[Basic] Peg + Cat Mafia -- TOWN WIN

[Eldrick4221]

[V]Tigs[/v]

[Eldrick4221]

 

Darthe- Null read, hasn't posted content other than to specify a quote or two either Wolfy or townie.

Tress- null read, only game content was to say she agreed with Ed that Adella is town and to say she likes the work Shanti has put in

Spade- never played with before (it just sounds wrong! I know I'm 31 and a mother of three but my mind goes bad places) but she seems to be legitimately trying to game solve. She's asking about votes and questioning things in a positive manner.

LZM- hasn't checked in

Eddie- hasnt said much which is game related. Common for him during day 1 but Eddie is one that I ALWAYS find scummy. It's how he got me last game. I try to give him the benefit of the doubt and it colors my game play with him. So I always keep an eye on him but other than remarking about Alex and spades back and forth, he hasn't said anything.

I'm going ahead and posting this because believe it or not it has taken me hours to type this out. Like I said, I am on mobile and it's a true process. Not to mention my one year old dive/princess/demon/drama queen/ beauty I am dealing with...kid likes to eat and poop and push buttons on my phone :(

I'm starting to work on the rest but know that it will prob be a while before I can get my thoughts on everyone else to you guys. ISOing on mobile and trying to type it all on my notepad to copy and paste to you guys is tedious.

 

 

QFR in case she flips scum. Good chance one of her teammates would be in this partial list.

[ReddBoiler]

Ok good someone else sees it. Thiught it was just me for a min there

[ReddBoiler]

I may already be voting her but i cant remember who im voting so just gonna vote tigs here

 

[V]tigraine[/v]

[Eldrick4221]

 

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNTAlex (2) - Shanti, EldrickSpades (1) - AdellaTress (3) - Tigraine, Redd, AlexLZM (1) - Dice/CassEd (1) - LZMEldrick (1) - DartheNot Voting: Songstress, Spadeszee, Ed, HalliaWith 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

  

[v]Spades[/v]

 

  

My head hurts now and I'm gonna take a break. I could switch to hally or tress rn, but I'm gonna [unvote] instead.

I have to go over Alex again and remember if there was more to me thinking he was scum besides him being conscious of how his posting looks.

  

[V]Tigs[/v]

 

 

UNOFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

Alex (1) - Shanti

Spades (2) - Adella, Ed

Tress (2) - Tigraine, Alex

LZM (1) - Dice/Cass

Ed (1) - LZM

Eldrick (1) - Darthe

Tigraine (2) - Eldrick, Redd

 

Not Voting: Songstress, Spadeszee, Hallia

 

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

 

(Redd vote not quoted as he posted it as I was typing this)

[Eldrick4221]

Ok good someone else sees it. Thiught it was just me for a min there

It's pretty obvious if you look for it.

[Eldrick4221]

Not solving doesn't guarantee wolf, but it's a dang good reason to Day 1 lynch.

[Eldrick4221]

I may already be voting her but i cant remember who im voting so just gonna vote tigs here

[V]tigraine[/v]

You were voting tress

[LedZepMan]

that was some pretty quick bandwagoning fellas, especially in the wee hours of the morning. Is your QT more active than the thread right now?

[Eldrick4221]

that was some pretty quick bandwagoning fellas, especially in the wee hours of the morning. Is your QT more active than the thread right now?

Assuming you're referring to Redd and me voting tigs. Feel free to look at her iso and give us your opinion.

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

I'm not proving or disproving anything. I am pointing things out that I find interesting or suspicious.

I figured it was implied, but in my opinion it doesn't count because people generally feel the need to respond when you call them out specifically. Quoting the vote count leaves everyone in a vague group, while you get to say "yuh huh, I did call everyone out HERE!!" and that just doesn't fly with me.

 

Well, the people who were actively voting and speaking I did ask directly.  I mentioned that they were early votes and that they usually don't hold much to them, but wanted to hear cases if they had them. *shrug* I don't think I really need to be more specific than that.

Also doesn't feel right, I had hardly posted and you asked about my vote. Not lining up. You're also feeling a little too defensive with all of this.

 

[v]Spadeszee[/v]

I don't see why this is so much of an issue. Adella, what's the problem here? I thought her asking people for their reasons was a good idea.

[LedZepMan]

Not solving doesn't guarantee wolf, but it's a dang good reason to Day 1 lynch.

Same could be said of me. I dont build cases day 1, and according to cass I've not had much substance either.

 

I think that hogwash, as I've explained myself for the little bits of info I have provided.

 

Now, I don't have an opinion on tigs yet, but what I do feel confident in is her wagon. Or more precisely whose on the wagon. Hopping on a wagon is mafioso 101. Which just happened in the space of five minutes I think.

 

So, I'm gonna [unvote]. And lay a FoS on Redd for that bandwagon attempt.

 

I may vote to consolidate a lynch, since we have a three way tie ATM, but until then I'm going to [v]Redd[\v] for his hopping on the Tigs wagon.

 

And I ain't doing this ISO thing, feels like meta gaming to me and that's no bueno.

[LedZepMan]

Stupid.

 

[v]Redd[/v]

[Eldrick4221]

Big difference in making cases and trying to solve. Solving involves trying to figure out reasons behind posts and asking game-related questions. Both of which Tigs hasn't done

[Eldrick4221]

Iso has absolutely nothing to do with meta gaming. It's just looking at what a particular person said. Sometimes there's clarity found in exclusion. You can see better how their train of thought went along. who they focused on or avoided. What they followed up on and what they didn't.

[Eldrick4221]

In a vaccuum, redd's vote looks like a bandwagon, but he was already suspicious of her.

[Shad_]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT

 

Alex (1) - Shanti

 

Spades (1) - Adella

 

Tress (2) - Tigraine, Alex

 

LZM (1) - Dice/Cass

 

Eldrick (1) - Darthe

 

Tigraine (2) - Eldrick, Redd

 

Redd (1) - LZM

 

Not Voting: Songstress, Spadeszee, Ed, Hallia

 

 

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

 

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

Votes

Pg1

Eldrick - Aussie hydra - cuz hydra (joke vote)

Cass - Eldrick - Post count (joke vote)

Pg3

Alex - Hally - no listed reason

Pg4

Alex - Shanti - no listed reason

Pg5

Redd - Hally - soul read wolf between hally/spades

Shanti - Alex - too defensive too early

Adella - Shanti - welcome vote

Redd - Spades - seemingly omgus to be called wolf

Pg9

Alex - Spades - "good vote". probably irt post 171

Redd - Tigs - no listed reason

Pg11

Tigs - Redd - because he's randomly changing his vote without reason

Pg12

Redd - Alex - no listed reason. Voted after Alex defended Tigs

Pg13

Tigs - Tress - irt stalker comment (joke vote)

Pg14

Redd - Tress - no listed reason

Pg15

Adella - Spades - too defensive? Asked for reasons for people's votes..

Pg16

Eldrick - unvote - liked dice's tone

Eldrick - Alex - paying attention to if he sounds sunny

Pg17

Cass - Led - summon vote

Pg20

Alex - Tress - no listed reason. Maybe irt her responding to Tigs asking about hally's possible slip

Pg21

Led - Ed - cuz of past history (joke vote)

Pg23

Darthe - Alex - found his response to Redd/Tigs interaction scummy?

Pg25

Darthe - Eldrick - "pocket denied"

Pg29

Ed - Spades - "lack of scum hunting and deduction skills" seemed to be directed at everyone, but still voted Spades for it

Pg30

Eldrick - unvote - unsure if there was more reason than "being conscious of how his posting looks"

Pg31

Eldrick - Tigs - No solve

Redd - Tigs - confirming his vote was on her (it wasn't)

Led - Redd - interpreting Redd's vote as a bandwagon vote

 

 

 

If anyone's vote was incorrectly explained, or if you'd like to explain your votes, please respond. Otherwise, this is just for my records, and for any townies that want to make use of the info.

[Eldrick4221]

@Shanti what is your current view of alex?

 

@Tigs do you have a serious reason to be voting tress?

 

@Cass you haven't had a serious vote all game. Who is your wtl?

[Eldrick4221]

I am going to attempt to sleep (even though I got up ~5 hours ago).

[ReddBoiler]

 

Not solving doesn't guarantee wolf, but it's a dang good reason to Day 1 lynch.

Same could be said of me. I dont build cases day 1, and according to cass I've not had much substance either.

 

I think that hogwash, as I've explained myself for the little bits of info I have provided.

 

Now, I don't have an opinion on tigs yet, but what I do feel confident in is her wagon. Or more precisely whose on the wagon. Hopping on a wagon is mafioso 101. Which just happened in the space of five minutes I think.

 

So, I'm gonna [unvote]. And lay a FoS on Redd for that bandwagon attempt.

 

I may vote to consolidate a lynch, since we have a three way tie ATM, but until then I'm going to [v]Redd[\v] for his hopping on the Tigs wagon.

 

And I ain't doing this ISO thing, feels like meta gaming to me and that's no bueno.

Id love to respond to you but i dont know wtf youre even trying to say here. Come again, obky this time english

[Adella]

 

 

 

 

 

I'm not proving or disproving anything. I am pointing things out that I find interesting or suspicious.

I figured it was implied, but in my opinion it doesn't count because people generally feel the need to respond when you call them out specifically. Quoting the vote count leaves everyone in a vague group, while you get to say "yuh huh, I did call everyone out HERE!!" and that just doesn't fly with me.

 

Well, the people who were actively voting and speaking I did ask directly. I mentioned that they were early votes and that they usually don't hold much to them, but wanted to hear cases if they had them. *shrug* I don't think I really need to be more specific than that.

Also doesn't feel right, I had hardly posted and you asked about my vote. Not lining up. You're also feeling a little too defensive with all of this.

 

[v]Spadeszee[/v]

 

I don't see why this is so much of an issue. Adella, what's the problem here? I thought her asking people for their reasons was a good idea.

I didn't have a problem with her questions, I had a problem with the fact that she claimed to have asked everyone about every vote, which was untrue.

[Eldrick4221]

 

 

 

 

 

 

I'm not proving or disproving anything. I am pointing things out that I find interesting or suspicious.

I figured it was implied, but in my opinion it doesn't count because people generally feel the need to respond when you call them out specifically. Quoting the vote count leaves everyone in a vague group, while you get to say "yuh huh, I did call everyone out HERE!!" and that just doesn't fly with me.

 

Well, the people who were actively voting and speaking I did ask directly. I mentioned that they were early votes and that they usually don't hold much to them, but wanted to hear cases if they had them. *shrug* I don't think I really need to be more specific than that.

Also doesn't feel right, I had hardly posted and you asked about my vote. Not lining up. You're also feeling a little too defensive with all of this.

 

[v]Spadeszee[/v]

 

I don't see why this is so much of an issue. Adella, what's the problem here? I thought her asking people for their reasons was a good idea.

I didn't have a problem with her questions, I had a problem with the fact that she claimed to have asked everyone about every vote, which was untrue.

She didn't ask each person specifically, but she did ask broad spectrum.

 

I also don't see why that would be an issue to begin with.

[ReddBoiler]

I thibk hallias aa wolf and i think spades knows she is but doesnt wsnt to asmit she is yet for whatever personal reasons. But i think if u ask spades to be honest or maybe give the girk some truth serum, shell tell u hallias a wolf

[ReddBoiler]

If i had to guess a 3 person wklf team right now id say

 

Tigraine

LedZepMan

Hallia