg + Cat Mafia -- TOWN WIN

[ed2funy]

spades dont townread me out of pity because i cried like a baby because i got scumread. it makes me feel pathetic

 

 

 

Yooooooo

[Spadeszee]

you got anything for me and cas spadeS?  before i gotta run in a few mins?

Sorry, went to do the dishes. I read Cass, not so much you. I'll let you know if anything changes, so far you two are neutral with town tilt.

[ed2funy]

For all you new folks you need to know that I'm the nice one here and they pick on me.

 

I legit lawled

[ed2funy]

 

Whew. 

Would be a little awkward if you were a wolf, please don't be.

 

Even worse if you were a villager in one game and wolf in another!  hahaha 

 

 

 

Here

[Cass]

Wheee caught up on quotes!

 

Splitting these and then I'm pretty much done for the day.

 

redd probably town

 

Unless they're WW, I don't hate this thought from Alex, especially at the point when Redd charges in and upsets several apple carts.

 

 

@Reddboiler, where have you played your most recent games/can you link me to some (scum and Town) pls?

 

 

 

@Cass - spades sounds fine to me currently

@Alex - I'll call you That unless you betray me

Having a hard time taking Redd seriously
Those are my at work brief takes

 

Halleh, have you played with Redd before?

Can you explain the why of your thoughts and if this is an alignment related thing?

 

 

[Shad_]

Well that was a long day.

 

Vote count incoming.

[Shad_]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

 

Alex (2) - Shanti, Eldrick

 

Spades (1) - Adella

 

Tress (3) - Tigraine, Redd, Alex

 

LZM (1) - Dice/Cass

 

Ed (1) - LZM

 

Not Voting: Darthe, Songstress, Spadeszee, Ed, Hallia

 

 

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

 

[Cass]

 

Also, lololololololololololololololololololololololololololololol

 

Ask Correh if I'm confident     

That is my opinion of how you've been playing.

 

 

Kk, I didn't necessarily mean in relation to this game, but ^.^ / 

 

There is a reason I wanted my boyfriend to mentor me on my first game here <3 Cuz he's the best!

_{(mostly because I want to spend time with him, shhh, don't tell him)}

 

*Nails Correh's feet to the floor*

 

 

you got anything for me and cas spadeS?  before i gotta run in a few mins?

Sorry, went to do the dishes. I read Cass, not so much you. I'll let you know if anything changes, so far you two are neutral with town tilt.

 

 

I think he meant did you have any questions

 

 

 

Whew. 

Would be a little awkward if you were a wolf, please don't be.

 

Even worse if you were a villager in one game and wolf in another!  hahaha 

 

 

 

Here

 

 

Eddddd

 

Who's the Town?

Who's the Scum?

[Cass]

 

 

why not?

 

earlier i voted you. why didnt you ask me about it then, but now you are asking me about my new vote?

there is no motive. it's a random vote. for the purpose of getting people to react to it and push the game forward

 

but saying this outloud kind of defeats the purpose. i feel a bit rustled for answering this

These came off as defensive to me, and are hence part of the reasons I voted for Alex.

She has seriously only played one day phase! She's good at this....I think I've brought her over to the dark side of my mafia addiction 

 

 

This post feels off kilter to me. Like possible pocketing. I'm not sure why else these thoughts would had to have been expressed.

 

#smallthings / lololol if it is and :wub: if it's genuine though

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Thats alot of responses that dont really say much tigraine. You werent even on my radar 2 mins ago and now the urge to place my vote on you is strong.

I get the feeling you're going to place your vote on literally everyone at some point :P

Agreed!

 

@Redd, I didn't have much to say. I let stuff build until I can get a proper read on someone. I have never seen spamming the thread as a townie move. So unless i have something specific to say, I don't say it.

 

 

 

FTR I agree with Redd on this being a lot of responses (spoilered) that don't say much. 

I also don't see most of it as specific/non-spam so *watches Tig*

 

 

 

Adella is Town. Even if annoying. 

  

 

Ed is scum...even when he's not :)

 

 

How long should it take for this coffee to kick in?  *falls asleep on her desk*

 

Also, as frightening as it is for me to have to agree with the monkey man, he's right about one thing.  Adella is town.

 

 

Never agree with Eddie...it's always a scum tell ;)

 

 

Shanti i dont soeak caligrophy. Please change your text back to english

I'll say thank you to her on your behalf.... :D

 

  

 

Are you a member of the Mafia Universe Discord?

no

 

@(Not) _Eb_

"Are there many differences in setup/game start etc between the games you've played RL and ones you've read online? Would you say you tend to be more of a gut feel or direct logic kind of player?"

 

definitely different, but i read a decent amount of games online. i read mostly based on tone and gut rather than direct logic

 

spades is being really scummy atm

 

 

You and dice will have a brilliant time deciphering tones :)

 

there cant be both aggresive and defensive vibe in the same thing

  

 

Yes there can

 

Spades and Alexander sre wolves together. Neither care about the questions theure asking each other

  

 

I could buy this theory.

 

 

there cant be both aggresive and defensive vibe in the same thing

 

And actually, defensive aggression is a thing.  

 

 

What she said :)

 

 

Redd, the reason I ask is I want to know if you're just grasping at air or if you're actually trying to solve the game.

 

Spades and Alexander sre wolves together. Neither care about the questions theure asking each other

I care, you also never answered my question. Make a case on me if you're going to vote me.

My case is that you must've branded wolf since you keep making wolfy posts

It would really help if you multiquoted those ;)

 

 

 

 

[LedZepMan]

Why would you ask Ed?

 

In my experience even when he's town he's scum.

 

So, my analysis from my brief fifteen minute skim/read through-

 

Alex coming in hot and heavy, Tress on the wrong end of the train, and all in all general D1 sadism.

 

And, for the love of god, what is a hydra?

[Cass]

i have an urge to vote for tigraine aswell but i dont want to be seen as im sheeping reddboiler. i know this is scummy for me to say but i dont care

 

Do you think her posts are wolfy, or not - beyond the recognising possible OMGUS thing?

 

Why is sheeping Redd a bad thing if you agree with the read?/Have him as Town?

 

 

 

 

 

i have an urge to vote for tigraine aswell but i dont want to be seen as im sheeping reddboiler. i know this is scummy for me to say but i dont care

 

Do you think her posts are wolfy, or not - beyond the recognising possible OMGUS thing?

 

Why is sheeping Redd a bad thing if you agree with the read?/Have him as Town?

 

[Spadeszee]

 

 

Also, lololololololololololololololololololololololololololololol

 

Ask Correh if I'm confident     

That is my opinion of how you've been playing.

 

 

Kk, I didn't necessarily mean in relation to this game, but ^.^ / 

 

There is a reason I wanted my boyfriend to mentor me on my first game here <3 Cuz he's the best!

_{(mostly because I want to spend time with him, shhh, don't tell him)}

 

*Nails Correh's feet to the floor*

 

 

you got anything for me and cas spadeS?  before i gotta run in a few mins?

Sorry, went to do the dishes. I read Cass, not so much you. I'll let you know if anything changes, so far you two are neutral with town tilt.

 

 

I think he meant did you have any questions

 

 

 

Whew. 

Would be a little awkward if you were a wolf, please don't be.

 

Even worse if you were a villager in one game and wolf in another!  hahaha 

 

 

 

Here

 

 

Eddddd

 

Who's the Town?

Who's the Scum?

 

He will be catching up and see your comment eventually :P

 

Oh! Not at this moment. Will just take seeing how Dice interacts more to do the trick.

[Spadeszee]

Why would you ask Ed?

 

In my experience even when he's town he's scum.

 

So, my analysis from my brief fifteen minute skim/read through-

 

Alex coming in hot and heavy, Tress on the wrong end of the train, and all in all general D1 sadism.

 

And, for the love of god, what is a hydra?

Two heads, one body.

Two people in the same slot.

[Cass]

Why would you ask Ed?

 

In my experience even when he's town he's scum.

 

So, my analysis from my brief fifteen minute skim/read through-

 

Alex coming in hot and heavy, Tress on the wrong end of the train, and all in all general D1 sadism.

 

And, for the love of god, what is a hydra?

 

Have you read all the pages?

 

I can ask you the same questions?

 

GTH who's Scum/Who's Town?

 

Can you explain the Ed thing? Is it a joke or for real? In the last two games he was scummyscummscumscumMcScum. Here he feels different. 

How does he read to you?

 

 

Why's Tress on the wrong end of the train for you?

 

And \o/ Sadism 

[Cass]

Can't tell if these are tongue in cheek or serious. *Scowl face either way*

 

@alex- I agree with her that you were being defensively aggressive.


Don't twist my words.

@Redd- I can see that you and I have very different play styles. I like to quote people I find scummy so others can see what I'm referring to. I think that's a big part of being a team player so that fellow townies don't have to spend their time searching my reasoning. It gives them time to give their own reads on people

Im not a socialist, i dont work so others can reap the free benefits. Im a capitalist.

 

 

 

 

im asking you to quote me where my responses haven't been genuine. because im pretty sure they have

As opposed to what, being 100% sure that they are?

 

 

They're overly flippant and  -ev either way.

 

@Redddddddd where's the answers to my questions/moar hunting/further reads?

 

 

"pretty sure" is a.. uh.. figure of speech? im not a native english speaker not sure if thats the phrase im looking for

 

it means the same as 100% sure

It didn't stand out to me /shrug

Out of curiousity, what's your first language?

 

 

 

 

Thats alot of responses that dont really say much tigraine. You werent even on my radar 2 mins ago and now the urge to place my vote on you is strong.

 

actually i kinda liked her response.

 

 

TO THE QT! (If Dice means the MQ rather than the follow up posts, we're maybe gonna have a biiiiiig problem!)

[Cass]

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

and now you're saying someone is town for doing what you said was scummy. Not looking too good here.

if i said that she is scummy for doing it, how would you react?

 

Would depend on how you say it, honestly. How someone words something is really important in a game like this.

 

tigraine is scummy for being self-aware about her omgusing

 

react to this

 

You're really trying to distract off of yourself, aren't you? I think this is why people are accusing us of arguing for the sake of it, because you just redirect everything and leave no substance.

 

I know this is a lie, so I can't react to it genuinely.

 

if my jimmies werent rustled, i would have said

 

"why are you not scumreading me for scumreading tigraine over something i did myself (being self-aware over doing something scummy)"

 

but this whole thing is getting complicated. if you are town i hope scum kills you tonight

 

 

 

Hey, if you're actually town, we can't start getting frustrated and fight each other. Wishing for scum to kill your fellow villagers is asking for bad juju and we don't need that here.

I've put you in a bit of a hot seat, part of getting someones reactions out, I see you're very frustrated by this and I don't know that a wolf would be so upset. I could be wrong in that and you're good at putting on a show, but I'm going to trust my gut and say you're not scum. Sorry for pushing you so hard, I never want someone to have a bad time playing this.

 

I'm trying to look at everything from several perspectives. Once more people become active I think more answers will come forward.

 

This post generally reads like encouraging good Town Play so +1 for Spadez (- minutiae for tinfoil). 

 

But I actually liked Alex's outburst and the bold part of the post the least of all his stuff to here.  <.<

[Cass]

 

 

Wow, 5 pages before lunch. I'm gonna have fun just keeping up with all of this during the day.

 

[V]Shanti[/v]

Hey Shanti, welcome to DM! I'm in that other game with you too.

Can you explain your vote please?

Literally just a "welcome" vote. It will change by EOD I'm sure. Catching up you bunch of spammers.

 

@Adella,

 

Where are you at for reads?

 

*ISOs*

 

What do you make of Spadeszee's reads post/work after you voted her?

 

What reads/leans do you have for everybody else?

 

YOLO these two not likely to be WW

[LedZepMan]

 

Why would you ask Ed?

 

In my experience even when he's town he's scum.

 

So, my analysis from my brief fifteen minute skim/read through-

 

Alex coming in hot and heavy, Tress on the wrong end of the train, and all in all general D1 sadism.

 

And, for the love of god, what is a hydra?

Have you read all the pages?

 

I can ask you the same questions?

 

GTH who's Scum/Who's Town?

 

Can you explain the Ed thing? Is it a joke or for real? In the last two games he was scummyscummscumscumMcScum. Here he feels different.

How does he read to you?

 

 

Why's Tress on the wrong end of the train for you?

 

And \o/ Sadism

Yes, I've been through all the pages, but thoroughly, meh.......no. Mobile version blows.

 

And Ed being scum all the time is a joke. He usually gets himself lynched early no matter what side he's on. But it's been five years or so since I played a game so........ stuff changes.

 

Like GTH. What's that mean? Never seen that acronym before.

 

And Tress is on the wrong end of the voting train. First place right now for a free noose around the neck. That's not a race I'd want to win.

[Cass]

songstress can you do stuff

Small thing, but I find the phrasing/interjecting of this at this point +1

Less so later on, with the vote that has no reason and ?not having a look at the database I linked. -1

 

Alex, can you elaborate on your current thoughts?

[Cass]

 

 

Why would you ask Ed?

 

In my experience even when he's town he's scum.

 

So, my analysis from my brief fifteen minute skim/read through-

 

Alex coming in hot and heavy, Tress on the wrong end of the train, and all in all general D1 sadism.

 

And, for the love of god, what is a hydra?

Have you read all the pages?

 

I can ask you the same questions?

 

GTH who's Scum/Who's Town?

 

Can you explain the Ed thing? Is it a joke or for real? In the last two games he was scummyscummscumscumMcScum. Here he feels different.

How does he read to you?

 

 

Why's Tress on the wrong end of the train for you?

 

And \o/ Sadism

Yes, I've been through all the pages, but thoroughly, meh.......no. Mobile version blows.

 

And Ed being scum all the time is a joke. He usually gets himself lynched early no matter what side he's on. But it's been five years or so since I played a game so........ stuff changes.

 

Like GTH. What's that mean? Never seen that acronym before.

 

And Tress is on the wrong end of the voting train. First place right now for a free noose around the neck. That's not a race I'd want to win.

 

 

GTH is "gun to head"/if you HAD to make a call.

 

I hear ya on the mobile version blows.

 

 

and not in a good way

 

 

And ok for not wanting to be where Tress is...

 

but so far this is all commentary and no hunting/opinions/leans/reads?

 

*Hides brownies behind her back*

 

How did you go with reading Ed back in the day? How do you read him here?

 

What are your thoughts on Tress and her train?

[Cass]

 

Eldrick, is there ever going to be a game where you don't scream WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOF to me right at the start?

 

Ever?

 

 

While we're at it,

 

*Crashtackles Darthe* #tryagain/youwoofin?

 

*Hands over Chocolate to Tress* 

townie

 

 

Yes.

 

And

possipocketattemptdenied.gif

 

 

 

For all you new folks you need to know that I'm the nice one here and they pick on me.

 

LOLOLD so hard

 

 

Cass typically asks questions to get to know people, it's non-alignment indicative for her imo

Isn't this what we all do..?

 

 

:/ Darthe, thoughts on Halli/her play this game?

Had this particular post and the one after (can't tell me what to do!) it as null-townish on tone/content.

 

#Dosomework/exposeyourbrain!

[Cass]

I'm not proving or disproving anything. I am pointing things out that I find interesting or suspicious.

 

I figured it was implied, but in my opinion it doesn't count because people generally feel the need to respond when you call them out specifically. Quoting the vote count leaves everyone in a vague group, while you get to say "yuh huh, I did call everyone out HERE!!" and that just doesn't fly with me.

Agreed with this initially, but Spadeszee looking pretty Townish for breadth of interaction/pressure/consideration since then/so far.

 

Unlikely to be WW imo

 

 

 

 

My nap was amazing, I am now working but can participate while doing so.

 

Tress..... are you wolfy? 

 

All stalky and stuff    

 

Nahhh, town and more town.

 

Stalking is fun, though.  I swarez. *innocentface*

 

 

Agreed!

 

 

 

I don't think spades is wolf. Villager who is wolfy feels like it fits more.

Also agreed

 

What do you make of Alex right now?

[Cass]

e fair, she's right that you switching from Hally to Shanti so quickly is odd. Why didn't you wait to see if anything happened from the Hally vote?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Thats alot of responses that dont really say much tigraine. You werent even on my radar 2 mins ago and now the urge to place my vote on you is strong.

I get the feeling you're going to place your vote on literally everyone at some point :P

Trying to keep it confined to just the wolves

I don't like this response.

I liked the way Redd was going at the thread. Felt like he was going at everyone to see what happens. But when he's called out for it, he responds that he's trying to keep it to the wolves.

Which doesn't make sense. Only wolves would know who is wolves before voting. And the voting and pushing is how town finds out who the wolves are. This response was weird.

 

 

@Eld

What do you make of Redd's response to her initial post?

Do you think his reply here was serious? A slip? 

 

This is example #2 of possi-shade/easy reach on another player, based around 'my logic is this simple'/huhconfused type post on your part. And there have been others where you've looked interested in the shade, but not necessarily at expressing your opinions/working it out, which is something I associate with your game as Scum, not Town.

 

Skimmed ISOs of Hackers (Town) and Wild West Mafia Mischiefs (Scum) and #feelzconfirmed

 

Another example is you finding Alex's reference to himself being possi-scummy  'always a red flag', but not commenting on the fact he suggests Tigs is doing the same. 

FOS at yoooouuu.

 

Moar readz please. 

 

1. What did you actually think of the Tigs post Redd commented on? 

2. Her OMGUS comments?/The rest of her play?

3. Do you have a read on her yet?

[Darthe]

I woke up this morning, went to work, got home...

 

Totally forgot that this game existed.  Brb

[Darthe]

Spades and Alexander sre wolves together. Neither care about the questions theure asking each other

We have the best hot takes, don't we folks?